Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58456 (KAR)

DIGAMBAR AND ORS v. THE STATE

CRL.RP/200019/2022 · 2025-07-15

V Srishananda

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#!$ #$ % &%'()* +%(( , !! ! " #! $ ! % "! $ ! ! ! & % # ! $ !% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !&'( & !! " ! ! & ! '' & & ! ! & " ) $! ) % *+,- ,. +/0123 !+0.4 4*+,/*- 516/2*4 +77*+,./8 91,03*7*0.0.1/*,2+/-,.+:+-+,3+3+;6--./4*+,/*- .83 16,0 1<*,/:*/0 !4*+-*, +77*+,./8 91, 03* ,*271/-*/00+0* 3*,*<.2.1/7*0.0.1/*,2+,*03*+5562*-7*,21/2 =31 2699*,*- +/1,-*, 1951/<.50.1/./ 1'' +/-2*/0*/5*-+26/-*, - 3 - !"# $ %&' % ( !$# $ %&' % ( ) ! !# $ %&' % # ( ) *$# $ %&' % # ( - 4 - *"# $ %&' % *+,- '&' !+ &. / 0 1 3* <+4.-.0> 19 03* 1,-*, 19 51/<.50.1/ +/- 2*/0*/5* =+2 ?6*20.1/*- ;*91,* 03* .20,.50 16,0 ./ ,.:./+477*+41 @ *+,/*- 6-8* ./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0 +90*, 2*56,./8 03* ,*51,-2 3*+,- 03* +,86:*/02 1903*7+,0.*2 ./-*0+.4+/-+441=*-03*+77*+4./7+,0;>:1-.9>./803* A6-8:*/0 19 51/<.50.1/ +/- 1,-*, 19 2*/0*/5* 7+22*- ;> 03*4*+,/*- ,.+4+8.20,+0* - 5 - 3*,*91,* 03* 7*0.0.1/*,2 +,* ;*91,* 03.2 16,0 ./03.2+77*+4 B &+502 ./ ;,.*9 =3.53 +,* 60:120 /*5*22+,> 91, -.2712+41903*7,*2*/0,*<.2.1/7*0.0.1/*,+,*+26/-*, 3* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/*,2 =*,* 53+,8*23**0*- ;> 03* 31=C !14.5* 0+0.1/ +4+;6,8. 1/ 03* 51:74+./0 41-8*- ;> ;-64 +00+, 51/0*/-./8 03+0 1/ +0 +;160 7:./ 9,1/0 19 /*= +AC+:+4 +, +/- *20+6,+/0 2.06+0*- +0 6:/+;+- ,1+- =3*/ 51:74+./+/0 +/- 3.2 9,.*/- =*,* 81./8 01 03* 7*0,14 76:7 01 9.44 03* -.*2*4 ./ 03*., 5+, ;*+,./8 1@D@B ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/*,2 ;*./8 03* 7*-*20,.+/2 =*,* =+4C./8 1/ 03* 5*/0,* 19 03* ,1+- B 3* 5+, =+2 -,.<*/ ;> 03* 9,.*/- 19 03* 51:74+./+/0+/-3*20177*-03*5+,+/-810-1=/9,1:3.2 5+, +/- ,*?6*20*- 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 01 4*+<* 03*=+> 91,03*5+,+/-03*>23164-=+4C1/03*91107+03 /03+0 251,* 03*,* =+2 +/ +40*,5+0.1/ =3*,*./ 03* ,*<.2.1/ - 6 - 7*0.0.1/*,2 +;62*- 03* 9,.*/- 19 03* 51:74+./+/0 ./ 9.403> 4+/86+8*+/-+5562*-13*4-9,.*/-1903*51:74+./+/0 0.8304> +/- +22+640*- 3.: 1/ 3.2 ;+5C +/- 201:+53 =.03 3+/-25562*-1+22+640*-=.03.,1/,1-1/3.23*+- +/- 5+62*- ;4**-./8 ./A6,> 5562*- 1 +22+640*- =.03 .,1/24100*-2711/1/3.29+5*+/-03*,*;>5+62*-;4**-./8 ./A6,.*2 B"3*/03*51:74+./+/0=*/001,*256*3.29,.