- 1 - ! "#$%#% && '($) * !"# $%& ' ( ) * + , $%& ' ( * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! && ! ) ,&%& %%& ) ! ) &%&%& &&% ) () * !) ! ! ) + -) $# ./0 123456 1789: ;;154 /0 </41: => ;45/9?/<<0 ;65>/92 ?8 01? 50/:1 ?.1 @3:2A19? 59: :17611 :5?1: ,&%&;5001:/9 8%%&=>?.1::/?/8954 19/86/B/4)3:2134=5625789</6A/92?.1@3:2A19?59: :17611 :5?1: &%&%& ;5001: /9 8&&% => ?.1::/?/8954/B/4)3:21()9*34=5625 ;;14459?0 $;45/9?/<< 80 59: .5: </41: 03/? /9 8&&% 525/90? ?.1 610;89:19? $:1<19:59? 011C/92 614/1< 8< :174565?/89 ?.5? ;45/9?/<<0 561 8D9160 8< 03/? ;68;16?> =156/92 > 8& A15036/92 & 57610 239?50 ?8D56:0 150?169 ;86?/89 83? 8< & 57610 - 3 - 239?50 .5B/92 =839:56/10E 50? 85:F +10? 45>83? /9 > 8&F 86?. ;;68B1: 45>83? 8< > 8&,F 83?.1A5/9/92;86?/898<459:> 8&.105/: 03/? ;68;16?> 0/?35?1: 5? .1C 8G5 685: 545=3652/ 45/9?/<<0 .5B1 5408 </41: 03/? <86 614/1< 8< 6178B16> 8< ;800100/898<;86?/898<03/?;68;16?>59::/617?/89?8?.1 :1<19:59? <86 61A8B54 8< /441254 7890?637?/89 A5:1 8B16 ?.1 03/? ;68;16?> 59: .59:8B16 B5759? ;800100/89 ?8 ?.1 ;45/9?/<<0 ? /0 7501 8< ;45/9?/<<0 ?.5? 459: =156/92 > 8& A15036/92 & 57610 239?50 0/?35?1: 5? .1C8G5685: 545=3652/D508D91:59:;800100/89=> 891.59C16583=1:5659:./095A1D505;;156/9250 8D916 59: ;80010086 /9 ?.1 ;68;16?> 61786:0 .1 05/: .59C16583=1:56 :/1: 89 ,HH 415B/92 =1./9: ./0 D/<1 $ A? 3A59=5/ 59: ?D8 0890 95A14> 5IA/C59?. 59: .59:1658 <?16 ?.1 :15?. 8< ?.1 .59C16583=1:56?.103/?459:59:8?.16;86?/8908< 459:75A1?8=1A3?5?1:/9?.195A108<5IA/C59?.59: - 4 - .59:165850@8/9?8D91659:;800100868<> 8& .105/:5IA/C59?.59: .59:1658084:?.103/?459:?8 ;45/9?/<<039:16612/0?161:0541:11::5?1:&&&59: :14/B161: B5759? ;800100/89 8< 03/? 459: ?8 ;45/9?/<<0 45/9?/<<028?A3?5?1:?.1/695A10/9?.161786:8<6/2.?0 , .1:1<19:59?745/A/92?8=1?.18D9168<891 239?5 /9 ?.1 03/? 459: 544121: ?8 .5B1 =119 ;367.501: <68A.84:168<.59C16583=1:5639:160541:11: :5?1: &%&HH <86 7890/:165?/89 8< 0,&&&E 59: ?6>/92?8;3?3;57890?637?/898B16?.105/:03/?;68;16?> .1 ;45/9?/<<0 </41: 8 && 89 ?.1 </41 8< ::/?/8954/B/4)3:21()69*34=5625011C/92?.1614/1< 8<;16;1?354/9@397?/89<68AA5C/9259>7890?637?/898B16 ?.1 03/? ;68;16?> .1 5;;4/75?/89 </41: => ;45/9?/<<0 011C/92 ?1A;8656> /9@397?/89 75A1 ?8 =1 61@17?1: .1615<?16 ?.1 05/: 03/? 75A1 ?8 =1 :/0A/001: 89 A16/?0 => @3:2A19? :5?1: &&& 45/9?/<<0 .5B1 </41: 6123456 </60? 5;;154 /9 8&&& =1<861 ?.1 ::/?