Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58448 (KAR)
SHIVAPPA v. NARAYANRAO VITHALRAO KULKARNI
MFA/202359/2022 · 2025-07-15
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58448 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58448 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"# "
$! % #!&'
% !#!! ! !$$
()* +& ! !$$ ,
()*
! !$$
()*
! !$$
,
()*
! !$$
()*
! !$$
()*
! !$$
&
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"# ! $
! %#&'(
"
$
! "&$)*&' +
(,(
-
"
*, .&&
(,("("" ,$"(. )/ 0
! !$$ ,
&
- 3 -
!1' ! $
! %#&'(
"
$
! "&$)*&' +
(,(
-
"
*, .&&
(,("("" #$"(. )/ 0
! !$$
&
- 4 -
!1(
! $
! %#&'(
"
$
! %#&'(
"&$)*&' +
(,(
-
"
*, .&&
(,("("" 1$"(. )/ 0
! !$$
,
&
$
!,. ! $
! 0+!%#&'(&
+
)/
- 5 -
! ! $
! %#&'("
"&$)*&' +
(,(
"
%#&'(
+
)/
-
"
*, .&&
(,("(""
1$"(. /
1....($)
2
! !$$
&
$
!1#
- 6 -
! $
! 0+!%#&'(&
+
)/
! ! $
! %#&'("
"&$)*&' +
(,(
"
%#&'(
+
)/
-
"
*, .&&
(,("(""
#$"(. /
- 7 -
1....($)
2
! !$$
&
!"1 ! $
! 0+!%#&'(&
+
)/
! ! $
! %#&'("
"&$)*&' +
(,(
"
%#&'(
+
)/
-
"
- 8 -
*, .&&
(,("(""
,$"(. /
.(,((($)
2
! ! 3
3
# ! 3
44567689:;<7<9576:=58>?@AA<?:8<44@B:;<?@CC@8 DE>9C<8:58>5F5A>>5:<>(,("(""68 @4, 1 58> # @B "(.
@8 :;< B67< @B :;< @:@A ??6><8:
756C4 A6GE857 @/ 6D5=5HEA5 IA6GE8572 B@A 4;@A:
G@:;:;<84EA58?< @CH58=58>:;<?756C58:45A<G<B@A< :;64 @EA:68:;<4<5HH<574
- 9 -
" ;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= ;54 544567<> :;< DE>9C<8: 58> 5F5A> @8 :;< 9A@E8> @B 765G676:= 58> JE58:EC;<?756C58:4;5K<4@E9;:B@A<8;58?<C<8:@B ?@CH<845:6@8
, <5A> :;< 7<5A8<> ?@E84<7 5HH<5A689 B@A :;< 84EA58?< @CH58=58>:;<7<5A8<>?@E84<75HH<5A689B@A :;<?756C58:458>H<AE4<>:;<C5:<A657@8A<?@A>
1 <5A8<> ?@E84<7 5HH<5A689 B@A :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= F@E7> ?@8:<8> :;5: :;< A6GE857 ;54 B567<> :@ HA@H<A7= 5HHA<?65:< :;< <K6><8?< @B " ?@CH756858: F;6?;6468?@8464:<8:58>E8A<765G7<:64?@8:<8><>:;5:
<H@A: >@<4 8@: 68>6?5:< 58= >5C59< :@ :;< BA@8:
