- 1 - !" #$%$$ $ &' &()* '&)) + !"#$ % & !"#$ $ $! '" "% ( %( #'"# " % $$ ) $ ##"# $ ) ' ) ( ##"# * + ( , Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )% % )% % % + ( !"!, % $ ( (- !"! * + ). ) ( ) ( ), ) ! ) +"!), ) % / !## # + ' #" ) ( ,) )) !'+, '+, ! +, $ $ +, '#)#$ ) )( ) ( ) 0 % - 3 - + 0 % , 123 45626278 23 92:5; <= 615 28:>?3 79 615 35@78; A53478;586 @7B4:>28>86355C28DEF>3128D796154A7@55;28D3 458;28D 28 7 # +>A2328D 7F6 79 A2B5 7' #" A5D2365A5; <= >8G2 7:2@5 6>6278 236A2@6 >2@1FA,7861592:5792G2:F;D5>8;)>6>8G297A615 79958@53 4F8231><:5 F8;5A 5@62783 !'+, '+, ! +,$ $ +,A ?5@6278'#796151>A>62=>=>=> >8126> #$ )>@63:5>;28D67615@>35>A5>3F8;5A 15 35@78; A53478;586H;>FD165A28:>? 1>3 :7;D5; > ?A26658@7B4:>28678#!#">::5D28D61>678&#" >6 ><7F6 $# >B 15A 1F3<>8; >8; 28:>?3 G23265; 15A 4>A586>: 17F35 >8; >::5D5;:= ><F35; 15A 28 92:61= :>8DF>D5 >8; 3F<I5@65; 15A 67 1>A>33B586 @628D F478 615 3>2; @7B4:>286615IFA23;2@6278>:7:2@51>G5A5D2365A5;>@>3528 A2B5 7' #" 97A 615 79958@53 A5:>628D 67 @AF5:6= >8; 7615A>::25;4A7G232783478@7B4:562787928G5362D>6278615 - 4 - 8G5362D>628D 992@5A 1>3 92:5; 615 @1>AD5 31556 <597A5 615 @7B456586 7FA6 15 456262785A3 ?17 >A5 >AA>=5; >3 >@@F35;7367<528D6159>615A28:>?B7615A28:>? >8; 61A55 B>AA25; 32365A328:>? 79 615 @7B4:>28>86 1>G5 >44A7>@15; 6123 7FA6 355C28D EF>3128D 79 615 4A7@55;28D3 78615DA7F8;61>6615>::5D>62783B>;528615@7B4:>286>A5 D585A>:G>DF5>8;7B82<F3288>6FA5623@78658;5;61>6 615A5>A587345@292@7G5A6>@63>66A2<F65;67615456262785A3 >8; 61>6 615 4A53586 4A7@55;28D3 >A5 >8 ><F35 79 615 4A7@53379:>?28262>65;7F67945A378>:>82B7326=A53F:628D 28 > 6>2865; 28G5362D>6278 @F:B28>628D 28 615 92:28D 79 615 @1>AD531556 $ 5>A; 615 :5>A85; @7F835: >445>A28D 97A 615 456262785A3 615 :5>A85; 2D1 7FA6 7G5A8B586 :5>;5A A54A5358628D 615 92A36 A53478;586H6>65 >8; 615 :5>A85; @7F835:>445>A28D97A61535@78;A53478;586H@7B4:>28>86 " 597A5 >;G5A628D 67 615 A2G>: @7865862783 6123 7FA6;55B326>44A74A2>65675J6A>@6615A5:5G>8647A627879 - 5 - 615 ?A26658 @7B4:>286 :7;D5; <= 615 35@78; A53478;586H ;>FD165A28:>??12@1A5>;3>397::7?3 & #" $# !" #$% &'() #$% *+ , - & ./0 1 , 2(34 3*&2 5 67) 8(') #$% 2(&9) #$% :* 5 /; +1 <=,>? @AB@C$< , D&E &F. , #*&G - *6 AB < , D G 5 7H I @ 1 , K 3& *; <& +J&K .