Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58425 (KAR)
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA v. QAMAR QUADRI AND ORS
RFA/200001/2025 · 2025-09-16
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58425 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58425 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$
" " ! %%
" %
& #
' ())'* )*'
%
%
' #
' ())'* )*'
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* %
%
" +%
' #
())(
)*'
'
,,
)-
$ ,, *! - ,
-( ! "
! .' ,
! ('-
/
", # #
- 3 -
# ! 0123 450 6012703 8.97:06 1;;012<7= >.2 450 1;;066174: 173 450 6012703 8.97:06 1;;012<7= >.2 450 20:;.73074:.7<74026.894.2?1;;6<814<.7>.28.73.714<.7.> 3061?.>'-31?:
50 1;;016 <: ><603 1=1<7:4 450 93=@074 173 08200 31403 ('- ;1::03 <7 .' .7 450><60.>2<78<;16<A<693=027!14<31216.7=B<45 13061?1;;6<814<.74.8.73.704503061?.>'-31?:<7 :9;;.24 .> 45<: 1;;6<814<.7 17 1>><31A<4 <: :B.27 C? 450 ::<:4174 .@@<::<.702 1:1AD16?17 :414<7= 4514 E93=@074 173 308200 B1: ;1::03 .7 ('- 173 14 45144<@02<14<6B1:4509;02<74073074.>4501<6 0 B1: 4217:>02203 .7 --- >402 5<: 4217:>02 2<<213124..D8512=0173614022<17E1;;1C081@0 450 9;02<74073074 .> 450 1<6 >2.@ 4. (' 9C:0F90746? 2<130D12 4..D 8512=0 1: 9;02<74073074 >2.@ (' 4. - 50201>402 2<,96<@17< >2.@ *
4. - 4 -
*2<51C933<7
160
517B1:9;02<74073074 >2.@*4.&'2<512171C1:1;;1B5. B1: :02A03 >2.@ &' 4. ' 2< 2166<D12E97 4..D 8512=0 1: 9;02<74073074 >2.@ ' 4. *& 92<7= 450 ;02<.3 >2.@ ('-
4. ' 45020 120 4.416 :0A07 9;02<74073074:B0208517=03173450:09;02<74073074: 3<37.441D017?:40;:7.2B020450?@1301B120.>450 ;073<7=6<4<=14<.7 * 50 308200 5.6302 ><603 450 G0894<.7 04<4<.7 !<7503082005.630220@1<703:<6074>.2:0A07 ?012:17316:.:B.274.171>><31A<4B1:4514B1:7.4 ><603 0126<02 166.B<7= 450 6<@<414<.7 4. ;1:: :. 4514 450 30>073174:B.96320@1<7971B120.>450:9<4/:.948.@0 ' 50 20:;.73074: 30>073174: B020 70<4502 <7>.2@03 1C.94 450 ;1::<7= .> 450 308200 C? 450 .A027@0743A.81407.23<350;2.A<3060=1613A<80.7 B504502<4B1:1;;2.;2<1404.><60171;;016
- 5 -
509;02<74073074:B0208517=0321;<36?173 2<166<D12E971. >.2 450 ><2:4 4<@0 81@0 4. D7.B 1C.94450308200B507450B1:><6031734501:D03 5<@ 4. :<=7 450 .CE084<.7: .7 - 4 <: :41403 4514 1;;066174: B020 971B120 4514 :985 1 308200 513 C007;1::03974<6 (B507 .(( B1:
><603 173 450 9;02<74073074 .> 1<6 B1: 1:D03 4. ><60 .CE084<.7: ;20;1203 C? 450 173 :<=703 450 :1@0.7 -500;94?.@@<::<.702.><312816603>.2 450 :4149: .> 450 ;073<7= 81:0: C06.7=<7= 4. 450 <:42<84 2<:.7<312445144<@0<43<:86.:034514450:9<4B1: 3<:;.:03 .> <7 - <4:06> 50201>402 @130 1 20;20:07414<.71730;94?.@@<::<.702B2.4016044024. 450 .A027@074 B5<85 ;02@<4403 450 ><6<7= .> 17 1;;016 .7 & A<30 770G920) 50 .A027@074 16:. 1;;.<7403 450 ::<:4174 .@@<::<.702 1:1AD16?17 1: <4<=14<.7 .73984<7= >><802 50 9;02<74073074 .> 450 ;2<:.7 >.2B12303 450 .A027@074/: ;02@<::<.7 4. 450 ::<:4174 .@@<::<.702 .7 & 390 4. 8.A<3)-
- 6 -
;1730@<8 B5<85 1>>08403
127141D1 >2.@ ) 45020 B020 >924502 3061?: 173 604402 16:. =<A07 1: ;02 770G920)
50 <4<=14<.7 ;;.<74@074 >><802 B1: 1;;.<7403.7--173::<:4174.@@<::<.70216:.
