- 1 - ! "# $ ## # % &%'() *&% (( + ! " # $ %&& & " # $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' % #$ ! % % %% !#$# $'() % % % #$ % % * # * $ +, -,././01,23456673,8 03 .0 52, 9,:02, .+/3 072.3,,;/1<<251.0:95/=718,2 ,6./01'0:+525./>5 5<52/; 725;3+5 51+/.5 ! #:02 3+02. ? @$ /1 2/A, 0 ! 0: 5825A/ 0=/6, .5./01 -,18/1< 01 .+, :/=, 0: .+, =,521,8/B/= 78<, #$ C % ,D52</ 2,</3.,2,8 :02 .+, 0::,16,3 -71/3+59=, 718,2 ,6./013 !#$ # $ ' ( ) 0: +525./>5 >5>5 51+/.5 !E:023+02.?.+, !@F01.+,953/30:.+,:/23. /1:02A5./01 =08<,8 9> .+, /1:02A51. G 2/ 5+/9009 5/;08/ - 3 - ,528 2/ 535B5=/1< 53/ =,521,8 60713,= :02 .+, -,././01,23 518 2/ 5A5852 +5+59788/1 =,521,8 /<+072.0B,21A,1.=,58,2:02.+,2,3-018,1.4 .5., ,273,8.+,A5.,2/5=3012,6028 1 B/,D 0: .+, 2/B5= 601.,1./013 72<,8 9> .+, =,521,860713,=:0290.+.+,-52./,3.+,-0/1..+5.D07=8 52/3,:02A>6013/8,25./01/3 > 513D,2 .0 .+, 590B, -0/1. /3 ? @:02.+,:0==0D/1< +, /1:02A51. =08<,8 .+, :/23. /1:02A5./01 5<5/13. 56673,8 03 .0 ( 5==,</1< .+5. .+, 8,6,53,8 585-,,2/3+/3920.+,2518+,+58/==/6/.2,=5./013+/-D/.+ 56673,8 0 +/3 :56. 65A, .0 =/<+. 518 .+,2, D53 5 -516+5>5. /1 .+, B/==5<, 5.,2 56673,8 0 9,/1< .+, - 4 - +739518 0: 56673,8 0 518 56673,8 0 9,/1< .+,/2 301 =,:. .+, B/==5<, 518 3.52.,8 2,3/8/1< /1 5825A/ 0D,B,2 .+, 8,6,53,8 3.5.,8 .0 +5B, :0==0D,8 56673,8 0,B,1/15825A/+,1.+,8,6,53,8D53.5=;/1<.0 56673,8 0 56673,8 03 518 +5B, 3,,1 .+,A .0<,.+,2 125<,8 9> .+, 601876. 0: .+, 8,6,53,8 56673,8 0 -/6;,8 7- 5 3+52- ,8<,8 3.01, 1 .+, A,51./A, .+, 0.+,2 56673,8 +5B, /13./<5.,8 56673,8 0 .0 6573, .+, 8,5.+ 0: .+, 8,6,53,8 66028/1<=> 56673,8 0 53357=.,8 .+, 8,6,53,8 01 +/3 +,58 53 5 2,37=. 0: D+/6+ +, 8/,8 :.,2 2,</3.25./01 0: % 6673,8 03 518 D,2, 522,3.,8 01 (!! 518 56673,8 0 D53 522,3.,8 01 !! /16, .+,1 .+,> 52, /1 H78/6/5= 673.08> :.,2 /1B,3./<5./01 6+52<, 3+,,.65A,.09,:/=,8 203,67./01+536/.,853A51>53(D/.1,33,3 07.0:.+,A34).052,6/.,853,>,D/.1,33,3+,/2 3.5.,A,1.3 D,2, 2,6028,8 90.+ 9> .+, 1B,3./<5./1< ::/6,2 5189> .+,=,521,8 5</3.25., +,,>,D/.1,33,3 - 5 - +5B, 3.5.,8 .+5. 5. .+, ./A, 0: 56673,8 0 53357=./1< .+,8,6,53,8.+,>+5B,3,,1+/A97.3/16,.+,56673,8 +5B, .+2,5.,1,8 .+,A .+,> +5B, :=,8 :20A .+, 3-0. 18,2 376+ 6/267A3.516,3 .+, 601.,1./01 0: .+, =,521,8 60713,=:02.+,-,././01,23.+5..+,2,/3/1028/15.,8,=5>/1 2,6028/1< .+,/2 3.5.,A,1. 65110. 9, .+, <20718 :02 ,1=52</1<56673,800195/= ( 3 -,2 6+52<, 3+,,. /. /3 56673,8 0 D+0 53357=.,8.