- 1 - !"#"" "$$ %&' %($)* %)) *+ "$$ %&' %($)* %)) "$$ %&' %($)* %)) * + ! " #$ $ % &## # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &## # ' # '' () ! " & * # & % & ')"% & +, & ') ' ' - & && ' ) ''')$ . & * + / ' #/ . ' 0 (' ! " % - 3 - &## # &## # ) # '' () ! " & * # & % & ')"% & & & 1 "% ' ' ') $ - - & * + # ('( ! " % - 4 - &## # &## # ) # '' () ! " & * # & % & ')"% & & & &1 "% ' ' ') $ - - & & & $ 2 - 5 - #" " 2 % 34 566477589 :8 ;7 + <4:8= 5>>?@4A + 934 566477589 :8 ;7 + . <4:8= 5>>?@4A + 58A 934 566477589 :8 ;7 +. <4:8= 5>>?@4A + :8 64>:57 5@4 "% +' ' +8 934 ,:74 +, 934 745;84A AA:9:+857 4@@:+8@ ?A=4 5:>3?; 5;4 :B6?=8:8= 934 C?A=B489 +, >+8D:>9:+8 58A +;A4; +, @48948>4 >+8D:>9:8= 934B 57+8= E:93 5>>?@4A +@' 58A ,+; 934 +,,48>4@ 6?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8@ ' ) '' ') +, 8A:58 4857 +A4 ",+; @3+;9 F G% 58A 4>9:+8 '":%"H% +, >34A?74A 5@94@>34A?74A ;:<4@ " ;4D489:+8 +, 9;+>:9:4@%>958A@48948>:8=934B5@?8A4; !!" #$ % " !&&&' %" !! " $! - 6 - ( !!" ) %" !)&&&' % " !! " $! * !!" %" !)&&&' % " !! " $! ) !! " % " !&&&' % " !! " $! & +! !!" % " !)&&&' % " !! " $! &( - 7 - !! " & % " !&&&&' %" !! " , $! -.-&. / +!)) !!" %" !&&&' %" !! " $! %% % !0 34>5@4+,9346;+@4>?9:+8:8<;:4,:@9359 $ 7+A=4A 934 ,:;@9 :8,+;B59:+8 E:93 5;I49 5;A +7:>4 959:+8 5:>3?; 5=5:8@9 5>>?@4A +@ 9+ ' 5774=:8= >+BB:@@:+8+,934+,,48>4@6?8:@35<74?8A4;4>9:+8@') ;45A E:93 4>9:+8 ' +, 8A:58 4857 +A4 58A 4>9:+8 '" %"H% +, 934 >34A?74A 5@94@>34A?74A ;:<4@ " ;4D489:+8 +, 9;+>:9:4@% >9 34 :8C?;4A $ E5@ 5AB:994A9+9343+@6:95758AE5@9;4594A9594B489@+, 934 :8C?;4A 58A 934 4J4E:984@@4@ E4;4 ;4>+;A4A ,94; >+B6749:8= 934 :8D4@9:=59:+8 >35;=4@3449 >5B4 9+ <4 ,:74A5=5:8@95779345>>?@4A,+;9345,+;4@5:A+,,48>4@ - 8 - ' 45;84A 5=:@9;594 9++I >+=8:K58>4 +, 934 +,,48>4@ 58A >+BB:994A 934 B5994; 9+ 934 745;84A 4@@:+8@ ?A=4";:57 +?;9% 34;:57 +?;9 @?BB+84A 5>>?@4A+@ 9+34J35D456645;4A<4,+;4934;:57 ?A=458A6745A4A8+9=?:79J58A>75:B4A9+<49;:4A 34 6;+@4>?9:+8 :8 +;A4; 9+ 6;+D4 934 =?:79 +, 9345>>?@4A35D44H5B:84A )E:984@@4@5@ $@ 9+ ) =+9 B5;I4A A+>?B489@ 5@ 64; H@ 9+ 58A :A489:,:4A 9+':8@?66+;9+,:9@>+89489:+8>>?@4A 35D4 A48:4A 577 934 :8>;:B:859:8= B594;:57@ 5D5:75<74 +8 ;4>+;A<?935D48+974A58J4D:A48>4:8934:;A4,48>4 34 ;:57 +?;9 5,94; 95I:8= :89+ >+8@:A4;59:+8 577 934@4 B594;:57@ 5D5:75<74 +8 ;4>+;A >5B4 9+ 934 >+8>7?@:+893596;+@4>?9:+8:@@?>>4@@,?7:89346;+D:8=934 =?:79 +, 934 5>>?