Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58417 (KAR)
SHIVAYOGISWAMY MEMORIAL EDUCATION SOCIETY v. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY AND ORS
WP/203758/2024 · 2025-11-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""#$"%&'! ! (! ')#'#'
*'#+ ! !"! #
$ %
&'
"
() !(
)
))
!(
* )+)) , !"! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
-
)
!"! ! ) . !"! (
) !"-
)) ) !"! " )) !"! / ))
!"- # $
. ) -
/0 )
*'
)
( ))
'
) -- -+ '
)
*- !("/ -* -! -)
+ - ! ( *'
) )
)
)
- 3 -
1
. " $
1
. '
23 345456738 59 :3;683 4259 6<84 933=57> ;6??6@57> 83?53;A90 ' 99<3 B @854 6; C384568B85 D<B9257> 423 5EF<>73G F86C33G57>9FB993G:H839F67G3746-GB43G- -I5G3773J<83 :'99<3B@8546;EB7GBE<9G583C457>423839F67G374 69* - ! ( " B7G / 46 C6795G38 423 83F839374B4567 GB43G - * - B7G ! - 6; 423 F345456738 I5G3 773J<83 - ! B7G( C'7H64238BFF86F85B43@8546868G3868G583C4567B9 G33E9 ;54 <7G38 423 ;BC49 B7G C58C<E94B7C39 6; 423 CB93EBH=57G?H:3FB993G
23CB936;423F345456738590
2B4 423 345456738 6C534H 83>594383G <7G38 423B87B4B=B6C534539
3>5948B4567C4/($;6892684 K423 C4A' 2B4 42383 @B9 C384B57 G59F<43 @542 83>B8G 46 423F6946; 8395G374 B7G 423 3738B? 3C834B8H :34@337 423 6C534H B7G 673 B7L<7GB9@BEH 9<54 57
- 4 -
6*"//! @B9 ;5?3G 67 423 ;5?3 6; 5I5? .<G>3 $.87' 3GBE :H 673 25IBH6>59@BEH 3E685B? G<CB4567 6C534H B7G 25IB?57>B9@BEH B>B5794 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH933=57>;6883?53;6;G3C?B8B45672B4673 2B74BI338B9@BEH 59 423 G<?H 3?3C43G 8395G374 6; 423 6C534HB7G423F?B5745;;6 25IB?57>B9@BEH59423G<?H 3?3C43G 3738B? 3C834B8H 6; 423 9B5G 96C534H B9 F38 423 3738B? 6GH 33457> 23?G 67 /(//! B7G 42B4 423 B??3>3G 8396?<4567 GB43G -//! FB993G :H B7L<7GB9@BEH G3;37GB74 6 4238357 B9 7<?? B7G I65G B7G764:57G57>67423F?B5745;;239B5G9<54CBE346:3 G3C833G67*!7BFF3B?57
6/-!@B9 ;5?3G :H 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH @25C2 B?96 839<?43G 57 G59E599B?:H68G38GB43G/9B>B5794@25C2B 83><?B8 93C67G BFF3B? 57
6*- @B9 ;5?3G :H B7L<7GB9@BEH239B5GBFF3B?CBE346:3G59E5993GB9 @542G8B@767/!"B92BI57>:3C6E357;8<C4<6<9
257>9 9466G 42<9 423 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 2BG9<:E5443G?5946;E3E:3896;423B7B>57>6EE54433
- 5 -
4642359485C4
3>5948B86 6F38B45I36C534539B7G3F<4H 3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 9 B>B5794 @25C2 423 F3454567382383572BG9<:E5443GB83F839374B45676FF6957> 423 83>5948B4567 6; 423 ?594 6; 423 B7B>57> 6EE54433 3E:3899<:E5443G:H9B5GB7L<7GB9@BEH2359485C4 3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 B7G 423 3F<4H 3>5948B8 6;
6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 4B=57> 5746 C6795G38B4567 423 L<G>E374 B7G G3C833 FB993G 57 6*"//!