H@A:6@8 @B :;< A5?:@A :;E4 ?@8:A5>6?:689 :;< ?756C @B
" F;@ 4:5:<> :;5: :;< 684EA<> A5?:@A ) @BB<8>689 K<;6?7<?5C<685A54;58>L69L59C588<A68:;<@HH@46:< >6A<?:6@8 58> ?@776><> @8 F6:; 65996@ E:@)A6?M4;5F G<5A689 @)".$)##( IE:@2 B@A 4;@A: : 64 ?@8:<8><> :;5: :;< 5??6><8: @??EAA<> @8 (&('"(& GE:
- 10 -
:;<F54A<964:<A<>@87=@8,('"(&58>:;5::;<A< 64 58 E8<NH7568<> ><75= 68 7@>9689 :;< ?@CH7568: : 64 5K<AA<> :;5: F;<8 :;< ?756C58:4 577<9<> :;5: :;< A5?:@A 4:AE?M :;< BA@8: @B :;< E:@ :;< E:@ >A6K<A ;5K689 8@: 4E4:568<>58=68DEA=A564<4>@EG:45G@E::;<@??EAA<8?<@B :;<5??6><8:G=:;<@BB<8>689K<;6?7<:64?@8:<8><>:;5:
B6N689 :;< 765G676:= EH@8 684EA<> A5?:@A 8<<>4 :@ G< 5G4@7K<> 58> :;< 765G676:= ;54 :@ G< B54:<8<> EH@8 :;< @F8<AB@AC5M6895BA5E>E7<8:?756C
# <5A8<> ?@E84<7 5HH<5A689 B@A :;< A<4H@8><8:) ?756C58:4DE4:6B6<4:;<DE>9C<8:58>5F5A>@B:;<A6GE857 58>?@8:<8>4:;5::;<5??6><8:@??EAA<>4@7<7=>E<:@A54;
58> 8<9769<8: >A6K689 @B :;< >A6K<A @B A5?:@A)A567<A G<5A689<964:A5:6@8@)"&$)*&'F;6?;?5C<BA@C @HH@46:< >6A<?:6@8 68 5 L69L59 C588<A 58> ?@776><> F6:;
E:@ A<4E7:689 68 4<A6@E4 68DEA6<4 :@ :;< ?756C58:4 : 64 ?@8:<8><> :;5: :;< H@76?< A<?@A> ?7<5A7= <4:5G764;<4 :;< A@7< @B :;< >A6K<A @B :;< A5?:@A 68 ?5E4689 :;< 5??6><8:
- 11 -
F;6?; ;54 G<<8 A69;:7= ?@846><A<> G= :;< A6GE857 58> B54:<8<>:;<765G676:=EH@8:;<684EA<A@B:;<A5?:@A
' 8 A<95A> :@ :;< ?756C @B <8;58?<C<8: @B ?@CH<845:6@8 6: 64 ?@8:<8><> :;5: :;< ?@CH<845:6@8 5F5A><> :@ :;< ?756C58:4 E8><A K5A6@E4 ;<5>4 >@<4 8@:
?@CC<84EA5:< F6:; :;< 85:EA< 58> <N:<8: @B :;< 68DEA6<4 4E4:568<> 58> ;<8?< :;< ?756C58:4 5A< <8:6:7<> B@A DE4: 58>HA@H<A<8;58?<>?@CH<845:6@8
* ;< A6GE857 F;67< 5>>A<44689 :;< 644E< @B 8<9769<8?< ?@8?7E><> :;5: :;< 5??6><8: @??EAA<> >E< :@ A54; 58> 8<9769<8: >A6K689 @B :;< >A6K<A @B :;< A5?:@A) A567<A58>8@:>E<:@:;<>A6K<A@B:;<E:@;<A6GE857 B@E8> :;5: :;< ?756C58:4 ;5K< HA@K<> :;5: :;<= ;5K< 4E4:568<> 68DEA6<4 68 :;< A@5> :A5BB6?