*/- +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 +;62*- 03* 51:74+./+/0 +421 ./ 9.403>4+/86+8*+/-+22+640*-3.:=.033+/-21/3.2*/0.,* ;1-> B 90*, +22+640 03* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/*,2 8+<* 4.9* 03,*+00103*51:74+./+/0+/-3.29,.*/-03+003*>=.440+C* +=+>03*.,4.9* ( 90*, ,*8.20,+0.1/ 19 03* 5+2* /<*20.8+0.1/ 8*/5> ./<*20.8+0*- 03* :+00*, ./ -*0+.4 +/- 9.4*- 53+,8*23**0+8+./2003*+5562*-7*,21/2 - 7 - !,*2*/5*19 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 =*,* 2*56,*- ;*91,*03*16,0+/-53+,8*2=*,*9,+:*- ' 5562*-7*,21/274*+-*-/1086.40> 3*,*91,* 0,.+4=+23*4- /1,-*,01;,./831:*03*86.401903*+5562*- 7,12*560.1/ ./ +44 *E+:./*- 2.E =.0/*22*2 +2 !" 01 !"B +/- 74+5*- 1/ ,*51,- 9.<* -156:*/02 =3.53 =*,* *E3.;.0*-+/-:+,C*-+2E2!01! ;-64 +4**: .2 03* ./A6,*- +/- 3.2 =16/- 5*,0.9.5+0* :+,C*- +0 *E3.;.0 !@ 231=2 03+0 03*,* .2 + 8,.*<162 ./A6,> 103 ;-64 +00+, +/- ;-64 +4**: 26771,0*- 03* 5+2* 19 03* 7,12*560.1/ ./ 0101 710 :+3+F+, .2 7,1<*- ;> 03* /<*20.8+0.1/ 99.5*, =3*,*6/-*, +/- =*,*2*.F*- 3*,*+90*, 4*+,/*- ,.+4 6-8* ,*51,-*- 03* +5562*-20+0*:*/02+2.251/0*:74+0*-6/-*,*50.1/ 19 1-* 19 ,.:./+4 !,15*-6,* +/- /10.5./8 03+0 .0 .2 - 8 - +5562*- 1 =31 3+2 +22+640*- !" =.03 +/- ,*2640./8 ./ 8,.*<162 ./A6,> 51/<.50*- +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 91, 199*/5*2 6/-*, *50.1/2 @ B @ +/-B,*+-=.03*50.1/@1903*/-.+/!*/+41-* 1=*<*, 4*+,/*- 6-8* ./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0 +441=*- 03* +77*+4 ./ 7+,0 +/- :+./0+./*- 03* 51/<.50.1/ 19 +5562*- 1 +41/* 91, 03* 199*/5* 6/-*, *50.1/B1903*/-.+/!*/+41-*+/-+421:+./0+./*- 03* 51/<.50.1/ 19 +5562*- 1 +41/* 91, 03* 199*/5* 76/.23+;4*6/-*,*50.1/@1903*/-.+/!*/+41-* @ &6,03*, 4*+,/*- 6-8* ./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0+5?6.00*-+5562*-12+/-91,03*199*/5*6/-*, *50.1/ B 19 03* /-.+/ !*/+4 1-* +/- +421 +5?6.00*- +5562*- 12 +/- 91, 03* 199*/5* 76/.23+;4* 6/-*, *50.1/@1903*/-.+/!*/+41-*/219+,+203*103*, 199*/5*2+,*51/5*,/*-4*+,/*- ,.+416,051/9.,:*-03* 1,-*,1951/<.50.1/+/-2*/0*/5* - 9 - *./8 96,03*, +88,.*<*- ;> 03* 2+:* +5562*- 7*,21/2+,*;*91,*03.216,0./03.2,*<.2.1/7*0.0.1/ B ,. +/0123 !+0.4 4*+,/*- 516/2*4 91, 03* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/*,2 ,*.0*,+0./8 03* 8,16/-2 6,8*- ./ 03* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/ <*3*:*/04> 51/0*/-*- 03+0 ;103 03* 16,02 3+<* /10 7,17*,4> +77,*5.+0*- 03* :+0*,.+4 *<.