CB7C3??3G 423 ?594 6; 6EE54433 3E:389 9<:E5443G :H 423 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 57 438E9 6;
6EE<75CB4567 GB43G *" 9 B>B5794 @25C2 B @854 F3454567 @B9 ;5?3G :H 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 57
6-!!"" @25C2 CBE3 46 :3 G59F693G 6; 67 /83938I57>?5:384H46423F34545673846;5?3G<?H C679454<43G 9<54 933=57> BFF86F85B43 83?53;A9 23 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 42383B;438 BFF3B89 46 2BI3 ;5?3G B764238 ?594 6; B7B>57> 6EE54433 3E:389 ;68 423 H3B8
- 6 -
* 7 423 E3B7@25?3 2B74I338B9@BE5 423 4237 8395G374 FB993G B@BH 67 // B7G 25IB?57>B9@BE5 @B9 3?3C43G B9 423 8395G374 6; 423 F345456738 2B4 B 83F839374B4567 GB43G "/ CBE3 46:3;5?3G:HB948B7>38C?B5E57>46:3 3738B?3C834B8H 6; 423 F345456738 6C534H 46 423 857C5FB? 3C834B8H 6;
3FB84E3746;6 6F38B456776446374384B5742383D<3946;
25IB?57>B9@BEH @26 C?B5E9 46 :3 423 8395G374 6; 423 F345456738 6C534H 2383<F67 423 857C5FB? 3C834B8H 57 438E9 6; ?34438 GB43G *// 2BG G583C43G 423 3>5948B8 6C534539 764 46 374384B57 423 83F839374B4567 6;
25IB?57>B9@BEH @26 C?B5E9 46 :3 423 8395G374 6;
F345456738 23 8395G374 6; 423 F345456738 42383B;438 9<:E5443G B 83D<394 67 (// 46 423 857C5FB? 3C834B8H 37C?6957> IB856<9 G6C<E3749 46 394B:?592 259 C?B5E 6; 23 :357> B 8395G374 6; 423 F345456738 6C534H 2383<F67 423 857C5FB? 3C834B8H 6; 423 3FB84E374 6;
6 6F38B4567 BGG83993G B ?34438 GB43G // 46 423 3>5948B86C53453942B442383@383B??3>B4567B7GC6<7438
- 7 -
B??3>B4567 :34@337 9B5G 25IB?57>B9@BEH B7G B7L<7GB9@BEH 83>B8G57> 42358 E3E:38925F 57 423 F345456738 6C534H 3 @B9 CB??3G <F67 46 57I3945>B43 B7G 9<:E54 B 83F684 B:6<4 423 94B4<9 6; 42358 E3E:38925F 57 423F345456738 6C534H@5425742345E3945F<?B43G - 4 59 423 C674374567 6; 423 6C534H 42B4 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH @26 2BG 8395>73G B9 B 8395G374 3;;3C45I3;86E/(//!2BG76EB77386;85>2457423 B;;B589 6; 423 F345456738 6C534H 57 423 ?5>24 6; G3C833 FB993G576*"//!B99<C2B7HG6C<E3749;5?3G :H 25E 926<?G 764 :3 BCC3F43G 6@3I38 423 CC6<749 3738B? 6GH 33457> F86C33G57>9 B7G 423 ?594 6;
J3C<45I3 6EE54433 3E:389 9<:E5443G :H 423 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 9<:93D<374?H @B9 BCC3F43G @25C2 @B9 C2B??37>3G :H 423 F345456738 6C534H :H ;5?57> B @854 F3454567 57 6*-*(/ @25C2 @B9 G59E5993G 83938I57> ?5:384H 46 423 F345456738 6C534H 46 BFF86BC2 BFF86F85B43;68<E
- 8 -
!
