- 1 - !" ! #"$! #"$" !! % ! "# $ #! % &'' ( ! "# #! ) # $* #! +'' & $$'( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' ) #! +' ' ' ,) - - "( - ) ' ' - % '' ' - ) ./01- 2%%!%!!"%!# '' ) ) - %#!#%!% - 3' - 4 )- 5 ' 5 - '$" '5 - 678 9::19; .</1= 1>?72< "( =19/ @7?6 =/1= .;18 9</ % 2A ' BC ?61 .<8.>>188A.; /1A1</9<?8 - 3 - >9;;7<0 7< D.18?72< E./0F1<? 9</ /1>=11 :9881/ 7< 2%%! /9?1/ %!!"%!# BC </ //7?72<9; 1<72= 7G7; ./01 * - 7/9= @61=1BC ?61 8.7? A7;1/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AAA2==1>2G1=C2A?619F2.<?2A8H!!! 9;2<0 @7?6 7<?1=18? 9? ?61 =9?1 2A #I :1= 9<<.F @98 :9=?;C /1>=11//7=1>?7<0?61/1A1</9<?8?2:9C?619F2.<?8.:=9 62@1G1=@7?67<?1=18?9?#I:9 % 61 :9=?718 9=1 =1A1==1/ ?2 98 :1= ?61 =9<J7<08 B1A2=1?61?=79;2.=? B=71A 2.?;7<1 2A A9>?8 ;19/7<0 ?2 A7;7<0 2A ?678 9::19;9=198A2;;2@8 .=G1C 2%# ?2?9;;C F198.=7<0 #9>=18 0.<?98 @67>6 @98 B7A.=>9?1/ 7<?2 ?@2 '9=?8 %# F198.=7<0 ( 9>=18 0.<?98 9</ %#% F198.=7<0 % 9>=18 ! 0.<?98 B1;2<08 ?2 ?61A9F7;C2A /1A1</9<? <28 ?2 1A1</9<? <2 % 78 ?61 C2.<01= B=2?61= 2A /1A1</9<? <2 9</ /1A1</9<?<278?61@7A12AC2.<01=B=2?61=2A/1A1</9<? - 4 - <2BC<9F19?1)7E9C .F9==1078?1=1/90=11F1<??2 81;;>9F1?2B11<?1=1/B19=7<0/2>.F1<?2"#%!! /9?1/ !!%!! B1?@11< /1A1</9<? <28 ?2 9</ 2<1 6=78?9 .F9=7@7A12A281:62<2<1:9=?9881;;1=89</ 2<1 9</ .F9= 9</ :;97<?7AA 98 :.=>6981= 98 ?61 2?61= :9=? 61=1.</1= ?61 :9=?718 69G1 90=11/ ?2 81;; 9</ :.=>6981 ( 9>=18 ! 0.<?98 2A ;9</ 2.? 2A ( 9>=18 0.<?98 2A ;9</ 7< .=G1C 2%# 98 :1= ?61 8>61/.;1 8?9?1/ 7< ?61 897/ 90=11F1<? 9? K67B7? ' A2= 9 ?2?9; 89;1 >2<87/1=9?72< 2A 8("!!!!! 71 8!!!!!! :1= 9>=1 < ?61 90=11F1<? ?2 81;; 9 8.F 2A 8!!!!!! @98:97/.</1=?@2>61D.18BC?61:;97<?7AA <1>61D.1A2=98.F2A8(%!!! 7<A9G2.=2A6=78?9 .F9=79</9<2?61=A2=98.F2A8H!!! 7<A9G2.= 2A/1A1</9<?<2 F?69<?9J.F9=7 @62698=1>17G1/ ?61 89F1 2< 61= B169;A 9</ 2< B169;A 2A 2?61= /1A1</9<? <28%9</ ?78A.=?61=8?9?1/7<?61897/90=11F1<??2 - 5 - 81;; ?69? 9 8.7? 7< 2 %% 2A %!!% 78 :1</7<0 A2= :9=?7?72<7<=18:1>?2A?61897/8.=G1C<.FB1=B1?@11<?61 A9F7;C F1FB1=8 9</ /1A1</9<? <28 ?2 < ?61 897/ 90=11F1<?7?@989;828?9?1/?69?2?61=869=162;/1=8@62 9=1?61A9F7;CF1FB1=82A/1A1</9<?28?2>2<81<?1/ A2=89;12A(9>=18(0.<?982A;9</@7?62.?:28818872< ? 78 A.=?61= >2<?1</1/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AA ?69? ?61 8.7? 7< 2%% 2A %!!% @98 /78:281/ 2< %!%%! 61=19A?1= /1A1</9<? <28 ?2 82;/ ;9</ 7< .=G1C 2 %# F198.=7<0 % 9>=18 ! 0.<?98 7< A9G2.