- 1 - !"#"" "$ % &'(&)*% '+&** , ! " # $ # % !$ " # $ % &' % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % &!'(! & ) ((! ) % % )&(! & !) ((!(! % % * # * $ +, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,-56670,8 /0 9,:1-, 4+/0 17-49,/2;5;;-/,.,89<4+,=78;>,241:612./64/12528 1-8,- 1: 0,24,26, 854,8 &!'(! & 3500,8 /2 1 ) ( 1: (! ) 9< 4+, ?,5-2,8 88/4/125? /./? 78;, 528 % 5?597-5;/#+,-,/25:4,- -,:,--,8 41 50 *-/5? 17-4* :1- 9-,./4<$ :1- 4+, 1::,26,0 372/0+59?, 728,- ,64/120 ('& 528 !) 1: 28/52 ,25? 18, #:1- 0+1-4 @A$ 528 ,64/12 ' 1: 141- ,+/6?,0 64 #:1- 0+1-4 @ 64A$ 528 0,24,26/2; +/> 41 728,-;1 0/>3?, />3-/012>,24 :1- 5 3,-/18 1: ! >124+0 :1- 4+, 1::,26, 372/0+59?,728,-,64/12('&1:5284135<5:/2,1: - 3 - 0!!B41728,-;10/>3?,/>3-/012>,24:1-53,-/181: !C>124+05284135<:/2,1:0!!B41728,-;10/>3?, />3-/012>,24:1-53,-/181:!C>124+05284135<:/2,1: 0)!!!:1-4+,1::,26,728,-,64/12!)1:528 41728,-;10/>3?,/>3-/012>,24:1-53,-/181:!C>124+0 528 41 35< :/2, 1: 0(!! :1- 4+, 1::,26, 372/0+59?, 728,- ,64/12 ' 1: 64 D/4+ 8,:57?4 0,24,26,0 D+/6+D50612:/->,89<4+,?,5-2,888/4/125?/04-/64 528,00/12078;,5?597-5;/#+,-,/25:4,--,:,--,84150 *%/-04 33,??54, 17-4* :1- 9-,./4<$ ./8, =78;>,24 854,8 !) ((!(!3500,8/2-/>/25?33,5?1)&1:(! & ( ,5-8 -/ 045;/ ?,5-2,8 61720,? :1- 4+, -,./0/123,4/4/12,-528-/135?-/0+25585.?,5-2,8 /;+17-41.,-2>,24?,58,-:1-4+,-,03128,24454, ,-70,8 4+, >54,-/5?0 12 -,61-8 /26?78/2; 4+, -/5? 528 33,??54,17-4,61-80 - 4 - 2 ./,D 1: 4+, -/.5? 6124,24/120 7-;,8 9< 4+, ?,5-2,861720,?:1-914+4+,35-4/,04+,31/244+54D17?8 5-/0,:1-><6120/8,-54/12/0 ) < 520D,- 41 4+, 591., 31/24 /0 E F:1-4+,:1??1D/2; +, ?,5-2,8 61720,? :1- 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- ,.,2 4+17;+ +50 -5/0,8 0,.,-5? ;-17280 /2 4+, 3,4/4/12 />37;2/2; 4+, =78;>,24 1: 612./64/12 528 1-8,- 1: 0,24,26,3500,89<4+,-/5?17-45285?014+,=78;>,24 3500,89<4+,%/-0433,??54,17-4+,+50-,04-/64,8+/0 5-;7>,240410,,G?,2/,26<D+/?,0,24,26/2;4+,56670,8 :1-4+,591.,05/81::,26,0 - 5 - C 4 /0 03,6/:/65??< 079>/44,8 9< 4+, ?,5-2,8 61720,?:1-4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-4+54+,+50;/.,2735?? 14+,-;-172807-;,8/24+,-,./0/123,4/4/12:1-6+5??,2;/2; 4+, />37;2,8 =78;>,24 1: 612./64/12 528 1-8,- 1: 0,24,26, ' ,5-2,8 61720,? :1- 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 6124,28,84+54/24+,>141-.,+/6?,0650,:/?,89<4+,?,;5? -,3-,0,2454/.,0 1: 4+, 8,6,50,8 5 61>3,2054/12 1: 0 )!!!!! D50 5D5-8,8 , 079>/40 4+54 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- /0 D1-G/2; 50 741 -/.,- +5./2;D/:, 5286+/?8-,24107331-4,5?01079>/404+544+,-,./0/12 3,4/4/12,-/0/2=78/6/5?670418<50124185<0/26,:1-59174 (!85<028,-076+6/-67>04526,+,3-5<0:1-0+1D/2; ?,2/,26<52841-,04-/644+,07904524/.,0,24,26,12?<:1-5 3,-/18 1: (! 