20F90:403 450 33<4<.716 3A.8140 070216 .>
161C921=< 20=123<7=450><6<7=.>4501;;016604402:31403(' 173 & @12D03 1: 173 450 1;;016 B1: ><603.7' & 50 3061? <7 ><6<7= 450 1;;016 B1: 7.4 <74074<.716 C94 390
4. 21;<3 8517=0: <7 450 9;02<74073074: 173 450 13@<7<:4214<A0 ;2.80:: 0780 3061? @1? C0 8.73.703 50 20:;.73074: 51A0 ><603 :4140@074: .> .CE084<.7 173 8.7407303 4514 45020 B1: 1 3061?.>31?:3061?.>1C.94?012:@.745:173 51:7.4@074<.703<74501;;0164<:8.74073034514450 308200B1:;1::03<7-<4:06>7.201:.7:1201::<=703 >.2 :00D<7= 8.73.714<.7 .> 3061? 173 >.2 1 ;02<.3 .> ?012:450?1207.4><6034501;;016173:1@08177.4C01
- 7 -
=2.973 >.2 :00D<7= 8.73.714<.7 .> 3061? .76? .7 450 =2.9734514>.241D<7=:40;:1>402450<@;9=703E93=@074 B1: ;1::03 173 4514 <: 7.45<7= C94 70=6<=0780 .2 812060::70:: .> 450 >><802: 50 201:.7: 1::<=703 <7 450 1;;6<814<.7 3.0: 7.4 :5.B 17? :9>><8<074 819:0 120 >1849166? <78.22084 >16:0 <@1=<712? 173 8.74212? 4. 450 .>><8<16208.23:1738.73.714<.7.>3061?.>@.204517 ?012:@.745:173F90:4<.7.>8.73.7<7=450<7.23<7140 3061?3.0:7/412<:0 ( 4 <: 16:. 8.7407403 4514 1>><31A<4 ><603 <7 :9;;.24.>450.<::B.274.C017 >><802B5.51:
7. ;02:.716 D7.B603=0 1C.94 450 >184: 30;.:03 45020<7 173 ><6<7= .> :985 1>><31A<4 C? 1 ;02:.7 B5. 51: 7. ;02:.716D7.B603=01C.94450>184::4140345020<721<:0: 3.9C4:1C.94<4:A0218<4?173450.C6<F90@.4<A0.>:.@0 .>><8<16:.>450;2<:.730;124@074 - 4<:16:.8.74073034514<>450:9>><8<074819:0 <: 7.4 :5.B7 F90:4<.7 .> 8.73.7<7= 450 3061? 3.0: 7.4
- 8 -
12<:0 50 ;61<74<>> 20:;.73074 :.9=54 4. 3<:@<:: 450 1;;6<814<.7>.28.73.714<.7.>3061? 5060127038.97:061;;012<7=>.220:;.73074:
<7 :9;;.24 .> 5<: 12=9@074 206<03 9;.7 450 E93=@074 .> .7/C60 ;0G .924 ;1::03 <7 4140 .>
127141D1 173 %51@12
5132<C?/:<745081:0.>
9720;.2403 E93=@074 <7 <A<6 ;;016 .&-' 31403 - C2.9=54 4. 7.4<80 .> 45<: .924 <7 ;121=21;5 .H5<:.92451:8.73.7034503061?.>*-31?:
.7 188.974 .> 80241<7 61;:0: 14 450 13@<7<:4214<A0 60A06: 173.>45020C0<7=7.>.66.B)9;:<7450;2.8003<7=:16.7= B<45><73<7=80241<7@02<4:<745081:0.>20:;.73074. 1=1<7:4450@1<741<71C<6<4?.>450:9<4.>4501;;066174173 4514 .> 450 206<0> @.6303 C? 450 <2:4 @073@074 .924 50;0G.92416:.@13017.C:02A14<.7451445020<:7. 50:<414<.7 <7 :414<7=4514 :985 =2.973: 120 7.B50207012
4. C0<7= I:9>><8<074 819:0J 1: ;02 084<.7 .> 450 -* 84 50 <=5 .924 6.:4 :<=54 .> 450 >184 4514 450
- 9 -
;20803074:1731945.2<4<0:<4206<039;.7C?<45133061?:
.>4B.)3<=<4:.20A074514.>:<7=60)3<=<4@.20;124<896126? 450 3061? <7 45.:0 81:0: B020 :9;;.2403 C? :9>><8<074 819:0 50 ;20:074 81:0 5.B0A02 :4173: .7 1 A02? 3<>>02074 >..4<7= .B<7= 4. :985 17 07.2@.9: 3061? 0780 B0 120 7.4 <786<703 4. 1880;4 450 8.73.714<.7 .> 4503061?C?450<=5.924
50 ;0G .924 16:. 8.@0: 4.