*, = L I <1 5 = :& <& I= .*, L*1 M @ -& K ./ +J&K .*, 5N :& >5=N* *+ KA. .*, 5N3& *; <& +J&K .*,= < O&5 P Q, 5NK RN* *+ .S:*TIT,UV- @ !" :* - & ./ I !" ;=W:*@=&E5 7H*+Q+X.*, 5=N :* 7HPX @ 1 , *&Y& 17HPX - 0 .! W I 5=* Z + W I .& +#*&! <[K + L ,M\ ]^ I * 1 - 6 - <&+ -& .! X :* SPM\ _ 7 <&+`&N/,5`&3.* (D \N VL 15 ><7G5 5J6A>@65; 47A6278 79 615 @7B4:>286 <A7>;:= ;542@63 615 >::5D>62783 :5G5::5; <= 615 35@78; A53478;586H ;>FD165A28:>?>D>283615A1F3<>8;>8;28:>?3845AF3>: 79 615 @>F35 626:5 26 23 5G2;586 61>6 456262785A 7 615 B7615A28:>?23>=5>A7:;:>;=A532;28D45AB>8586:=>6 >2@1FA 56262785A 7 615 9>615A28:>? 23 > &=5>A7:; A562A5; 7G5A8B586 35AG>86 >:37 A532;28D >6 >2@1FA 56262785A3 $ 67 >A5 615 B>AA25; 32365A328:>? 79 615 @7B4:>28>86 5>@1 79 615B ?5::3566:5; 28 6152A A5345@62G5 4A795332783>8;:2G28D354>A>65:=28;2995A586@2625356262785A 7$ 23 > 4A>@62@28D 7@67A A532;28D >6 5:>8D>8> ?12:5 456262785A3 73" >8; >A5 796?>A5 8D2855A3 3566:5; >6 58D>:FAF 15 B>65A2>: 78 A5@7A; 61F3 ;23@:7353 61>6 8785 79615456262785A3>A5A532;28D?261615@7B4:>28>86>8;15A 1F3<>8;>8;615A523875G2;58@579615B1>G28D31>A5;> @7BB7817F3517:;>6>8=472867962B5 - 7 - 8 > @>A59F: 3@AF628= 79 615 @1>AD5 31556 B>65A2>: 6123 7FA6 23 @7836A>285; 67 7<35AG5 61>6 26 23 =56 >87615A2836>8@5A59:5@628D615A>B4>86B23F35794A7G232783 >8>:7D7F3 67 5@6278 "'! 79 615 8;2>8 58>: 7;5 87? @7AA53478;28D675@6278! 796151>A>62=>=>=>>8126> #$2B5>8;>D>28615 78M<:5F4A5B57FA6>8;6123 7FA61>G55J4A5335;35A27F3@78@5A87G5A615658;58@=79 2B4:2@>628D6155862A59>B2:=796151F3<>8;28@:F;28D>D5; 4>A5863>8;;236>86A5:>62G53?2617F6>8=345@292@7A@A5;2<:5 >::5D>6278315:5D23:>62G5286586<5128;28@7A47A>628D458>: 4A7G232783 A5:>628D 67 @AF5:6= ?>3 67 5J658; 4A765@6278 67 ?7B58 >D>2836 D58F285 >@63 79 1>A>33B586 >8; @AF5:6= ?26128615B>6A2B782>:17B5 7?5G5A262387?9A5EF586:= 8762@5; 61>6 3F@1 4A7G232783 >A5 28G7C5; >3 > ?5>478 79 A56>:2>6278A>615A61>8>3125:;794A765@6278 6 23 F897A6F8>65 61>6 28 615 4A53586 @>35 615 >D5; 4>A586328:>? ?17 >A5 :2G28D 354>A>65:= >6 >2@1FA 1>G5 <558 >AA>=5; >3 >@@F35; ;534265 615A5 <528D 87 >::5D>6278 79 6152A 4>A62@24>6278 7A 28362D>6278 28 615 >::5D5; >@63 G58 B7A5 ;236FA<28D 23 615 B5@1>82@>: 28@:F3278 79 - 8 - 456262785A3 $ 67 615 B>AA25; 32365A328:>? ?17 >A5 >:: 