Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58429 (KAR)
GAJANAND v. DAYANAND AND ANR
MFA/201308/2024 · 2025-11-11
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58429 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58429 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%" &!'"%"
&!'"#'$!!#
"!"%%! ($) *+
"!"%%! *
+
!"#$# %
&&
#
&& ' & (#'("## $$
!"#$#
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&&
& & ! #$ %
' ) $$!$ #
' ' & #*+# '
'
& $!($!($+
! $# &
' !"$$$( , +$$$$$$( #,
*
+
&"
%
&
#
!-./01 23145.11/56 ' & 2./045758(#'("## $$-.0/564
- 3 -
( !"#$#
&&
' & 9
&
&( ! #$ %
' ) ##$:$ #
' ' & #*+# '
'
& $$+$" & !$#
'&&
'; ' && <&
<&
!'
<&
# '8$#+$!$"356.0.=>485#*+#8?8>80 .@4=A.1 => #:!! @.0.45/?>.0 0.?.00.6 >8 /1 B>@. =>; @/1 2..5 ?4A.6 2- >@. =A/4C/5>(/D/5/56 =@/AA.57457 >@. D367C.5> 6/>.6 $!$!$+ E/11.6 2- 664>485/A 41>04=> /56 .114851 830> /56 664>485/A 46/0 /1/F/G/A-/5458! $#
'8$#+"$ 356.0.=>485#*+#8?8>80 .@4=A.1 => #:!! @.0.45/?>.0 0.?.00.6 >8 /1 B>@. =>;
- 4 -
@/1 2..5 ?4A.6 2- >@. =A/4C/5>(@/5G/0.EE/ =@/AA.57457 >@.D367C.5>6/>.6$$+$"E/11.62->@..54804F4A
367. /56 664>485/A /1/F/G/A-/5 45
8!$#
+ '/=>1 74F457 041. >8 >@. ?4A457 8? >@. /EE./A1 204.?A- 1>/>.6 /0. >@/> 85 +$##$$ /> /283> *$$ EC H@.5 >@.=A/4C/5>1/D/5/56/56@/5G/0.EE/H.0.E08=..6457 85 C8>80=-=A. 2./04570.741>0/>4858(+!(*" ?08C 80>/( F4AA/7. >8 /1/F/G/A-/5 @/5G/0.EE/ H/1 046457 >@. 1/46 C8>80=-=A. /56 /> >@/> >4C. H@.5 >@.- H.0. H4>@45 >@. A4C4>1 8? 3=@/A/C2 F4AA/7. 5./0 >@. A/56 8? 85. /D.560/ 366. / 3C8 F.@4=A. 2./0457 0.741>0/>485 8(#'("## 2.457 604F.5 2- 4>1 604F.0 />/@47@1E..6/5645/0/1@/565.7A47.5>C/55.0=/C. 41 8EE814>. 640.=>485 6/1@.6 >8 >@. F.@4=A. 8? >@. =A/4C/5>1 1 / 0.13A> 8? >@. /?80.1/46 /==46.5> >@. =A/4C/5>1 ?.AA 68H5 131>/45.6 704.F831 45D304.1/56H.0. @81E4>/A4I.6
- 5 -
" @.=A/4C/5>1?4A.6E.>4>4851356.0.=>485#8?>@. =>1..G457=8CE.51/>485>H/1EA./6.6>@/>>@.-1E.5> 14754?4=/5>/C835>>8H/061C.64=/A.JE.51.1=85F.-/5=. =@/07.1 /56 8>@.0 0.A/>.6 =81>1 > H/1 ?30>@.0 EA./6.6 >@/> >@. /==46.5> 8==300.6 18A.A- 85 /==835> 8? 0/1@ /56 5.7A47.5>604F4578?>@.8??.56457F.@4=A.2-4>1604F.0