259?3G46;5?57>6;B764238?5946;E3E:389;68 423F3856G6; *:H9B5GB7L<7GB9@BEH>5I57>8593 46673E68383F839374B4567;5?3G:H423F345456738 6C534H 67(/46423
3>5948B8 6C53453946CB7C3?4239B5G ?5946;C6EE54433E3E:389 ( 257>9 9466G 42<9 423 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH F<8F6843G?H9<:E5443GB764238?5946;E3E:389C6EF85957> 6;25E93?;B7G642389;68423F3856G6;* (@25C2@B9 BC=76@?3G>3G :H 423
3>5948B8 6C534539 ?3BG57> 46 F345456738 ;5?57> B764238 83F839374B4567 67 *(- :857>57> 46 423 7645C3 6; 839F67G374 B:6<4 423 3B8?538 F86C33G57>9 57C3 423 9BE3 @B9 764 C6795G383G F345456738 BFF86BC23G 4259 6<84 :H ;5?57> B764238 @854 F3454567 57 6-"- C2B??37>57> 423 ?594 6;
6EE54433 3E:389 9<:E5443G :H 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH ;68 423 438E * ( B7G B?96 96<>24 ;68 G583C4567 46 839F67G374 <426854H 46 C6795G38 423 83F839374B4567 6;
6C534H GB43G *(- B7G 46 BCC3F4 423 ?594 6; 6EE544333E:3899<:E5443G:H4236C534H;68423H3B8
- 9 -
- !236 68G57B4337C26;42596<84C6795G3857> 423 CB93 B7G 423 ;BC49 B??6@3G 423 9B5G @854 F3454567 G583C457>42359485C4
3>5948B86;6C53453946C6795G38423 83F839374B45676;423F345456738 6C534HGB43G*(- B9@3??B9423?5946;J3C<45I36EE544333E:3896;423 F345456738 6C534H ;68 423 H3B8 - ! B9 9<:E5443G :H 423 F345456738 6C534H B7G 46 FB99 BFF86F85B43 68G389 @54257BF3856G6;42833E67429;86E423GB436;83C35F46; 423C6FH6;4239B5G68G38
7423E3B7@25?342368G38GB43G/- 5EF<>73G 57 4259 @854 F3454567 CBE3 46 :3 FB993G :H 423 839F67G374 6- <F67 423 C6EF?B574 ;5?3G :H 423 F345456738238357@54283>B8G464239B5GB7L<7GB9@BEH G39F5437642BI57>B7H85>244657438;3835746423B;;B5896;
423 6C534H F86C33G57> 46 BFF6574 3BC257> B7G 67 3BC257> 4B;;9 57 423 579454<4567 8<7 :H 423 F345456738 6C534H 4 @B9 F65743G 6<4 42B4 57 423 ?5>24 6; 423 L<G>E374 B7G G3C833 FB993G 57 6*"//! G3C?B857> 423 8396?<4567 GB43G -//! FB993G :H
- 10 -
B7L<7GB9@BEH :357> 7<?? B7G I65G B7G 42383 :357> 76 83C6>7545676;25994B4<957423F345456738 6C534H232BG 76B<426854H4657438E3GG?3@542423B;;B5896;4236C534H 6@3I38839F67G3746-4B=57>5746C6795G38B45676;423 85IB? C?B5E9 EBG3 :H 423 FB84539 4238357 C?693G 423 C6EF?B5746;423F34545673823835783?3>B457>423F345456738 46 BFF86BC2 423 BFF86F85B43 B<426854H 46 8396?I3 423 G59F<43 357> B>>853I3G 423 F345456738 59 :3;683 4259 6<84 * B84H 57 F38967 4B=57> 4259 6<84 4286<>2 423 83C68G9 B7G 423 ;BC49 7B88B43G B:6I3 9<:E549 42B4 839F67G374 6- C6<?G 764 2BI3 FB993G 423 68G38 GB43G -- 95>73G 67 -- 57B9E<C2 B9 423 599<3 @542 83>B8G 46 423 85>24 6; 9B5G B7L<7GB9@BEH 2B9 B?83BGH:337G3C5G3G:H423L<G>E374B7GG3C83357 6*"//!26?G57>4238396?<4567<7G38@25C223C?B5E9 46 :3 423 8395G374 46 :3 7<?? B7G I65G 7 438E9 6; 423 68G38 FB993G :H 423 6 68G57B43 37C2 6; 4259 6<84 57
6-"- GB43G ! 423 59485C4
- 11 -
3>5948B8 6; 6C534539 B7G 423 3F<4H
3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 2B9 B?83BGH :337 G583C43G 46 C6795G38 423?5946;J3C<45I36EE544333E:3896;423F345456738 6C534H 9<:E5443G :H 423 F345456738 6C534H ;68 423 H3B8 - !