@4A ,+; 934 5774=4A +,,48>4@ 58A 5>>+;A:8=7J >+8D:>94A 58A @48948>4A 934B 5@ @9594A 5<+D4 4:8= 5==;:4D4A <J 934 @5B4 934 5>>?@4A 35D4 6;4,4;;4A934@4566457@ - 9 - ( ?;:8= 934 648A48>J +, 934 566457@ 5>>?@4A +@' 58A E3+ 5;4 934 566477589@ :8 ;7 + . 35D4 A:4A 58A 934 566457 ,:74A <J 934B =+95<594A ) 45;A;:535894@34@5:745;84A>+?8@47 ,+;934566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58AB9;59: 59:7 745;84A :=3 +?;9 +D4;8B489 745A4; ,+; 934 ,:;@9 ;4@6+8A48958A;:?A35I5;5+745;84A>+?8@47,+; 934 @4>+8A ;4@6+8A489 4;?@4A 934 B594;:57@ 5D5:75<74 +8;4>+;A 8 D:4E +, 934 ;:D57 >+89489:+8@ ?;=4A <J 745;84A>+?8@47@,+;93465;9:4@9346+:899359E+?7A5;:@4 ,+;BJ>+8@:A4;59:+8:@ 1 ""%%' +! ) 2 $ $" 3 $ 2 " /% 4 - 10 - . J58@E4;9+9345<+D46+:89:@ ,+;934,+77+E:8= 9 :@ 934 >+89489:+8 +, 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 9359 5>>?@4A + 5@@5?794A 934 :8C?;4A $ E:93 5 57E5; * 5>>?@4A + 5@@5?794A 3:B E:93 5 I8:,4 58A 5>>?@4A +' E:93 5 <44; <+9974 ' E:93 58 :89489:+8 9+ >5?@4 3:@ A4593* 5>>?@4A + 58A E4;4 3+7A:8= 934 :8C?;4A E3:74 5>>?@4A +@ 58A ' E4;4 5@@5?79:8=3:B934;4<J934J35D4>+BB:994A934+,,48>4@ 9 :@57@+ 934 >+89489:+8 +, 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 93595>>?@4A +35A5<?@4A934:8C?;4A:8,:793J758=?5=4<J;4,4;;:8= 9+ 3:@ >5@94 E:93 58 :89489:+8 9+ >5?@4 3?B:7:59:+8 58A 934;4<J >+BB:994A 58 +,,48>4 6?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 '" %"H% +, 934 >34A?74A 5@94@>34A?74A ;:<4@ " % >9 + 6;+D4 :9@ >+89489:+8 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 4H5B:84A934:8,+;B589E3+:@4J4E:984@@9+934:8>:A489 - 11 - 5@ $ 3:@ E:984@@ 35@ A46+@4A 9359 5>>?@4A +@ 58A E4;4 3+7A:8= 934 :8C?;4A E3:74 5>>?@4A + 5@@5?794A3:BE:93557E5;+83:@@9+B5>358A57@+9;:4A 9+5@@5?79+83:@84>I>>?@4A+5@@5?794A934:8C?;4A E:935I8:,4+83:@@9+B5>3>>?@4A+'5@@5?794A3:B E:93 5 <44; <+9974 E3:74 5>>?@4A +@ 58A E4;4 @9:77 3+7A:8= 934 :8C?;4A 58A 34 35A @448 934 5>>?@4A >+BB:99:8=+,,48>4@:8934@9;4497:=39$34893464;@+8@ @95;94A =5934;:8= 934;4 934 5>>?@4A 35D4 93;+E8 934 E456+8@58A,74A,;+B934@6+9 $:@934:8C?;4A4J4E:984@@58A3:@4D:A48>4 57@+ >+;;+<+;594@ 934 4D:A48>4 +, $ <J @959:8= 9359 5>>?@4A + 5@@5?794A 3:B E:93 5 57E5; 5>>?@4A + 5@@5?794AE:935I8:,458A5>>?@4A+'5@@5?794AE:935 <44;<+9974E3:745>>?@4A+@58AE4;43+7A:8=3:B 4 :A489:,:4@ @ 9+ ' 58A 57@+ @9594A 9359 5>>?@4A + 5<?