5??6><8: 58> ?5:<9@A6L<> 6: 54 ?@CH@46:< 8<9769<8?< :;<A<G= <8:6:7689 :;< K6?:6C4 :@ 4<<M ?@CH<845:6@8 BA@C 58= @B :;< :@A:) B<54@A4;<A6GE857BEA:;<A;<7>:;5::;<><75=68B67689 ?@CH7568: ?588@: G< ;<7> B5:57 :@ :;< ?54< ;< A6GE857
- 12 -
B54:<8<>:;<765G676:=@8:;<684EA58?<?@CH58=:@H5=:;< ?@CH<845:6@858>A<?@K<A:;<45C<BA@C@F8<A$684EA<>
& <5A8<> ?@E84<7 5HH<5A689 B@A :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= F@E7> 574@ ?@8:<8> :;5: 54 @8 :;< >5:< @B :;< 5??6><8::;<A5?:@A)A567<A>6>8@:H@44<44K576>H<AC6:
58> :;<A< 64 K6@75:6@8 @B H@76?= ?@8>6:6@84 ;< A6GE857 F;67< ?@846><A689 :;64 54H<?: ;<7> :;5: E8><A N :;< H<AC6:F54K576>BA@C(*"(&:@((*"(",F;67<:;< 5??6><8: 68 JE<4:6@8 @??EAA<> @8 (&('"(& 75?689 A<7658?< EH@8 ><?646@8 @B :;< H<N @EA: 68 :;< ?54< @B ! "# "$ " %& '( %& )* *&"&! )"( "+& ;<7> :;5: :;< E4< @B K<;6?7< 68 HEG76? H75?< F6:;@E: H<AC6: 64 BE8>5C<8:57 4:5:E:@A= 68BA5?:6@8 ;@F<K<A :;< 684EA<A ;54 :@ H5= :;< ?@CH<845:6@85C@E8::@:;<?756C58:54@G4<AK<>68:;< 5G@K<><?646@8;<A6GE857A<76<>EH@8N4:@,:;< H@76?< A<?@A>4 58> 8@:6?689 :;5: :;< ?;5A9<)4;<<: F54 7<K<7<>595684::;<>A6K<A@B:;<A5?:@A%A567<A58>:;<
1
- 13 -
A<H@A: % N# 68>6?5:< :;5: G@:; K<;6?7<4 >5C59<> 58>?@AA@G@A5:<:;<B5?:@B@??EAA<8?<@B5??6><8:
. A@C :;< A<?@A>4 F< 8@:6?< :;5: N 64 :;< N" 64 :;< ?@CH7568: " 7@>9<> :;< B6A4:
68B@AC5:6@8A<H@A: 54<F54A<964:<A<>595684::;<>A6K<A @B:;<A5?:@A%A567<AN,64:;< A6C<<:5674@AC F;<A<68:;<H@76?<?@8>E?:<>:;<4H@:C5;5L5A58>4<6L<> :;< K<;6?7< 68K@7K<> 68 :;< 5??6><8: N# 64 :;<
A<H@A: A<B7<?:4 :;5: G@:; :;< K<;6?7<4 F<A< >5C59<> ?@8B6AC689:;<@??EAA<8?<@B:;<5??6><8: <A<7=G<?5E4< 6: 64 ?@8:<8><> G= :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= :;5: :;< >5C59<:@:;<A5?:@A%A567<AF54:@:;<A69;:46><A<5A F;<<7 >64? >5C59<> 58> :;5: :;< >A6K<A @B :;< E:@ ;5> 8@:4E4:568<>68DEA=F<?588@:@K<AAE7<:;<B5?::;5::;< 5??6><8: @??EAA<> 5: :;< H75?< 54 68>6?5:<> >E< :@ :;< 68K@7K<C<8: @B :F@ K<;6?7<4 F;6?; ?@AA@G@A5:<4 F6:; :;< 4H@: C5;5L5A 58> 4<6LEA< @B :;< K<;6?7<4 68K@7K<> 68 :;< 5??6><8: 54 H<A N, N' 64 :;< B6857 A<H@A: 58> H@76?< 5B:<A 68K<4:695:6@8 ;5K< B67<> ?;5A9<)4;<<: 595684:
- 14 -
:;<>A6K<A@B:;<A5?:@A%A567<A;E4:;<?@8:<8:6@8@B :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= 5G@E: 8@8 68K@7K<C<8: @B :;< A5?:@A%A567<AB5774:@9A@E8>
( 84@B5A54:;<><75=687@>9689:;<?@CH7568:64 ?@8?<A8<> :;< A6GE857 ;54 A69;:7= ;<7> :;5: 4E?; ><75= 6:4<7B?588@:G<:A<5:<>54B5:57:@:;<?756C
: 64 F<77 4<::7<> 75F :;5: ><75= 68 7@>9689 :;< ?@CH7568: 64 8@: B5:57 E8><A C@:@A 5??6><8: ?756C 54 HA6@A6:= @B :;< K6?:6C4 @A :;<6A B5C676<4 64 B@?E4<> @8 4<?EA689C<>6?57:A<5:C<8:@A><57689F6:;:;<6CC<>65:< 5B:<AC5:;@B:;<5??6><8:8:;<684:58:?54<><75=;54 G<<8 A<54@85G7= <NH7568<> 58> >@<4 8@: 5BB<?: :;< ?A<>6G676:=@B:;<?756C;E4:;< B68>689@B:;<A6GE857 @8 B54:<8689 :;< 765G676:= @8 :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= 64 DE4:6B6<>
" ;< A6GE857 ;<7> :;5: :;< 84EA58?< ?@CH58= 64765G7<:@H5=?@CH<845:6@85C@E8:5::;<B6A4:684:58?< 58> A<?@K<A :;< 45C< BA@C :;< @F8<A @B :;< @BB<8>689
- 15 -
K<;6?7<685??@A>58?<F6:;75F: 64 A<7<K58: :@ 8@:< :;5:
:;< @F8<A @B :;< @BB<8>689 K<;6?7< ;5> HA<B<AA<>
@"("#,.$"("" $F @"("#1'$"("" 58>
@"("#1&$"("" 544567689 :;< K<A= DE>9C<8: 58> 5F5A> H544<> 68 @4,$"(. 1$"(. 58> #$"(.