-*/5* 1/ ,*51,- ./ 7,17*, :+//*, ,*2640./8 ./ :.25+,,.+8*19A620.5* ( *=164-96,03*,51/0*/-03+0+0,.<.+4./5.-*/0 3+2;**/;41=/160197,171,0.1/+/-+9+42*53+,8*23**0 5+:* 01 ;* 9.4*- ;>03*/<*20.8+0.1/ 8*/5> +8+./20 03* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/*,2 =3.53 3+2 ;**/ *20+;4.23*- 03,1683 031,16835,122*E+:./+0.1/1903*7,12*560.1/=.0/*22*2 *27*5.+44> !" +/- !" =3.53 3+2 ;**/ .8/1,*- ;> ;103 03* 16,02 +/- 216830 91, +441=./8 03* ,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/ 40*,/+0.<*4> ,. +/0123 !+0.4 =164- 51/0*/- 03+0+4403*+5562*-7*,21/2=*,*./56201->91,+7*,.1- - 10 - 19 2*<*/ -+>2 +/- 0+C./8 /10* 19 03* 2+:* 2./5* 03* 7*0.0.1/*,2+,*03*9.,200.:*199*/-*,2+/-./03*+;2*/5* 19 D,+> 9.4: +/- ,+-.1418.5+4 ,*71,0 74+5*- ;> 03* 7,12*560.1/ 03* 51/<.50.1/ 1,-*, /**-2 01 ;* :1-.9.*- *<*/ ./ ,*27*50 19 +5562*- 1 91, 03* 199*/5* 6/-*, *50.1/B19/-.+/!*/+41-*+/-21683091,+441=./8 03*,*<.2.1/ 7*0.0.1/ 01 03+0*E0*/0 ;> */3+/5./8 03* 9./* +:16/0+/-2*00./8+2.-*03*.:7,.21/:*/07*,.1- ' & ,. +:+-+, 3+3+;6--./ 4*+,/*- .83 16,0 1<*,/:*/0 !4*+-*, 26771,02 03* .:768/*- A6-8:*/0 +/- 51/0*/-*- 03+0 <146/0+,.4> +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/23+<*5+62*-./A6,.*201!"+/-!"*.F6,* 19 +/- :+C*2 .0 54*+, 03+0 03* ./A6,.*2 2620+./*- ;> !" .2 ;> +22+640 9,1: +/- =3.533+2;**/,.8304>+77,*5.+0*-;>;10303*16,02 *=164-96,03*,51/0*/-03+04*+,/*-6-8*./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0 /10*- 03+0 .0 .2 +5562*- 1 =31 +22+640*- =.03 01 !" ,*2640./8 ./ 8,.*<162 - 11 - ./A6,.*2+/-03*,*91,*03*,*.2/1*4*:*/0197,*51/5*,0 +:1/8 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 21 +2 01 +00,+50 03* 199*/5* 6/-*,*50.1/B,*+-=.03*50.1/@1903*/-.+/!*/+4 1-* +/- 03*,*91,* /1 96,03*, :1-.9.5+0.1/ 19 03* 51/<.50.1/+/-2*/0*/5*.2.:7*,:.22.;4*3+<./8,*8+,-01 03*4.:.0*-71=*,219,*<.2.1/+4A6,.2-.50.1/+/-21683091, -.2:.22+41903*,*<.2.1/7*0.0.1/./0101 +<./83*+,-03*+,86:*/021/;1032.-*203.2 16,07*,62*-03*:+0*,.+41/,*51,-:*0.5641624> /26537*,62+41903*:+0*,.+41/,*51,-03* ./5.-*/0 +2 .2 */6/5.+0*- ;> 03* 7,12*560.1/ 20+/-2 *20+;4.23*- ;> 74+5./8 /*5*22+,> 1,+4 +/- -156:*/0+,> *<.-*/5*1/,*51,- !"+/-!"/101/4>.-*/0.9.*-03*+5562*- 7*,21/2 ;*91,* 03* 16,0 ;60 +421 -*712*- ;*91,* 03* 16,0 =.03 8,+73.5 -*0+.42 +2 01 03* ./5.