Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58497 (KAR)
SIDDARAM v. SHANTAPPA
WP/202858/2024 · 2025-07-15
M I Arun
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58497 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58497 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"$
%&#!&
'&(
! "#$%
&
&
' %%( '
' & ' ' ) $**$%$%! ' ''' '
!+ '
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%$*( ,
"
' &
-)
-)
../01213456718/31/39613$**$%$%!:9;;138< 80< 8!+%$*(456711<08/020=)>3.196 =9<3 671 31?1<39<6 671/10< 79; :/1?1//13 670; @/06 :160608<
% 71 /1;:8<31<6 71/10< ?0=13 8!+%$*( 0< /1;:1A6 8? 671 ;>06 ;A713>=1 :/8:1/601; @067 671 ?8==8@0<. :/951/;
- 3 -
! "
"
#
# 71 :160608<1/ 71/10< 31<013 606=1 8? 671 /1;:8<31<668671;>06;A713>=1:/8:1/601;9<3:/9513?8/ 30;B0;;9=8?671;>06 ! &71<671A9;1@9;:8;613?8/?0<9=9/.>B1<6; 671 /1;:8<31<6:=90<60?? ?0=13 8 41?8/1 671 /09= 8>/6 ;11C0<. 68 9B1<3 671 :=90<6 @71/1 671 ?8==8@0<. :/951/@9;;8>.7668410<6/83>A13 $%&$&'()*(+)*(+
",-*'.-/&%)(",%-&+&/&0+(%1 $&''(''&%2$(%$(.,-+3.+"-&+ -
2
4
71 :160608<1/31?1<39<6 84D1A613 68 671 ;9B1 8< 671 ./8><3 6796 06 A79<.1; 671<96>/18? 671;>06 9<3 671 ;>06 0; 9=;8 49//13 45 =0B069608< 9<3 ?>/671/ 671
- 4 -
9B1<3B1<60;;8>.7696671?9.1<38?671A9;1@71<060; :8;613?8/9/.>B1<6;9<36796060;0<208=9608<8?:/820;8 68 /31/>=1*(8? E 8@121/ 671 /09= 8>/6 0< 8/31/ 68 92803 B>=60:=0A0658?:/8A1130<.;416@11<671:9/601;9<39=;868 3161/B0<1 671 /19= F>1;608< 8? =9@ 79; 9==8@13 671 9B1<3B1<69::=0A9608<9;:/9513?8/71@/06:160608<0; :/1?1//139.90<;6671;9038/31/ ( /31/>=1*(8?020=
/8A13>/1831*+$ /193;9;><31/ 56
"
# 1
7
$
1
"
1
- 5 -
4
71 :/820;8 68 /31/ >=1 *( 8? 0;
0<6/83>A13 @067 9< 0<61<608< 8? A>/690=0<. 31=95 69A60A;
1B:=8513 45 671 :9/601; 68 671 8/0.0<9= ;>06 6 0; 9=;8 0<A8/:8/961341A9>;16719.06960<.:9/601;9/1/1F>0/1368 41 A8<;A08>; 948>6 6710/ /0.76; 9<3 ;78>=3 <86 ;78@ 9<5 ;=9AC<1;;0<1<?8/A0<.671;9B18@121/67130;A/1608< 0; 21;613 @067 671 6/09= 8>/6 68 9==8@ 671 9B1<3B1<6 @71/1 06 311B; ?06 0< 671 0<61/1;6 8? D>;60A1 68 3161/B0<1 671 9A6>9= F>1;608<; 8? =9@ 9<3 ?9A6; 0< 671 30;:>61 416@11< 671 :9/601; 9<3 9=;8 68 92803 B>=60:=0A065 8? :/8A1130<.; 8@121/ A9/1 79; 68 41 69C1< 68 A8<;031/ @71671/671A=90BB93145671:=90<60??0;60B149//138/ <86 + < 671 0<;69<6 A9;1 ><31/ 671 .021< :1A>=09/ ?9A6; 9<3 A0/A>B;69<A1; 8? 671 A9;1 671 /09= 8>/6 0< 8/31/ 68 3161/B0<1 671 9A6>9= F>1;608<; 0<28=213 0< 671
- 6 -
30;:>61 416@11< 671 :9/601; 9<3 68 92803 B>=60:=0A065 8? :/8A1130<.;79;9==8@136719B1<3B1<69;:/9513?8/ *$ 38 <86 ;11 9<5 /19;8< 68 0<61/?1/1 0< 671 30;A/1608< 1G1/A0;13 45 671 /09= 8>/6 .021< 671 :1A>=09/ ?9A6; 9<3 A0/A>B;69<A1; 8? 671 A9;1 8@121/ 06 0; 671 ;:1A0?0AA8<61<608<8?671:160608<1/6796671:/951/;8>.76 68410<6/83>A1345@958?9B1<3B1<60;60B149//13? 6796A8<61<608<0;69C1<45671:160608<1/31?1<39<60<70; @/0661<;6961B1<66841?0=13686719B1<313:=90<6671< 0< 6796 121<6 .021< ?9A6; 9<3 A0/A>B;69<A1;8? 671 A9;1 0<61/1;6 8? D>;60A1 @8>=3 41 B16 0? 671 /09= 8>/6 0;
30/1A613 68 6/196 671 0;;>1 :1/690<0<. 68 =0B069608< 9; :/1=0B0<9/50;;>19<3671/19?61/:/8A113@067671A9;1 ** 1<A1671?8==8@0<. 0 71/09=8>/6;79==.0219<8::8/6><065?8/ ?0=0<. 8? @/0661< ;6961B1<6 68 671 :160608<1/31?1<39<6686719B1<313:=90<6
- 7 -
9<3 0?
671 31?1<39<6 /90;1; 671 0;;>1 8? =0B069608< 0< /1;:1A6 8? :/951/ @70A7 0;
;8>.76 45 @95 8? 9B1<3B1<6 :/1=0B0<9/5 0;;>1 ;79== 41 ?/9B13 /1.9/30<. 671 ;9B1 9<3671/19?61/671/09=8>/6;79==:/8A113 @067671A9;1 00 9/601;9/130/1A61368A8"8:1/961@067671 /09=8>/6?8/F>0AC30;:8;9=8?6718/0.0<9= ;>06@0678>6:/950<.?8/9<593D8>/<B1<6 000 &/06 :160608< ;69<3; 30;:8;13 8? 9AA8/30<.=5
!)* '&( #
0;68*=8%$