Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58524 (KAR)
SMT. KAVITA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/202231/2024 · 2025-07-03
M I Arun
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58524 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58524 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" %
&%'(
!"
#
! $
!"
!%
$
$
!"
! ! $
!"
! $
!"
&
! $
!"
'$
( $ )
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* $
*
"
#
$
$
"
$
!"
! !"
!"
&
$
!"
%
$
!"
$$
!"
+ $
!"
- 3 -
" $$
!"
$$
!"
# $
!"
$$
$$
!"
'$
(
*
,
$$ *
&
)
$
*
##& ##%
*
*
$
)
*
$
#"%#"#! *
# #"# #%&&" $
$
# $ - $$
$
* $
$
$
)
*
$ $
$ - ""#"#! ""#"#! $
*
*
- 4 -
. ($
. )
//012324 56 782 9:;<717=71:; :> ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 7: 01 1442<8A?0 2@BC2 :;;1D201 31CC?/2 14?0?C=D?;41<70197782B27171:;20<8?32B02>20024781< A017B27171:; # 82 7?72 1< 02E=1024 7: 9:;<717=72 ? ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 >:0 01 1442<8A?0 2@BC2 1;
?99:04?;92 A178 2971:; # :> 782 ?0;?7?D? 1;4= 2C1/1:=< ;<717=71:;< ?;4 8?017?5C2 ;4:A@2;7< 97 ++%(>:0<8:07F78297G)
2971:; # () :> 782 1;4= 2C1/1:=<
;<717=71:;< ?;4 8?017?5C2 ;4:A@2;7< 97 02?4< ?< =;420
- 5 -
! "
! #
! $
%
&'
( ( )
* + *
) ) ! ! , ! $
, ! + #
! ,
- 6 -
! ! #
+
+
(
-
$
+
. *
( (
/0&1 !
82 /0123?;92 :> 782 B27171:;20< 1< 78?7 782 ?5:32B0:31<1:; @?;4?72< 78?7 ?7 C2?<7 :;2 B20<:; C131;/ 1; 782 C:9?C176 8?< 7: 52 B?07 :> 782 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 71<<=5@1772478?71;7821;<7?;79?<278202 ?02<2320?C423:722<:>78272@BC21;9C=41;/<:@2:>782 B27171:;20<82021; A8: C132 1; :;;1D201 31CC?/2 17<2C> ?;4 ;:;2 :> 782@ 8?32 522; @?42 B?07 :> 782 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722
; 782 <?14 /0:=;4 17 1< B0?624 78?7 782 @?;?/2@2;7 9:@@17722 A8198 1< 9:;<717=724 ?< B20 ;;2H=027:782A017B27171:;52<27?<142?;47827?72 52410297247:9:;<717=72?>02<89:@@17722561;9C=41;/?7 C2?<7:;2B20<:;C131;/1;:;;1D20131CC?/2
- 7 -
2?0;24 9:=;<2C ?BB2?01;/ >:0 02<B:;42;7 :<& 7: <=5@17< 78?7 FC:9?C176G @2?;< 17 ;224 ;:7 52 C1@17247:B?0719=C?031CC?/2 7@?61;9C=427822;71020?@ $?;98?6?7 2 >=07820 <=5@17< 78?7 232; :7820A1<2 782 098?D :> 782 72@BC2 1< >0:@ :;;1D201 31CC?/2 ?;4 17 <?71<>12<7829:;4171:;78?7?B20<:;>0:@782C:9?C1768?< 7: 52 B?07 :> 782 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 *:0 782 <?14 02?<:;171<B0?62478?7782A017B27171:;5241<@1<<24 & 2?0;24 44171:;?C :320;@2;7 43:9?72 <=BB:07<7829:;72;71:;:>C2?0;249:=;<2C>:002<B:;42;7 :<&7:?;4B0?6<>:041<@1<<?C:>782A017B27171:; % 82 E=2<71:; 78?7 ?01<2< >:0 9:;<1420?71:; 1< A8278201;782C1/87:>2971:;# ():>78297=;420782 /132;>?97<?;49109=@<7?;92<:>7829?<21<7821@B=/;24 :0420<=<7?1;?5C2I
< B20 782 1@B=/;24 :0420 + B20<:;< 8?32 522; 1;9C=424 1; 782 2@BC2 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 ?< 9:;72@BC?724 =;420 2971:; # :> 782 97 2971:; # ()
- 8 -
:>78297@?D2<179C2?078?7:>782+B20<:;<:;28?<7:
52 782 098?D :;2 8?< 7: 52 >0:@ 9824=C24 ?<72 :0 9824=C24 0152 # A:@2; ?;4 ?7 C2?<7 :;2 >0:@ ?@:;/ 782 B20<:;< C131;/ 1; 782 C:9?C176 A8202 782 1;<717=71:; 1< <17=?724 + $20=<?C :> 782 9:;4171:;< 0232?C< 78?7 :;2 B20<:; >0:@ 782 C:9?C176 A8: 8?< 7: 52 B?07 :> 782 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 <8:=C4 52 <:@2:;2 :7820 78?; 782098?DA8:1<B?07:>782?;?/2@2;7:@@17722:;
782 <702;/78 :> 82 521;/ ?; 098?D *=07820 782 720@ FC:9?C176G1<;:742>1;241;78297?;4A28?327:/:56782 41971:;?06 @2?;1;/ A8198 @2?;< ? B20<:; <8:=C4 52 >0:@?B?0719=C?0BC?92
"
; <:@2 9?<2< 78202 ?02 72@BC2< A8202 78202 ?02 ;: 423:722< >0:@ 782 <?@2 31CC?/2 ?;4 4=01;/ <=98 71@2?4J:1;1;/31CC?/2<<8?CC529:;<142024?<B?07:>782 C:9?C176>:0782B=0B:<2<:>2971:;# :>78297:A2320 A82; 423:722< ?02 ?3?1C?5C2 1; 782 <?@2 31CC?/2 782 31CC?/217<2C>8?<7:529:;<142024?<C:9?C176?;4?B20<:;
- 9 -
A8:1<?02<142;7:>782<?1431CC?/2<8:=C45298:<2; ;
782 1;<7?;7 9?<2 17 1< ;:7 1; 41<B=72 78?7 78202 ?02 423:722< 1; 782 <?@2 31CC?/2 82 1@B=/;24 ;:71>19?71:;
4:2< ;:7 1;9C=42 ?
B20<:; >0:@ 782 C:9?C176 1; 782 ?;?/2@2;7:@@17722
*:0 782 ?>:02@2;71:;24 02?<:;< 782 2@BC2 ?;?/2@2;7:@@177229:;<717=724?<B20;;2H=027: 782A017B27171:;1<820256<27?<142 # 2<B:;42;7<?02410297247:>:078A1789:;<717=72 ?;?/2@2;7 :@@17722 >:0 01 1442<8A?0 2@BC2 :;;1D201 31CC?/2 56 ?48201;/ 7: 782 @?;4?72 :> 2971:;
# () :>78297 56 1;9C=41;/ :;2 C:9?C B20<:;?< B?07:> 782:@@17722 017B27171:;<7?;4<41<B:<24:>?99:041;/C6
)' &%(
"
1<7:C: "