- 1 - !! " #$%&$& '' (%) * ! " " # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " # % # % & " " " % % " ! % ! % ! % - 3 - % ! " " !! " % " % "" " "" " % " '!# ("" ) * " + , " - 4 - '!# ( ) % " * %" % % $ %" % " " ) * % % ! %" % % " " )*"" " % , % " -" % $ ./0 012345 677168 /0 9/815 :; <.1 =40=221009=8 786/4</990 2.68814>/4> <.1 =5>?14< 645 512@11 56<15 $ 760015 /4 3 :; @/42/768 /A/8 =5>1 ) @ 4* /56@ B.1@1/4 <.1 =5>?14< 645 512@11 56<15!760015/4 3!:;<.1@/42/768 /A/8=5>1)@4*/56@.60:114699/@?15 - 5 - 16@5<.1816@41523=401893@<.167718864<0645 <.1816@41523=401893@<.1@10734514< .1 677168 26?1 <3 :1 65?/<<15 <3 2340/51@ <.1 93883B/4>0=:0<64</68C=10</3403986B ! " # !"$%&&'( )%* + , - .1 67718864<0786/4</990 9/815 0=/< /4 3! 6>6/40< <.1 @10734514<51914564<0 011D/4> @18/193971@71<=68/4E=42</34@10<@6/4/4><.151914564<09@3? /4<1@91@/4>/4716219=87300100/34390=/<02.15=817@371@</10 .1 0=/< 02.15=81 7@371@</10 5102@/:15 6@1 =@A1; 30& 645& 5=8;234A1@<15/4<3434F6>@/2=8<=@68 8645A/513F #!F#56<15 &#645677@3A15 86;3=<:16@/4>3F"6;3=<#F#$56<15!!&#$ - 6 - 60 71@ <.1 ?67 6441G15 <3 <.1 786/4< 645 :3=4515 60 93883B0 60< ?1<1@0B/51A6264<8645<.1@169<1@ @6/8B6;<@62DH 10<!?1<1@B/51@365/4<.186;3=<39 786/4</990645<.1@169<1@783<039<.1 786/4</990H 3@<."645 ;3##645#!H 3=<."645 ;3&#393<.1@0 ! .1 786/4</990 234<145 <.6< <.1 51914564< /0 /4<1@91@/4> /4 786/4</990I 7300100/34 3A1@ <.1 0=/< 02.15=81 7@371@</10.151914564<0514/15<.1260139<.1786/4</990 .1<@/683=@<9@6?15<.193883B/4>/00=10 , + , + + , + - 7 - , + .173B1@396<<3@41;.3851@39<.1786/4</990.60 :114 1G6?/415 60 645 643<.1@ B/<4100 .60 :114 1G6?/41560645>3<?6@D15532=?14<060G<3 G .1 51914564< 3 .60 :114 1G6?/415 60 645 >3< ?6@D15 532=?14<0 60 G <3 G$ .1 <@/68 3=@< 69<1@ .16@/4> <.1 6@>=?14<0 9@3? :3<. 0/510 677@12/6<15 <.1 1A/51421 34 @123@5 645 640B1@15 /00=1 30 645 /4 <.1 41>6</A1 645 /00=1 3 /4 <.1 699/@?6</A1 645 5/0?/0015 <.1 0=/< 39 <.1 786/4</990 .1 786/4</990 6>>@/1A15 :; <.1 06/5 =5>?14< 9/815 3 .1 9/@0< 6771886<1 3=@< 69<1@ .16@/4> <.1 6@>=?14<0 645 @1F677@12/6</4> <.1 1A/51421 34 @123@5 .60 5/0?/0015<.106/56771689/815:;<.1786/4</990:;2349/@?/4> <.1=5>?14<645512@11760015:;<.1<@/683=@< $ "16@415 23=4018 93@ <.1 67718864<0 A1.1?14<8; 234<14515 <.6< <.1 1A/51421 39 141@68 3B1@ 39 <<3@41; 3851@.6043<:1142340/51@151A14/407/<139<.1512/0/34 39 <.1 34I:81 71G 3=@< /4 <.1 2601 39 - 8 - @173@<15/419=@<.1@0=:?