Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58405 (KAR)
NINGAYYA v. NAGAPPA @ NAGARAJ AND ANR
MFA/200258/2024 · 2025-11-21
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58405 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58405 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
"!#$
% "&"'""! ""''
($) *
! "
# ! $ %
%
%
&&'$( '
$$)$
'
&&$)' ! "
'
'( ) ')'*
$ #
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$+"$#
% $' $' ')''
%
&( ')')
%
,%
&! " ,%
#
-./ 011203 ./ 4.325 67 8-2 011233098 :30.;098 <952= 2:8.>9 $+"$# >4 >8>= 2-.:32/ :8 $? :-03329@.9@ 8-2 A<5@;298 095 0B0=5 50825$' $' ')'' 10//25 67 8-2 :><=8 >4 8-255.8.>90329.>=.C.3%<5@20952;62=
080306<=0@. .9> &( ')')8>;>5.478-2/0.5A<5@;29809529-09:2 8-2:>;129/08.>9 ' 20=58-20=@<;298/>48-2320=925:><9/234>=8-2 011233098095320=925:><9/234>==2/1>95298> ' >8.:28> =2/1>95298> $./5./129/25B.8- 9A<=25:30.;0980@25&720=/;28B.8-090::.5298 >9) $' ')$?0954.325:30.;128.8.>9:30.;.9@:>;129/08.>9
- 3 -
>4 / ) 30D-/
-2 8=.6<903 :>9/.52=.9@ 8-2 298.=2 2C.529:2 >9 =2:>=5 @=09825 / $'*')) 03>9@ B.8- .982=2/8 08 8-2 =082>4(E1 0 4=>;5082>4128.8.>98.33=203./08.>9 * @@=.2C25678-2/0.5>=52=8-271=242==2509011203 095 ;0.937 :>9829525 8-08 8-2 :30.;098 B0/ 0@25 06><8 ' 720=/ 2 /</80.925 @=2C.></ .9A<=.2/ 095 -05 2F0;.925 8B> 5>:8>=/ 6<8 8-2
=.6<903 0 25 8-2 5./06.3.87 >9 0 3>B2= /.52 2 B0/ 20=9.9@ / *))))) 12= 099<; <8 8-2 =.6<903-0/80D29;20@2=0;><98>4/ $'&) B.8-><8097 60/./ 095 03/> 8-2 0;><98 @=09825 <952= >8-2= -205/ 0=2 ;20@2=
-2=24>=2=2G<2/8254>=29-09:2;298>48-2/0;2 3/> .982=2/8 =2G<.=2/ 8> 62 29-09:25 08 8-2 =082 >4 ?E .9/8205>4(E & 20=925 :><9/23 4>= =2/1>95298 :>9829525 8-08 5>:8>=/ 0=2 9>8 8=20825 095 9> 92<=>/<=@2>9 B0/ 2F0;.925 //<:--2./9>88-21=>12=12=/>98>0 8-292<=>3>@.:03 :>95.8.>9
-28=.6<903-0/=.@-837:>9/.52=258-25./06.3.87095 .89225/9>.982=42=29:2 28.8.>92=-0/9>84.325097.9:>;2 1=>>40950::.5298>::<==25.98-2720=')$? -28=.6<903-0/
- 4 -
=.@-837 80D29 8-2 9>8.>903 .9:>;2 0/ / $'&) 095 8-2 ;<38.13.2=./$( 2B0/0@25720=/
-2/0.5>=52=9225/ 9> .982=42=29:2 / 12= 8-2 B><95 :2=8.4.:082 08 F ( 8-2 128.8.>92= /</80.925 4=0:8<=2/ >4 /-048 >4 3248 :30C.:32 095 4=0:8<=2>46>57>4;095.632920=/7;1-/./
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
>8035./06.3.87./0 25088-2=082>4)E8>8-2=.@-8 32@ 3.;6 095 B->32 6>57 5./06.3.87 03/> )E .//<25 F $ ' .//<25 5./06.3.87 :2=8.4.:082 08 F $' 67 = 0A295=0 >8-0=. 29.>= <=@2>9 0/ >8-0=.