2<9 423 85>24 B7G B<426854H 6; 423 F839374 8395G3746;6C534H6<>24462BI3:33783C6>75M3G:H423 839F67G374 6- <426854H :3;683 83?3>B457> 423E 46 423 BFF86F85B43B<426854H3;<842389<:E54942B442359485C4 3>5948B8 6C534539 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 B7G 3F<4H 3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 2B9 764 FB993G B7H 68G38 45?? GB43 2383;683 57 438E9 6; 423 L<G>E374 B7G G3C833FB993G576*"//!423F345456738 6C354H 92B?? :3 C6795G383G 46 :3 83F8393743G :H 259 F839374 8395G374 25IB?57>B9@BEH @26 59 423 FB84H 57 F38967 25E93?; 3 B?96 9<:E549 42B4 423 5EF<>73G 68G38 B4 773J<83 2B9:337FB993G@5426<4B7H37D<58H37C3 933=9;68B??6@57>6;423F3454567 - 3B873G 67 57948<C4567 9<:E549 42B4 F<89<B74 46 423 68G38 GB43G ! FB993G :H 4259
- 12 -
6<8457 6-"-42359485C4
3>5948B86;6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 B7G 3F<4H
3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 2B9 B?83BGH 599<3G B7 37G6893E374 GB43G
"-! 83L3C457> 423 ?594 6; J3C<45I3 6EE54433 3E:389 F8393743G :H 423 F345456738 ;68 423 H3B8 - ! 3 42383;683 9<:E549 57 423 ?5>24 6; 423 9B5G 37G6893E374 B?83BGH 2BI57> :337 599<3G 423 F345456738 6C534H 76@ 83F8393743G :H 25IB?57>B9@BEH @6<?G 764 2BI3 B7H <7?399 423 ?594 6; J3C<45I3 6EE54433 3E:389 59 BCC3F43G :H 423
3>5948B8 57 423 EB7738=76@746?B@ ! 345456738 B84H 57 F38967 26@3I38 F?3BG9 5>768B7C3 B:6<4 9<C2 37G6893E374 2BI57> :337 599<3G B7G 23 9<:E549 42B4 23 2B9 76 =76@?3G>3 6; 9<C2 37G6893E374:357>599<3G ( 3B8GF38<93G42383C68G9
9 7643G B:6I3 423 599<3 F384B579 46 423 B7B>3E374 GE575948B4567 B7G ;<7C456757> 6; 423
- 13 -
F345456738 79454<4567@25C259BGE5443G?H83>594383G<7G38 423 F86I595679 6; B87B4B=B 6C534539
3>5948B4567 C4 /(3C4567!6;423C483BG9B9;6??6@90 N! ,-./01 21 345 56/73080 539 $' 23 3>5948B8 EBH 67 259 6@7 E64567 B7G 92B?? 67 423 BFF?5CB4567 6; 423 EBL6854H 6; 423 E3E:389 6; 423 >6I38757> :6GH 686; 764 ?399 42B7 673 4258G 6; 423 E3E:389 6; 423 96C534H 26?G B7 37D<58H 68 G583C4 96E3F38967B<4268593G:H25E:H68G3857@85457>57 BCC68GB7C3@5424238<?39EBG3574259:32B?;4626?G B7 37D<58H 5746 423 C679454<4567 @68=57> B7G ;57B7C5B?C67G545676;B83>594383G96C534H $' 23
3>5948B8 68 423 F38967 B<4268593G :H 25E <7G38 9<: 93C4567 $' 92B??