= 2A 2<1 G7<986 2 61869=92 ?6=2.06 9 =1078?1=1/ 89;1 /11/ /9?1/ !"%! @7?62.? <2?7>1 9</ J<2@;1/01 2A ?61 :;97<?7AA 61 :;97<?7AA 7FF1/79?1;C ?61=19A?1= 9::=29>61/ /1A1</9<?<28%9</67=78?9 .F9=7@61=1.:2<?61 /1A1</9<?8 7<A2=F1/ ?61 :;97<?7AA ?69? /.1 ?2 7<?1=<9; /7AA1=1<>1 B1?@11< ?61 869=162;/1=8 ?61 /1A1</9<?8 @1=1 <2? 7< 9 :287?72< ?2 1K1>.?1 9 =1078?1=1/ 89;1 /11/98 :1= ?61 =1078?1=1/ 90=11F1<? 2A 89;1 /9?1/ !!%!! 9</ - 6 - :=2F781/?2=1:9C?619F2.<??61C69G1=1>17G1/.</1=?61 89;190=11F1<? ( <A.=?61=9<>12A:=2F781F?6=78?9 .F9=7 @7A1 2A 281:6 698 =1:97/ 8.F 2A 8(%!!! @61=198 ?61 /1A1</9<? <2 @62 698 =1>17G1/ 9 8.F 2A 8H!!! .</1= 9 >61D.1 B19=7<0 2( /9?1/ H!%!! 2< 61= B169;A 9</ 2< B169;A /1A1</9<? 28 % 9</=1F97<1/.<:97//18:7?1?61=1:1?7?7G1/1F9</89</ =1D.18?8F9/1BC?61:;97<?7AA87<>1?612?61=:9=?C71 9</9J.F9= 698 <2? 862@< 9<C 7<?1=18? ?2 =1>2G1= ?61 897/ 9F2.<? 98 ?61 9F2.<? 78 :97/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AA 9;2<1 ?61:;97<?7AA69G7<0;1A?@7?6<22?61=9;?1=<9?7G1=1D.18?1/ ?61 /1A1</9<?8 ;98?;C 2< !H!%! @67>6 ?61C 69G1 =1A.81/ ?2 :9C 9G7<0 ;1A? @7?6 <2 2?61= 9;?1=<9?7G1 ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 7<8?7?.?1/ 8.7? 811J7<0 A2= =1>2G1=C 2A F2<1C 8H!!! 9;2<0 @7?6 #I 7<?1=18? 9097<8? /1A1</9<? <28?2 - 7 - H .B81D.1<? ?2 ?61 7<8?7?.?72< 2A ?61 8.7? 7< =18:2<81?2<2?7>1788.1/BC?61?=79;2.=?/1A1</9<?<28 9</%9::19=1/9</A7;1/?617=@=7??1<8?9?1F1<?/1<C7<0 ?61>9812A:;97<?7AA>2<?1</7<0?69??619G1=F1<?88?9?1/7< ?61 :;97<? 9=1 A9;81 9</ <2? 9/F7??1/ -.=?61= 8?9?1/ ?69? ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 8.::=1881/ ?61 A9>? 9</ 8?9?1/ ?69? ?61 1<?7=1 ;9</ 2A 8.=G1C 2%# F198.=7<0 # 9>=18 0.<?98 @61=198 8.=G1C <2 %# 78 /7G7/1/ 7<?2 % :9=?8 98 %#F198.=7<0(9>=180.<?989</%#%98%9>=18! 0.<?98 61:;97<?7AA 698 8?9?1/7< ?618.7? 2< ?61 B98782A 90=11F1<?@61=17<9;82?61=17898?9?1F1<??69??612?61= 869=162;/1=8 2A ?61 A9F7;C 69G1 >2<81<?1/ A2= 89;1 2A ?61 :=2:1=?C 8?9?1/ 7< ?61 90=11F1<? 2A 89;1 6281 :1=82<8 @1=1 <2? F9/1 98 :9=?718 7< ?61 8.7? 8 8.>6 ?61 8.7? 8.AA1=8A=2F<2< E27</1=2A<1>1889=C:9=?718 # 61 >2<?1<?72< 2A ?61 :;97<?7AA ?69? ?61 /1A1</9<?88.B81D.1<??2/78:289;2A?618.7?7<2%% ?2 %!!% 82;/ ?61 :=2:1=?C 7< A9G2.= 2A G7<986 /1<71/ - 8 - @61=198 ?61=1 78 8:1>7A7> >2<?1<?72< ?9J1< ?69? 7? 78 ?61 :;97<?7AA 9</ 9<2?61= :1=82< 9</9J.F9= @62 69G1 9>?7G1;C:9=?7>7:9?1/7<01??7<0 8J1?>6A2=?61:.=:281 2A 89;1 /11/ 7< A9G2.