- 1 - ! " # $ $$ % ! " #!$% & ! $' !$$ ( ()* !(& ! '+ !(& " #!!', )&% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' &)#&%' -% .! ! / $ ' ' $ )0 ! $ !&& &0! ' '$ ' $1 1 2!$ # 3-45 673 -489:3;6< => ?3-4;35 @=9;<3? -AA3-4B;8 >=4 C=67673A-46B3< 7B< -AA3-? B< A43>34435 -8-B;<6 673 D958:3;6 -;5 -E-455-635)0B;=&& &0A-<<35CF673 =946 => 55B6B=;-? 3;B=4 BGB? $9583 -;5 -?-C94-8B 73 >-@6< => 673 @-<3 -43 67-6 =; &&& -6 -C=96 A: ;3-4 -;64-<7E-5B 364=? 9:A -?-C94-8B -AA3??-;6E-<43694;B;86=7347=:3->634>B;B<7B;8734<@7==? 596F -6 67-6 6B:3 - :=6=4 @F@?3 C3-4B;8 38B<64-6B=; = ( ()*@-:3B;-4-<7-;5;38?B83;6:-;;34-;55-<735 - 3 - 6= 673 -AA3??-;6 < - 43<9?6 -AA3??-;6 <9<6-B;35 84B3G=9< B;D94B3<-;5-5:B66356=!-7:-;B=<AB6-? -?-C94-8B ;D9435 @?-B:-;6 >B?35 - @?-B: A36B6B=; @?-B:B;8 @=:A3;<-6B=; => <& ( EB67 B;6343<6 73 4BC9;-? ->634 @=;<B534B;8 3;6B43 :-634B-? =; 43@=45 -E-4535 6=6-? @=:A3;<-6B=;=>< (EB67B;6343<6-66734-63=>*H A34-;;9:>4=:6735-63=>A36B6B=;6B??6735-63=>43-?BI-6B=; 884B3G35CF673<-B5=453467B<-AA3-?B<A43>34435 B; E7B@7 B6 B< @=;63;535 67-6 :3-834 @=:A3;<-6B=; E-< -E-45359;53467373-5=<<=>'96943-4;B;87=987 -<<3<<35 673 6=6-? 5B<-CB?B6F -6 H 673 4BC9;-? 34435 B; 6-JB;8 673 <-:3 -6 H 73 E-< 3-4;B;8 <& ( A34 :=;67 C96 673 4BC9;-? 7-< 6-J3; 673 B;@=:3 -6 <&&) ( A34 :=;67 73 E-< -835 -C=96 F3-4< -6 673 6B:3 => -@@B53;6 C96 673 4BC9;-? 7-< 6-J3; 673 -83 -< *& F3-4< A?-@B;843?B-;@3=;673--57-4-45=>734<A34K&673 5B<-CB?B6F B< 6= C3 6-J3; & 45 => H C96 673 4BC9;-? 7-< 6-J3; =;?F H E7B@7 B< 43L9B435 6= C3 43(@=;<B53435 73 -:=9;684-;6359;534673:35B@-?CB??<A-B;-;5<9>>34B;8-;5 - 4 - =673473-5<-43:3-83467343>=4343L93<635>=43;7-;@3:3;6 -;56=-??=E673-AA3-? * 36B6B=;34 3K-:B;35 M =@6=4 -;5 -?<= >B?35 5B<-CB?B6F@346B>B@-63B<<935CF7B:3:36EB67-;-@@B53;6=; &&& -;5 -?<= <9<6-B;35 @=:A=9;5 >4-@6943< => B876 BCB- -;5 'BC9?