Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58494 (KAR)
MALLANNA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201671/2025 · 2025-11-18
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58494 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58494 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$%
&$' $$
$
()!(*+,)! ( ++ -
! "
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
$
%
! "
"
& %
! %
%
&
- 3 -
'
(
)
*
%
* +$&
'
(
)
* !$
*
( ) !$ *(%)
%
+ *
*
%
#& & *
*
** $"() "()
"() () $() $() &"() ! () %
"& * % * * * ( )
#& &
*
%
,
- 4 -
( ,)
-. /012345.6 1.232345 37 839.6 :; 2-. 1.232345.<7 =56.<./2345!$48-0<023;00>0<3?=<0?7-005-320 & 7..?35> 0523/31024<; :039 35 <3@. 4#& & <.>372.<.6 :; .@:-0A3
493/. 202345 06>3< 372<3/2 1.5635>452-.839.482-.3A39=6>.056*-4<01=< 84<2-.488.5/.71=537-0:9.=56.<./23457$"()"()
"()()$()$()&"()!() <.06B32-./2345"&48-0<023;0;0;005-320&
-.>372482-./4@190352946>.645"&"&37 2-02 02 0:4=2 & 1@ 2-. ;4=5>.< :<42-.< 48 2-. /4@19035052 B07 022.@1235> 24 -05> B.2 /942-.7 45 0 190723/ 131. 732=02.6 35 05 41.5 0<.0 :.2B..5 2-. /4@19035052C7-4=7.0562-02482-.83<720//=7.622-02 D=5/2=<. 0//=7.6 47 056 # 099.>.69; <.@4A.6 2-. /942-.72-<.B2-.@0736.056637@0529.62-.190723/131. 8<4@ 2-. 41.5 710/. %-.5 2-. /4@19035052C7 ;4=5>.< :<42-.< E=.72345.6 2-.3< /456=/2 32 37 099.>.6 2-02 2-. - 5 -
0//=7.6 1.<7457 0770=92.6 2-. /4@19035052C7 80@39;
@.@:.<7 B32- 05 3<45 <46 056 0 723/? /0=735> ><3.A4=7 35D=<3.7 457.E=.529; 0 /4@190352 B07 946>.6 <.7=9235> 35<.>372<02345482-./07.35<3@.4#& &
.0<5.6/4=57.984<2-.1.232345.<7<.32.<0235>2-. ><4=567 =<>.6 35 2-. 1.232345 7=:@327 2-02 2-. 35/36.52 -07<.7=92.6350/07.056/4=52.<+/07.0562-.6371=2.37 .77.523099;/3A3935502=<../452.5672-022-.1.232345.<7 35/9=635>B4@.5@.@:.<7482-.80@39;-0A.:..58097.9; 3@193/02.6 . 8=<2-.< 7=:@327 2-02 .A.5 07 1.< 2-. /4@190352 2-. 71./383/ 4A.<2 0/27 0<. 022<3:=2.6 459; 24 0//=7.6470560//=7.64:.35>099.>.624-0A. 0770=92.6B32-053<45<460560//=7.64B32-0723/? -.<.@03535>0//=7.6-0A.:..53@193/02.6B32-4=205; 71./383/ 099.>023457 -.<.84<. -. 7=:@327 2-02 2-. 1.232345.<7 42-.< 2-05 0//=7.6 47 056 0<. .52329.6 241<42./23458<4@2-374=<2
- 6 -
! .< /452<0 2-. 9.0<5.6 3>- 4=<2 4A.<5@.52 9.06.< 7=:@327 2-02 099 2-. 0//=7.6 -0A. 10<23/3102.6 35 2-. A349.52 35/36.52 542B32-7205635> 2-. 80/2 2-02 2-. =56.<9;35> 6371=2. @0; :. /3A39 35 502=<. . 2-.<.84<. /452.5672-022-37375420832/07.84<><052480523/31024<; :039.A.5242-.42-.<0//=7.6
0A35> -.0<6 2-. 9.0<5.6 /4=57.9 011.0<35> 45 :42-736.72-.84994B35>143520<37.784</45736.<02345
!! " #
$
%
&
$ '()* ()* ()+* )* ')* ')* !()* , + +)*
- $ (! . $ !+/
# 50/0<.8=9<.0635>482-./4@1903523237.A36.52 2-022-.6371=2.37.77.523099;/3A3935502=<.0<3735>8<4@
- 7 -
=7. 48 0 /4@@45 710/. :.2B..5 2B4 06D43535> 80@393.7 -.7/=889.011.0<724-0A.:..52<3>>.<.6:;2-.099.>.6 0/2 48 2-. 0//=7.6 35 <.@4A35> 2-. 190723/ 131. 056 2-<4B35> 2-. /942-.7 2-02 B.<. -=5> 4=2 24 6<; 2 2-37 1<.93@350<;720>.45.F0@3535>2-.4A.<20/27022<3:=2.6 24 .0/- 0//=7.6 32 37 /9.0< 8<4@ 2-. 83<72 3584<@052C7 A.<7345 2-02 459; 1.232345.< 47 056 0<. 099.>.6 24 -0A. 0770=92.6 2-. /4@19035052C7 80@39; @.@:.<7 4 71./383/4A.<20/270<.022<3:=2.6241.232345.<47! 056#24
1.<=709482-./0=7.2329.09743563/02.72-022-. .523<. B4@.5849? 48 2-.
