- 1 - !" #$% %% &!' ( !"#$# % & ' # () * $+ ),$" ), (# #$ - &'.!$$$($ ( " * $+ ),$" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &'!$+($+ **!)$ * / & ' $$$# % & 0 # ( ' * * #)&#' * *- ($$(($($ - (((($#, * * !$"($$ * - 1 - $ # 234566758349387:;<=27>853?5@=5A53@4==27 BC:A?7@= 5@: 5D5E: :5=7: ($$(($($ 65447: ;< =27 ::3=3F@58 34=E3>= 5@: 7443F@4 -C:A7 5@: 53>2CEG9FE42FE=HE3;C@58IJ3@F(((($#"477K3@A 7@25@>7?7@=F9>F?67@45=3F@ - 3 - ( 27 3@BCE7: >853?5@= 5A7: ( <75E4 ?7= D3=2 5@ 5>>3:7@= F@ ()$!($#, 5@: 4C4=53@7: AE37LFC4 3@BCE374 7 9387: >853? 67=3=3F@ ;79FE7 =27 E3;C@58 477K3@A >F?67@45=3F@ F9 4+$$$$$ 27 E3;C@58 59=7E >F@43:7E3@A =27 7@=3E7 7L3:7@>7 F@ E7>FE: 5D5E:7: =27>F?67@45=3F@F9 4+#"$$ D3=23@=7E74=5="M67E 5@@C? 9EF? =27 :5=7 F9 67=3=3F@ =388 E7583N5=3F@ 5@: :3E7>=7:E746F@:7@=F @4CE5@>7F?65@<=F65<=27 >F?67@45=3F@ AAE37L7: ;< =27 453: 5D5E: =27 5667885@= >853?5@=2546E797EE7:=234566758 75E: 5EAC?7@=4 F9 ;F=2 =27 65E=374 5@: 67EC47:=27?5=7E35845L5385;87F@E7>FE: 27?53@>F@=7@=3F@F9=275667885@=34=25==27 >F?67@45=3F@ 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;C@58 34 F@ =27 8FD7E 43:7 D23>2 E7OC3E7: =F ;7 7@25@>7: E754F@5;8< = 34 >F@=7@:7: ;< =27 875E@7: >FC@478 9FE =27 5667885@= =25= >853?5@= 254 4C4=53@7: F67@ E5:7 9E5>=CE7 F9 879= 97?CE9E5>=CE7F9 6EFP3?586258<@PF9 879= E75= =F7 5@: @538;7:5LC843F@F9879=AE75==F75@:=E75=7:543@65=37@= - 4 - @4C66FE=F9234>547>853?5@=AF=7P5?3@7:=27F>=FE 54 D2F5447447:(!M:345;383=<=FD2F87;F:<;C= =27E3;C@58254=5K7@F@8<#$M=34584F>F@=7@:7:=25= =275667885@=D5475E@3@A 4#!$$$ 67E?F@=2;C==27 E3;C@58 254 =5K7@ 3@>F?7 F9 4"$$$ 67E ?F@=2 =27E79FE7 E7OC74=7: 9FE 7@25@>3@A =27 >F?67@45=3F@ 3@ 23495LFCE ! = 34 4C;?3==7: ;< =27 875E@7: >FC@478 9FE E746F@:7@= F . @4CE5@>7 F?65@< =25= =27 >F?67@45=3F@5D5E:7:;<=27E3;C@5834BC4=5@:6EF67E 5@:@77:4@F3@=7E97E7@>7 , @ 7P5?3@5=3F@ F9 >853?5@= . F>=FE F;47EL7: 653@ 3@ 879= K@77 5@: =23A2 D3=2 E74=E3>=3F@ F9 ?FL7?7@=F9879=2365@:=273@=7E@585@:7P=7E@58EF=5=3F@ F923634653@9C85@:2734@F=5;87=F4OC5=5@:43=F@=27 98FFE 5@: =27E7 34 42FE=7@3@A F9 83?; ;< # >? 7 584F F;47EL7:=25=9E5>=CE7F9879=97?CE34C@3=7:5@:3?685@=4 3@43=C>>FE:3@A8<275447447:(!M:345;383=<=FD2F87 ;F:<27E3;C@58>F@43:7E3@A=277L3:7@>7F9 5@: - 5 - 584F F=27E E787L5@= 95>=FE4 254 >F@43:7E7: #$M 54 9C@>=3F@58 :345;383=< 234 FCE= 93@:4 @F E754F@ =F 3@=7E97E7D3=2=2745?7 ) 2FCA2 >853?5@= 4=5=74 =25= 27 D54 75E@3@A 4#!