29.>= <=@2>9 0/ >8-0=. >/1.803 B-2=2.9.8.//808258-08
/:09>4-205=2C20325>4;095.632 >9 /.52 1329.: .9A<=7 B.8- -2;>12=.8>92<;
-2 5>:8>=
- 5 -
0 258-25./06.3.87.95280.30954.90337/808258-088-2=2./ ('E 5./06.3.87 8> 8-2 298.=2 6>57 095 -2 4<=8-2= /80825 8-08 )E5./06.3.87./5<28>@.55.92//-2050:-228: 0950/8-2=2 ./ 4=0:8<=2 >4 ;095.632 8-2 5./06.3.87 8> 8-2 ;><8- ./ '&E >9/.52=.9@8-2;25.:032C.529:20955./06.3.87:2=8.4.:082/095 >8-2==232C0985>:<;298/8-./:><=84.95/.8=20/>906328>80D2 5./06.3.870/*)E
-2.9:>;2./:>9/.52=250// $'&) 095 /.9:2 128.8.>92= B0/ 0@25 & 720=/ ;<38.13.2= 80D29 ./ H$(I
-2=24>=28-23>//>44<8<=220=9.9@:010:.87:>;2/8> / $'&)J$'J$(J*)EK+
,
-28=.6<903 -0/@=09825+,4>=;25.:032F129/2/095.89225/ 9> .982=42=29:2 2 B0/ ->/1.803.L25 4>= ') 507/ 29:2 :>9/.52=.9@ 8-2 908<=2 >4 .9A<=.2/ 095 >8-2= =232C098 40:8>=/ 8-./ :><=8 4.95/ .8 =20/>90632 8> @=098 09 0;><98 >4 + 4>=10.9095/<442=.9@+,4>=3>//>4 0;29.8.2/ 095 +, 4>= 8=09/1>=808.>9 2F8=0 9><=./-;298095088295098:-0=@2/ 28.8.>92=;.@-89>8-0C2 08829525097>8-2=B>=D4>=012=.>5>4*;>98-/
-2=24>=2 / $'&)F*K+ 4>=3>//>4.9:>;25<=.9@30.5<1 12=.>5 //<=@2=7./=2G<.=254>==2;>C03>48-2.;13098/8-./
- 6 -
:><=84.95/.8=20/>906328>@=098+ 8>B0=5/4<8<=2 ;25.:032F129/2/ (
-</.9033:>;1>9298/0B0=525678-./:><=80=20/ 623>B 29:2 8-2 011233098:30.;098 ./ 298.8325 4>= 8>803 :>;129/08.>9 >4 +
, 03>9@ B.8- .982=2/8 08 8-2 =082>4(E1 0 .9/8205>4/ $'*')) 0/@=09825678-2 8=.6<903
+ 98-2=2/<388-24>33>B.9@>=52=./10//25 0=8.:<30=/ ;><98 .9/ >// >4 4<8<=2 20=9.9@ :010:.87 $)$+()) 25.:032F129/2/ *)))) 0.9095/<442=.9@ $))))) >//>40;29.8.2/ &)))) =09/1>=808.>92F8=0 9><=./-;298095 088295098:-0=@2/ &)))) >//>4.9:>;25<=.9@30.5 <112=.>5 &))) <8<=2;25.:032F129/2/ &)))) -./
- 7 -
. 11203./ .910=8
.. -2 A<5@;298 095 0B0=5 50825 $' $' ')'' 10//25 67 8-2 553 29.>= .C.3 %<5@2 095 2;62=
080306<=0@..9> &( ')') ./;>5.4.25
... -2 :30.;098 ./ 298.8325 8> 0 /<; >4
03>9@ B.8- .982=2/8 08 (E 1 0 4=>; 8-2 5082 >4 128.8.>9 8.33 8-2 5082 >4 =203.L08.>9 .9/8205 >4 / $'*')) @=09825 678-28=.6<903
.C 2/1>95298 > ' 9/<=09:2 :>;1097 03=2057 521>/.8250B0=5250;><98678-28=.6<903095 ./5.=2:8258>521>/.88-2=2;0.9.9@0;><98>4 / &)'*)) 03>9@B.8-.982=2/8088-2=082>4 (E 1 0 B.8-.9 >92 ;>98- 4=>; 8-2 5082 >4 8-./>=52=
C
9 /<:- 521>/.8 :30.;098 ./ 12=;.8825 8> B.8-5=0B8-2298.=20;><9803>9@B.8-.982=2/8 0::=<25>98-2/0;2
- 8 -
C.
9 '( ) ')'* 8-2 52307 >4 '&? 507/ ./ :>95>925 67 8-./><=8>98-2:>95.8.>98-088-2:30.;098B.339>862 298.83254>=8-2.982=2/8.9:0/2>429-09:2;298 29:2 =2/1>95298> './9>83.06328>1078-2.982=2/84>=8-2 523072512=.>5
+0, ('""!) &! ./8> $3> (?