- 1 - ! "# $ ## # % %&'( % '' ) ! ! ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! # $ $ $ %%% $ ! $ %%% & ' $ ' $ % ' ' $ ' $ " ' '%$ ( )$ % % * - 3 - $ & %$ %% $ %% %$+#& ( )$ , * # &&&$ ' ' +&& ) #&* $ & & -$ ' - 4 - ) -$ ' * ./ 0/121234/56 7/248 9::;6/< 36 13 24 3&& ) 3#&* 34 1./ =2>/ 3= 1./ >/954/< 524:209> 2?2> ';<8/ 94< ' .3590;5 5/8261/5/<=351./3==/4:/0;426.97>/;4</5/:12346 && 5@ 3= 95/ 2A0;84248 1./ 35</5 <91/< &&&5/=/552481./A911/5;4</5/:1234!)*3= 5 /95< 52 .92194B9C;A95 .94<52C2 >/954/< :3;46/> =35 1./ 0/121234/56 94< A15912 912> >/954/< 28. 3;51 3?/54A/41 >/9</5 =35 1./ 5/6034</41 D 191//5;6/<1./A91/529>6345/:35< 4 ?2/@ 3= 1./ 52?9> :341/412346 ;58/< 7B 1./ >/954/<:3;46/>=35731.1./09512/61./032411.91@3;>< 9526/=35AB:3462</59123426 !"#$% - 5 - B 946@/5 13 1./ 973?/ 03241 26 24 1./ & E=351./=3>>3@248 ./ 34>B :341/41234 5926/< 7B 1./ >/954/< :3;46/> =35 1./ 0/121234/56 26 1.91 @./4 1./ 5/6034</41+ :3A0>924941 .96 =2>/< 1./ 052?91/ :3A0>9241 24 3&&9>>/8248:3AA2662343=3==/4:/0;426.97>/ ;4</5/:12346&&5@3= 1./>/954/< 98261591/ :3;><43124?3C/ /:1234!)* 3= 5 13 5/=/5 1./ 24?/612891234 13 1./ 03>2:/ 94< 19C/ :3842F94:/ 34 6;:. 03>2:/ 5/0351 24 ?2/@ 3= :>/95 795 ;4</5 /:1234 #)*):*3= 5 ! /954/< :3;46/> =35 1./ 0/121234/56 .96 0>9:/< 5/>294:/ 34 1./ </:26234 3= 1.26 3;51 24 @./5/24 1./ :3+35<2491/ $/4:.3=1.26 3;51./><2409598590.36!96;4</5 1 &&%&"! - 6 - '() * () + ,- . /(.( ) ( 0 + ! * / ( 0 . (0 . 1 " . /(.( ( 0 . "./(.(/ () (0 ! ,- 2 ( 3 4 - 7 - " / .96 9>63 5/=/55/< 13 1./ </:26234 3= 1.26 3;5124 *+&*,*+-. //0-.122(12304*303+212@./5/24 1./:3+35<2491/$/4:.3=1.26 3;51.96:91/8352:9>>B./>< 1.9124?2/@3=/:1234#3= 5 43 3;516.9>>19C/ :3842F94:/3=943==/4:/0;426.97>/;4</5 .901/5GG3= 1./ 4<294 /49> 3</ /H:/01 ;034 1./ :3A0>9241 A9</ 7B 63A/ 0/5634 98852/?/< 7B 1./ 3==/4:/ 35 7B 31./5 0/5634:3?/5/<7B1./053?263@21.1./>/9?/3=1./ 3;51 /4:/1./ 3;51./><1.9119C248:3842F94:/3=943==/4:/ 7B 5/=/55248 1./ :3A0>9241 13 1./ 03>2:/ =35 24?/612891234 ;4</5/:1234!)*3= 5 2679<;4</5>9@ # 2A2>95>B1./:3+35<2491/$/4:.3=1.26 3;5124 98924 5/=/55/< 13 1./ 3==/4:/ 0;426.97>/ ;4</5 /:1234 3= 94</:1234#)*):*3= 5 ./><1.911./>/954/< 2 52A249>00/9>3!!#! 3 &)*% - 8 - 98261591/ :3;>< 431 .9?/ 5/=/55/< 1./ :3A0>9241 =35 24?/612891234;4</5/:1234!)*3= 5 /:1234 #)*):* 3= 5 A9C/6 21 :>/95 1.91 @./4 9 0/5634 @.3 26 98852/?/< 7B 1./ 3==/4:/ 0;426.97>/;4</5/:12343= 261./@2=/:3A0>9241 A9B 7/ A9</ 7B ./5 35 34 ./5 7/.9>= 7B ./5 5/>912?/6 A/41234/< 1./5/24 @21. 1./ >/9?/ 3= 1./ 3;51 /:1234 #)* 3= 5 7956 19C248 :3842F94:/ 3= 1./ 3==/4:/ 0;426.97>/;4</5 .901/5GG3=1./ /H:/01;0341./ :3A0>9241A9</7B1./0/563498852/?/<7B6;:.3==/4:/ <A211/<>B/:1234#)*3= 5 =9>>6;4</5 .901/5GG3= 1./ 94< 1./5/=35/ 1./ 795 ;4</5 /:1234 #)* 3= 5 900>2/6131./69A/ & ./ 2A0;84/< 35</5 0966/< 7B 1./ 529> 3;51 13 5/=/5 1./ A911/5 =35 24?/612891234 26 28435248 1./ 795 053?2</<;4</5/:1234#)*3= 5 94<1./5/=35/21 26>297>/137/6/1962</41./A/9412A/1./03>2:/5/0351 @96 =2>/< 94< 1./ >/954/< 98261591/ 900/956 13 .9?/ 19C/4:3842F94:/3=1./3==/4:/341./796263=6;:.03>2:/ - 9 - 5/0351 96 0/5 35</5 <91/< &&#& ?/4 1.3;8. 1./ 692< 35</5 26 431 :.9>>/48/< 7B 1./ 0/121234/56 ./5/24 24 ?2/@ 3= 1./ 6/11>/< 03621234 3= >9@ 5/=/5/4:/ 3= 1./ :3A0>9241;4</5/:1234!)*3= 5 131./03>2:/=35 24?/612891234 5/0351 94< 19C248 :3842F94:/ 3= 1./ 3==/4:/ 0;426.97>/;4</5/:12343= 341./796263=6;:. 03>2:/ 5/0351 26 79< ;4</5 >9@ 731. 1./6/ 35</56 95/ 5/I;25/<137/6/1962</ ::35<248>B 946@/5 1./ 973?/ 03241 24 1./ 94<053://<1309661./=3>>3@248 )9* ./0/12123426! )7* ./ 35</5 <91/< &&& ;4</5 /:1234 !)* 3= 5 5/=/55248 1./ :3A0>9241 =35 24?/612891234 94< 1./ 35</5 <91/< &&#& 19C248 :3842F94:/ =35 1./ 3==/4:/ 0;426.97>/ ;4</5 /:12346 & & 5@ 3= - 10 - 98924619::;6/<3613341./7962603>2:/ 5/035195/6/1962</ ):* /954/< 98261591/ 26 <25/:1/< 13 19C/ :3842F94:/ 3= 1./ 3==/4:/6 34 1./ 79626 3= 1./ :3A0>924124?2/@3=1./<26:;662346./><973?/ ./5/82615B26<25/:1/<13:3AA;42:91/1.2635</513 1./529> 3;51 3( %##' $ % 2613>3! %