12D1:=5;F@>65;4A79533278>:3A532;28D28;2995A586@2625315 8G5362D>628D992@5A?2617F65J>B2828D6152B4A7<><2:26=79 6152A28G7:G5B5867AG5A29=28D6152A28;5458;58636>6F31>3 4A7@55;5; 67 92:5 > @1>AD5 31556 37:5:= 78 615 36A58D61 79 7B82<F3 >8; 3?55428D >::5D>62783 B>;5 28 615 @7B4:>286 F@1 >8 28G5362D>6278 ;5G72; 79 ;F5 >44:2@>6278 79 B28; A53F:63286151>A>33B586792887@58645A3783>8;6A2G2>:2N53 615G5A=4FA47357961536>6F67A=4A7G23278 & <>A5 A5>;28D 79 615 5J6A>@65; 47A6278 79 615 @7B4:>286A5G5>:361>6615A5>A587345@292@7A4A7J2B>65>@63 >66A2<F65; 67 61535 456262785A3 15 5862A5 6587A 79 615 @7B4:>28647286367?>A;3>B>6A2B782>:;23@7A;<56?558615 @7B4:>28>86 >8; 15A 1F3<>8; +>@@F35; 7, ?17 ?5A5 >;B2665;:= A532;28D >6 =;5A><>; 15 >::5D>62783 >D>2836 615 28:>?3 >A5 D585A>: 28 8>6FA5 @7F@15; 28 G>DF5 :>8DF>D5 >8; 5G2;586:= >8 >965A617FD16 67 2B4:2@>65 615 1F3<>8;M3 9>B2:= B5B<5A3 7FA63 1>G5 A545>65;:= 5B41>32N5;61>6?15861528:>?3>8;B>AA25;32365A328:>? >A5 :2G28D 354>A>65:= >8; 1>G5 87 A7:5 28 615 ;>=67;>= - 9 - >99>2A379615@7F4:5A7428D615B28>B7F86367@:5>A><F35 79 615 @A2B28>: IF362@5 3=365B 78628F>6278 79 3F@1 4A7@55;28D3 876 78:= A53F:63 28 1FB2:2>6278 >8; 6A>FB> 67 5:;5A:= >8; A5345@6><:5 28;2G2;F>:3 <F6 >:37 F8;5AB2853 615 @A5;2<2:26= 79 D58F285 @>353 ?15A5 ?7B58 >A5 28;55; 3F<I5@65;67@AF5:6= ! 8 6123 @7865J6 6123 7FA6 23 79 615 @7832;5A5; G25? 61>6 >::7?28D 615 4A735@F6278 67 @78628F5 >D>2836 615 456262785A3?7F:;>B7F8667>B23@>AA2>D579IF362@5>8;>8 ><F35796154A7@53379:>?15456262785A34>A62@F:>A:=615 >D5; 4>A586328:>? >8; 615 B>AA25; 32365A328:>? :5>;28D 28;5458;586:2G53;535AG54A765@62789A7B3F@1F8?>AA>865; 4A735@F6278154A7@55;28D3615A597A5@>8876<53F36>285; >D>2836 615B 7?5G5A 615 @>35 >3 >D>2836 >@@F35; 7 6151F3<>8;B>=4A7@55;28>@@7A;>8@5?261:>? ' )7A 615 97A5D728D A5>3783 6123 7FA6 4>3353 615 97::7?28D 2 15A2B28>:56262782315A5<=>::7?5; - 10 - 22 15 4A7@55;28D3 28 7 # +>A2328D 7F6 79A2B57' #"A5D2365A5;<=>8G27:2@5 6>6278 236A2@6 >2@1FA, 458;28D <597A5 615 7FA6796152G2:F;D5>8;)>8G297A615 79958@53 4F8231><:5 F8;5A 5@62783 !'+, '+, ! +, $ $ +, A5>; ?261 5@6278 '# 79 615 1>A>62=> =>=> >8126> #$>A5 EF>315; 28379>A>3 615 456262785A3>A5 @78@5A85; 222 15 6A2>: >D>2836 >@@F35; 7 B>= @78628F5 28 >@@7A;>8@5?261:>? ,* &$$) % 2367:7$$