-*/0 03+0 3+2 1556,,*- =3*,*./ +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 +22+640*- !"2*19 +/-;>+5562*-12+/-.2+421 - 12 - *20+;4.23*- /10 1/4> 9,1: 03* 1,+4 0*20.:1/> ;60 03* 2*.F6,* 19 03* 2+:* 6/-*, 03* 7+/53+/+:+ /219+, +2 +5562*- 1 .2 51/5*,/*- 3* 3+2 +22+640*- 03* !" +/-!"=.033+/-2 @ +C./8 /10* 19 03*2* +27*502 19 03* :+00*, 51674*- =.03 03* "16/- *,0.9.5+0* 4*+,/*- ,.+4 6-8* =+2A620.9.*-./51/<.50./803*+5562*-7*,21/2 1=*<*,.0.201;*/10*-03+001*20+;4.2303* 8,.*<162./A6,.*2*E5*70*<.-*/5*19!"+/-0*20.:1/> 19 03* 1501, =31 .226*- E!@ 03*,* +,* /1 103*, :+0*,.+4*<.-*/5*1/,*51,-/03*+;2*/5*191,.8./+4D ,+>9.4:1,03* +-.1418.5+4 *71,0 ,.+46-8*16830/10 3+<*51/<.50*-03*+5562*-7*,21/291,03*199*/5*6/-*, *50.1/B1903*/-.+/!*/+41-* B *+,/*- 6-8* ./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0 031683 +5?6.00*- +5562*- 12 +/- 91, 03* 199*/5* 6/-*, *50.1/ B 19 03* /-.+/ !*/+4 1-* :+./0+./*- 03*51/<.50.1/./,*27*5019+5562*-191,62*19 - 13 - +/- 03* ./A6,> 03+0 3+2 ;**/ 5+62*- 01 !" ;> 62* 19 ( 8+./ 03* 4*+,/*- 6-8* ./ 03* &.,20 77*44+0* 16,0.8/1,*-03*7,./5.74*2194+=*/6/5.+0*-./03*5+2* 19 ,*71,0*-./ =3.4*:+./0+././803*51/<.50.1/ 19+5562*-191,03*199*/5*6/-*,*50.1/B1903* /-.+/!*/+41-*5+44./891,./0*,9*,*/5*;>03.216,0./ 03.2,*<.2.1/ +C./8/10*1903*9+5003+003*+5562*-=*,*./ 56201-> 91, + 7*,.1- 19 2*<*/ -+>2 +0 03* 0.:* 19 ./<*20.8+0.1/ .9 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 +,* +441=*- 03* ;*/*9.01956201->7*,.1-+2+7*,.1-19.:7,.21/:*/091, 03* ,*:+././8 199*/5*2 ;> */3+/5./8 03* 9./* +:16/0 01 ;*7+.-;>+5562*-12+/-./+26:19 2 *+53 +/-+5562*- 1 ./+26:19 2 */-219 A620.5*=164-;*:*0 ' 551,-./84>03*91441=./8 - 14 - .% 3*,*<.2.1/7*0.0.1/.2+441=*-./7+,0 ..% 5562*- 1 .2 +5?6.00*- 91, 03* 199*/5* 6/-*, *50.1/ B 19 03* /-.+/ !*/+4 1-* ...% 3* 51/<.50.1/ 19 +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 91,,*:+././8199*/5*2.2:+./0+./*- .<% 3*56201->7*,.1-192*<*/-+>2+4,*+-> 6/-*,81/* ;> 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 .2 0,*+0*-+203*7*,.1-19.:7,.21/:*/091, 03* ,*:+././8 7,1<*- 199*/5*2 ;> */3+/5./8 03* 9./* +:16/0 01 ;* 7+.- ;> +5562*- 1 +/- ./ + 26: 19 2 *+53 +/- +5562*- 1 ./ + 26: 19 2 1/ 1, ;*91,* <% &+.46,*017+>03**/3+/5*-9./*+:16/0 +44 03* +5562*- 7*,21/2 23+44 6/-*,81 2.:74* .:7,.21/:*/0 91, + 7*,.1- 19 1/* >*+, - 15 - <.% 601903*9./*+:16/0,*51<*,*-+26: 19 2( .2 1,-*,*- 01 ;* 7+.- +2 51:7*/2+0.1/01!" <..% 99.5*.2-.,*50*-01,*06,/03* ,.+416,0 *51,-2 =.03 517> 19 03.2 1,-*, 91, .226* 19:1-.9.*-51/<.50.1/=+,,+/0 ,-*,*-+551,-./84> -) %$( ! ! .20141 !