5 8!$# 3E85 1.0F4=. 8? 58>4=. >@. 0.1E856.5> 81# /56 /EE./0.6 >@0837@ >@.40 =8351.A /56 ?4A.6 H04>>.5 1>/>.C.5> 6.5-457 >@. /F.0C.5>1C/6. 45>@.=A/4CE.>4>48558! $#3E851.0F4=.8? 58>4=.>@.0.1E856.5>8/EE./0.6>@0837@=8351.A/56 ?4A.6H04>>.51>/>.C.5>6.5-457>@./F.0C.5>1C/6.45>@. =A/4C E.>4>485 @. 0.1E856.5> 8# 6.1E4>. 1.0F4=. 8? 58>4=.64658>/EE./02.?80.>@.04235/A/56H/1EA/=.6 .J(E/0>. 5 >@. 2/141 8? >@. EA./64571 8? >@. E/0>4.1 >@. A/4C104235/A?0/C.6>@.4113.1/56>@.0./?>.00.=806.6 >@. .F46.5=. @. 04235/A 2- 4CE375.6 D367C.5> /56
- 6 -
/H/06@/1E/0>A-/AA8H.6>@.=A/4CE.>4>4851/56@.A6>@/> >@. =A/4C/5> 45 8! $# 41 .5>4>A.6 >8 / =8CE.51/>485 8? 1!"$$$( /56 =A/4C/5> 41 8!$# 41 .5>4>A.6 >8 / =8CE.51/>485 8? 1##+$"+ (/A857H4>@45>.0.1>/>>@.0/>.8?,E/ /56640.=>.65130/5=.8CE/5-41640.=>.6>86.E814>>@. =8CE.51/>485 /C835> /A857 H4>@ 45>.0.1> .457 /7704.F.6>@.E0.1.5>/EE./A1@/F.2..5?4A.6
*
($ *
)
* @. A./05.6 =8351.A ?80 >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 0/41.6 >@.
?8AA8H457=85>.5>4851 / '401>A- >@. =A/4C/5> /11.0>1 >@/> @. H/1 ./05457 1# $$$(E.0C85>@/56H/11.A?.CEA8-.68H.F.0 >@.04235/A@/1.00.645>/G457>@.45=8C./1C.0.A-/1 1#$$$$(E.0C85>@ 2 .=856A->@.=A/4C/5>@/1.J/C45.6>@.68=>801/1 0/D.560/8>@/04 0>@8E.64=1307.85/1 (/560
- 7 -
/5D..F 3C/0 .-. 1E.=4/A41> /1 (+ @. 04235/A 356.0F/A3.6>@. =A/4C/5><1 H@8A.(286- 641/24A4>- /> #$, =85>0/64=>457>@..F46.5=.8?>@.68=>80>@/>>@.=A/4C/5> 13??.0.6$,641/24A4>->8H@8A.047@>.-. = /1>A- 63. >8 >@. /==46.5> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 131>/45.6704.F83145D304.1.H/1>0./>.6/145E/>4.5>?80 / E.0486 8? + 6/-1 F.5 /?>.0 641=@/07. ?08C >@. @81E4>/A@.H/158>45/E814>485>8641=@/07.@410.73A/0 H80G . @/1 13??.0.6 A8> 8? E/45 630457 >0./>C.5> 85146.0457 >@. 1/C. >@. 8F.0/AA =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2->@.04235/A4185>@.A8H.0146. 4>@ >@. /28F. =85>.5>4851 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A 1837@>>8/AA8H>@./EE./A ! 5 >@. 8>@.0 @/56 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A ?80 >@. 5130/5=. 8CE/5- @/1 0/41.6 >@. ?8AA8H457 =835>.0( =85>.5>4851 / '401>A->@./11.0>4858?=A/4C/5>>@/>@.H/1./05457 1# $$$( E.0 C85>@ 0.C/451 351321>/5>4/>.6 63. >8 A/=G8?68=3C.5>/0-.F46.5=.5>@./21.5=.8?E088?8? - 8 -
