Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58447 (KAR)

AISHA BEGUM @ RUBINA D/O LATE ABDUL JABBAR v. VEERABHADRAPPA AND ORS

WP/200630/2016 · 2025-11-18

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"#!$%& ' &("&"& )&* ! " # $ %%& "$$$' (% )&%&* ! &%% &%% "$ ''" & "!"$ ' &&%% '" + Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &%% ", && % - + "$'''$ % %&% &%% "$ '! % "$ $ " " " " " " +%% . +% " '$' "!"$ + & ) * $ ,!! %%% "!"$ +& ) * , !' + %& + + "!"$, . &+ ) * ', !% + "!"$' & + + - 3 - '" '$' "!"$ "$ , - " , ! " "$$$' ! -- ! " "$$$' + ! ! " "$$$' $ - - "$ + "!"$ (% )+ &#/ &#")*/ & + &# $/ ,!&* - 4 - % # '',# # % )* $'$% 0' 0'$$ # # & # % # . / )* '"$,'$ % 01 " '$$ # # & ##% # . / )* %%% # # % #% 23 % 4 + ! )% 4 + * %5676708591 :95 ;5<095 6=71 0>96 155?78@ <0AA0B78@ 95A75<1 !"# $# % & '()* +,- .+ !" !/( $# % & '(* % &# 0%0 " 0 1 - 5 - ' #:C61 78 ;975<:956=:6 : 1>76 78 0'0< '$$,B:1<7A5D;E085&559:;=:D9:FF::8D1=0?086=5 <7A50< 7G7A >D@5 )98* 7D:9 :@:7816 ;D>A :;;:9 )D5:D* =H5D ;5D>AA:= :=5; )951F08D586 0 =59578* - >?=7E: 5@>H )D5:D* . ?6=:9>8711: 5@>H )951F08D586 0 =59578* :8D ;D>A :I:? )951F08D586 0$ =59578* <09 95A75< 0< 1F5C7<7C F59<09H:8C5 0< :8 :@955H586 0< 1:A5 78 951F5C6 0< A:8D ;5:978@E 0,H5:1>978@ ,:C951@>86:0< 79J:F>9 :JA:F>97D:971697C6 =:6 6=5 1:7D 1>76 B:1 D71H7115D <09 808 F:EH5860<0>96<55G7D509D59D:65D$'$''$$=:6 ;5<095 6=5 D71H711:A 0< 6=5 1>76 : H5H0 95F09678@ 6=5 D5:6= 0< >?=7E: 5@>H D5<58D:86 0 B:1 <7A5D 08 $!'$$! =:6 :<659 6=5 D71H711:A 0< 6=5 1>76 6=5 FA:7867<<1 <7A5D H71C5AA:850>1 F5676708 78 71C%5676708 0'$$ >8D59 9D59 . >A5 % =0>@= >?=E7: 5@>H D5<58D:86 0 =:D :A95:DE F:115D :B:E 1=5 B:1 1=0B860;5:A7G5786=51:7D H71C5AA:850>1F5676708 - 6 - 86=5H5:8B=7A5D5<58D:86 0=:D:A10F:115D:B:E =595:<659:8:FFA7C:6708B:1<7A5D>8D599D59..>A5 95:D B76= 5C6708 " 0< % 60 ;978@ 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5C5:15D D5<58D:86 0 ;D>A :;;:9 8:H5AE 6=5 F5676708591 =59578 :8D =H5D 0=78>DD78 ->;:79 )951F08D586 0,* 0=:HH:D 7B5I :I55 )951F08D586 0 !* :8D 71=: 5@>H )F567670859 =59578* 8 <>96=59:8C5 60 6=5 1:7D :FFA7C:6708 : F90CA:H:6708B:1711>5D08''$'$ B=5957878165:D0< 1=0B78@ 6=5 8:H51 0< 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5C5:15D D5<58D:86 0 :1 8065D :;0G5 8:H51 0< 5K71678@ D5<58D:861 8:H5AE =H5D ;5D>AA:= :=5; ?6=:9>8711:5@>H:8D;D>A:I:LB5951=0B8 =595:<659 ;E 09D59 D:65D '"$,'$ F90D>C5D :6 885K>95 6=5 97:A 0>96 :AA0B5D 6=5 :FFA7C:6708 ) 01& :8D &* F59H76678@ 60 ;978@ 08 95C09D 6=5 95H:7878@ A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5C5:15D 951F08D586 0 08 95C09D 8 :H58D5D F5676708 :1 F59 885K>95B:1<7A5D786=:6951F08D586 01,:8D!:8D - 7 - 6=5 F567670859 =59578 B595 1=0B8 :1 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< =H5D ;5D>AA:= :=5; )6=5 097@78:A D5<58D:86 0'* :8D951F08D586 0 =59578 