=2A G7<986 < ?6181 >7=>.F8?9<>18 ?61 8.7? A7;1/ A2= =1>2G1=C /218 <2? 9=781 7<>1 9<2?61= :9=?C@6278:9=?C?290=11F1<??281;;<2?E27<1/67869</8 7<?618.7?A2==1>2G1=C>;19=;C862@8?69??61=178<2?67<0 =1F97<1/ 7< ?61 90=11F1<? 9</ ?61=1 =1F97<8 <2?67<0 ?2 :9CB9>J98>2<?1</1/BC?61:;97<?7AA " -.=?61= >2<?1</1/ ?69? ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 862@< 7F907<9=C/9?12A>9.812A9>?72<9</?618.7?@7?62.?>9.81 2A9>?72<78<2?9?9;;F97<?97<9B;161=178<22.?8?9</7<0 9F2.<? 98 >2<?1</1/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AA 61C 69G1 8.B81D.1<?;C A7;1/ 9//7?72<9; @=7??1< 8?9?1F1<? >2<?1</7<0 ?69?@61<?618.7?@98:28?1/A2=1G7/1<>12A:;97<?7AA61 698 A7;1/ 9< 9::;7>9?72< 811J7<0 ?2 9F1</ ?61 :;97<? @61=1BC @7?6/=9@< >1=?97< 9/F78872<8 62.06 /1A1</9<? - 9 - <2@9881=G1/9</9::19=1/?6=2.06>2.<81;61/7/<2? A7;19<C@=7??1<8?9?1F1<? ! 61 ?=79; >2.=? 9A?1= >2F:;1?72< 2A :;19/7<08 A=9F1/?61A2;;2@7<0788.18@67>6=19/898A2;;2@8 1. “Whether the plaintiff proves that he has paid an amount of Rs.43,75,000/- to the defendants under the Registered Agreement of Sale bearing document No.938/2010-11 dated 03.05.2010 entered in between himself and the defendant as alleged? 2. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties to this suit? 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the recovery of the amount of Rs.43,75,000/- with interest at the rate of 18% p.a. from the defendants as prayed for? 4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for reliefs claimed in the suit? 5. What order or decree?” 61:;97<?7AA7<2=/1=?2:=2G1678>9811K9F7<1/ 98 ' 9</ F9=J1/ ?6=11 /2>.F1<?8 98 K67B7? ' ?2 ' 9</ 1K9F7<1/ 9G7</=9 2 9;;9CC9 @9FC 9</ 9</9J.F9= 2 901</=9 @62 9=1 ?61 @7?<188 9</ 9<2?61= :9=?C ?2 ?61 90=11F1<? 98 '% 9</ ' 9</ - 10 - >;281/67887/161/1A1</9<?869G1<2?>6281<?2;19/9<C 1G7/1<>12@1G1=F9=J1/?6=11/2>.F1<?898K67B7?8 ' ?2'9</>;281/?617=87/18.B81D.1<?;C?61F9??1=@98 :28?1/ A2= 9=0.F1<? 61 ?=79; >2.=? 9A?1= 619=7<0 ?61 :9=?718 9</ 9A?1= 027<0 ?6=2.06 ?61 1<?7=1 F9?1=79; :;9>1/ B1A2=1 7? :=2>11/1/ ?2 9<8@1= ?61 788.18 7< ?61 A2;;2@7<0 F9<<1= “Issue No.1: In the Affirmative. Issue No.2: In the Negative. Issue No.3: In the Partly Affirmative. Issue No.4: In the Affirmative. Issue No.5: As per final orders for the following” % 8:1=?61A7</7<082<?61788.18?61?=79;2.=? A2.</ ?69? ?61=1 78 :9CF1<? 2A F2<1C =1>17G1/ BC /1A1</9<?<22<B169;A2A/1A1</9<?<28%9</?2?61 ?.