45=8C. >@. 04235/A @/1 /11.11.6 >@. 45=8C. 8? >@. =A/4C/5>58>485/AA- 2 .=856A- >@. 04235/A =85146.0457 >@. 45D304.1 131>/45.62->@.=A/4C/5>/56.F46.5=.8?>@.68=>80@/1 047@>A-/11.11.6>@.H@8A.286-641/24A4>-/>#$, = @406A- =85146.0457 >@. 45D304.1 131>/45.6 2- >@. =A/4C/5> /56 =85146.0457 >@. /7. /56 /F8=/>485 8? >@. =A/4C/5> >@. 8F.0/AA =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2- >@. 04235/A 41 D31> /56 0./185/2A. /56 4> 68.1 58> H/00/5> 45>.0?.0.5=. 4>@ >@. /28F. =85>.5>4851 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A 1837@>>8641C411>@./EE./A :
./06 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A ?80 >@. E/0>4.1 /56 E.031.6>@.D367C.5>/56/H/068?>@.04235/A
#$ > 41 58> 45 641E3>. >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 131>/45.6 45D304.145>@.08/6>0/??4=/==46.5>8==300.685+$##$$ 63.>80/1@/565.7A47.5>604F4578?>@.8??.56457F.@4=A. 2-4>1604F.0
- 9 -
## @.=A/4C/5>=A/4C1>@/>@.H/1./054571# $$$( E.0 C85>@ 3> @. @/1 58> E0863=.6 /5- 68=3C.5>1 >8 1321>/5>4/>.@41=A/4C@.0.?80.45>@./21.5=.8?E088? 8?45=8C.58>485/A45=8C.@/1>82./11.11.6==806457 >8 >@. 7346.A45.1 4113.6 2- >@. /05/>/G/ >/>. .7/A .0F4=.1 3>@804>- ?80 /==46.5>1 8==300.6 45 >@. -./0 $$58>485/A45=8C.1@/AA2.>/G.5/>1#+* $(EC
# 1E.0H8356=.0>4?4=/>.>@.=A/4C/5>@/1131>/45.6 /20/14851 85 047@> G5.. C./130457 J =C1 /56 A/=.0/>.685047@>>.CE80/A0.74858?1@.AAC./130457 =C J=CA/=.0/>.685047@>.-.2/AA>0/3C/>4=20/4545D30- ?/=4/A /56 0(.-. 45D304.1 ?8356 E81>30/A 746645.11 @./6/=@.@./F45.1145@./60..A4571.51/>4856.?80C.6 A88G 8? ?/=. A811 8? .-.147@> 41 63. 400.E/0/2A. 6/C/7. E/0>4/A A811 8? @./0457 . @/1 .J/C45.6 0 /D.560/ G8>@/04 0>@8E.64= 1307.85( ( /56 0 /5D..FG3C/0 -. 1E.=4/A41> /1 (+ ( 45 @41 .F46.5=. @/1 =/>.7804=/AA- 1>/>.6 >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 13??.0.6 45D30-
- 10 -
>8>@.?/=4/A/56@./6/56/11.11.6>8>/A641/24A4>-/1 , >8H@8A.286- (+@/1/11.11.6>@.641/24A4>-=/31.6>8 >@. .-. /> $, 85146.0457 >@. .F46.5=. 8?