2BI3 423 ;6??6@57> F6@3897BE3?HO $B'2392B??B4B??83B967B:?345E392BI3;833BCC399 46 423 :66=9 BCC6<749 G6C<E3749 93C<854539 CB92 B7G64238F86F384539:3?67>57>466857423C<946GH6;
423 96C534H B7G EBH 9<EE67 B7H F38967 57 F69939956768839F6795:?3;68423C<946GH6;B7H9<C2 :66=9BCC6<749G6C<E374993C<854539CB926864238 F86F384539 46 F86G<C3 423 9BE3 B4 B7H F?BC3 B4 423 23BGD<B843896;42396C534H68B7H:8B7C2423836;0 $:'23EBH9<EE67B7HF38967@26232B983B967 46:3?53I32B9=76@?3G>36;B7H6;423B;;B5896;423 96C534H 46 BFF3B8 :3;683 25E B4 B7H F?BC3 B4 423 23BGD<B84389 6; 423 96C534H 68 B7H :8B7C2 423836; B7GEBH3JBE5739<C2F38967676B420 $C' $5' 23 EBH 764@54294B7G57> B7H4257> C674B573G 574259C46857B7H8<?36883><?B4567F839C85:57>423 F3856G6;7645C3;68B>3738B?E33457>6;42396C534H 83D<583 423 >6I38757> :6GH 6; 423 96C534H 46 CB?? B
- 14 -
>3738B? E33457> B4 9<C2 45E3 B7G F?BC3 B4 423 23BGD<B84389 6; 423 96C534H 68 B7H :8B7C2 423836;
B7G 46 G3438E573 9<C2 EB44389 B9 EBH :3 G583C43G :H25E;423>6I38757>:6GH6;42396C534H83;<939 68;B5?946CB??BE33457>2392B??2BI3F6@3846CB?? 5425E93?;0 $55' B7H E33457> CB??3G <7G38 9<: C?B<93 $5' 92B?? 2BI3 B?? 423 F6@389 6; B >3738B? E33457> CB??3G <7G384238<?396883><?B456796;42396C534HB7G549 F86C33G57>9 92B?? :3 83><?B43G :H 9<C2 8<?39 68 83><?B456790 $555'@237B737D<58H59EBG3<7G38425993C4567423 3>5948B892B??C6EE<75CB43423839<?46;42337D<58H 4642396C534HC67C3873GP
" 23G59F<43:34@3374234@6;8BC45679673?3G :H B7L<7GB9@BEH B764238 :H 25IB?57>B9@BEH @26 59 423 FB84H 57 F38967 :3;683 4259 6<84 59 95EE3857> B7G ?57>3857> 957C3 423 H3B8 //! I37 5; 423 L<G>E374 B7G G3C833 FB993G 57 6*"//! @B9 FB993G 57 ;BI6<8 6; 423 25IB?57>B9@BEH @26 C?B5E9 46 :3 423 4237 3738B? 3C834B8H 76@ 423 8395G374 423 9B5G L<G>E374 B7G G3C833 @B9 67?H 57 839F3C4 6; 423 3738B? 6GH 33457>42B4@B923?G67//! /()<84238423G3C8336; 57L<7C4567@25C259>8B743G574239B5G9<54EB=3954C?3B8 42B4423G3;37GB744238357@B983948B573G;86E57438;3857>
- 15 -
57 423 B;;B589 6; 423 F345456738 6C534H 67?H ;68 423 H3B8 //! /( 7;684<7B43?H 423 59485C4