B=0 71167AA :A7G5 =595:<659 : 8067C5 6=90>@= F:F59 F>;A7C:6708 B:1 711>5D1=0B78@6=58:H510<6=5951F08D586 01,:8D! :8D 6=5 F567670859 =59578 08 ''$,'$ 6 71 08AE 6=58 6=5F5676708591A5:986:;0>66=5E=:G78@;558;90>@=608 95C09D:16=5A5@:A95F951586:67G510<D5<58D:86 0'B=0 71 167AA :A7G5 5:9878@ :;0>6 6=5 1:H5 6=5 F5676708591 =59578 <7A5D :8 :FFA7C:6708 >8D59 5C6708 " % :1 F59 885K>95 155?78@ 60 95C:AA 6=5 09D59 '"$,'$ ;978@78@ 6=5H 08 95C09D :1 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5<58D:86 0'=51:7D:FFA7C:6708C:H560;595J5C65D ;E 6=5 697:A 0>96 G7D5 09D59 D:65D $'$ =>1 ;578@:@@975G5D;E6=5:<0951:7D09D591D:65D'"$,'$ :8D$'$6=5F5676708591:95;5<0956=710>96 " 5:985DC0>815A<096=5F56767085916:?78@6=71 0>96 6=90>@= 6=5 95C09D1 95<5995D 60 =59578:;0G5 1>;H761 6=:6 6=5 F5676708591 =:D 80 0FF096>876E 0< ;578@ - 8 - =5:9D ;5<095 6=5E B595 ;90>@=6 08 95C09D :1 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5<58D:86 0' 5 1>;H761 6=:6 6=5 FA:7867<< :1 B5AA :1 6=5 697:A 0>96 =:G5 H71C08C57G5D 6=5 <:C61 78 6=:6 B=58 6=5 097@78:A D5<58D:86 0 ;D>A :;;:9B=0716=5<:6=590<951F08D586 01,:8D!:8D 6=5 F5676708591 =59578 =:D F:115D :B:E :8D =71 8:H5 =:G78@ ;558 D5A565D 6=595 B:1 80 F0117;7A76E 0< 951F08D586 01,!:8D6=5F5676708591=59578;90>@=608 95C09D :1 6=5 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 0< D5<58D:86 0'951F08D586 0=595785<>96=591>;H7616=:66=5 F5676708591 =:G5 6=579 97@=6 60 0;J5C6 ;578@ ;90>@=6 08 95C09D :1 A5@:A 95F951586:67G51 >8A511 76 B:1 1=0B8 6=:6 6=5E=:G5 : C:>15 0< :C67081>9G7G78@08 6=5H =597:A 0>96 7@80978@ 6=515 A5@:A 95L>795H5861 =:1 H595AE ;9>1=5D:17D56=5@90>8D1>9@5D;E6=5F5676708591B=7A5 95J5C678@6=5:FFA7C:670858C56=5F5676708 5:985D C0>815A <09 951F08D586 0FA:7867<< <:79AE 1>;H761 6=:66=595 :FF5:91 60 ;5 C596:78 :80H:A751 B=7A5D51C97;78@6=5F:96751:8DH:?78@:8:FFA7C:670860 - 9 - C0H5 08 95C09D B=7C= =:1 A5D 60 6=5 F:1178@ 0< 6=5 7HF>@85D09D5915<>96=591>;H7616=:66=5F567670859;5 @7G58 :8 0FF096>876E 60 C086516 6=579 :FFA7C:6708 <7A5D >8D59 5C6708 " % :1 B5AA :1 6=5 :FFA7C:6708 <7A5D >8D59 9D59 .. >A5 % :8D 6=5 97:A 0>96 ;5 D795C65D60F:11:FF90F97:6509D5916=595:<659 , >;H711708716:?580895C09D ! 8 G75B 0< 6=5 <:C61 8:99:65D :;0G5 :8D 6=5 1>;H711708 H:D5 ;E 6=5 C0>815A <09 6=5 F5676708591 :8D 6=5951F08D5861:18065D:;0G56=5<0AA0B78@ ! )7* 976%567670871 )77* 9D59 D:65D '"$,'$ F:115D 08 01:8D"78 71C%5676708 0'$$ 08 6=5 <7A5 0< DD76708:A 7G7A >D@5 :8D #7D:9F90D>C5D:6885K>952 3:1 B5AA:16=509D59D:65D$'$F:115D 08 0' F90D>C5D :6 885K>95 :95 L>:1=5D - 10 - )777* :66597195H7665D606=597:A0>96B=7C= 1=:AA :<659 :<<09D78@ 0FF096>876E 60 6=5 F567670859 :8D 951F08D586 01, :8D ! =59578 60 <7A5 0;J5C67081 08 6=5 :FFA7C:6708 <7A5D >8D59 9D59 .. >A5 % ;E 6=5 FA:7867<<1 78 6=5 71C5AA:850>1 %5676708 0'$$ F:11 :FF90F97:65 09D591 78 :CC09D:8C5B76=A:B "+, )&"&* (! + 716 0A 0' 6F?