/8954 /B/4 )3:21 (69* 34=5625 59: ?.1 05/: - 5 - 5;;154540875A1?8=1:/0A/001:89A16/?0=>@3:2A19? :5?1: && .1615<?16 ;45/9?/<<0 .5B1 </41: ?.1 ;61019? 03/? 011C/92 614/1< 89 ?.1 26839: ?.5? 19?/61 7890?637?/89 A5:1 => ?.1 :1<19:59? /0 D/?.83? 59> 6/2.? 59:/?/0/4412547890?637?/89 .1 :1<19:59? </41: .16 D6/??19 0?5?1A19? 59: 789?19:1: ?.5? 03/? <86 /9@397?/89 </41: => ;45/9?/<<0 /9 && .50=119:/0A/001: 89 A16/?0 59: 1B19 ?.1 5;;154</41:=>;45/9?/<<0/9 8&&& .505408=119 :/0A/001:59:?.161<861?.103/?/098?A5/9?5/95=41.1 :1<19:59? 789?19:1: ?.5? ?.1 ;45/9?/<<0 832.? ?8 .5B1 /9743:1:D.841745/A/9610;17?8<05A1753018<57?/89/9 1564/1603/?59:789?19:1:?.5??.103/?/098?A5/9?5/95=41 50;16 6:163418<.1:1<19:59?.50:/0;3?1: ?.1:1076/;?/898<?.103/?;68;16?>?/?418<;45/9?/<<08B16 ?.103/?;68;16?>59:.59:/928B16;800100/898<?.103/? ;68;16?> 39:16 05/: 0541 :11: :5?1: &&& => 5IA/C59?. 59: .59:1658 ?8 ;45/9?/<<0 .1 :1<19:59? 789?19:1: ?.5? 0.1 .50 ;367.501:891 239?5 459: /9 > - 6 - 8& 39:16 0541 :11: :5?1: &%&HH 59: 7890?637?1: =3/4:/92 => 8=?5/9/92 7890?637?/89 ;16A/00/89 <68A 65A 597.5>5?. 59: 7890?637?1: ?D8 688A0 59: .16 95A1 /0 19?161: /9 ?.1 61786: 8< 6/2.?0 +/?. ?.101 :1<19:59?;65>0<86:/0A/00548<?.103/? 9 ?.1 =50/0 8< ?.1 05/: ;415:/920 ?.1 ?6/54 836?.50<65A1:?.1<8448D/92/00310F ! " # $ % & '(' ! %)*+,"- 45/9?/<< 8.50=1191I5A/91:50+59: 28?A56C1::873A19?050I?8%.1:1<19:59?.50 - 7 - 98? 415: 59> :1<1971 1B/:1971 59: 98? ;68:371: 59> :873A19?0 .1 ?6/54836? 5<?16.156/92 5623A19?0 59: 5;;617/5?/92 1B/:1971 89 61786:0 .50 590D161: /0031 80 ?8 59: 5::/?/8954 /0031 /9 ?.1 9125?/B1 59: :/0A/001:?.103/?8<;45/9?/<<0 % 226/1B1: => ?.1 05/: @3:2A19? 8< ?.1 ?6/54 836? ;45/9?/<<0 .5B1 </41: </60? 5;;154 /9 8%%& .105/:5;;15475A1?8=1:/0A/001:89A16/?05<</6A/92 ?.1@3:2A19?59::17611;5001:=>?.1?6/54836? H .1 ;61019? 1789: ;;154 75A1 ?8 =1 5:A/??1:?87890/:16<8448D/9203=0?59?/54J310?/898<45DF .! / ( $ 0 !1 ( 2 ! 3 ' 4 $ ' ! 0. - - 8 - & 156: 415691: 7839014 <865;;14459?0 15691: 7839014<86?.1610;89:19?/05=019? 15691: 7839014 <86 5;;14459?0 D834: 789?19: ?.5??.1610;89:19?$:1<19:59?.50;367.501:891239?5 459:/9> 8&<68A.84:16$/25A=56588< .59C16 58 3=1:56 => B/6?31 8< 191654 8D16 8< ??8691> :5?1: &HH, 59: 50 89 ?.1 :5?1 8< 0541 :11:/1&%&HH ?.105/:.59C16583=1:56D50 98?54/B159:.1:/1:89,HH50;16I$:15?. 716?/</75?1.161<861?.1.84:16$/25A=1658.50 9853?.86/?