Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58402 (KAR)
M/S MUKESH AND ASSOCIATE4S v. CENTRAL UNIVERSITY OF KARNATAKA
CMP/200007/2025 · 2025-09-22
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58402 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58402 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"## #
$
! "#"$
! %%" ! &
!! ! ''%
'$'%(
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! )
*
* +&
% ,-. /-0-1 2-./31145367. 839-9-65 -. :-13; 75;3< 3/9-65 %%" = 6: 9,3 <>-9<49-65 45;
65/-1-49-65 /9 %((:6<4886-5923596:4.613 <>-9<496<-593<2.6:
147.3 $% 6: 4?<332359 ;493; % 553@7<3' 45;
.7881323594<A 4?<332359 ;493; $%( 553@7<3' 96 <3.6103 9,3 ;-.8793. >39B335 9,3 839-9-653< 45; 9,3 <3.865;359 4. 83< 9,3 8<60-.-65. 6: <>-9<49-65 45; 65/-1-49-65 /9%((45;713. <-3::4/9.134;-5?96:-1-5?6:9,-.839-9-654<34. 75;3<*
,3 839-9-653< B,6 -. 35?4?3; -5 9,3 >7.-53.. 6:
8<60-;-5? 2719-;-./-81-54<A /65.71945/A .3<0-/3. :<62 /65/389 96 /622-..-65-5? :6< 2719-'.3/96<41 8<6C3/9. -5 4 14<?3./4134/<6..5;-4,4.3593<3;-596454?<332359B-9, 9,3<3.865;359;493;%968<60-;39,3<3.865;359
- 3 -
B-9,9,3814545;;3.-?56:9,3/4287.75;3<94D3394-13;
5?-533<-5? <4B-5? .9-249-65 )6<D. -5/17;-5? 411 <3' 65.9<7/9-65 4/9-0-9-3. :6< 9,3 /65.9<7/9-65 6: >7-1;-5?. .-93 ;303168235939/0-;3 553@7<3' !6<9,3.4-;8<6C3/99,3 <6C3/9454?32359
65.71945/AB4.4116993;96. 9; B,-/, -. 4 603<52359 6: 5;-4 593<8<-.3 75;3< 9,3 -5-.9<A 6: 4-1B4A. . 83< 9,3 4?<332359 3@3/793;
>39B335 . 9; 45; 9,3 <3.865;359 ;493;
% . 9; B4. .7886.3 96 603<.33 411 D-5;. 6: 8<6C3/9 2454?32359 B6<D. -5/17;-5? /65.9<7/9-65. -5 411 <3.83/9. 45; <30-3B 6: 8<3'/65.9<7/9-65 4/9-0-9-3. /65.9<7/9-65 .783<0-.-65 E741-9A /659<61 39/ 0-;3 553@7<3' 5 83<7.41 6: >69, 4?<332359. 9,3 839-9-653< B,6B4.651A.7886.3968<60-;39,3;3.-?5.45;;<4B-5?. 4. 4 84<9 6: -9. 1-2-93; <3.865.->-1-9A 45; 9,3 . 9;B4..7886.396603<.3345;>3-5'/,4<?36:9,34/9741 ;3031682359 45; /65.9<7/9-65 B6<D. 665 4:93< 9,3 3@3/79-65 6: 9,3 4?<332359. 9,3 B6<D :6< 9,3 8<6C3/9 B4. -5-9-493; >A 9,3 839-9-653< -5 9B6 8,4.3. 5 9,3 23459-23 4569,3< .7881323594<A 4?<332359 ;493; $%( B4. - 4 -
3@3/793; >39B335 9,3 84<9-3. B,3<3-5 9,3 839-9-653<F. :33 83</3594?3B4.<3;7/3;:<62(G6:9,3969418<6C3/9/6.9 96"G6:9,3969418<6C3/9/6.90-;3 553@7<3'
7<-5? 9,3835;35/A6:9,3.4-;8<6C3/9.303<41>7-1;-5?/622-9933 2339-5?.45;8<6?<3..<30-3B2339-5?.B3<3,31;B,3<3-5 9,3 839-9-653< B4. 8<3.359 ,3 <3.865;359 -..73; 4 .,6B' /47.3569-/365(4113?-5?;424?3./47.3;;7396 565'81455-5? 6: /7.962-H3; 4/4;32-/ >7-1;-5?.:6< ;-::3<359 ;384<92359.:4719A81455-5?6: 45;<4-5B493<.96<4?3 8<6C3/9. 8<6165?3; ;314A -5 -..73 6: ! ;<4B-5?. 45; :4-17<3 96 265-96< 9,3 /<338-5? ;3:3/9. ;7<-5? /65.9<7/9-65 .94?3.0-;3 553@7<3',3839-9-653<.359-9.;394-13;<381A ;493;%0-;3 553@7<3',3<3.865;359;-;569 /134< 9,3 835;-5? 84A2359. >79 -5 97<5 9,3 <3.865;359 .67?,9 4 <3:75; 96 9,3 9753 6: .%#(' :<62 9,3 839-9-653< 0-;3 569-/3 ;493; %$% 553@7<3' ,3 839-9-653< >A <381A ;493; % ,4. /14<-:-3; -9. .945; 553@7<3'% ,3 839-9-653< .7>2-993; 4 :-541 >-11 65 %"426759-5?96.$%%""'0-;3 553@7<3'& ,3 839-9-653< .359 4569,3< 13993< ;493; #" 0-;3
- 5 -
553@7<3' <3E73.9-5? :6< 84A2359 /134<45/3 45; 41.6 .7??3.93; 23;-49-65 6: 9,3 -..73 4. 83<
147.3 $ 6: 9,3 4?<332359 ,3 <3.865;359 .359 4 569-/3 65 %" B,3<3-5 9,3 <3.865;359 -5.9<7/93; 9,3 839-9-653< 96 .,6B <34.65. 4.