@4A 3:B :8 ,:793J 758=?5=4 <J ;4,4;;:8= 9+ 3:@ >5@9458A3?B:7:594A3:B - 12 - ' $'58A $5;49344J4E:984@@4@34J35D4 57@+ ,?77J @?66+;94A 934 >5@4 +, 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 58A >+;;+<+;594AE:93934D4;@:+8+, $@ 58A $@()58A.5;4>:94A5@4J4E:984@@4@ D48 93+?=3 $ 9+ @+B4 4H9489 @?66+;94A 934 >5@4 +, 9346;+@4>?9:+8347594;9?;84A3+@9:74 $@(9+.35D4 8+9 @?66+;94A 934 >5@4 +, 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 $ :@ 934 B+934; +, $ E3+ :@ 5 345;@5J E:984@@ $ ' :@ 934 +>9+; E3+4H5B:84A 934 :8C?;4A 58A:@@?4A 934$+?8A 4;9:,:>594 5@64;H >>+;A:8= 9+ E3:>3 934:8C?;4A 35A @?@95:84A ,+?; @:B674 :8C?;:4@ 58A 9E+ =;:4D+?@ :8C?;:4@@64;H 934,+77+E:8=:8C?;:4@E4;4,+?8A9+ 35D4<448@?@95:84A<J $ ! 5 2 $ ,6,6$7-. )! 5 2 $ $ ) , ) , # $ 7!28% " ! 5 2 % 9$ $ !,6,6$7-. - 13 - ! 5 2 % $ , 6 , 6 $ 7 $2$ " 2 $ % %%"-:%. ! 5 2 $ ,,&!$7-. #! / "2 $ %"! (! ;$ $% < "2 = 8% %% )% $%2 !5 52,$728% "!0 $ ' 35@ A46+@4A 5<+?9 934@4 :8C?;:4@ @64>:,:>577JD4893+?=3:8C?;J+@58A(5;4A4@>;:<4A 5@ =;:4D+?@ :8C?;:4@ 5@ 934J E4;4 75>4;594A E+?8A 58A 948A4;84@@+D4;93474,958A;:=39E;:@9@+, $934@5B4 >588+9<494;B4A5@:8C?;:4@+8934D:95765;9@+,934<+AJ +E4D4;:8C?;J+):@A4@>;:<4A5@>+774>9:+8+,<7++A+, 5<+?97:9;4@:89345<A+B48>5D:9JE:9375>4;59:+8+8934 7:D4;B45@?;:8=H>B@E:935>9:D4<744A:8=:@A4@>;:<4A 5@ ,5957 :8C?;J <J $ ' E3:>3 :@>+;;4@6+8A:8= 9+:8C?;J - 14 - + E3:>3 :@ 75>4;594A E+?8A +D4; 934 ;:=39 @:A4 +, 5<A+B48B45@?;:8=H>B@D4893+?=39344H94;857 :8C?;J E5@ @:B674 :8 859?;4 :9 E5@ A4@>;:<4A 5@ ,5957 :8 D:4E+,:9@:894;857:B65>9 ( D48 93+?=3 934;4 E5@ ;4,4;48>4 9+ 934 ,;5>9?;4+,934;:=39E;:@9,+;45;B74,9E;:@949>8+@?>3 B594;:57@ 5;4 675>4A <4,+;4 934 +?;9 9+ 6;+D4 @?>3 ,;5>9?;4@ 34;4,+;4 :9 :@ +87J :8C?;J +) E3:>3 :@ 934 :894;857:8C?;J>+;;4@6+8A:8=9+:8C?;J+:@A4@>;:<4A5@ ,5957:8C?;JE3:>3>+?7A35D4>5?@4A934A4593+, $:, 34E5@8+9:BB4A:5947J9;4594A<J934+>9+; ) 8A4; 934 @6+9 B535K5; @ 9+ ' E4;4 ;4>+D4;4A58A9344J4E:984@@4@:8>7?A:8=934:8C?;4A35D4 :A489:,:4A934@5B4&;+B9344D:A48>4+, $@ 9+58A $ ' 745;84A>+?8@47 ,+;934566477589@ 35@ 8+947:>:94A 58J93:8= 9+ A:@<47:4D4 934:; D4;@:+8 8A4; 934@4 >:;>?B@958>4@5B+,934+6:8:+893599346;+@4>?9:+8:@ @?>>4@@,?7 :8 6;+D:8= 934 =?:79 +, 934 5>>?@4A <4J+8A ;45@+85<74A+?<9 - 15 - D4893+?=3:9:@>+8948A4A93595>>?@4A35D4 >+BB:994A934+,,48>4?8A4;4>9:+8')+,8A:58 4857 +A4A+8+9,:8A58J=;+?8A9+:8D+I4934@5:A6;+D:@:+8 +, 75E @:8>4 934 :8C?;4A 35@ @?@95:84A +87J 75>4;59:+8 +D4;934D:95765;9@+,934<+AJ:,595779345>>?@4AE4;4 35D:8= 58J :89489:+8 9+ >5?@4 934 A4593 +, 934 :8C?;4A 934J 35D4 8+9 >5?