Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58412 (KAR)
BEERESHWAR CO. OPERATIVE CREDIT SOCIETY LTD v. SMT. HEMAVATI W/O MALLIKARJUN
CRL.A/200093/2022 · 2025-08-05
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58412 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58412 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!! !##
$%&$'#()
*$(( +
!"# $
% &' '
& %
(
!"# $
)*! "
' +,,,, ' '
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
--#%,#! #)! '
.'
"! .'
/0 122033145 60748 5/0 9:;23174145 74 :--#%,#! :4 5/0 <730 :< 5/0 301=40> >>757:413 7?73 '@>80 14> '@>79713 187A5=150 7=A5 31AA 7>1= <:= A/:=5 B5/0
=713 :@=5C 7A 7;2@84748 5/0 D@>8;045 >150> +,,,, 19E@755748 5/0 199@A0> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 #)! :< 5/0 08:571630 4A5=@;045A95#!!#<:=A/:=5B95C
, 1=570A 1=0 =0<0==0> 5: 1A 20= 5/07= =14F748 60<:=05/0
=713 :@=5<:=5/0A1F0:<9:4?0470490
- 3 -
) /0 <195A :< 5/0 91A0 74 6=70< 1=0 5/15 5/0 9:;23174145 /1A <730> 5/0 2=7?150 9:;231745 74 :,"%,#! 18174A5 5/0 199@A0> 13308748 9:;;7AA7:4 :< 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 #)! :< 5/0 95 5 7A 5/0 9:450457:4 :< 5/0 9:;23174145 5/15 75 7A 5/0 =087A50=0> ::20=157?0:9705GH/79/304>A5/01;:@455:
75A ?1=7:@A ;0;60=A 4 133 A0?04 20=A:4A 7493@>748 5/0 199@A0> /1?0 1?1730> 3:14 @4>0= ;@33G1 :14 9/0;0 <=:;5/09:;23174145I:9705G14>5/0G/1?0@4>0=51F04 5:=021G5/03:141;:@45H75/H00F3G74A5133;045A
/0 199@A0>A5::>1AA@=05G5:5/0A17>8=:@2:<A7J;0;60=A 14> 0J09@50> 4090AA1=G >:9@;045A ?04 5/:@8/ 6:==:H0=A /1?0 :651740> 5/0 3:14 H75/ A@=05G :< 5/0 199@A0>5/0G/1?04:5=0217>5/03:141;:@45=08@31=3G
" :H1=>A =021G;045 :< 5/0 3:14 1;:@45 199@A0>607485/0A@=05G7AA@0>5/09/0E@01A20=J# <:= A#-)-% :4 *##,#* /04 5/09/0E@0 H1A 2=0A0450> <:=0491A/;045 5/0A1;0 H1A >7A/:4:@=0>1A B<@4>A 74A@<<797045C
/0 30813 4:5790 H1A 7AA@0> 9133748
- 4 -
@2:45/0199@A0>5:21G5/09/0E@01;:@454A2750:< A0=?790 :< 4:5790 199@A0> /1> 4:5 =0217> 5/0 9/0E@0 1;:@455/0=06G9:;;7550>5/0:<<04902@47A/1630@4>0= 0957:4#)!:<5/09599:=>7483G2=7?1509:;231745 H1A91;05:60<730>
/0 301=40> 187A5=150 5::F 9:847K1490 :< 5/0 :<<0490 =087A50=0> :--#%,#! 14> A@;;:40> 5/0 199@A0>
/0199@A0>/1>12201=0>60<:=05/0
=713 :@=5 14>2301>0>4:58@735G
/09:;231741450J1;740># 14>8:5;1=F0>JA#5:*74A@22:=5:<75A9:450457:4 /0 199@A0> 9=:AA 0J1;740> # 14> >0470> 5/0 749=7;7415748 ;150=713A 1?1731630 :4 =09:=> 74 /0= A5150;045 @4>0= 0957:4 )#) :< = 6@5 /1A 4:5 30> 14G 0?7>0490 74 A@22:=5 :< /0= >0<0490
/0
=713 :@=5 1<50= 51F748 745: 9:4A7>0=157:4 133 5/0A0 ;150=713A :4 =09:=> 91;0 5: 5/0 9:493@A7:4 5/15 5/0 9:;23174145 /1A 4:5 2=:?0> 5/0 8@735 :< 5/0 199@A0> 60G:4> =01A:41630 >:@65 14> 5/0=0<:=0 19E@7550> 5/0 199@A0> 0748 188=70?0>6G5/0A1;09:;231741457A60<:=05/7A :@=5
- 5 -
- 01=> 301=40> 9:@4A03 =7 1/1450A/ 1573 12201=748 <:= 5/0 122033145
/0 =0A2:4>045 =0;1740> @4=02=0A0450> 74 A2750 :< A0=?790 :< 4:5790 0=@A0> 5/0 ;150=713A:4=09:=>7493@>7485/0
=713 :@=5=09:=>A
* 4 ?70H :< 5/0 9:450457:4A @=80> 6G 301=40> 9:@4A03<:=5/01220331455/02:7455/15H:@3>1=7A0<:=;G 9:4A7>0=157:47A
G14AH0=5:5/016:?02:7457A745/0B C <:=5/0<:33:H748
!