96 B,A 9,3 839-9-653< .,671; 569 >3 >14/D 1-.93; 0-;3 553@7<3' ,3 839-9-653< 4?4-5 <3E73.93; :6< 23;-49-65 6: 9,3 -..73 >A 4 13993< ;493; (" 0-;3 553@7<3' ,3 <3.865;359 .359 569-/3 ;493; " 96.9;96<3/603<9,34267596:3@/3..84A2359 :<629,3839-9-653<4165?B-9,>14/D1-.9-5?9,3839-9-653<:6< 9,3148.3.0-;3 5553@7<3' %,3839-9-653<>A569-/3;493;
""0-;3 553@7<3',4.-506D3;4<>-9<49-6559,3
69-/3 6: 506/49-65 6: <>-9<49-65 9,3 839-9-653< ,4. 41.6 .7??3.93; 9,3 5423 6: 9,3 .613 <>-9<496< 45; /4113; 7865 9,3<3.865;359964::-<29,3562-549-654886-5923596:9,3 4>603 .613 <>-9<496< ,3<3.865;359 :4-13; 96<381A 969,3 506/49-656:9,3 <>-9<49-65569-/3,3<3:6<39,3839-9-653< :-13; 9,3 8<3.359 839-9-65 .33D-5? 4886-592359 6: .613 <>-9<496< 96 4;C7;-/493 9,3 ;-.8793;-::3<35/3. 9,49 ,403 4<-.35 -5 93<2. 6: 4?<332359 ;493; % 45;
- 6 -
.7881323594<A 4?<332359 ;493; $%( ,3 <3.865;359,4.569:-13;.949323596:6>C3/9-65. 34<; 9,3 4<?72359. 6: 9,3 134<53; /675.31 :6< 9,3839-9-653<45;9,3134<53;/675.31:6<9,3<3.865;359
34<53;/675.31:6<9,3<3.865;359.7>2-993;56 6>C3/9-65 :6< 9,3 4886-592359 6: <>-9<496< 96 <3.6103 9,3 ;-.8793>39B3359,3839-9-653<45;9,3<3.865;359
" 34<53;/675.31:6<9,3839-9-653<45;9,3134<53;
/675.31 :6< 9,3 <3.865;359 ,403 C6-591A :-13; 4 2326 .7??3.9-5? 9,3 5423 6: 65F>13 ,<- &7.9-/3 424/,45;<4 7;;4< !6<23< &7;?3 -?,
67<9 6: 4<5494D4 96 >3 4886-593;4.4.613 <>-9<496<
65.-;3<-5? 9,3 4<>-9<49-65 /147.3 -5 9,3 4?<3323590-;3 553@7<3' 96<3.61039,3;-.8793>39B335 9,3839-9-653<45;9,3<3.865;3594.613 <>-9<496<<3E7-<3. 96>34886-593;
$ 50-3B6:9,34>6039,3:6116B-5?*
- 7 -
- ,3 -0-1 -./31145367. 39-9-65 -. 4116B3;I
-- ,<- &7.9-/3 424/,45;<4 7;;4< -. 562-5493; 4. .613 <>-9<496< 96 <3.6103 9,3 ;-.8793 >39B335 9,3 84<9-3. 96 9,3 839-9-65 -5 93<2. 6:
147.3 $ 6: 9,3 4?<332359 ;493;
% 45; .7881323594<A 4?<332359 ;493; $%( 4. 83< 9,3 8<60-.-65. 6: <>-9<49-65 45;
65/-1-49-65 /9%((45;713.I
--- ::-/3 -. ;-<3/93; 96 /62275-/493 9,-. 6<;3< 96 9,3 134<53; .613 <>-9<496< 45; 96 9,3 <>-9<49-6545;
65/-1-49-65
3593<35?417<7I
-0 11 /659359-65. 6: 9,3 84<9-3. 4<3 D389 6835
%& '##(
"
-.9 6*%1 6*