/<0 <.6< <.1 1A/51421 34 @123@5 .60 43< :114 7@371@8; 677@12/6<15:;:3<.<.13=@<0 # "16@41523=401893@<.1@10734514<B3=850=:?/< <.6<1A14/9<.11A/5142139<.1141@683B1@39<<3@41; 3851@ /0 <6D14 /4<3 2340/51@6</34 <.1 1A/51421 34 @123@5 B/88 43< 10<6:8/0. <.1 2601 39 <.1 786/4</990 .1 <@/68 3=@< 645 <.1 6771886<1 3=@< .6A1 @/>.<8; 677@12/6<15 645 @1F 677@12/6<15<.11A/5142134@123@5645@/>.<8;5/0?/0015<.1 0=/<39<.1786/4</990 & 6A/4> .16@5 <.1816@415 23=4018067716@/4> 93@ :3<.0/510<./03=@<.6071@=015<.1/?7=>415=5>?14<0 39 <.1 <@/68 3=@< 645 6771886<1 3=@< 645 <.1 ?6<1@/680 78621534@123@5 .1 0=/< 02.15=81 7@371@</10 234<6/40 <B3 7@371@</10:16@/4> =@A1;3& 645& .11G<14< 39162.39<.106/5<B37@371@</10.6043<:1140<6<15/4<.1 786/4<.1068151157@35=2156<G645G 71@<6/40 <3 =@A1; 3& .1 0681 5115 71@<6/40 <3 =@A1; - 9 - 3& .60 43< :114 7@35=215 .1 786/4</990 .6A1 43< 0<6<15/4<.1786/4<<.14=?:1@39783<093@?15/4<.186;3=< .1786/4</990234<14515<.6<<.151914564<@10734514<<@/15 <3 51?6@26<1 <.1 :3=456@/10 /4 6 @152383=@ 6@16 0.3B4 /4 <.1?6714283015<3<.1786/4<340/51@/4><.106/560712< <.1 <@/68 3=@< .60 43< 62217<15 <.1 1A/5142139 645 .1 51914564< B.3 815 1A/51421 .60 7@35=215 0681 5115 /4 @10712< 39 =@A1; 30& $ 645 &$ 39 6865D1@/ A/886>1 645 <.1 @1A14=1 @123@50 6@1 0.3B4 /4 <.1 46?1 39 51914564<645<.1;6@16<G<3645<3 .1 <@/68 3=@< .60 43< :18/1A15 <.1 1A/51421 39 34<.1>@3=45<.6<.1/06141@683B1@39<<3@41; 3851@ 39 786/4</990 .1@193@1 <.1 C=10</34 39 2340/51@/4> <.10=:0<64</68C=10</343986B6< 83531043<6@/01.1 <@/68 3=@< .60 @/>.<8; 3:01@A15 <.6< <.1 1A/51421 39 5310 43< 10<6:8/0. <.6< <.1 51914564< .60 /4<1@91@15 /4 <.1 0=/<02.15=817@371@</10340/51@/4><.11A/5142134@123@5 <.1 <@/68 3=@< .60 @/>.<8; 3:01@A15 <.6< <.1 :3=456@/10 39 0=/< 86450 0.3B4 /4 <.1 ?67 6441G15 <3 <.1 786/4< 645 <.1 :3=456@/10 39 <.1 0=/< 8645 0.3B4 /4 <.1 0=/< 6@1 14</@18; - 10 - 5/991@14< 340/51@/4> <.101 60712<0 <.1 <@/68 3=@< .60 @/>.<8;677@12/6<15<.11A/5142134@123@56455/0?/0015<.1 0=/< 39 <.1 786/4</990 .1 6771886<1 3=@< .60 6803 @1F 677@12/6<15<.11A/5142134@123@5645@/>.<8;5/0?/0015<.1 67716839<.167718864<0786/4</990 4A/1B39<.16:3A1<.10=:0<64</68C=10</3439 86B 6< 83 /0 640B1@15 6223@5/4>8; 645 <.1 677168 /0 +, (&$&) % "/0<3 83