<12A8H!!! BC@9C2A9>61D.1@67>6A9>?698 B11< :=2G1/ BC ?61 8?9?1F1<? 2A 9>>2.<?8 9? K67B7? ' @61=17< ?61=1 78 9 >;19= F1<?72< ?69? 9 8.F 2A 8H!!! :97/ 7< A9G2.= 2A F?69<?69 .F9=7 71 - 11 - /1A1</9<? <2 9</ 61;/ ?69? ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 :=2G1/ 678 >981 61?=79;2.=?6988.B8>=7B1/?27?8=1982<7<07< :9=90=9:6 ! @61=17< ?61 ?=79; 2.=? 698 8?9?1/ ?69? ?61 /1A1</9<?8 <2? /78:.?1/ ?69? ?61C 69G1 1K1>.?1/ ?61 90=11F1<?2A89;17<A9G2.=2A:;97<?7AA9</9</J.F9=9</ ?61C 69G1 9/F7??1/ =109=/7<0 ?61 =1>17G7<0 ?61 9F2.<? ?6=2.06 >61D.1 61 @7?<18818 @62 69G1 B11< 1K9F7<1/ 7<>;./7<0 ' 9</J.F9= 8?9?1/ ?69? ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 :97/ 19=<18? F2<1C 9F2.<? ?2 ?61 /1A1</9<?8 K67B7? ' 862@8?69?69<?69J.F9=7=1>17G1/9>2<87/1=9?72<9F2.<? 2A8H!!! 61?=79;2.=?A.=?61=61;/?69?7<?619B81<>12A 9<C1K:;7>7?9</>;19=?1=F87<?61>2<?=9>??61=1>9<<2?B1 9<C A2=A17?.=1 98 >2<?1</1/ BC ?61 /1A1</9<?8 2A 19=<18? F2<1C :97/ 98 ?61 9/G9<>1 F2<1C B17<0 :9=? 2A 19=<18? F2<1C@61<?61<2< :1=A2=F9<>178<2?9??=7B.?9B;1?2?61 - 12 - :1=82< @62 698 :97/ ?61 9F2.<? 61 9F2.<? :97/ 98 9/G9<>1F2<1CB17<0?61:9=?2A?6119=<18?F2<1CA2=?61 :9=? :1=A2=F9<>1 2< B169;A 2A ?61 :.=>6981=8 78 A2= 9 0.9=9<?11 A2= ?61 /.1 :1=A2=F9<>1 2A ?61 >2<?=9>? 7<>1 ?61 /1A1</9<?8 69G1 A97;1/ ?2 :1=A2=F ?617= :9=? 2A ?61 >2<?=9>? 9</ ?61 90=11F1<? 7?81;A 78 A=.8?=9?1/ BC ?61 8.B81D.1<?89;1/11/89?K67B7?8 '* < ?6181 >7=>.F8?9<>18 61;/ ?69? ?61 /1A1</9<?869G1<2?;1/9<C1G7/1<>1?28.B8?9<?79?1?617= >;97F89</?61:;97<?7AA69G7<0:=2G1/678>9819>>2=/7<0;C :9=?;C/1>=11/?618.7?/7=1>?7<0?61/1A1</9<?8?2:9C:9=? >2<87/1=9?72<9F2.<?2A8H!!! ?2?61:;97<?7AA@7?6 A.?.=17<?1=18?9??61=9?12A#I:1=9<<.FA=2F?61/9?1 2A 8.7? ?7;; ?61 /9?1 2A =19;789?72< BC :9=?;C /1>=117<0 ?61 8.7? ? 78 ?678 E./0F1<? 9</ /1>=11 :9881/ BC ?61 ?=79; 2.=?@67>678>9;;1/7<D.18?72<7<?6789::19; - 13 - ( 19=/ =797=9E .JJ9 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; 9::19=7<0 A2= 9::1;;9<?8 61 82;1 =18:2</1<? ?62.06 81=G1/=1F97<1/.<=1:=181<?1/ H =7 97=9E 6.JJ9 @7?6 9;; G161F1<>1 8.BF7??1/ ?69? ?61 8.7? A7;1/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AA 78 <2? F97<?97<9B;1 9</ 78 67? BC ?61 :=7<>7:;1 2A <2< E27</1= 2A <1>1889=C9</:=2:1=:9=?7188:1=?61>2<?1<?72<88?9?1/ 7<?618.7?98@1;;98?6190=11F1<?2A89;1.</1=@67>67? 789;;101/?69?9<9F2.<?2A8H!!! 698B11<:97/ 7< A9G2.= 2A /1A1</9<? <2 61=81;A 9</ 2< B169;A 2A /1A1</9<?8 <28 % 9</ 9</ ?61 90=11F1<? ?2 89;1 @98 1<?1=1/ @7?6 ?61 >2<81<? 