1$"(. 58> #$"(. @F<K<A :;<4< 5HH<574 F<A< 4EG4<JE<8:7= F6:;>A5F8 G= :;<@F8<A58>G=58@A><A@B:;64 @EA:>5:<>"1('"("# :;<456>5HH<574F<A<>64C644<>54F6:;>A5F88K6<F@B :;<45C<:;<B68>689@B:;<A6GE857;@7>689:;<84EA58?< ?@CH58= 765G7< :@ H5= :;< ?@CH<845:6@8 F6:; 76G<A:= :@ A<?@K<A:;<45C<BA@C:;<@F8<A4:58>45BB6AC<>
, 84@B5A 54 :;< ?@CH<845:6@8 5F5A><> :@ :;< ?756C58:4 F< F@E7> B6A4: ><57 F6:; @"('''$"("" 5A64689 @E: @B @,$"(. ;< 5??6><8: @??EAA<> @8 (&('"(& 5: 5A@E8> &(( HC F;<8 :;< ?756C58:4 F<A< :A5K<7689 68 :;< E:@ 5: 5AD@7 ?A@44 :@F5A>4 5AD@7 K67759<5::;5::6C<:;<@BB<8>689A5?:@A%A567<A?5C<68 5 A54; 58> 8<9769<8: C588<A >A6K<8 G= 6:4 >A6K<A 58> >54;<> 595684: :;< E:@ ?5E4689 :;< 5??6><8: ;<
- 16 -
?756C58: 68
@,$"(. 4E4:568<> 4<9C<8:57 ?@CC68E:<> BA5?:EA< @B A69;: :6G65 58> B6GE75 58> A69;:
4;5B: B<CEA 54 H<A :;< @E8> <A:6B6?5:< 5: N1 58> 64?;5A9< 4ECC5A= 5: N* ;< A69;: 7<9 @B :;< ?756C58: 5G@K< :;< M8<< 7<K<7 ;54 G<<8 5CHE:<> 54 64 <K6><8: BA@C N& ;< >64?;5A9< ?5A> 5: N* 68>6?5:<4 :;5: :;< ?756C58: ;54 E8><A9@8< 4<K<A57 4EA9<A6<4 58> F54 E8><A :A<5:C<8: ;< A6GE857 ;54 5F5A><> :@:57 ?@CH<845:6@8 @B 4"".*((($) E8><A :;< B@77@F689;<5>4!