- -;5 =G34 4B876 ?38 < A34 K 73 <9<6-B;3584B3G=9<B;D94B3< K<) -;5-43 673 B<@7-483 -45<73E-<7=<AB6-?BI35>=4-A34B=5=>05-F<7=987 A36B6B=;34 7-< <6-635 67-6 <73 E-< -835 F3-4< -< A34 K&* <73 E-< C=4; =; &&&0) -;5 <73 :36 EB67 -; -@@B53;6B;673F3-4&-;5679<734-83E-<*&F3-4<-<=; 6735-63=>-@@B53;6-;56734BC9;-?7-<4B876?F@=;<B53435673 <-:33;@3673-AA4=A4B-63:9?6BA?B34B<6=C36-J3;-<N). ) 73@=;63;6B=;=>673-AA3??-;6=;6735B<-CB?B6FB3 & 45 => H E7B@7 E-< -E-4535 CF 673 4BC9;-? 67B< =946 >B;5<43-<=;-C?36=6-J3673<-:3-6&H-;567B<=946>B;5< 43-<=;-C?3 6= @=;>B4: 673 :35B@-? 3KA3;<3< &* ( -< 67343B<;=5B<A963438-45B;8673<-B5-:=9;6 ; GB3E => 673 -C=G3 673 ?=<< => >96943 3-4;B;8 @-A-@B6FE=9?5@=:36=1 - 5 - &&)K&K)K&HO0) ( 0 73:B876;=67-G3-663;535-;FE=4J-6?3-<6>=4- A34B=5 => 67433 :=;67< 73;@3 ?=<< => B;@=:3 594B;8 ?-B5 9A A34B=5E=9?5@=:3<6=< (#&&)K%-;567B<=946 >B;5<43-<=;-C?36=3;7-;@3673@=:A3;<-6B=;9;53467373-5 4-;<A=46-6B=; 964B6B=9< '==5 -;5 663;5-;6 7-483< 6= < (-;5< (6=E-45<-B;-;59>>34B;8 & ; -?? 673 6=6-? @=:A3;<-6B=; @=:3< 6= &' (-?=;8EB67B;6343<6-66734-63=>*H>4=:673 5-63=>A36B6B=;6B??43-?BI-6B=; && 73-E-45=>@=:A3;<-6B=;A-<<35CF6734BC9;-? B<:=5B>B35-<9;5341 )*+& ,-./0.& &-B;-;5<9>>34B;8 ( 35B@-?3KA3;<3< &* ( =<< => 3-4;B;8 594B;8 ?-B5 9A A34B=5>=467433:=;67< ( =<<=>>969433-4;B;8@-A-@B6F 0) ( 4-;<A=46-6B=; 964B6B=9< >==5 -;5-663;5-;6@7-483< ( * =<< => -:3;B6B3< -;5 ?=<< => 7-AAB;3<< ( /*1 ' ( - 6 - @@=45B;8?F 673 6=6-? @=:A3;<-6B=; @=:3< 6= <*0 ( -;5 673 -AA3??-;6 @?-B:-;6 B< 3;6B6?35 >=4 -; 3;7-;@35 @=:A3;<-6B=; => <00) ( -?=;8 EB67 B;6343<6 -6 6734-63=>*HA34-;;9: & ;67343<9?6673>=??=EB;8=4534B<A-<<351 B% 73-AA3-?B< BB% 73 @?-B:-;6 B< 3;6B6?35 >=4 - 6=6-? @=:A3;<-6B=;=><&0 (EB67B;6343<6 -6*HA34-;;9:>4=:6735-63=>A36B6B=; 6B??6735-63=>43-?BI-6B=; BBB% 3<A=;53;6 ( ;<94-;@3 =:A-;F -?43-5F 53A=<B635 673 -E-45 -:=9;6 C3>=43 673 4BC9;-?73;@3673;<94-;@3=:A-;FB< 5B43@6356=53A=<B63;7-;@35@=:A3;<-6B=; => <00) ( -?=;8 EB67 B;6343<6 -6 *H EB67B; =;3 :=;67 >4=: 673 5-63 => 67B< =4534 - 7 - BG% ;<9@753A=<B6673-AA3??-;6B<A34:B6635 6=EB6754-E673-:=9;6-?=;8EB67B;6343<6 -@@4935=;B6 &+( 2$ 3 # B<6=1&?=1)* 1$