0//=7.6 80@39; -0A. :..5 3@193/02.645736.<35>2-0235A.723>023453772399=56.<B0; 056352-.0:7.5/.4805;71./383/4A.<20/27022<3:=2.624 2-.@2-374=<237482-.A3.B2-021.232345.<47! 056 # 24 0<. .52329.6 24 0523/31024<; :039 -.3< @.<. 1<.7.5/. 35 1<4F3@32; 0<3735> 8<4@ 2-. 80/2 2-02 :42- 80@393.7<.736.06D0/.5224.0/-42-.</05542:.0><4=56
- 8 -
24 6.5; 2-.@ 1<42./2345 //4<635>9; 2-. 14352 84< /45736.<0234537057B.<.610<29;352-.0883<@023A. $*4<2-.84<.>435><.074572-374=<21077.72-. 84994B35>
-.1.2323453710<29;0994B.6
-. 1.232345 37 <.D./2.6 357480< 07 1.232345.< 47 0560<./45/.<5.6
4B.A.<93:.<2;37<.7.<A.6241.232345.<47056 24 7=<<.56.< :.84<.2-. D=<3763/234509 4=<2 056 0119; 84< <.>=90<:039
-. <.71456.52G
493/. 0<. 63<./2.6 24 <.9.07. 1.232345.<47!056#2445:039352-..A.5248 2-.3< 0<<.72 35 /455./2345 B32- <3@. 4#& & <.>372.<.6 :; .@:-0A3
493/. 202345 06>3< 372<3/2 1.5635>452-.839.482-.3A39=6>.056*-4<01=< 84<2-.488.5/.71=537-0:9.=56.<./23457$"()"()
- 9 -
"()()$()$()&"()!() <.06 B32- ./2345 "& 48 2-. -0<023;0 ;0;0 05-320 &7=:D./2242-.84994B35>/456323457
3)
.232345.< 47 ! 056 # 24 7-099 011.0< :.84<. 2-. 5A.723>0235> 883/.< B32-35 8382..5() 60;78<4@ 2-. 602.48<./.31248 0 /.<2383.6 /41; 48 2-37 4<6.< 056 7-099 .F./=2. 1.<74509 :4567 84< 0 7=@ 48 7&&&&& + (=1..7 5.0?-459;).0/-B32-2B47=<.23.7 84< 2-. 93?. 7=@ 24 2-. 7023780/2345 48 2-. 5A.723>0235> 883/.<
33) -.;7-099/4+41.<02. B32- 2-. 35A.723>02345 056 7-099 011.0< :.84<. 2-. 5A.723>0235>
883/.<07056B-.5<.E=3<.6
333) -.; 7-099 542 20@1.< B32- 2-.1<47./=2345 B325.77.7 4< .A36.5/. .32-.< 63<./29; 4< 3563<./29;
3A)-.;7-099<.>=90<9;011.0<:.84<.2-.<309 4=<26=<35>2-./4=<7.481<4/..635>7=59.77 .F.@12.684<A0936<.07457:;2-.<3094=<2
- 10 -
A) -.; 7-099 542 35A49A. 2-.@7.9A.7 35 05;
73@390<4<42-.</<3@35090/23A323.7358=2=<. A3) .35> 06D43535> 4B5.<7 2-.; 7-099 =56.<20?. 542 24 352.<8.<. 4< 356=9>. 35 05; 73@390<0/2748A349.5/.6=<35>2-.1.56.5/;48 2-.35A.723>023450562<309
., ( $$+ '
372494