7 @
<5>4 F5A>G=:;< A6GE857C@E8: 684
8DEA6<4 H568 58> 4EBB<A689 #(((($)
" @44@B<5A8689?5H5?6:= @8 5??@E8: @B H<AC58<8: H;=46?57 >645G676:= **''(($) ,
<>6?57<NH<84<4
".*.'"$) 1 @@> 8@EA64;C<8: 4H<?657 >6<: 58> 68?6><8:57?;5A9<4 #((($) # ::<8>58: 58> ?@8K<=58?<?;5A9<4
"((($) ' @44@B5C<86:6<4
"(((($) * @44 @B C5AA659< HA@4H<?:4 ((((($)
- 17 -
1 <5A8<> ?@E84<7 5HH<5A689 B@A :;< ?756C58:
4EGC6:4 :;5: :;< >645G676:= G= :;< ?756C58: 64 C@A< :;58 #(O 58> :;< A6GE857 @E9;: :@ ;5K< 5>><> BE:EA< HA@4H<?:468769;:@B:;<><?646@8@B:;<H<N @EA:68:;< ?54<@B "!)"( "+& ,"-.$ '(
"- &%"$ %&( EA:;<A:;<5F5A>@B ?@CH<845:6@8E8><AK5A6@E4;<5>48<<>4:@G<<8;58?<> 58>DE4:HA@H<A?@CH<845:6@88<<>4:@G<5F5A><>:@:;< ?756C58:
# ;< 59< @B :;< ?756C58: 64 "( =<5A4 54 @8 :;< >5:< @B :;< 5??6><8: ;< H<AC58<8: >645G7<C<8: 54 H<A 5A:)@B?;<>E7<)@B:;<CH7@=<<4 @CH<845:6@8?:
.", :;< 5CHE:5:6@8 G<7@F ;6H F6:; 4:ECH <4?<<>689
"*( ?C4 68 7<89:; C<54EA<> BA@C :6H @B 9A<5:
:A<8?;58:<A GE: 8@: G<=@8> C6>>7< :;69; :;< H<A?<8:59<
2 & @44 @B 68?@C< >EA689 756>)EHH<A6@> ,#"#($)
-./
, +
01232-
+
- 18 -
@B 7@44 @B <5A8689 ?5H5?6:= @8 5??@E8: @B H<AC58<8:
>645G7<C<8: 64 :@ G< ?@846><A<> 54 *(O <8?< :;< <N:<8: @B H<AC58<8: >645G7<C<8: ?@846><A<> G= :;< A6GE8575:*(O64DE4:6B6<>;<?756C58:?@8:<8><>:;5:
;< F54 5 54@8 ;@F<K<A ;< ;54 8@: HA@>E?<> 58= >@?EC<8::@4;@F:;<5?:E5768?@C<;<A6GE857:5M689 68:@?@846><A5:6@8:;<=<5A@B5??6><8:6<"(&544<44<> :;< 8@:6@857 68?@C< 54 H<A :;< 9E6><768<4 644E<> G= :;< 5A85:5M5 :5:< <957 <AK6?<4 E:;@A6:= 58> :@@M :;< 68?@C< @B :;< ?756C58: 5: 4*#($) H<A C@8:; F;6?; 5??@A>689:@E464DE4:6B6<>@F<K<AF;67<?57?E75:689:;< 7@44@B<5A8689?5H5?6:=@85??@E8:@BH<AC58<8:H;=46?57 >645G676:=:;<A6GE857B567<>:@5>>BE:EA<HA@4H<?:468:;< 769;: @B :;< ><?646@8 @B :;< H<N @EA: 68 :;< ?54< @B
"-&%4:5:<> @846><A689:;<59<58>:;< >645G676:= 64 5G@K< #(O 1(O BE:EA< HA@4H<?:4 ;54 :@ G< 5>><> :@ 4*#($) F;6?; ?@C<4 :@ 4'1#($) P4*#($) Q 1(O 1*(($)R 58> :;< 5HH76?5G7< CE7:6H76<A642&254:;<59<@B:;<?756C58:64"(=<5A45:
- 19 -
:;< :6C< @B 5??6><8: ;E4 :;< ?756C58: 64 <8:6:7<> B@A ?@CH<845:6@8@B4"1&*"1($)4'1#($)N*(ON" N&E8><A:;<;<5>7@44@BBE:EA<<5A8689
' ;<5F5A>@B?@CH<845:6@8E8><A:;<B@77@F689 ;<5>4 574@ 8<<>4 :@ G< <8;58?<> 58> DE4: 58> HA@H<A ?@CH<845:6@8 8<<>4 :@ G< 5F5A><> ;< ?756C58: 64 <8:6:7<>B@A?@CH<845:6@854E8><A! 7 @ <5>4 F5A>G=:;< A6GE857 F5A><>G=:;< 69; @EA:
@44 @B BE:EA< <5A8689
=A6GE857! *#( N " N & N *(O
=69; @EA:!