85<0 9< /26-,50/2; 4+, :/2, 5>1724 41 9, 35/8D+/6+D/??9,+1217-,89<4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,- ,5-2,8 /;+ 17-4 1.,-2>,24 ?,58,- +1D,.,- 13310/2; 4+, 079>/00/12 >58, 9< 4+, ?,5-2,8 61720,?:1-4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-079>/404+544+,-,./0/12 - 6 - 3,4/4/12,- 9,/2; 52 5741 8-/.,- >5< 9, />310,8 :/2, 1: 0!!!! D+/?, -,876/2; 4+, 3,-/18 1: 07904524/., 0,24,26, & 23,-705?1:4+,>54,-/5?012-,61-8/4/06?,5- 4+54 /0 4+, /2=7-,8 ,<,D/42,00 41 4+, /26/8,24 /2 H7,04/12,:7??<07331-4,84+,650,1:4+,3-10,674/12 +,8,6,50,8D505;,8)<,5-0544+,4/>,1:/26/8,24 +, -/5? 17-4 528 4+, %/-04 33,??54, 17-4 12 533-,6/54/121:4+,>54,-/5?,./8,26,12-,61-8:17284+, 56670,8 ;7/?4< 528 5661-8/2;?< 612./64,8 528 0,24,26,8 +/> 81 214 :/28 52< -,5012 41 /24,-:,-, D/4+ 4+, />37;2,8 =78;>,24 1: 612./64/12 3500,8 9< 4+, -/5? 17-4 1D,.,- 6120/8,-/2; 4+, 079>/00/120 >58, 9< 914+4+,0/8,0:/28/4533-13-/54,41>18/:<4+,1-8,-1: 0,24,26,9<4-,54/2;4+,3,-/181:8,4,64/12728,-;12,9< 4+, 56670,8 41 9, 0,4 1:: 5;5/204 4+, 0,24,26, 1: />3-/012>,24 528 9< ,2+526/2; 4+, :/2, 5>1724 661-8/2;?< 520D,- 4+, 591., 31/24 35-4?< /2 4+, 5::/->54/.,,26,4+,:1??1D/2; - 7 - /$ +,-,./0/123,4/4/12/05??1D,8/235-4 //$ +, />37;2,8 =78;>,24 1: 612./64/12 854,8 &!'(! & 3500,8 /2 -/>/25? 50, 1 ) ((! ) 9< 4+, -/5?17-4 612:/->,8 /2 -? 1)&(! & ./8, =78;>,24 854,8 !) ((!(! 9< 4+, %/-04 33,??54, 17-4 /2 -,03,64 1: ,64/120 ('& 528 !) 1: 528,64/12 '1: 64/0+,-,9<612:/->,8 ///$ 1D,.,- 4+, 1-8,- 1: 0,24,26, /0 >18/:/,850728,- #5$ +,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-/00,24,26,84135< :/2, 1: 0 !!! :1- 4+, 1::,26, 372/0+59?, 728,- ,64/12 ('& 1: /2 8,:57?44135<:/2,4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,- 0+5??728,-;10/>3?,/>3-/012>,24:1- 85<0 #9$ %1-4+,1::,26,728,-,64/121: 4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-/00,24,26,84135< 5:/2,1:0 !!!/28,:57?44135<:/2, - 8 - 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 0+5?? 728,-;1 0/>3?,/>3-/012>,24:1- 85<0 #6$ %1-4+,1::,26,728,-,64/12!)1: 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 0+5?? 728,-;1 0/>3?, />3-/012>,24 :1- 4D1 >124+0 528 41 35< :/2, 1: 0)!!! /2 8,:57?4 41 35< :/2, +, 0+5?? 728,-;1 :7-4+,- 0/>3?, />3-/012>,24:1-12,>124+ #8$ %1- 4+, 1::,26, 372/0+59?, 728,- ,64/12 '1: 644+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-0+5?? 35< :/2, 1: 0 !!! /2 8,:57?4 41 35< :/2,+,0+5??728,-;10/>3?,/>3-/012>,24 :1- 85<0 #,$ +,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-/0,24/4?,8:1-0,41:: 503-1./8,8728,-,64/12)(1:- #:$ 741:4+,4145?:/2,5>1724419,35/89< 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 5 07> 1: 0)!!! /0 1-8,-,8 41 9, 35/8 41 4+, D/:, 1: 4+, 8,6,50,8 50 61>3,2054/12 728,-,64/12'1:- - 9 - ::/6,/08/-,64,8410,28956G4+,-/5?17-4,61-8 528 4+, %/-04 33,??54, 17-4 ,61-80 D/4+ 613< 1: 4+/0 1-8,-:1-4+D/4+:1-/007,1:>18/:/,8612./64/12D5--524 -% &""* # /041 ?1C