>?81I173?10541:11::5?1:&%&HH =501: 89?.11I173?1:=>.59C16583=1:56.161<861 ?.1:1<19:59?.5098?57J3/61:59>?/?418<891239?5459: /9 > 8& 1 <36?.16 03=A/?0 ?.5? 1B/:1971 8< + .50 61A5/91: 3961=3??1: 50 ?.161 /0 98 76800 1I5A/95?/89 890/:16/92 ?.1 05A1 ?.1 ?6/54 836? 59: !/60?;;1445?1836?832.??8.5B1=14/1B1:?.11B/:1971 8< + 59: :17611: ?.1 03/? +/?. ?.101 .1 ;65>0 ?8 5448D?.15;;154 - 9 - 5B/92 .156: 415691: 7839014 ?.1 836? .50 ;16301:?.1/A;3291:@3:2A19?059:?6/54836?61786:0 .1 ;68;16?> :1076/=1: /9 ;565 8 8< ?.1 ;45/9?/05039:16F 3 ),"+$ . 5 5 !!6 6& 6/7$),"+$ ) 6$ ),# 6& ),"+$ 8&92/! :; <- 45/9?/<<0;367.501:?.103/?;68;16?>39:160541:11: $I .1 :1076/;?/89 8< ?.1 ;68;16?> ;367.501: => ;45/9?/<<050;160541:11:$I/05039:16F 3 ! ! ! ! ),"+$$ . 5 5 !!6 6=)> 2/! - 10 - 6/7$ ) 6),# 8 &9 6& ? ),"+$$ 8 &92/! - 9;1630548<=8?.:1076/;?/898<?.1;68;16?>=8?. D/4498??544>68;16?>;367.501:39:160541:11:$I /0986?.169;86?/898<> 8&A15036/92&57610 & 239?50 83? 8< & 57610 239?50 3? ?.1 ;68;16?> :1076/=1: /9 ?.1 ;45/9? /9 ;565 8 /0 150?169 ;86?/89 8< > 8& A15036/92 & 57610 239?50 83? 8< & 57610239?50+.191B16;45/9?/<<0745/A0:174565?/898< ?/?41?.1:1076/;?/898<?.1;68;16?>0.834:=1;68;1659: 577365?1 , ?/0789?19?/898<5;;14459?0$;45/9?/<<0?.5??.1 :1<19:59? ;367.501: 891 239?5 459: /9 > 8& 39:160541:11::5?1:&%&HH <68A891/25A=5658 $.84:168<.59C16583=1:5659:?.105/:/0 :5?1: &HH, 45/9?/<<0 .5B1 98? ;68:371: 716?/</1: 78;> 8< 05/: 0541 :11: :5?1: &%&HH 59: :5?1: - 11 - &HH, 1B19 ?.832. =8?. 561 612/0?161: :873A19?0 9 ?.1 5=01971 8< 05/: ?D8 :873A19?0 03=0?59?/54 J310?/89 8< 45D 8 75998? =1 7890/:161: 0/971 :5?1 8< 0541 :11: 59: :5?1 8< :873A19? 561 61J3/61: <86 7890/:165?/898<03=0?59?/54J310?/898<45D 8 45/9?/<<0 789?19:1: ?.5? ;68;16?> A15036/92 891239?5;367.501:=>?.1:1<19:59?D/44<544D/?./9?.1 ;68;16?> ;367.501: => ;45/9?/<<0 A15036/92 & 57610 239?50 /9 > 8& 9 86:16 ?8 ;68B1 ?.1 05/: 789?19?/89981B/:1971/0;4571:8961786:45/9?/<<0832.? ?8.5B128?789:37?1:036B1>/986:16?810?5=4/0.?.5??.1 ;68;16?> 8< ?.1 :1<19:59? A15036/92 891 239?5 D/44 <544 D/?./9 =839:56/10 8< ?.1 ;68;16?> ;367.501: => ;45/9?/<<0 39:16 0541 :11: $I 9 ?.1 5=01971 8< ?.1 05/: 50;17?0 1B19 ?.832. ?.161 /0 98 76800 1I5A/95?/89 8< ;45/9?/<< 8 $+ ?.1 03/? 8< ;45/9?/<<0 75998? =1 :17611: ;457/92 614/5971 89 ?.1 7./1< 1I5A/95?/89 8< + - 12 - 890/:16/92 544 ?.101 50;17?0 03=0?59?/54 J310?/898<45D 8059:561590D161:57786:/924>59: .11789:;;154/0 +( '%#%) $ /0? 84 8