$$$ 67E ?F@=2 27 254 @F= 6EF:C>7: 5@< :F>C?7@= =F 6EFL7 =27 45?7 4 =27 5>>3:7@= 34 F9 =27 <75E ($#, 54 67E =27 >25E= 6E765E7: ;< =27 5E@5=5K5 =5=7 7A58 7EL3>74 C=2FE3=< =234 FCE= :77?4 3= 566EF6E35=7 =F E7544744 =27 3@>F?7 F9 =27 >853?5@= 5= 4")!$ 67E ?F@=2 = =27 =3?7 F9 5>>3:7@= =27 >853?5@= D54 5A7: ( <75E4 5@: 566EF6E35=7 ?C8=36837E 56683>5;87 =F 234 5A7 AEFC6 34 H#,I >>FE:3@A8< =27 >853?5@=347@=3=87:9FE8F44F99C=CE775E@3@A54C@:7E 4")!$ P#(P#,P#$MQ 4#,"$$$ " 27 >853?5@= D54 =E75=7: 54 3@65=37@= 9EF? ()$!($#, =F #$!($#, F@43:7E3@A =27 67E3F: F9 2F463=583N5=3F@ @5=CE7 F9 3@BCE374 5@: F=27E E787L5@= 95>=FE4 =234 FCE= 93@:4 3= E754F@5;87 =F 7@25@>7 =27 - 6 - >F?67@45=3F@ =F 4(!$$$ 9FE 8F44 F9 5?7@3=374 5@: 4!$$$ 9FE8F44F93@>F?7:CE3@A853:C667E3F:9FE=27 E754F@ =25= :C7 =F 3@BCE374 =27 >853?5@= ?3A2= @F= 25L7 5==7@:7:5@<DFEK5=8754=9FE567E3F:F9?F@=2427 E3;C@582545D5E:7: 4#$)#,, 9FE?7:3>587P67@474 4!$$$$ 9FE 653@ 5@: 4C997E3@A 4$$$$ 9FE =E5@46FE=5=3F@ 7P=E5 @FCE342?7@= 5@: 5==7@:5@= >25EA74 5@: 4#!$$$ 9FE9C=CE7?7:3>587P67@4742745?734 BC4=5@:6EF67ED23>2@77:4@F3@=7E97E7@>7;<=234FCE= + 27 >F?67@45=3F@ 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;C@58 34 ?F:3937:54C@:7E 8 F 75:4 D5E:;<=27 E3;C@58 D5E:;<=234 FCE= # 53@5@:4C997E3@A 4!$$$$ 4!$$$$ ( 7:3>58P67@474 4#$)#,, 4#$)#,, F44 F9 9C=CE7 75E@3@A>565>3=< 4#!,$$ 4#,"$$$ E5@46FE=5=3F@ 7P=E5 @FCE342?7@= 5@: 5==7@:5@= >25EA74 4$$$$ 4$$$$ - 7 - ! F44F95?7@3=374 4($$$$ 4(!$$$ , F44 F9 3@>F?7 :CE3@A 853: C6 67E3F: 4#,$$$ 4!$$$ ) *C=CE7 ?7:3>58 7P67@474 4#!$$$ 4#!$$$ F=58 4+#),, 4$#,, 27E7D388;77@25@>7?7@=F9 4"$$ #$ 746F@:7@= F . @4CE5@>7 F?65@< 254 58E75:< :76F43=7: =27 >F?67@45=3F@ 5?FC@= 5D5E:7: ;< =27E3;C@58 ## @=27E74C8==279F88FD3@AFE:7E3465447: &3' 6675834 &33' 27 >853?5@= 34 7@=3=87: 9FE =27 7@25@>7: >F?67@45=3F@ F9 4"$$ D3=2 3@=7E74= 5= ,M 67E 5@@C? 9EF? =27 :5=7 F9 67=3=3F@=388=27:5=7F9E7583N5=3F@ &333' 746F@:7@= F . @4CE5@>7 F?65@< 34 :3E7>=7: =F :76F43= =27 59FE7453: - 8 - >F?67@45=3F@5?FC@=58F@AD3=23@=7E74=D3=23@ F@7?F@=29EF?=27:5=7F9=234BC:A?7@= &3L' @ 4C>2 :76F43= =27 >853?5@= 34 67E?3==7:=FD3=2:E5D=277@=3E75?FC@=58F@A D3=23@=7E74=5>>EC7:F@3= )*+ &%' $ 34=F#8F+ -