5 7A 5/0 9:450457:4 :< 5/0 9:;23174145 5/15 1 8=:@2 :< A7J ;0;60=A /1?0 1?1730> 3:14 <=:; 75A :9705G @4>0= ;@33G1 9/0;0
/0 199@A0> A5::> 1A A@=05G 5:
5/0A17>3:14
:H1=>A>7A9/1=80:<5/03:141;:@455/0 199@A0>/1>7AA@0>5/09/0E@0601=748:">150>
- 6 -
*##,#* H/79/ H1A 2=0A0450> <:= 0491A/;045
/0 9/0E@0H1A91;05:60>7A/:4:@=0>1A5/0=0H1AB<@4>A 74A@<<797045C
/0199@A0>74A2750:<A0=?790:<308134:5790 /1A4:5=0217>5/09/0E@01;:@4514>5/0=06G9:;;7550> 5/0:<<0490 + : 2=:?0 5/7A 9:450457:4 5/0 9:;23174145 I :9705G 0J1;740> 75A J09@57?0 <<790= 1A # 0 /1A <730> 1<<7>1?75 =0750=15748 5/0 9:450457:4 51F04 74 5/0 2=7?1509:;23174514>8:5;1=F0>JA#5:*5:A@22:=5 A@9/ 9:450457:4 01=40>9:@4A03<:= 5/0199@A0> 9=:AA 0J1;740>5/0H7540AA1530485/57A0379750>>@=7489=:AA 0J1;74157:4 5/15 019/ :< 5/0 6:==:H0=A /1?0 :651740> 3:14:<A,%
/0H7540AAA5150>5/15155/057;0 :< 304>748 5/0 3:14 5/0 9:;23174145 I :9705G /1A 4:5 51F04 5/0 9/0E@0 <=:; 5/0 199@A0> 5 7A A@880A50> 5:
# 5/15 H=75748A <:@4> :4 J# 7A 9:49:950> 6G 5/0 9:;23174145 I :9705G
/0 A1;0 H1A >0470> 6G 5/0 H7540AA
- 7 -
# 57A 20=574045 5:4:505/15 745/00457=0 9=:AA 0J1;74157:4 5/0 199@A0> /1A 40?0= >0470> 5/15 5/0 9/0E@0 15 J#603:48A 5: /0= 14F199:@45 5 7A 13A:
4:5 >0470> 5/15 J# 601=A /0= A78415@=0 /04 :490 5/0 199@A0> 1>;75A 7AA@1490 :< 5/0 9/0E@0 H75/ /0= A78415@=05/02=0A@;257:4@4>0=0957:4A##!14>#)+:< 5/095H:@3>1=7A0
/06@=>04A/7<5A:45/0199@A0> 5: =06@5 5/0 2=0A@;257:4 J9025 5/0 613> 9=:AA 0J1;74157:4 5: # 5/0=0 7A 16A:3@503G 4: ;150=713A 5:
=06@5 5/0 30813 2=0A@;257:4
/0 199@A0> 13A: 4:5 A50220>745:5/0H7540AA6:J5:>02:A0/0=>0<0490 ## ;1G=0<0=5:5/0>097A7:4:<5/0:4C63020J :@=5 74 5/0 91A0 :<
H/0=0745/020J :@=56G=0<0==7485:75A01=370=>097A7:4 /03>7421=18=12/:A)"14>)-1A@4>0=
! "
# $ #
1 ,#+" #+*
- 8 -
$
" $
" $
% &
! " #
# $ $ # $
'
()*
+#
$
" $
,
#, ;1G13A:=0<0=5:5/0>097A7:4:<5/0:4C630 20J :@=5 74 5/0 91A0 :<
! H/0=074 5/0 5/=00 049/ :< 5/0 20J :@=5 >7A9@AA0> 15 30485/ 16:@5 2:AA0AA7:4:<31HH75/=081=>5:5/06@=>04:<2=::<745/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 #)! :< 95 5 =0<0==0> 5: 75A 01=370= >097A7:4 74 5/0 91A0 :<
"" ""#$%!&!'())!*+, 14>/03>7421=18=12/:A#"##-14>#!1A@4>0=
2 ,,# ,!)
- 9 -
(+
#$
! $
'
((- '
() * + '
./
" 0
#
1
1
#
$ 2 3 4
5 ' 6
$ $ 7
#
$
'
()* +#
"
$
$ 8
$ $ 8
$
$ +
- 10 -
#
$
#
1
$
9 ,
(:;
< +
" = #
" $
$
93
8
$
$ ' $
#
$
(% * #
#
'
((- '
() + >'*
> ' ?# $ $
- 11 -
@
. /#
# $
#
$
? &8. /#$
$
$
(- &
$ ! !