'1#( N " N & N *(O
4**''(($)
4"1&*"1($)
" 56858>4EBB<A689 4#(((($) 4*#((($) ,
<>6?57<NH<84<4 4".*.'"$) 4".*.'"$) 1 @@> 8@EA64;C<8: 4H<?657 >6<: 58> 68?6><8:57?;5A9<4 4#((($) 4"(((($) # ::<8>58: 58> ?@8K<=58?<?;5A9<4 4"((($) 4"1((($) ' @44@B5C<86:6<4 4"(((($) 4#(((($) * @44 @B C5AA659< HA@4H<?:4 4((((($) 4((((($)
- 20 -
* ;< ?756C58: 64 <8:6:7<> B@A :@:57 ?@CH<845:6@8 @B 4,"1*(($) 54 595684: 4"".*((($) 5F5A><> G= :;<A6GE85758><8;58?<>?@CH<845:6@8@B4&"**(($) F6:;68:<A<4:5::;<A5:<@B'OH<A588EC
& 84@B5A 54 :;< ?756C58:4 68
@4"(",#.$"("" 5A64689 @E: @B @#$"(. 58>
@"(",#&$"("" 5A64689 @E: @B @1$"(. :;< A6GE857 ;54 5F5A><> 97@G57 ?@CH<845:6@8 @B 4"#((($) 68 :;<4< :F@ 5HH<574 N4" 58> , 5A< :;<F@E8>?<A:6B6?5:<4F;6?;>64?7@4<:;5::;<?756C58:68
@1$"(.;544E4:568<>@8<46CH7<68DEA=58>:;< ?756C58: 68 @#$"(. ;54 4E4:568<> :F@ 46CH7< 68DEA6<4;<A6GE857;5K689B@E8>:;5:8@@:;<A68DEA6<4 G<689 4E4:568<> @8 5??@E8: @B :;< 5??6><8: 58> 574@ & @44 @B 68?@C< >EA689756>EHH<A6@> *#(N' 4,#"#($) 4*(#(($)
@:57 4"".'&"$) 4,"1*("$)
01232 4
+ 4 5+
8;58?<> ?@CH<845:6@8 4, +
- 21 -
8@:6?689 :;5: 8@ H<AC58<8: H;=46?57 >645G676:= ;54 5F5A><> 5 97@G57 ?@CH<845:6@8 @B 4"#((($) F6:; 68:<A<4:5:'OH<A588EC<>@8@:B68>58=677<9576:=68 5F5A>689 ?@CH<845:6@8 :@ :;< ?756C58:4 68 G@:; :;<4< ?756C H<:6:6@84 58> :;< 45C< >@<4 8@: F5AA58: 68:<AB<A<8?<
. @A 577 :;< B@A<9@689 A<54@84 F< H544 :;< B@77@F689! 6 ;<C64?<7758<@E4B6A4:5HH<574B67<>G=:;< 84EA58?< @CH58= 68
@4"(''$"(""
"(,&'$"("" 58>
"(,.'$"(""5A<;<A<G=264764432 66 ;< C64?<7758<@E4 B6A4: 5HH<57 B67<> G= :;< ?756C58: 68 @"(",'($"(""
@,$"(. 64 !! /&$ " , ;< 5HH<7758:$?756C58: 64 <8:6:7<> B@A 5 :@:57 ?@CH<845:6@8 @B 4,"1*(($) 54 595684:
4"".*((($) 5F5A><> G= :;< A6GE857 58> <8;58?<> ?@CH<845:6@8 @B
- 22 -
4&"**(($) F6:; 68:<A<4: 5: :;< A5:< @B 'OH<A588EC 666 ;<C64?<7758<@E4B6A4:5HH<574B67<>G=:;< ?756C58:4 68 @"(",#.$"(""
@#$"(. 58> @"(",#&$"(""
@1$"(.5A<;<A<G=>64C644<> 6K ;< <8;58?<> ?@CH<845:6@8 4;577 G< ><H@46:<> G= 84EA58?< ?@CH58= F6:;68 B@EA F<<M4 B567689 F;6?; :;< 5C@E8: 4;577 ?5AA=><B5E7:68:<A<4:5:.OH<A588EC K ;<5C@E8:68><H@46:4;577G<:A584C6::<> :@ :;< A6GE857 57@89 F6:; :A657 @EA: A<?@A>4 K6 <4:@B:;<@A><AH544<>G=:;<A6GE85764 8@:>64:EAG<>
!2+ (&'* #
!2+ (! * #
64:@!7@!' !