- 1 - ! "#!$ # % & %'() &%(( * !" # $% !" & $$ !" ! % !" $$ & !" '$ ($ $ ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * $ $ $$ * + " $% $ !" % '$ ( $* , $$* $ * ) $* ! *$( ) * (%) $ % $ $ $ - " $ ( "&) * * ** **$ &&!- "!" %!-$&! *$ $ $. $ * % / - 3 - ($ / ) 01232415300647189:;12$1<4==012503>?:5@0=A?2 <B0 60<4<4?502@ 24 1;1312 B1B1C:3345 =012503 4DB ?:2< ?E025;05<$=01302A?220@6?5305<?153:;14@B51E4 =012503>?:5@0=16601245DA?2241E4$1<4==012503>?:5@0= A?220@6?5305<? B0 620@05< 60<4<4?5 4@ A4=03 :5302 0><4?5 ! ?A <B0 ?30?A24;451=$2?>03:20F4<B<B0A?==?F45D621802 !"!! # $ % & ' ())* !"!+, - - . / /01 # $ - -- ' +!+ 2)3 4"2 4"* 2 5& ' + 2 - 6& 3 378# -9 : & *1><@?A<B0>1@045C240AFB4>B120:<;?@<50>0@@128A?2 34@6?@1=?A<B0620@05<60<4<4?51201@:5302 0@6?5305<?2$21<4;1A4=031>?;6=145<F4<BB1=94 :21=$?=4>020D4@<02034524;0?- "?5"&" "A?2 - 4 - <B0 ?AA05>0@ 6:54@B1C=0 :5302 0><4?5@ !- && "! " !- ?A <B0 53415 $051= ?30 153 0><4?5@ & 153 ! ?A <B0 ?F28$2?B4C4<4?5><- ! B0 D4@< ?A <B0 >?;6=145< 1E02;05<@ F?:=3 20E01= <B1< 20@6?5305<?D?<;122403<?1>>:@03?1@602<B0453: 24<0@153>:@<?;@ ?5""1534<F1@1=?E0;12241D0 <<B0<4;0?A;12241D0&<B?=1D?=3153@&"""" >1@B F1@D4E051@3?F28 B0 >?:6=0 =4E03 B1664=8 A?2 <F? ;?5<B@ B0201A<02 <B020 F1@ @024?:@ 6B8@4>1= 153 ;05<1= B121@@;05< ;0<03 ?:< <? <B0 20@6?5305< ? ?5 <B0 D2?:53 <B1< @B0 C0=?5D@ <? 1 =?F02>?;;:54<8153<B020F1@30;153A?23?F28 %B05<B030;153A?21334<4?51=3?F28F1@5?<;0<F4<B 6B8@4>1=153;05<1=B121@@;05<D?<45>201@03FB4>B:=<4;1<0=8 20@:=<034520@6?5305<?A4=45D1>?;6=145<F4<B<B06?=4>0 # A<02 20D4@<0245D <B0 >?;6=145< <B0 6?=4>0 >?53:><03 30<14=03 45E0@<4D1<4?5 153 A4=03 <B0 >B12D0 @B00< 1D145@< <B0 1>>:@03602@?5@ - 5 - 012503 241= 1D4@<21<0 <??9 >?D54G15>0 153 20D4@<0203 <B0 >24;451= >1@0 1D145@< <B0 60<4<4?502@ 153 ?<B02@ 153 62?>00303 F4<B <B0 >1@0 1;0 4@ >1==03 45 H:0@<4?5 45 <B4@ 60<4<4?5 - 24 153006 47189:;12 $1<4= =012503 >?:5@0= A?2 <B0 60<4<4?502@ 204<021<45D <B0 D2?:53@ :2D03 45 <B0 60<4<4?5 E0B0;05<=8 >?5<05303 <B1< 13;4<<03=8 60<4<4?502 ? 153 60<4<4?502 ? FB? 120 1>>:@03 ?@& 153 45 <B0 >B12D0 @B00< 120 20@4345D @06121<0=8 153 343 5?< @B120 <B0 >?;;?5 2??A F4<B <B0 >?:6=0 ? 0@<1C=4@B @143 1@60>< ?A <B0 ;1<<02 >?68 ?A <B042 13B12 >123@ 1@ 13320@@ 62??A 120 6=1>03 ?5 20>?23 " B020A?20 >?5<45:1<4?5 ?A <B0 >24;451= 62?>00345D@ 1@ 1D145@<60<4<4?502?@153B1@20@:=<03451C:@0?A62?>0@@ ?A=1F 012503 >?:5@0= A?2 <B0 60<4<4?502@ @:C;4<@ <B1< <B0 60<4<4?5;18C034@;4@@034520@60><?A60<4<4?502?@&153 !153<B1<B0F?:=3A4=01;0;?<?<B1<0AA0>< B0@:C;4@@4?54@6=1>03?520>?23 - 6 - & & :;14@B51E4 =012503 >?:5@0= A?2 20@6?5305< ? 153 24 1;1312 B1B1C:3345 =012503 4DB ?:2< ?E025;05< $=01302 A?2 20@6?5305< ? ?66?@0 <B0 60<4<4?5 D2?:53@ C8 >?5<05345D <B1< - ;1<0241= B1@ C005 >?==0><03 C8 <B0 5E0@<4D1<4?5 AA4>02 1D145@< 1== <B0 60<4<4?502@153<B020A?20@?:DB<A?234@;4@@1=?A<B060<4<4?5 ! 1E45D B0123 <B0 12D:;05<@ ?A C?<B @430@ <B4@ ?:2< 602:@03<B0;1<0241=?520>?23;0<4>:=?:@=8 5 @:>B 602:@1= ?A <B0 ;1<0241= ?5 20>?23 <B0 13B12 123@ FB4>B 120 6=1>03 ?5 20>?23 1@ 62??A ?A 20@4305>0 45 20@60><?A60<4<4?502?@153FB?1201>>:@03?@&153 F?:=3;1904<>=012<B1<<B083435?<@B120<B0>?;;?52??A F4<B20@6?5305<?153B02B:@C153 3;4<<03=8 60<4<4?502 ?@ 153 F020 20@4345D @06121<0=8 153 1==0D1<4?5 =0E0=03 1D145@< <B0; 45 <B0 >B12D0 @B00<4@?;54C:@153D05021=4551<:20F4<B?:<<B020C045D158 @60>4A4>?E02<1><@ # 1945D5?<0?A<B0@01@60><@?A<B0;1<<021531=@?<B0 6245>46=0@ ?A =1F05:5>41<03C8 <B0?5IC=0 60J ?:2< 45 <B0 - 7 - >1@0?A 206?2<03 45 >?5<45:1<4?5?A<B062?>00345D@1D145@<60<4<4?502?@153 F?:=320@:=<451C:@0?A62?>0@@?A?:2<153<B020A?205003@ <?C0H:1@B03 >>?2345D=8 45 E40F ?A A?20D?45D 34@>:@@4?5 <B0 A?==?F45D (4) $0<4<4?54@ ! (44) $0<4<4?5 4@ 1@ 1D145@< 60<4<4?502 ?@&153! (444) $0<4<4?5 4@ 45 20@60>< ?A 60<4<4?502 ?@ 153 153 605345D >24;451= >1@0 45 ? "&?5<B0A4=0?A<B04E4= :3D0153 *B1=944@B020C8H:1@B03 (4E) < 4@ ;130 >=012 <B1< <B4@ ?:2< B1@ 5?< 0J620@@03158?6454?5?5<B0;024<@?A<B0;1<<02 +) %$( ! 9>; 4@<?=?&- $