( /56
(+ /56 H8356 =.0>4?4=/>.(J : 641/24A4>- =.0>4?4=/>.( J #/56J #+H./0.8?>@.8E45485>@/>H@8A.286- 641/24A4>-@/1>82./11.11.6/1"$,@.=A/4C/5>41/7.6 /283>"-./01/>>@.>4C.8?>@./==46.5>/56C3A>4EA4.0 /EEA4=/2A. >8 @41 /7. 7083E 41 B#!; @31 >@. =A/4C/5> 41 .5>4>A.6 ?80 =8CE.51/>485 8? , * 1#+* $(K#K#!K"$, 85 /==835> 8? <A811 8? ?3>30. 45=8C.<
#+ @. 5/>30. 8? 45D304.1 4564=/>.1 >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> C31>@/F.2..5356.00.1>/56>0./>C.5>?80/E.04868?+ C85>@1 851.L3.5>A- >@. =A/4C/5> 41 .5>4>A.6 ?80 =8CE.51/>485 8? , * 1#+* $K+ C85>@1 356.0>@.@./6BA8118?45=8C.630457A/463EE.0486;
- 11 -
#" @. =A/4C/5> H/1 @81E4>/A4I.6 /1 /5 45E/>4.5> ?80 C80. >@/5 + 6/-1 45 >@. @81E4>/A /56 1321.L3.5>A- 0.=.4F.6?30>@.0>0./>C.5>@.0.?80.H./0.45=A45.6>8 .5@/5=. >@. =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 356.0 >@. @./6 8? B?886 583041@C.5> =85F.-/5=. /56 />>.56/5> =@/07.1;
?08C1"$$(>8, *
#
3. >8 >@. /==46.5> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 13??.0.6 704.F83145D304.1/56/A18356.0785.1307.0-85146.0457 >@. E08A857.6 E/45 630457 >0./>C.5> /1 H.AA /1 >@. E.0C/5.5> 641/24A4>- =.0>4?4.6 2- >@. 68=>80 H. /0. 45=A45.6 >8 .5@/5=. >@. =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2- >@. 04235/A 356.0 >@. @./6 8? <E/45 /56 13??.04571< ?08C 1$$$$(>8,
*/56/H/06/=8CE.51/>4858? 1 *356.0>@.@./68?<A8118?/C.54>4.1<
# 5 0.1E.=> 8? C.64=/A .JE.51.1 41 =85=.05.6 >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 E0863=.6 C.64=/A 24AA1(J #" >8 J #* ?80 13C 8? 1**:$$ ( 85146.0457 >@. C.64=/A 24AA1 H. /0.45=A45.6>8.5@/5=.>@.=8CE.51/>485/H/06.6356.0
- 12 -
>@. @./6 8? BC.64=/A .JE.51.1; ?08C 1$$$$$( >8 , *
#* 85146.0457>@.5/>30.8?45D304.1>@.=8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2- >@. 04235/A 356.0 8>@.0 @./61 41 D31> /56 0./185/2A. #! @31 >@. =A/4C/5> 41 .5>4>A.6 >8 >@. ?8AA8H457 =8CE.51/>485
-./0,1230405/6 53/6/02/15, ,17165/5 892:/ 638401; (,) ,17165/5 892:3, 462 (,)
/45/5613??.04571 $$$$ $$$$ .64=/A.JE.51.1 $$$$$ *!$$$$ >>.56/5>85F.-/5=. =@/07.1M3>04>4858? ?886.>=
"$$ # $$$ 8118?45=8C.630457 A/463EE.0486 $
"# $ 8118?/C.54>4.1 $ +$$$$ 8118??3>30.45=8C. #$$$ ##!!$$$ 21;
- 13 -
#: 5>@.0.13A>>@.?8AA8H457806.041E/11.6
4 @./EE./A411;;7/530.162 44 @.D367C.5>8?>@.A/4C104235/A41C864?4.6 444 @.=A/4C/5>41.5>4>A.6>8/>8>/A=8CE.51/>485 8?,
* 4F @. 5130/5=. 8CE/5- 41 640.=>.6 >8 6.E814> >@. =8CE.51/>485 /C835> /A857 H4>@ 45>.0.1> N , E/ ?08C >@. 6/>. 8? ?4A457 8? >@. =A/4C E.>4>485 >4AA >@. 6/>. 8? 0./A4I/>485 H4>@45 / E.0486 8? 14J H..G1 ?08C >@. 6/>. 8? 0.=.4E> 8? =8E-8?>@41D367C.5> F @.6.E814>/560.A./1.8?/C835>1@/AA2.C/6. 45>.0C18?>@./H/068?>@.04235/A
*
($ *
)
$ @. A./05.6 =8351.A ?80 >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 0/41.6 >@.