2A 2?61= 869=162;/1=8 61=1 9=1 2?61= A9F7;C F1FB1=8 @62 69G1 <2? B11< F9/1 98 :9=?C 82 9;82 9<2?61= :1=82< @62 78 9;82 9 :9=?C ?2 ?61 90=11F1<? BC <9F1 9</J.F9= 698 <2? B11< F9/1 98 :9=?C 61 8.7? A7;1/ 2< ?61 B9878 2A 90=11F1<? ?2 81;; @7?62.? 811J7<0 8:1>7A7> :1=A2=F9<>1 78 <2? F97<?97<9B;1 -.=?61= ?61 :;97<?7AA 698 <2? F9/1 F? 67=78?9 .F9=7 - 14 - @62 78 9;82 2<1 2A ?61 :9=?C 7< ?61 90=11F1<? ?2 81;; <2? F9/1 98 9 :9=?C ;7?709<? B1A2=1 ?61 ?=79; >2.=? 61 ?=79; 2.=?698A97;1/?2>2<87/1=?618198:1>?82AF9??1=9</?61 89F1698=18.;?1/7<F78>9==79012AE.8?7>1 # =797=9EA.=?61=8.BF7??1/?69??619F2.<?:97/ 98 9;;101/ BC ?61 :;97<?7AA 7< ?61 8.7? ?2 ?61 1K?1<? 2A 8H!!! 698B11<9/E.8?1/?2@9=/8?618.B81D.1<? 89;1/11/89?K67B7? '9</61?=79;2.=?698A97;1/ ?2>2<87/1=?67898:1>?2A?61F9??1=7<>1?61819F2.<?8 69G1 9;=19/C B11< 9/E.8?1/ ?2@9=/8 ?61 89;1 /11/ 7< =18:1>?2A?61>2<87/1=9?72<A7K1/.</1=?6189;1/11/?61 D.18?72< 2A =1:9CF1<? 2A F2<1C /218 <2? 9=781 < ?6181 >7=>.F8?9<>186182.06??29;;2@?619::19; " 9G7<0 619=/ ?61 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; A2= ?61 9::1;;9<?:1=.81/?611<?7=19::19;:9:1=8829;82?61?=79; 2.=? =1>2=/ ?61 :27<?8 ?69? @2.;/ 9=781 A2= 2.= >2<87/1=9?72<9=198.</1= - 15 - 7 61?61=?619::1;;9<?869G1F9/12.?9<C>981 ?2 7<?1=A1=1 @7?6 ?61 7F:.0<1/ E./0F1<? 9</ /1>=11 :9881/ BC ?61 ?=79; 2.=?L A ?61 9<8@1= 78 7< 9AA7=F9?7G1@69?2=/1=L 77 61?61=?61=1789<C=1D.7=1F1<?2AF2/7A7>9?72< 7<?61E./0F1<?9<//1>=11L %! .= 9<8@1= ?2 ?61 9B2G1 :27<?8 9=1 7< <109?7G1 A2=?61A2;;2@7<0 % ?782<=1>2=/?69??619F2.<?:97/787<A9G2.= 2A /1A1</9<? 2 BC @9C 2A >61D.1 9</ 7? 78 9 B9<J ?=9<89>?72< @67>6 698 B11< :=2G1/ BC ?61 1K?=9>? 2A 8?9?1F1<? 2A 9>>2.<?8 :=2/.>1/ 9? K67B7? ' 61=1 78 <2?67<0>2<?=9 :;9>1/BC /1A1</9<? 2 ?2 862@ ?69? ?61 9F2.<? 698 B11< =1:97/ 62.06 ?61 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; 9::19=7<0A2=?619::1;;9<?8698?9J1<9>2<?1<?72<?69??61 9F2.<? =1>17G1/ .</1= ?61 90=11F1<? 698 B11< 9/E.8?1/ ?2@9=/8 ?61 8.B81D.1<? 89;1 /11/8 @61< ?678 2.=? 7< - 16 - 2=/1= ?2 98>1=?97< D.18?72<1/ ?61 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; A2= ?61 9::1;;9<?8 98 ?2 @61?61= ?61=1 78 9<C 8.>6 J7</ 2A 8?9?1F1<?698B11<?9J1<7<?61@=7??1<8?9?1F1<?9</9<C 1G7/1<>1 ;1/ 7< ?69? ;7<1L 61 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; A2= ?61 9::1;;9<?78.<9B;1?2:27<?2.?9<C?67<02A?69?82=?17?61= 7< ?61@=7??1< 8?9?1F1<? 2= 7< ?611G7/1<>187<>1?61=1 78 <21G7/1<>1;1/2<B169;A2A?61/1A1</9<?8-.