450 8.7869:<.7 4514B0300@<41;;2.;2<1404.@1D0<41C9731746?86012 451413@<7<:4214<A0604512=?17361G<4?81770A02:41731: 1:9>><8<074=2.973>.28.73.714<.7.>3061?173B0B174 4.8.7A0?170@;514<8@0::1=04.166450<=5.924:4514 3061?: :5166 7.4 C0 8.73.703 .7 >2<A.6.9: 173 :9;02><8<16 =2.973: 974<6 1 ;2.;02 81:0 .> :9>><8<074 819:0 <: @130 .94B5020<74504140)@185<702?<:1C604.0:41C6<:54514 <4 18403 B<45 173 20@1<703 A<=<6174 166 452.9=5.94 2.803920 <: 1 5173@1<3 4. E9:4<80 1: <4 >1@.9:6? :1<3 94 .924: 173 @.20 ;124<896126? 450 8.7:4<494<.716 .924: .9=54 7.4 4. .CA<140 450 ;2.803920
- 10 -
>.2 1 6<4<=14<7= 4140 1=078? B5. 16:. 0F9166? :9>>02 450 C12:.>6<@<414<.7>2.@;92:9<7=6<4<=14<.7:3904.<4:.B7 618D131<:<816144<4930
1A<7= 50123 450 6012703 8.97:06 >.2 450 1;;066174:1:B0661:45060127038.97:061;;012<7=>.2450 20:;.73074: 8.7:<302<7= 450 =2.973: 92=03 <7 450 1;;6<814<.7 1: B066 1: 450 ;2<78<;60: 61<3 3.B7 <7 450 E93=@074 450;.<74 4514 B.963 12<:0 >.2 8.7:<30214<.7 .> 45<:.924<:# !"#"$ #" %%&&# ' (# # ) #" &* +,-. * &/ #" %%& ()# )( "0 #)#"&*12
* 50 ;.<74 >.2 8.7:<30214<.7 <: 450 3061? @074<.7031C.A00G86930:450;02<.3.> ,;02<.3173 7.4 <78693<7= 450 , ;02<.3 4 <: 16:. 7.4 <7 3<:;940 45144501;;066174:51A01;;01203<7450.2<=<716:9<4173 16:. E93=@074173 308200 B1:;1::03<7- 7.3.9C4 450 1;;066174: 51A0 ><603 1>402 :<G ?012: 50 A02? 8.74074<.7.>4501;;066174::41404514450?51A07.4><603 B<45<74<@08177.4C01880;403<7.23024.07>.280450
- 11 -
308200;02<.3.>?012:<:A16<3 >.207>.28<7=450:1@0 17361;:0:.7450;124.>4504140C948177.4><731>1964 B<4545020:;.73074:<7><6<7=50208.23:16:.0@02=0 4514 0A07 51A<7= ;029:03 450 1>><31A<4 16:. 450 ><603 173 7.4<80 B1: 16:. <::903 50 :1@0 B1: :02A03 .7 1;;066174:5020<7<717345.9=5<74501>><31A<4<4<:
:41403 4514 450? 51A0 =<A07 17 <7:42984<.7: 4. ><60 450 .CE084<.7: 4. 450 <74026.894.2? 1;;6<814<.7 C94 0A07 7.4 41D07 17? :40;: <@@03<1406? 4. 8516607=0 450 E93=@074 173 308200 A07 51A<7= 450 D7.B603=0 45.9=5 17 1660=14<.7<: @1304514450:1@0 B1:7.4C2.9=544.450 7.4<80 .> 450 4140 173 16:. 450 60=16 >><802: B5. 51A0 8.7398403 450 81:0 16:. 7.4 C2.9=54 4. 450 7.4<80 .> 450 1;;066174: 7 :;<40 .> 51A<7= 450 D7.B603=0 4514 45020 B1: 1 308200 0A07 188.23<7= 4. 450 1;;066174: 4514 450? 81@0 4. D7.B 1C.94 450 :1@0 <7 <@@03<140 :40;: B0207.441D0794<4<:16:.:414034514;02@<::<.7B1:
=<A07 C? 450 =.A027@074 <7 450 ?012 1>402 >.92 ?012:.>D7.B603=017345020<:7.17?0G;61714<.7.7450
- 12 -
;124 .> 450 1;;066174: B514 @130 450@ 4. 41D0 450 ;02@<::<.7 >2.@ 450 ?012 4. 173 0A07 1>402 =2174<7= .> ;02@<::<.7 <7 450 ?012 450 ;20:074 1;;016<:><603<7'17316:..76?450201:.7:1::<=703 4514 9;02<74073074: .> 450 E1<6 1945.2<4?
51A0 8517=03 :9C:0F90744.450;1::<7=.>308200173450?16:.3<37.4 C2<7=<44.4507.4<805<:.92416:.51A<7=7.4<8034514 45020 <: 17 022.2 .7 450 ;124 .> 450 .>><8<16: 3<208403 4. <7>.2@ 1C.94 17? 184<.7: 120 41D07 1=1<7:4 450 02203 .>><8<16: 173 .76? 1 6<:4 <: =<A07 <7 450 >927<:503 6<:4 16:. :.@0 .> 450@ 51A0 C007 204<203 >2.@ 450 :02A<80 173 <7 .2302 4. <7A.D0 450 ;2.8003<7=: 1=1<7:4 450@ 97302 084<.7'.>8.@0:<7450B1?501;;066174:7.B:1? 4514450?51A0<7<4<1403450;2.8003<7=:1=1<7:4.76?4B. .>><8<16: 173 16:. >.2 7.4 <7>.2@<7= 450 :1@0 4. 450 1;;066174:C?45060=16.>><802:17316:.B<4520=1234.450 61;:0: .7 450 ;124 .> 450 60=16 .>><802: 7. @1402<16 <: ;61803.7208.231C.9441D<7=17?184<.7;124>2.@4514 45020 <: 7. @1402<16 1C.94 17? 184<.7 41D07 B5. @130
- 13 -
450@4.61;:0:.>>.92?012:<789241<6<7=4505173:.>450 1;;066174:<741D<7=450;2.8003<7=:1=1<7:4450.>><8<16: ' 50 E93=@074 .> 450 .7/C60 ;0G .924 8140=.2<8166?50634514B50745020<:161G<4?.7450;124.> 450 0A07 .A027@074 16:. 45020 8177.4C0 17? 607<0780 .7 450 ;124 .> 450 .A027@074 .>><8<16: <7 8516607=<7= E93=@074 173 308200 A07 .7/C60 ;0G .924 860126? @13017.C:02A14<.7<7;121=21;5.(-173 (0A07<74508.7869:<.716:.<7;121=21;5.:173 8140=.2<8166? 5063 4514 9760:: 450? @130 .94 1 81:0 >.2:9>><8<074819:0F90:4<.7.>8.73.7<7=4503061?3.0:
7.4 12<:0 924502 17 .C:02A14<.7 <: @130 4514 450 .7:4<494<.7168.924:.9=544.C08.=7<K174.>4501;145? 173;17=:.>1;2<A1406<4<=174<4<=174:8177.4C0;61803 <7 :<4914<.7: .> ;02;04916 6<4<=14<.7 B5020<7 450 >29<4: .> 450<2 308200: .2 >1A.921C60 .2302: 120 >29:421403 14 61402 :41=0:0780@13017.C:02A14<.74514450?120;1<7:4. 20<40214045<:0A0261:4<7=42013173;94166450<=5.924:
4. 7.4<80 7.4 4. 20).;07 @14402: B<45 <7.23<7140 3061? - 14 -