?8AA8H457=85>.5>4851
- 14 -
/ '401>A- >@. =A/4C/5> /11.0>1 >@/> @. H/1 ./05457 1+$$$$( E.0 C85>@ 2- H80G457 /1 C/185 8H.F.0 >@.04235/A@/1.00.645>/G457>@.45=8C./1C.0.A-/1 1#+* $(E.0C85>@ 2 .=856A- >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 .J/C45.6 >@. 68=>80 /1
(@.04235/A356.0F/A3.6>@.=A/4C/5><1H@8A.(286- 641/24A4>-/># ,=85>0/64=>457>@..F46.5=.8?>@.68=>80 >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> 13??.0.6 $, 641/24A4>- >8 E/0>4=3A/0 A4C2 = /1>A- 63. >8 >@. /==46.5> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 131>/45.6704.F83145D304.1.H/1>0./>.6/145E/>4.5>?80 / E.0486 8? #$ 6/-1 F.5 /?>.0 641=@/07. ?08C >@. @81E4>/A@.H/158>45/E814>485>8641=@/07.@410.73A/0 H80G . @/1 13??.0.6 A8> 8? E/45 630457 >0./>C.5> 85146.0457 >@. 1/C. >@. 8F.0/AA =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2->@.04235/A4185>@.A8H.0146. 4>@ >@. /28F. =85>.5>4851 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A 1837@>>8/AA8H>@./EE./A
- 15 -
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
- 16 -
./06 >@. A./05.6 =8351.A ?80 >@. E/0>4.1 /56 E.031.6>@.D367C.5>/56/H/068?>@.04235/A
+ > 41 58> 45 641E3>. >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 131>/45.6 45D304.145>@.08/6>0/??4=/==46.5>8==300.685+$##$$ 63.>80/1@/565.7A47.5>604F4578?>@.8??.56457F.@4=A. 2-4>1604F.0
" @.=A/4C/5>=A/4C1>@/>@.H/1./054571+$$$$( E.0 C85>@ 3> @. @/1 58> E0863=.6 /5- 68=3C.5>1 >8 1321>/5>4/>.@41=A/4C@.0.?80.45>@./21.5=.8?E088? 8?45=8C.58>485/A45=8C.@/1>82./11.11.6==806457 >8 >@. 7346.A45.1 4113.6 2- >@. /05/>/G/ >/>. .7/A .0F4=.1 3>@804>- ?80 /==46.5>1 8==300.6 45 >@. -./0 $$58>485/A45=8C.1@/AA2.>/G.5/>1#+* $(EC @.04235/A@/1047@>A->/G.5>@.1/4645=8C. 1E.0H8356=.0>4?4=/>.>@.=A/4C/5>@/1131>/45.6 0/6.047@>641>/A?.C3045>.0=856-A/0?0/=>30.H4>@ A/>.0/A=856-A./56E/>.AA/1.F.0.A-=8CC354>>.6?0/=>30. H4>@ A/>.0/A =856-A. >424/ =8CC354>>.6 ?0/=>30. H4>@
- 17 -
C/540. =85>/C45/>485 /G457 45>8 =85146.0/>485 >@. 6.E814>485 8? >@. 68=>80 /56 45D304.1 C.5>485.6 45 >@. H8356=.0>4?4=/>.4>H83A62./EE08E04/>.>8/11.11H@8A. 286- 641/24A4>- /> $, @. =A/4C/5> 41 /7.6 /283> +! -./01/>>@.>4C.8?>@./==46.5>/56C3A>4EA4.0/EEA4=/2A. >8@41/7.7083E41B# ;@31>@.=A/4C/5>41.5>4>A.6?80 =8CE.51/>4858?, < *1#+* $K#K# K$, 85/==835>8?<A8118??3>30.45=8C.<
@. 5/>30. 8? 45D304.1 4564=/>.1 >@/> >@. =A/4C/5> C31>@/F.2..5356.00.1>/56>0./>C.5>?80/E.04868? $ C85>@1 851.L3.5>A- >@. =A/4C/5> 41 .5>4>A.6 ?80 =8CE.51/>485 8? , * 1#+* $K C85>@1 356.0>@.@./6BA8118?45=8C.630457A/463EE.0486;
* @.