3>5948B8 @26 59 B C6EF34374 B<426854H <7G38 423 C4 @25C2 59 B 9F3C5B? 94B4<43C679454<43G466I38933B7G9<F38I593423B;;B5896; 423579454<45679B942B46;423F345456738B42B7G83>594383G <7G384239B5GBC42B94<873G:?57G3H3;686I38*H3B89 B??6@57>423FB8453946?545>B4337G?399?H:H;5?57>F34545679 B;438F34545679:3;68342596<84 / 23F<8F6936;83>5943857>B6C534H<7G38423 C4EB=57>423J3C<45I33E:389?5B:?3B7GBCC6<74B:?3 ;68 C6EF?5B7C3 @542 423 F86I595679 6; 9B5G C4 46 :3 9<F38I593G :H 423
3>5948B8 59 764 ;B8 46 933= 4 59 46 F86I5G3?3>B?83C6>754567B7GEB=3549B;;B589BCC6<74B:?3 B7G B79@38B:?3 46 423 B<426854539 C679454<43G <7G38 423 94B4<43 3C4567 ! 6; 423 C4 3J48BC43G B:6I3 >5I39 94B4<468HB<426854HB7GL<859G5C45674642359485C4
3>5948B8 46 BGL<G5CB43 <F67 423 599<39 57I6?I57> @68=57> C679454<4567B7G;57B7C5B?C67G545676;4236C534H23C4 B?96F86I5G39;68BFF6574E3746;B7BGE575948B468464B=3
- 16 -
943F94626?G3?3C456746:857>768EB?CH39F54368G389:H 42596<8442359485C4
3>5948B82B97644B=37B7HBC4567 3JC3F4 76@ @25C2 59 :86<>24 46 423 7645C3 6; 4259 6<84 @238357 23 2B9 83L3C43G 423 ?594 6; J3C<45I3 3E:389 9<:E5443G:H423F345456738
8G38 B4 773J<83 :H 423 839F67G374 6- GG54567B?
6EE59956738 4B=57> 7643 6; 423 57438 93 G59F<439 :34@337 423 4@6 >86<F9 2B9 E383?H G583C43G 423E462BI342358EB44388396?I3G:3;683423BFF86F85B43 B<426854H@25C25942359485C4
3>5948B86;6C53453923 68G38 GB43G "-! F86G<C3G :H 423 ?3B873G 57G5CB43942B4423?5946;E3E:3896;J3C<45I36EE54433 B?67>@542423BCC6<7499<:E5443G:H25IB?57>B9@BEH;68 423 H3B8 - ! 2B9 :337 834<873G 23 F8BH38 42383;68396<>24;68574259F3454567837G3857;8<C4<6<9764 @54294B7G57>4239BE3
6795G3857> 423 C23D<383G 259468H 6; 4259 79454<4567@25C2BFF3B89462BI39F374E68345E3957423
- 17 -
C6885G689 6; 423 6<84 42B7 57 423 79454<4567 @5426<4 3JF839957> B7H6F57567 67423 E38549 68 64238@593 6; 423 CB93 F345456738 59 83?3>B43G 46 2BI3 423 599<3 8396?I3G :3;68342359485C4
3>5948B86;6 6F38B45I36C534539B7G 3F<4H
3>5948B8 6; 6 6F38B45I3 6C534539 57 438E9 6;
3C4567!6;423C42359485C4
3>5948B892B??26?GB7 37D<58H<7G383C4567!6;423C4672596@7E64567
23 F345456738 59 B?96 83938I3G ?5:384H 46 933= 9<C2 83E3GH B9 EBH :3 BIB5?B:?3 5; B>>853I3G :H 423 68G386;83L3C45676;E3E:3896;423J3C<45I36EE54433 94B43G462BI3:337FB993G:H423
3>5948B8
542423B:6I36:938IB45679423F345456759G59F693G 6; #:; *'#' + )"
5946?6! 4F=