- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) !" # $ % &' ( !" ) *+ + !" # $ +), % + + '$%+ "' ") )"- Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' )"! + + """" ).+ + / + ++ ( ( 0 $ 1234561237891:5;<3=9>=56;?41; ) 6?;2@@12A?;<?A14>B5619?:=3?:C8314DA2?92:5 31@31;1:514 >B 6?; 9=5613 ;11E?:7 5= ;15 2;?41 561 =3413 42514 "' ") )"- @2;;14 ?: = ' )"! >B 561 44?5?=:2A 1:?=3 ?F?A 8471 2:4 ?C2B2@832 $<=3 ;6=35G56153?>8:2AH% 6?A15619?:=3?:C8314DA2?92:5I2;@3=D114?:7 2A=:7I?566?;9=56135=I234;=A2713?2E2=:)' " )") 2 9=5=3DBDA1 >123?:7 317?;5325?=: = = ) '-& D291<3=9=A2713?;?41?:232;62:4:17A?71:592::132:4 42;6145=5619?:=3DA2?92:5 619?:=3DA2?92:5I2;2714 - 3 - " B123; 2; =: 561 4251 =< 561 2DD?41:5 61 53?>8:2A D=:;?413?:7 561 1:5?31 1F?41:D1 =: 31D=34 4?;9?;;14 561 DA2?9 @15?5?=: 773?1F14 >B 561 ;2?4 =3413 56?; 2@@12A ?; @31<13314 & 123:14 D=8:;1A <=3 561 2@@1AA2:5 62; 92?:AB D=:51:414 5625 481 5= 561 3=24 532<<?D 2DD?41:5 561 9?:=3 DA2?92:5 ;8;52?:14 <32D5831 ?:C83?1; 2:4 =5613 98A5?@A1 ?:C83?1;2AA=F13561>=4B 1I2;249?5514?:5613 2:72 =;@?52A ?C2B2@832 I6131?:61 I2;?:@25?1:5 <=3 42B; 2:4 8:4137=:1 ;83713B >B ;@1:4?:7 6871 29=8:5 <=3 5312591:5 3?9?:2A D2;1 ?: 3?91 = ) )" I2; 317?;51314 6153?>8:2A4?4:=51J29?:1561@=A?D131D=34; I6?D6 231 @8>A?D 31D=34; 2:4 <2?A14 5= 2@@31D?251 561 1F?41:D1 =< 2:4 ) 2:4 2A;= <2?A14 5= 2@@31D?251 1F?41:D1 317234?:7 :25831 =< ?:C83?1; 2:4 5312591:5 5= 561 9?:=3 ;@13561+ 61I2;;6?<5145=5616=;@?52A563=876 9>8A2:D1 =: )' " )" 25 2>=85 " )" @ 9 85 561 1F?41:D1 =< 561 5312514 =D5=3 I2; :=5 D=:;?41314 2:4 561 53?>8:2A 4?;9?;;14 561 @15?5?=: =: 561 73=8:4 5625 56131 ?; 41A2B=<"-42B;?:<?A?:7561D=9@A2?:5 - 4 - 61 53?>8:2A 62; =>;13F14 5625 561 <25613 =< 561 9?:=3 DA2?92:5 I2; :=5 1J29?:14 317234?:7 41A2B?:7?F?:7 561D=9@A2?:5 61 :;832:D1D=9@2:B4?;@85145612DD?41:5 ?: 561?3 I3?551: ;525191:5 2:4 2A;= 1J29?:14 2DD=34?:7AB4?;9?;;14561DA2?9@15?5?=: ! 61 @15?5?=:13 915 I?56 561 2DD?41:5 =: )' " )") 25 2>=85 " )" @ 9 ; @13 561 I=8:4 D135?<?D251 61 ;8;52?:14 <32D5831 ?:C83?1; I6?D6 231 73?1F=8; ?: :25831 1 I2; 249?5514 ?: 561 6=;@?52A =: )' " )" 2:44?;D623714=:" "- )"25 "2 9 61D=9@A2?:5 I2;7?F1:=:"& "- )"? 1 2<51356141A2B=<"-42B; ; @135614?;D62371;89923B61I2;249?5514=:)' " )" 2:44?;D623714=:" "- )" ' 6192?:D=:51:5?=:=<561 :;832:D1D=9@2:B?; 5625 56131 ?; := @3=@13 1J@A2:25?=: 317234?:7 41A2B =< "- 42B; ?: <?A?:7 561 D=9@A2?:5 49?5514AB ;?:D1 561 ?:C8314 DA2?92:5?;29?:=3;=:6?;<256139?76562F1>11:>8;B?: 52E?:7 D231 2:4 6=;@?52A?K25?=: =< 6?; ;=: ? 1 <3=9 )' " )") 5= " "- )") 2:4 561 D=9@A2?:5 I2; 7?F1: =: - 5 - "& "- )" I6?A1 561 ?:C8314 ;=: I2; ?: 561 6=;@?52A 6131<=319131AB=:56173=8:4=<41A2B?5D2::=5>1;2?4 5625 561 D=9@A2?:5 I2; >1A2514 2:4 41A2B ?; :=5 @3=@13AB 1J@A2?:14 61 312;=:?:7 =< 561 53?>8:2A ?; @251:5AB 133=:1=8;2:4?;;152;?41 ?:D1561=5=316?DA1;D5?;2 >1:1<?D?2A A17?;A25?=: 2:4 ?5 ;62AA 2AI2B; >1 ?:513@31514 ?: <2F=83=<561F?D5?9; 6131<=3156?;=835<?:4;?5@3=@135= ;152;?41561=3413=<56153?>8:2A2:45=3192:4561925513 5=56153?>8:2A DD=34?:7AB561<=AA=I?:7=3413( $?% 612@@12A?;2AA=I14 $??% 61 ?9@87:14 =3413 =< 561 53?>8:2A ?; ;152;?41 $???% 61 925513 ?; 3192:414 >2DE 5= 561 53?>8:2AI?562;@1D?<?D4?31D5?=:5=56153?>8:2A5= 7?F1 312;=:2>A1 =@@=358:?5B 5= >=56 ;?41; 5= 24F2:D1 561?3 237891:5; 2:4 5= 4?;@=;1 =< 561 925513 2<31;6 >B 48AB 7?F?:7 =@@=358:?5B 5= >=56 ;?41; I?56?: 5I= 9=:56; <3=9 561 4251 =< 56?; =34132;5612DD?41:5?;=<561B123)"! - 6 - $?F% 17?;53B?;4?31D5145=;1:456131D=34; 5=561D=:D13:1453?>8:2A?:=:1I11E $F% =56561@235?1;2314?31D5145=2@@123 >1<=3156153?>8:2A=:)' " )") *+ &% ( $ ?;5= (A= ( - (