=?61=?61=1 78<2?67<08.0018?1/7<?61>=2881K9F7<9?72<2A''% 9</ ' ?69? ?61 9F2.<? @67>6 698 B11< =1>17G1/ .</1= ?61 90=11F1<? ?2 81;; .</1= >61D.1 698 B11< 9/E.8?1/ ?2@9=/8 ?61 >2<87/1=9?72< 7< =18:1>? 2A 8.B81D.1<? 89;1 /11/8 < ?61 9B81<>1 2A ?6181 >9?102=7>9; 9G1=F1<?8 9</ 1G7/1<>1 ?61 9=0.F1<?8 2A ;19=<1/ >2.<81; 9::19=7<0 A2= ?61 9::1;;9<?8 ?69? ?61 9F2.<? 698 B11< 9/E.8?1/ >9<<2? B1>2.<?1<9<>1/ %% 61 /1A1</9<? 698 <2? ;1/ 9<C 1G7/1<>1 ?2 8.B8?9<?79?1 678 >;97F 1K>1:? :=2/.>7<0 ?61 /2>.F1<?8 @67>67<>;./18?618.B81D.1<?89;1/11/9</2<>1?61=178 89;1 2A ?61 :=2:1=?C @67>6 @98 862@< 98 9 8.7? 8>61/.;1 - 17 - :=2:1=?C 7< ?61 90=11F1<? 9</ 02<1 9@9C ?61=1 =1F97<8 <2?67<0A2=?61:;97<?7AA?2811JA2=:1=A2=F9<>19</1G1<7A 9<C9??1F:?78F9/17?@2.;/9F2.<??2A=.7?;188>;97F % 8 :1= 1>?72< ( 2A ?61 </79< 2<?=9>? >? #H% @67>6 :=2G7/18 ?69? 2B;709?72< 2A 9 :1=82< @62 698 =1>17G1/9/G9<?901.</1=G27/90=11F1<?2=>2<?=9>??69? B1>2F18G27/-2=198C=1A1=1<>1@11K?=9>??61:=2G7872< 82 9;82 ?61 7;;.8?=9?72< 07G1< 7< =18:1>? 2A ?61 :=2G7872< 2A ;9@@67>6=19/898.</1= “65. Obligation of person who has received advantage under void agreement, or contract that becomes void.-When an agreement is discovered to be void, or when a contract becomes void, any person who has received any advantage under such agreement or contract is bound to restore it, or to make compensation for it to the person from whom he received it. a) xxx b) A contracts with B to deliver to him 250 maunds of rice before the first of May. A delivers 130 maunds only before that day, and none after. B retains the 130 maunds after the first of May. He is bound to pay A for them.” - 18 - 24. 7<>1?6190=11F1<?7?81;A698B11<A=.8?=9?1/7< G71@2A8.B81D.1<?89;1/11/9</98?619F2.<?78:97/?2 /1A1</9<?2A2=61=9</2<B169;A2A2?61=/1A1</9<?89 87F:;18.7?A2==1>2G1=C2AF2<1C@67>6698B11<:97/9</ @7?6?61/2>.F1<?9?K67B7? '78G1=C@1;;F97<?97<9B;1 61=178<2<1>1887?CA2=?61:1=82<8@629=1<2?:9=?718?2 ?6190=11F1<??281;;B1F9/198:9=?71887<>1?61=178<2 8:1>7A7> :1=A2=F9<>1 82.06? @67>6 >2.;/ 02 9097<8? ?617= =706?8 61 =1;71A 82.06? 78 2<;C =1>2G1=C 2A F2<1C 7<>1 ?61=1789>9?102=7>9;8?9?1F1<?7<?61:;97<??69?9:1=82< @62 789 :9=?C ?2 ?61 90=11F1<? ?2 81;; BC<9F1 67=78?9 .F9=7 @62 698 =1>17G1/ 9 8.F 2A 8(%!!! 2.? 2A 8!!!!!! :97/7<9/G9<>1698=1:97/?619F2.<? < ?6181>7=>.F8?9<>18@69?78?2B1=1>2G1=1/782<;C98.F 2A 8H!!! @67>6 698 B11< :97/ ?2 /1A1</9<? 