"
!$
#
@' > !? #$ 7
&
! " #
# $ $
# $
'
() * +#
$" $
.& /
#) ;1G13A:=0<0=5:5/0>097A7:4:<5/0:4C630 20J :@=5745/091A0:<- . /
- 12 -
0 - /
1 +H/0=074757A/03>7421=18=12/:*1A@4>0= A
! "
"
"
"
$
#
" $
$
#
'
() * + 8
;
B$#
$ "
9
#
$
" $ $
"
"
$ 9
#
" $
# $
3 ,, +"
- 13 -
8
'
() * + #C $B #
9
# $
'
()* ++ # '
() +
8 9
"
"
# $ 8
#"
/@A 5/0 2:A757:4 :< 31H 7A ?0=G H033 A05530> /04 5/0 9:;23174145 7A A@990AA<@3 74 2=:?748 5/15 5/0 9/0E@07AA@0>6G5/0199@A0>H1A>7A/:4:@=0>A74905/0=0 7AB<@4>A74A@<<797045C745/0199:@45:<5/0199@A0>14>74 A2750:<A0=?790:<4:57905/0199@A0>/1A4:5=0217>5/0 9/0E@01;:@455/0:<<04902@47A/1630@4>0=0957:4#)! :< 5/0 95 7A 9:;23050 /04 5/0 199@A0> 1>;75A
- 14 -
7AA@1490 :< 9/0E@0 H75/ /0= A78415@=0 5/0 2=0A@;257:4 @4>0=0957:4##!:<5/095H:@3>1=7A0
/06@=>04 7A:45/0199@A0>5:=06@5A@9/2=0A@;257:4 # 45/02=0A04591A05/0199@A0>/1A4:5;1>0 14G 0<<:=5 5: =06@5 A@9/ 2=0A@;257:4 4>0= A@9/ 97=9@;A51490A199@A0>7A371630<:=9:4?7957:4 #- /1?08:405/=:@8/5/07;2@840>D@>8;045:< 19E@7551321AA0>6G5/0
=713 :@=5
/0
=713 :@=5=78/53G /03> 5/15 5/0 199@A0> /1A 4:5 >0470> 7AA@1490 :< 5/0 9/0E@0 H75/ /0= A78415@=0 5 13A: /03> 5/15 5/0 2=0A@;257:4@4>0=0957:4#)+:<5/095H:@3>1=7A0 18174A5 5/0 199@A0> 14> 6@=>04 A/7<5A :4 5/0 199@A0> 5:
=06@5 5/0 2=0A@;257:4 :H0?0= 75 2=:900>0> 5: /:3> 5/155/02=0A@;257:4@4>0=0957:4#)+:<5/0957A1 =06@551630 2=0A@;257:4 14> A7490 5/0 9:;23174145 I :9705G/1A4:52=:>@90>14G;150=713A5:2=:?05/155/0 3:14 1;:@45 =0;1740> @4217> 199@A0> 7A 0457530> <:= 19E@75513
/0<74>748A=09:=>0>6G5/0
=713 :@=57A?0=G
- 15 -
A5=14806@5757A4:574199:=>1490H75/31H4>0=A@9/ 97=9@;A51490A 75 7A 5: 60 /03> 5/15 5/0 199@A0> /1A 4:5 =06@550>5/0308132=0A@;257:414>5/0=0<:=07A371630<:= 9:4?7957:4
/0
=713 :@=5 /1A 9:;;7550> 0==:= 74 19E@7557485/0199@A0>04905/07;2@840>D@>8;045:< 19E@755139133A<:=7450=<0=04906G5/7A :@=599:=>7483G 14AH0=5/016:?02:745745/0 14>2=:900>5: 21AA5/0<:33:H748
7 /09=7;74131220137A2 77 /0 7;2@840> D@>8;045 >150> +,,,, 21AA0> 74 =7;7413 1A0 :--#%,#! 6G 5/0 301=40> >>757:413 7?73 '@>80 14> '@>79713 187A5=150 7=A5 31AA 7>1= 7A /0=06GA051A7>0 777 :4A0E@0453G 5/0 =0A2:4>045%199@A0> 7A 9:4?7950> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 #)! :< 5/0 95 /0 7A
- 16 -
A0450490>5:21G<740:<A,% 14> 74 >0<1@35 :< 21G;045 :< <740 A/0 A/133 @4>0=8: A7;230 7;2=7A:4;045 <:= 1 20=7:> :<A7J;:45/A 7? @5:<5/0<7401;:@455:60>02:A750>6G 5/0 =0A2:4>045%199@A0> 1 A@; :< A#% 7A :=>0=0> 5: 60 217> 5: 5/0 122033145%9:;231741451A9:;204A157:4 ?
4 ?70H :< >7A2:A13 :< ;174 ;1550= #%,, >:0A 4:5 A@=?7?0 <:= 9:4A7>0=157:4 14> 199:=>7483G A514>A >7A2:A0>:< ?7 087A5=G 5: A04> 619F 5/0
=713 :@=5 =09:=>A 13:48 H75/ 9:2G :< 5/7A D@>8;045 <:=74<:=;157:414><:=400><@31957:4
- 17 -
?77
/0 =713 :@=5 7A >7=0950> 5: 7AA@0 9:4?7957:4H1==14574199:=>1490H75/31H
,) $!!(
"
7A5:#3:," &