=A/4C/5> H/1 @81E4>/A4I.6 /1 /5 45E/>4.5> ?80 C80. >@/5 #$ 6/-1 45 >@. @81E4>/A /56 1321.L3.5>A- 0.=.4F.6 ?30>@.0 >0./>C.5> @.0.?80. >@. 04235/A @/1 047@>A-/H/06.6=8CE.51/>485/H/06.6356.0>@.@./68? B/>>.56/5>=@/07.1/56=85F.-/5=.;/1, *
- 18 -
! 3. >8 >@. /==46.5> >@. =A/4C/5> @/1 13??.0.6 704.F83145D304.1/56/A18356.0785.1307.0-85146.0457 >@. E08A857.6 E/45 630457 >0./>C.5> /1 H.AA /1 >@. E.0C/5.5> 641/24A4>- =.0>4?4.6 2- >@. 68=>80 H. /0. 45=A45.6 >8 .5@/5=. >@. =8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2- >@. 04235/A 356.0 >@. @./6 8? <E/45 /56 13??.04571< ?08C 1$$$$( >8,
*/56 356.0 >@. @./6 8?<A811 8?/C.54>4.1<?08C1$$$$(>8, * : 85146.0457>@.5/>30.8?45D304.1>@.=8CE.51/>485 /H/06.6 2- >@. 04235/A 356.0 8>@.0 @./61 41 D31> /56 0./185/2A. +$ @31 >@. =A/4C/5> 41 .5>4>A.6 >8 >@. ?8AA8H457 =8CE.51/>485
-./0,1230405/6 53/6/02/15, ,17165/5 892:/ 638401; (,) ,17165/5 892:3, 462 (,)
/45/5613??.04571 $$$$ $$$$ .64=/A.JE.51.1 $$ ! $$ ! >>.56/5>=@/07.1/56 $$$$ $$$$
- 19 -
=85F.-/5=. 8118?45=8C.630457 A/463EE.0486
"!$$ ! $$ 8118?/C.54>4.1/56 53>04>485 $$$$
"$$$$ 8118??3>30.45=8C. +*# $
": $$$ '3>30.C.64=/A.JE.51.1 $$$$ $$$$ 21;
+# 5>@.0.13A>>@.?8AA8H457806.041E/11.6
4 @./EE./A411;;7/530.162 44 @.D367C.5>8?>@.A/4C104235/A41C864?4.6 444 @.=A/4C/5>41.5>4>A.6>8/>8>/A=8CE.51/>485 8?, * 4F @. 5130/5=. 8CE/5- 41 640.=>.6 >8 6.E814> >@. =8CE.51/>485 /C835> /A857 H4>@ 45>.0.1> N , E/ ?08C >@. 6/>. 8? ?4A457 8? >@. =A/4C E.>4>485 >4AA >@. 6/>. 8? 0./A4I/>485 H4>@45 / E.0486 8? 14J H..G1 ?08C >@. 6/>. 8? 0.=.4E> 8? =8E-8?>@41D367C.5>
- 20 -
F @.6.E814>/560.A./1.8?/C835>1@/AA2.C/6. 45>.0C18?>@./H/068?>@.04235/A
"5* (%") '
"5* (#'$!!#) '
41>8#A8 "