2 A2=61=9</2<B169;A2A/1A1</9<?28%9</ % 7<>1 ?61=1 78 <2 /1<79; 2A :9CF1<? 2A 9F2.<? 9</<2@7<G71@2A?61>2<?1<?72<?69??6189F1698B11< 9/E.8?1/?2@9=/8?61>2<87/1=9?72<7<=18:1>?2A8.B81D.1<? - 19 - 89;1/11/8A97;1/7<?619B81<>12A9<C/2>.F1<?8?2?69? 1AA1>? @69? =1F97<8 ?2 B1 >2<87/1=1/ 78 ?61 9F2.<? =1>17G1/87<>1<2?=1:97/618.7?A2==1>2G1=C2A?61897/ 9F2.<? 78 A7;1/ ?9J7<0 ?61 >;97F 9097<8? ?61 :1=82<8 ?2 @62F ?61 9F2.<? 78 :97/ 61=1 78 <2 >2<?=9 1G7/1<>1 :;9>1/ BC /1A1</9<? 28% 9</ ?2 >2<?1</ ?69? ?61 9F2.<?=1>17G1/BC/1A1</9<?<278A2=61=81;A9</<2? 2<B169;A2A/1A1</9<?<2%9</ %( <?6181>7=>.F8?9<>18?61?=79;2.=?:=2>11/1/ ?2 :988 E./0F1<? 9</ /1>=11 :9=?;C /1>=117<0 ?61 8.7? /7=1>?7<0 ?61 /1A1</9<?8 ?2 F9J1 022/ 9 8.F 2A 8H!!! 9;2<0 @7?6 #I 7<?1=18? 98 9097<8? #I 7<?1=18?98>;97F1/BC?61:;97<?7AA78E.8?9</:=2:1= %H ?78?=7?1;9@?69?2<>1?6190=11F1<?B1>2F18 7F:2887B;1?2:1=A2=F?61:1=82<@62698=1>17G1/>1=?97< 9/G9<?90178B2.</?2=18?2=1?6189F17<>1?619F2.<? 698B11<:97/.</1=9>61D.1?6=2.06B9<J9</?6189F1 698 B11< :=2G1/BC :=2/.>7<0 ?611K?=9>? 2A 8?9?1F1<? 2A - 20 - 9>>2.<?9</7<?619B81<>12A9<C>2<?=91G7/1<>1?2?69? 1AA1>? 82 9;82 7< ?61 9B81<>1 2A 9<C 1AA1>?7G1 >=288 1K9F7<9?72<7<2=/1=?28.B8?9<?79?1?617=>2<?1<?72<8<2@ =9781/ ?62.06 <2? 7< ?61 @=7??1< 8?9?1F1<? 7? B1>2F18 G1=C 69=/ A2= ?678 2.=? 9>>1:? ?61 8.BF78872<8 2A ?61 ;19=<1/>2.<81;A2=?619::1;;9<?8 %# 61 7;;.8?=9?72< :=2G7/1/ ?2 1>?72< ( 2A 2<?=9>? >? @67>6 @1 69G1 9;=19/C 1K?=9>?1/ 9B2G1 >;19=;C 862@8 ?69? ?61 :1=82< @62 698 =1>17G1/ >1=?97< 9/G9<?901 78 B2.</ ?2 =18?2=1 7? < ?6181 >7=>.F8?9<>18 @1A7</<27<A7=F7?7187<?61E./0F1<?9<//1>=11:9881/BC ?61?=79;2.=? %" =7 9C9=9E 698 =1;71/ 2< ?61 E./0F1<? 2A 2<5B;1:1K2.=?7<?61>9812A")$ *+!, /9?1/ %%!%!% @61=17< ?612<4B;1:1K2.=?69861;/?69?7<?619B81<>12=<2< E27</1=2A9::=2:=79?1:9=?C@6281:=181<>178=1D.7=1/A2= :=2:1=9</1AA1>?7G19/E./7>9?72<2A?61/78:.?17<?618.7? - 21 - =1D.7=189=1F9</?2?61?=79;2.=?61E./0F1<?2A?61 2<4B;1:1K2.=?<2/2.B??=.1=109=/7<0?61<2< E27</1= 9</<1>1889=C:9=?71862@1G1=?61897/E./0F1<?@7;;<2? >2F1?2?6197/2A?619::1;;9<?7<G71@2A?61:1>.;79=A9>?8 9</>7=>.F8?9<>182A?61>9812<69</618.7?78A7;1/A2= =1>2G1=C 2A F2<1C 9097<8? /1A1</9<? 28 ?2 @62 9=1 ?61 :9=?718 ?2 ?61 90=11F1<? 9</ @62 69G1 =1>17G1/ ?61 9F2.<? 61 :=181<>1 2A 2?61= :1=82< @62 69/ 9;=19/C =1:97/?619F2.<?87<>1?61=178<2>;97F9097<8??61897/ :1=82< ! <?61>981=1;71/2<BC?61;19=<1/>2.<81;A2= ?61 9::1;;9<? 