974<6:9>><8<074819:00G<:4:1:C?3.<7=:.4508.924:.76? 133<7:9644.450<7E92?@.20;124<896126?<71;;016:97302 084<.7.>450B5020<7<4:E92<:3<84<.7<:162013? 6<@<4034.F90:4<.7.>61B
1A<7= 8.7:<30203 450 .C:02A14<.7: @130 C? 450.7/C60;0G.9241738.7:<302<7=450=2.973:B5<85 51A0 C007 92=03 <7 450 1>><31A<4 <7 :9;;.24 .> 450 1;;6<814<.77.45<7=:9>><8<074819:0:5.B74.8.73.70450 3061? .76? 17 <740280303 1660=14<.7 <: @130 1=1<7:4 450 .>><8<16: >2.@ 450<2 .B7 30;124@074 173 16:. 1C.94 450 60=16.>><802:B5.3<37.4<7>.2@450:41>>4508.7802703 74501C:0780.>17?:9>><8<074819:017316:.<74506<=54 .> 450 E93=@074.> 450.7/C60 ;0G .924 45020 8177.4 C017?1;145?<78.73.7<7=4503061?>.21;02<.3.>@.20 4517?012:<7><6<7=450;20:0741;;0160780B03. 7.4><7317?=2.9734.8.73.704503061?17316:.B03. 7.4><7317?:9>><8<074819:017316:.45<:4?;0.>6<4<=14<.7 B504502 <4 <: C? 1 ;02:.716 6<4<=14<.7 .2 C? 450 4140 .A027@0748177.4C08.73.703C?86.:<7=4500?0:4514
- 15 -
45020<:1.A027@0741=078?1734503061?B1:819:03 390 4. 450 .>><8<16: .> 450 .A027@074 B507 450 .A027@0743<37.441D09;17?:40;:<7><6<7=4501;;016 5.9=5<7:;<40.>45030820081@04.450D7.B603=0<7 450?012<4:06>173>.21C.94(?012:3061?<7><6<7= 45<: 1;;016 0A07 1>402 450 D7.B603=0 0780 45<:
604512=<8 144<4930 .> 450 4140 8177.4 C0 8.7:<30203 173 16:.8177.4:5.B17?607<0780<7>1A.92.>4504140173 450 4140 <: 450 @.:4 6<4<=174 <7 450 ;20:074 :80712<. 0780450208177.4C017?8.73.714<.7.>3061? 92 17:B02
4. 450 1C.A0 ;.<74 >.2 8.7:<30214<.7 <: <7 L0=14<A0/ 7 A<0B .> 450 3<:89::<.7: @1301C.A0B0;1::450>.66.B<7=#
<! 50 3061? 1;;6<814<.7 <: ' 8.7:0F90746?
450 0=9612 <2:4 ;;016 <: '
<<! 50 6012703 8.97:06 1;;012<7= 4. 450 20:;.73074: C2.9=54 4. 7.4<80 .> 45<: .924
- 16 -
450 3<2084<.7 =<A07 C? 450 .7/C60 ;0G .924 <7;121=21;5.:B5020<716:.450@14402 12<:0:.>45<:<:42<843<2084034.;2.8003B<45 450 0G0894<.7 .> 450 308200 <7 >1A.92 .> 450 1;;066174 <7 0G0894<.7 ;04<4<.7 . 4. 4508.7802703.9241733<208403:516607:920 4514 450 ;2.8003<7=: 8.786930 B<45<7 1 ;02<.3 .>4B.@.745:>2.@4503140.>450E93=@074
<<<! 1A<7= 8.7:<30203 45<: 3<2084<.7 16:. <4 <: 1;;2.;2<140 4. 3<2084 450 G0894<7= .924 4. 3<:;.:0 .> 450 G0894<.7 04<4<.7 B<45<7 1 ;02<.3 .> :<G @.745: >2.@ 450 2080<;4 .> 450 8.?.>45<:.2302
! ! <:4.#6.#- #