- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! " # $$ ! $ ! % ! ! $$ & ' (& ) ( ) * +((& $ '' ! ' ' +(( # $ $ ! ' , ! ) ( ( % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' %% ' ! $ $$ %+ (& ( ! &(( $ ' $ $ $$ ' ! - $ # ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 3<8/==./><8:<>.1/4/<78223./?/019:23.0<;57/> <7 ! 9 &(( 1/2.1 %+ (& ( =/88.1 ;@ 23. .6;.0 9290 AA<1.72 >/<68 0<;57/> B /1/4<0< :90 83902 C23. 0<;57/>D 7E50.1A>/<6/72 :<>.1 / A>/<6 =.2<2<97 A>/<6<74 A96=.78/2<979: 8 ((((( 3.0<;57/>/:2.0A978<1.0<74 .72<0.6/2.0</>970.A90140/72.1/7/695729: 8 +&F( ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: +G :096 1/2. 9: =.2<2<97 2<>> 0./><8/2<97 & 440<.H.1 ;@ 23. 8/<1 /69572 23<8 /==./> <8 =0.:.00.1<7?3<A3<2<882/2.123/2=.2<2<97.08582/<7.1:0/A250. 9:>.:2356.0958:0/A250.9:&6.2/2/08/>97>.:2:992/71 - 3 - 923.0=/0289:23.;91@/718=.72354.6.1<A/>.I=.78.8 . ?/8 ./07<74 8 ((( =.0 69723 ;@ 19<74 A>923 ;58<7.88 ;5223.0<;57/>3/82/J.723.8/6./8 8 %(((/71>.88.0 A96=.78/2<97?/840/72.1:90>9889:/6.7<2<.8 3.0<;57/> 3/82/J.797>@)G9:23.1<8/;<><2@239543$/88.88.123. ></;<><2@ /8 %+G 29 23. >9?.0 ><6; 3.0.:90. 0.K5.82.1 :90 .73/7A.6.72 .8=971.728 A9578.> 82/2.1 23/2 23. 0<;57/> A978<1.0.1 />> 23. /8=.A28 =09=.0>@ /71 /00<H.1 29 23. E582 A96=.78/2<97/71<27..1879<72.0:.0.7A. + 3./==.>>/723/882/2.123/23.?/8/4.1@./08 19<74 A>923 ;58<7.88 /71 ./07<74 8 ((( =.0 69723 ;52 3.3/8792:<>.1/7@<7A96.=099: 83.6.2?<23/7/AA<1.72 97 %& %% (%F /8 =.0 23. 45<1.><7.8 9: 23. /07/2/J/ 2/2. .4/>.0H<A.8 52390<2@3<8792<97/><7A96.<829;.2/J.7/8 8 %(=.069723 39543$/88.88.123.1<8/;<><2@/8 %+G23.20<;57/>3/82/J.797>@)GA978<1.0<7423.7/250.9: 23.<7E50<.8 .7A.23<89502:<718790./89729<72.0:.0.?<23 23. 8/<1 1<8/;<><2@ AA901<74>@ 23. >988 9: :5250. <7A96. A96.829 - 4 - %(I%I%)I)GL)F+( 3. 0<;57/> 40/72.1 8 %+%( 29?/018 6.1<A/> .I=.78.8/71<27..1879<72.0:.0.7A. ) 8 =.0 I $ B ?9571 A.02<:<A/2. 23. /==.>>/72 8582/<7.1 A0583 <7E50@ 9: >.:2 :992 /72.0<90 /8=.A2 %( IA6 ;97. 1..= 7.0H.8 <7H<8<;>. /71 />89 /;0/8<97 9H.0 :90.3./1 /711.4>9;<74<7E50@9:>.:2:992?<238.A97123<01/71:95023 6.2/2/08/>=9<72?3<A3/0.40<.H958<77/250. 3.0.:90.23<8 9502:<718<2<80./897/;>.2940/72/7/695729: 8 (((( :90=/<7/7185::.0<74/71 8 (((:90>9889:/6.7<2<.8/71 />89 8 (((( :90 20/78=902/2<97 .I20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72A3/04.8 F .6<4327923/H./22.71.1/7@923.0?90J/2>./82 :90 / =.0<91 9: :950 697238 3.0.:90. 3. <8 .72<2>.1 :90 8 (((%(I&29?/018>9889:./07<74150<74>/<15= =.0<91 %( 7 />> 23. 292/> A96=.78/2<97 A96.8 29 )**+?<23<72.0.82/223.0/2.9:+G=.0/7756:096 23.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>0./><M/2<97 - 5 - %% 3. /?/01 =/88.1 ;@ 23. 0<;57/> <8 691<:<.1 /8 571.0 ,-.) /01231) % 9889::5250.<7A96. )F+( $/<7/7185::.0<74 (((( 9889:/6.7<2<.8 ((( & .1<A/>.I=.78.8 %+%( 0/78=902/2<97 .I20/ 7950<836.72 /71/22.71/72A3/04.8 (((( + 9889:./07<74150<7423.>/<15= =.0<91:90+697238 ((( 2-4 **+ AA901<74>@ 23. A>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 / 292/> A96=.78/2<979: 8 &(&(< . .73/7A.1A96=.78/2<979: 8 %F+(( % 723.0.85>223.:9>>9?<74901.0<8=/88.1 < 3./==./><8/>>9?.1<7=/02 << 3.0.8=971.729 7850/7A.96=/7@ />0./1@ 1.=98<2.1 23. /69572 /?/01.1 ;@ 23. 0<;57/> 23.0.:90. 0.8=971.72 9 <8 1<0.A2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. .73/7A.1 A96=.78/2<979: 8 %F+((?<23<72.0.82 - 6 - /223.0/2.9:+G?<23<7%69723:09623. 1/2.9:23<8901.0 <<< 785A31.=98<223./==.>>/72<8=.06<22.1 29 ?<2310/? 23. .72<0. /69572 />974 ?<23 <72.0.82/AA05.197<2 ).+ %$ ' # <829 %>9 F