9 ?67=/ :1=82< 698 A7;1/ 9::;7>9?72< 811J7<0 7F:;19/F1<?9</1G1<?61:;97<?7AA7<?61897/8.7?698<2? A7;1/9<C2BE1>?72<?2?617F:;19/F1<? <?61:=181<?>981 2< 69</ ?61 :1=82<8 @62 9=1 1G1< 9>>2=/7<0 ?2 ?61 /1A1</9<?8 @62 9=1<1>1889=C 9</ :=2:1=?C :9=?718 ?2 ?61 8.7? 69G1 <2? A7;1/ 9<C 9::;7>9?72< A2= 7F:;19/7<0 87<>1 ?61=178<2=1;71A82.06?9</:9881/9097<8??617=7<?1=18? - 22 - 619F2.<?78:97/.</1=>61D.1?29:9=?7>.;9=:1=82<@62 698 =1>17G1/ 7? A2= 61= 98 @1;; 98 2< B169;A 2A 2?61= /1A1</9<?8 7< ?61 8.7? 9</ 87<>1 ?61=1 78 <2 8:1>7A7> 9881=?72< BC 2?61= /1A1</9<?8 ?69? <2 9.?62=7?C 07G1< ?2 /1A1</9<? 2 ?2 =1>17G1 ?61 9F2.<? 2< ?617=B169;A 9</ ?61 9F2.<? 78 =1>17G1/ BC /1A1</9<? 2 7</7G7/.9;;C < ?6181>7=>.F8?9<>18?61:=181<>12A2?61=:9=?7189=1<2? 9? 9;; <1>1889=C A2= 1AA1>?7G1 9/E./7>9?72< 2A ?61 ;78 7< ?61 >981 98 61;/ 7< ?61 E./0F1<? 2A ?61 2<4B;1 :1K 2.=? 8?9?1/8.:=9 < ?61 >981 2< 69</ ?62.06 /1A1</9<? 28 9</ % 69G1 A7;1/ 8?9?1F1<? 2A 2BE1>?72<8 B.? <2? ;1/ 9<C 1G7/1<>1 1K>1:? :=2/.>7<0 /2>.F1<?8 @67>6 1G1< 8?=1<0?61<8?61>9812A?61:;97<?7AA61=19=18.B81D.1<? 89;1/11/8@67>669G1A=.8?=9?1/?6190=11F1<??281;; < ?6181 >7=>.F8?9<>18 ?61 8.7? A7;1/ 811J7<0 A2= =1>2G1=C 2A F2<1C 1G1< @7?62.? 811J7<0 A2= 8:1>7A7> :1=A2=F9<>1 98 >2<?1F:;9?1/ BC ?61 ;19=<1/ >2.<81; A2= ?61 9::1;;9<? 78 F97<?97<9B;1 - 23 - % 8 8?9?1/ 8.:=9 .</1= 1>?72< ( 2A ?61 2<?=9>?>??61:9=?C?29<90=11F1<?@61<7?B1>2F18 7F:2887B;1?2:1=A2=F9</17?61=G27/2=2?61=@78178B2.</ ?2=18?2=1?619/G9<?9018@67>661698=1>17G1/.</1=?61 89F1 <?61A9>?89</>7=>.F8?9<>182A?61>981@169G1 02<1?6=2.06?611<?7=1=1>2=/8?61=178<2?67<01;7>7?1/BC ?61 /1A1</9<?8 1G1< 7< ?61 >=288 1K9F7<9?72< 2A ?61 :;97<?7AA 9</ 678 @7?<18818 ?69? ?61 9F2.<? =1>17G1/ 698 17?61= 9;=19/C B11< :97/ 2= 9/E.8?1/ ?2@9=/8 ?61 89;1 >2<87/1=9?72<7<=18:1>?2A8.B81D.1<?89;1/11/898<2@ >2<?1</1/ BC ?61 9::1;;9<?8 7< ?61 :=181<? 9::19; ? 78 01=F9<1?28?9?1?69?1G1<?61=178<28.>60=2.</=9781/ 7<?619::19;F1F2=9</.F <?619A2=1897/A9>?89</>7=>.F8?9<>18@1A7</ <2A2=>17<?619=0.F1<?2A?61;19=<1/>2.<81;9::19=7<0 A2=?619::1;;9<?9</69G7<0<2?A2.</9<C7<A7=F7?7187<?61 E./0F1<? 2A ?61 ?=79; 2.=? @1 A7</ <2 <1>1887?C 2A - 24 - 7<?1=A1=1<>19??6169</82A?6782.=?7<?61E./0F1<?9</ /1>=11:9881/BC?61?=79;2.=?>>2=/7<0;C@1:988?61 A2;;2@7<0 7 61 9::19; F1=7? 9</ 9>>2=/7<0;C 78F7881/ >2<A7=F7<0 ?61 E./0F1<? 9</ /1>=11 :9881/ 7< 2 %%! /9?1/ %!!"%!# BC </ //7?72<9; 1<72=7G7;./019</-7/9=78>2<A7=F1/ 77 < ?61 A9>?8 9</ >7=>.F8?9<>18 <2 2=/1= 98 ?2 >28?8 -) &!( $ -) &"( $