+,8,6,53,8D/.+3.01,5186573,8+/38,5.+ 3-,2-03.A02.,A2,-02..+,8,6,53,8+58373.5/1,853 A51> 53 I ,J.,215= /1H72/,3 518 .+, 8,5.+ D53 87, .0 +,A022+5<,5183+06;5352,37=.0:/1H72/,3373.5/1,8.0 .+,925/1 B,1 53 -,2 .+, 6+52<, 3+,,. 56673,8 03 518 .+07<+ D,2, 5. .+, 3-0. +5B, 10. 60AA/..,8 51> 0B,2. 56. /1 6573/1< .+, 8,5.+ 0: .+, 8,6,53,8 . /3 3.5.,8.+5.56673,803.0(+5B,5=2,58>9,,1<251.,8 51./6/-5.02> 95/= 1 B/,D 0: .+,3, :56.3 518 6/267A3.516,35A0:.+,0-/1/01.+5.56673,803518 A5> 9, ,1=52<,8 01 95/= ,.,1./01 0: 56673,8 03 - 6 - 518 /1 673.08> D07=8 5A071. .0 /1:2/1<,A,1. 0: .+,/2 2/<+..0=/:,518=/9,2.> ,16,5A0:.+,0-/1/01.+5. -,././01,203518 56673,80351852,,1./.=,8.0 9, ,1=52<,80195/= 379H,6. .0 6018/./013D+/6+D/==.5;, 652, 0: .+, 5--2,+,13/01 ,J-2,33,8 9> .+, =,521,8 /<+ 072. 0B,21A,1. =,58,2 .+5. .+, -,././01,23 A5> 5936018 02 A5> .5A-,2 02 .+2,5.,1 .+, -203,67./01 D/.1,33,3 7. 3/16, 56673,8 0 /3 .+, 57.+02 0: .+, 62/A, D+/6+ /3 -71/3+59=, ,/.+,2 D/.+ 8,5.+ 02 /A-2/301A,1.:02=/:,+,/310.,1./.=,8:0251>2,=/,: I 66028/1<=>513D,2.+,590B,-0/1.?-52.=>/1 .+,5::/2A5./B,@518-206,,8.0-533.+,:0==0D/1< +,-,././01/3 +,-,././01:/=,89>-,././01,20 56673,80/3 +,2,9> +,-,././01:/=,89>-,././01,203518 56673,8 03 518 /3 +,2,9> ,././01,2 03 518 - 7 - 56673,8035152,028,2,8.09,,1=52<,80195/=/1 2/A,0 ! 0:5825A/0=/6, .5./010109.5/1/1< .+, 9018 /1 5 37A 0: 3!!!!! 4 #7-,,3 D0 5;+3 01=>$ ,56+ D/.+ .D0 372,./,3 :02 .+, =/;,37A .0 .+, 35./3:56./01 0: .+, H72/38/6./015= 072. 379H,6. .0 .+, :0==0D/1<6018/./013 5$ ,././01,203518 56673,803518 3+5==10.60AA/.3/A/=520::,16,3K 9$ ,././01,203518 56673,803518 3+5== 10. .+2,5.,1 02 .5A-,2 D/.+ .+, -203,67./01D/.1,33,3K518 6$ ,././01,203518 56673,803518 3+5== 5--,52 9,:02, .+, 072. 53 518 D+,12,L7/2,8 : /1 653, .+, -,././01,23 B/0=5., 51> 0: .+, 6018/./013 53 3.5.,8 590B, .+, -203,67./01 D/== 9, 5. =/9,2.>.0A0B,.+,2/5=072.3,,;/1<6516,==5./010:95/= - 8 - 1 :721/3+/1< .+, 372,./,3 9> .+, -,././01,23 .+, 2/5=072./35.=/9,2.>.08/2,6..+,1B,3./<5./1<::/6,2.0 B,2/:> .+, 6022,6.1,33 0: .+, 5882,33 518 57.+,1./6/.> 0: .+, 8067A,1.3 :721/3+,8 9> .+, -,././01,23 518 .+, 372,./,3 518 5 2,-02. A5> 9, 65==,8 :02 /1 .+5. 2,<528 D+/6+/3.09,379A/..,89>.+,1B,3./<5./1<::/6,2D/.+/1 85>3 +, 2/5= 072. 01 35./3:56./01 A5> -206,,8 .0 566,-. .+, 372,./,3 :02 .+, -72-03, 0: 2,=,53/1< .+, -,././01,230195/= ,) %##( $ & /3.0 =0' &