Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58408 (KAR)

DK SIDRAM AND ANR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR

CRL.P/200086/2025 · 2025-10-14

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $%&%% % '! '()* ')) + ! " # $# % & ' # # # # ' # # ! " $## % # '(!& # # ' # # ! ' %&##!'#%#& # # # ' # # # # # !!" ' # # # #)!)!!" ' ''# # ##)" "!" # *' ## # ' ' + # + ' # # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # # ' # # # #, + # # % #, + # # & -./ 012.2.34 ./ 5.617 /118.49 :;</-.49 35 2-1 0=3>117.49/ 0147.49 .4 #3)!)!!" %<=./.49 3;2 35 =.?1#3 !!"=19./21=17@A-<8.3B436.>12<2.34& 342-15.6135.C.6+;791<47+ '-<68..7<=./2=.>253= 2-1 35514>1/ 0;4./-<@61 ;471= 1>2.34/ ) " "!" =1<7B.2-1>2.34 *35 ! -1/;@/2<4>1352-10=3/1>;2.34></1./2-<234 !D"!!"<2<@3;2<?B-.612-1>3?06<.4<42B</ 0=3>117.49.4<><=2-1012.2.341=/<6349B.2-23!32-1= 01=/34/<6619176A3@/2=;>2172-1C1-.>612./5;=2-1=<661917 2-<2 012.2.341= #3 %<>>;/17 #3& /4<2>-17 2-1 ><= 81A <//<;62172-17=.C1=23=1-.//-.=2<47<@;/17-.?.45.62-A 6<49;<91 </17 34 2-1/1 <6619<2.34/ < >3?06<.42 ><?1 23 @1 637917 <9<.4/2 2-1 012.2.341=/ 53= 35514>1/ 35 B=3495;6 - 3 - =1/2=<.42<47>=.?.4<6.42.?.7<2.340;4./-<@61;471=1>2.34/ <47)352-147.<414<6371;=/;<42232-1/<.7 >3?06<.42 < ></1 B</ =19./21=17 <47 <521= >3?0612.34 35 .4C1/2.9<2.34 2-1 4C1/2.9<2.49 55.>1= -</ 5.617 < >-<=91 /-112 " 1<=417 >3;4/16 <001<=.49 53= 2-1 012.2.341=/ =151==.49232-1=1>3=7/>342147/2-<22-10=1/142>3?06<.42 ./<>3;421=@6</2232-10=3>117.49/.4.2.<217<22-1.4/2<4>1 35 2-1 012.2.341=/ 2 ./ /;@?.2217 2-<2 2-1 //./2<42 12;=4.49 55.>1= -<7 637917 < >3?06<.42 .4 =.?1 #3 )!!"53=2-135514>10;4./-<@61;471=1>2.34D35 @</1734<=103=2/;@?.2217@A2-1012.2.341=/<6619.49 2-<2 2-1 /1>347 =1/0347142 B</ .6619<66A 7./2=.@;2.49 /<=11/ 7;=.49 2-1 161>2.34 ><?0<.94 -1 /<.7 >3?06<.42 617 23 =19./2=<2.3435<></1B-1=1.42-17=.C1=352-1C1-.>61;/17 53= /;>- 7./2=.@;2.34 ./ <6=1<7A 5<>.49 0=3/1>;2.34 -1 0=1/142 >3?06<.42 .2 ./ ;=917 ./ 432-.49 @;2 < =12<6.<23=A <>2.34232-1/<.70=3>117.49/ - 4 - 4 2-1 32-1= -<47 61<=417 .9- 3;=2 3C1=4?142 61<71= <001<=.49 53= 2-1 =1/03471422<21 /;@?.2/ 2-<2 2-1=1 <=1 /;55.>.142 ?<21=.<6/ 34 =1>3=7 23 0=3>117 <9<.4/2 2-1 012.2.341=/ <47 2-1=153=1 1E1=>./1 35 .4-1=142 03B1=/ ;471= 1>2.34 ! 35 2-1 371 35 =.?.4<6 =3>17;=1<22-.//2<91./432B<==<4217 <C.49-1<=72-161<=417>3;4/1653=2-10<=2.1/ <473401=;/<6352-1=1>3=7/2-./3;=25.47/.2<00=30=.<21 23 =10=37;>1 2-1 =161C<42 03=2.34 35 2-1 >3?06<.42 </ =1561>217.42-1'B-.>-=1<7/</;471= !"# !$%& ' ()* "+ , -. / '0 ! 1 2 3 4 - 1 2 3 4 - '5( 6 789 :+ ;<= >?@ / '0 ABCD "(E + F "60G +H' !I * J='K 36H< 8* L, (H *M " ?3 4=:!"8 N* NO=P* =Q:RC==Q=(H==Q&6.'K9 "S; TD& :! AQU ".6V :!=Q "(H! = :< WE ;X9Y >M. H !I 36-9 * =Q:RC7'KL8*L, !* J=Z?*M3 O - 5 - * J= O=Q L*6 [\! 4 ] =Q 36[ :! :-=Q TJ T ] 8 :< WE ;X9Y 7L 7P=Q!(H-L^.H<_`!>J*3 OTK ] AQ"H< :'K= "aY 4= :!=Q ([. H b6 6 8* L, ? 3 4= :! "8 =P * =Q c !d(H!J6=PST] !),9;=Pe, X. H !I:!J(fgL*6h2 -i['K 36-,< j _ K "=Q 8* L, ! [\! ; (H f_ hkD :! (P l>M ='K 8m J* n ] 8. H :=Q C BC6 4fH ] 8*6 3 O*6 (7 *M*6?o>* = (H, j e=Q'K 8* L, p (H *M " ? 3 :! &6.F! 4= S * =67= A* *M*6?o 78 6J= + ; S / '0 = q'" 1 2 :A r "E &6. sfL A* A D , i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t 36! +H S "S;u X[ !2 TH j ,6v 6A2 A( * =w 'K =6L b6f(= 6Q< O+ C * =*__ 9'K : c d(< - j;u i[ t " !/ !x(! KLCy !?'KL?=Q TWH! X@ j ,6v 6A2 A( * = 'K =6L+ z=w!Jix(] eXS+ z =w!+ z=w !&6.{B"a?*036-+ z =w (H !J {B "a?*0 X] 8*6 :K 9 + z =w 3 6 ! "3 b6f(= TH - 7 - 796Q< O+ C* =*__ * J='K9 L?=Q + z =w (H ! "h'K 4fH ] 89 (H, b6f(= U !I, A< 7 K, KLCy !?'L?=QTWH!I+ | } Y + ^. -(H, * D b6f(= sfL A* :A r<"-!IJ b6f(= ~ j ,6v 6A2 A(U JL] =E EU 'K"'K" -, 6•jA D'K=+ z=w!4fH] 8 ,9] =Q/ '0 = q'" 1 2 Q =w sfL 9'K 4f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