@4A 5 =;:4D+?@ 3?;9 +8 934 D:957 65;9@ !! >34@9 58A 5<A+B48 +, $ 34 A4@>;:69:+8 +, 934 :8C?;J 58A 934 4D:A48>4 +, $ ' ;4=5;A:8= @?>3 :8C?;:4@ @L?5;47J599;5>9@4>9:+8'(+,8A:58 4857+A45@934 5>>?@4A 35D4 D+7?895;:7J >5?@4A =;:4D+?@ 3?;9 <J A58=4;+?@ E456+8@ E3:>3 E5@ 7:I47J 9+ >5?@4 934 A4593 +,934 $3?@9346;+@4>?9:+8:@@?>>4@@,?7:86;+D:8= 934 =?:79 +, 934 5>>?@4A ?8A4; 4>9:+8@ ' ) ''58A'(+,8A:58 4857+A4 . D48 93+?=3 934 & E5@ ;4=:@94;4A ?8A4; 4>9:+8 '" %"H% +, >34A?74A 5@94@>34A?74A ;:<4@ " ;4D489:+8 +, 9;+>:9:4@% >9 58A 5@ 64; 934 ,:;@9 :8,+;B59:+8 H 934;4 :@ 8+ 5774=59:+8 9359 5>>?@4A - 16 - + 35A 5<?@4A 934 :8C?;4A <J ;4,4;;:8= 9+ 3:@ >5@94 $ @64>:577J@5J@93599345>>?@4A35D48+95<?@4A $ <J ;4,4;;:8= 9+ 3:@ >5@94 $@' 58A <4:8= 934 4J4E:984@@4@ 9+ 934 :8>:A489 35D4 57@+ 8+9 @9594A 58J93:8=;4=5;A:8=>+BB:@@:+8+,@?>3+,,48>49:@+87J $E3+A46+@4@93595>>?@4A+35@5<?@4A3:B<J ;4,4;;:8= 9+ 934 >5@94 34;4 :@ 8+ >+;;+<+;59:+8 9+ 934 4D:A48>4+,934 $:89359;4=5;A58A934;4,+;45B+, 934 +6:8:+8 9359 934 6;+@4>?9:+8 :@ 8+9 @?>>4@@,?7 :8 6;+D:8=934=?:79+,9345>>?@4A,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4;4>9:+8@'" %"H%+,934>34A?74A5@94@>34A?74A ;:<4@" ;4D489:+8+,9;+>:9:4@%>9 35D4=+8493;+?=3934:B6?=84AC?A=B489+, >+8D:>9:+858A+;A4;+,@48948>465@@4A<J934;:57+?;9 D4893+?=3934;:57+?;935@>+8@:A4;4A934B594;:57@ +8;4>+;A:8934;:=3964;@64>9:D49+>4;95:84H9489:935@ >+BB:994A 4;;+; :8 >+8D:>9:8= 934 566477589@5>>?@4A ,+; 934+,,48>46?8:@35<74?8A4;4>9:+8')+, 58A?8A4; 4>9:+8'"H%+,934" %>934;:57+?;935@ - 17 - 57@+ 6;+>44A4A 9+ @48948>4 934 5>>?@4A E:93 B5H:B?B :B6;:@+8B489 4D48 93+?=3 8+ ;45@+8@ 5;4 5@@:=84A 9+ :B6+@4@?>3B5H:B?B@48948>434;4,+;45B+,934 +6:8:+8 9359 934 :B6?=84A C?A=B489 +, >+8D:>9:+8 58A +;A4; +, @48948>4 9+ 9359 4H9489 >577@ ,+; :894;,4;48>4 <J 93:@ +?;9 >>+;A:8=7J 58@E4; 934 5<+D4 6+:89 :8 934 58A 6;+>44A 9+ 65@@ 934 ,+77+E:8= ":% 34>;:B:857566457@5;4 "::% 34:B6?=84AC?A=B489+,>+8D:>9:+858A+;A4; +, @48948>4 A594A ') 65@@4A :8 64>:57 5@4 "%+' '<J934745;84AAA:9:+857:@9;:>958A 4@@:+8@?A=45:>3?;>+8D:>9:8=934566477589@5>>?@4A +@ 58A,+;934+,,48>4@6?8:@35<74?8A4;4>9:+8 ' ) '''(58A:@34;4<J>+8,:;B4A ":::% 34 :B6?=84A C?A=B489 +, >+8D:>9:+8 +, 934 566477589@5>>?@4A +@ 58A ,+; 934 +,,48>4@ - 18 - 6?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 ') +, 58A ?8A4; 4>9:+8 '"H%+,934" %>9:@34;4<J@495@:A4 ":D% >>+;A:8=7J566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A 5;4 5>L?:994A ,+; 934 +,,48>4@ 6?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 ')+, 58A?8A4;4>9:+8'"H%+,934" %>9 "D% 34+;A4;+,@48948>465@@4A<J934;:57+?;9 :@B+A:,:4A5@?8A4; 5% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, +84 B+893 E:93 ,:84 +, @45>3,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 ' +, 58A :8 A4,5?79 934J@3577?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489,+; 564;:+A+,948A5J@ <% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, +84 B+893 E:93 ,:84 +, @45>3,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 ) +, 58A :8 A4,5?79 934J@3577?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489,+; 564;:+A+,948A5J@ - 19 - >% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, +84 B+893 E:93 ,:84 +, @45>3,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 +, 58A :8 A4,5?79 934J@3577?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489,+; 564;:+A+,948A5J@ A% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, 9E+ B+893@ E:93 ,:84 +, @ 45>3,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 '' +, 58A :8 A4,5?79 934J@3577?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489,+; 564;:+A+,,:,9448A5J@ 4% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, +84 B+893 E:93 ,:84 +, @45>3,+;934+,,48>46?8:@35<74 ?8A4; 4>9:+8 +, 58A :8 A4,5?79 934J@3577?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489,+; 564;:+A+,948A5J@ ,% 34566477589@5>>?@4A+@ 58A5;4 @48948>4A9+?8A4;=+@:B674:B6;:@+8B489 ,+; 5 64;:+A +, 9E+ B+893@ E:93 ,:84 +, - 20 - @ 45>3 ,+; 934 +,,48>4 6?8:@35<74?8A4;4>9:+8'(+, 58A:8 A4,5?79 934J @3577 ?8A4;=+ @:B674 :B6;:@+8B489,+;564;:+A+,+84B+893 "D:% ?9+,934,:845B+?89+,@ (5@?B +, @ :@ 9+ <4 65:A 9+ $ 5@ >+B648@59:+8 ?8A4;4>9:+8')+,; "D::% 34 566477589@5>>?@4A +@ 58A 5;4 489:974A ,+; @49 +,, 5=5:8@9 934 @48948>4 +, :B6;:@+8B489 ,+;93464;:+A+,A49489:+8?8A4;=+84<J934B5@6;+D:A4A ?8A4;4>9:+8+,; "D:::%?<@9589:D4@48948>4@@3577;?8>+8>?;;4897J 34 3:4, ?64;:8948A489 +, 489;57 ;:@+8 #575<?;5=: :@ A:;4>94A 9+ D4;:,J 9359 :, 934 566477589@5>>?@4A +@ 58A 35D4 57;45AJ ?8A4;=+84934@48948>49+;4745@4934B,+;93E:93:,934 ,:84 5B+?89 :@ A46+@:94A 58A :, 934J 5;4 8+9 ;4L?:;4A :8 58J+934;>5@4 - 21 - 4=:@9;J 9+ @48A <5>I 934 ;:57 +?;9 ;4>+;A@ 57+8= E:93>+6J+,93:@C?A=B489,+;:8,+;B59:+858A,+;844A,?7 5>9:+8 ,,:>4:@A:;4>94A9+@48A934+64;59:D46+;9:+8+,934 C?A=B4899+934C5:75?93+;:9J,+;93E:93,+;844A,?75>9:+8 ,* %"") # :@9+ 7+ #