Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58363 (KAR)

D SHIVAJI RAO v. SHARANABASAVA AND ANR

MFA/203187/2024 · 2025-11-11

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"!#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($) * !!!" " # " ! !" $%& ' ()'! &* ' $ !&!" $" !&!" # " +" ' $ $%"&!"$&$ ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +''"!*(! '+ + + + ' + $"!&"$&$( " + + " %&$&$$ '" + ' + + + ,+ &! ,+ -./0- 1-23 451167 -53 8.46 /9 :.7 5;42332.< =21- 8.<36<1 .: >657<6; 8./<36> :.7 9571263 21 23 15?6< /9 :.7 -6572<0" $" -23 59965> 23 :2>6; 5052<31 1-6 @/;046<1 5<; 5=57; ;516; $"!&"$&$( 95336; AB 1-6 ;;212.<5> 6<2.7 2C2> /;065<;+' 528-/72<+."%&.:$&$$" ("-62<@/76;8>5245<1506;(B6573=.7?2<0538..? 461=21-5<5882;6<1.<(&"&%"$&$$5<;:2>6;8>524599>28512.< 8>5242<0 8.496<3512.< .: 3"$&&&&&" -6 72A/<5> 8.<32;672<0 1-6 6<1276 6C2;6<86 .< 768.7; 075<16; 1-6 8.496<3512.< .: 3"()! $ =21- 2<167631 51 1-6 7516 .: ) 96786<19675<</4:7.41-6;516.:961212.<12>>5=57;" - 3 - "00726C6;AB1-6352;.7;671-2359965>23976:6776; AB1-65996>>5<18>5245<1452<>B8.<16<;2<01-51-6-53396<1 -/06 54./<1 1.=57;3 46;285> 6D96<363 5<; 1-6 54./<1 075<16; /<;67 1-6 .1-67 -65;3 23 465067" 6 =53 657<2<0 3"(&&&& 967 4.<1- A/1 1-6 72A/<5> -53 =7.<0>B 8.<32;676;-232<8.4653 3"! *&9674.<1-"-6;.81.7 5336336; 1-6 ;235A2>21B 53 (&E .: 1-6 =-.>6 A.;B A/1 1-6 72A/<5> -53 15?6< .<>B !&E 5<; -6<86 76F/6316; :.7 6<-5<8646<12<8.496<3512.<5<;5>3.2<167631/91.!$E967 5<</4" "657;1-6570/46<13.:A.1-32;63" )" 657<6; 8./<36> :.7 7639.<;6<1 2<3/75<86 8.495<B -538.<16<;6;1-51:/1/7697.396813=6765>765;B5;;6;1.1-6 2<8.46.:8>5245<1"123:/71-678.<16<;6;1-511-6;.81.7-53 5336336;;235A2>21B 53 (&E 5<; 1-6 72A/<5> -53 720-1>B 15?6< .<6 1-27; .: 1-6 3546 53 !&E" -6 72A/<5> -53 15?6< 1-6 <.12.<5>2<8.46.:1-68>5245<153 3"! *&9674.<1-5<; AB 5;;2<0 !&E:/1/76 97.396813 5336336; 1-6 1.15> 2<8.46 .: 1-68>5245<153 3"!)$$9674.<1-5<;-23506=5315?6< - 4 - 53 B6573511-61246.:1-65882;6<15<;1-64/>129>26753!!" -676:.7676F/6316;:.7;2342332<01-659965>" *"-6961212.<678>5245<1-533/3152<6;:7581/76.:;2315> -/467/3 .< 1-6 720-1 32;6" D" " =./<; 86712:28516 3-.=3 ;239>586; :7581/76 2<C.>C2<0 >51675> 8.<;B>6 5<; >51675> 6928.<;B>6 .: ;2315> -/467/3 =21- 42<245> 9.31672.72<:672.7 ;23>.8512.< .: /><5 :7.4 .>6875<.<:.335 =21- >29.-64571-7.323 .: 6>A.=" 1 =53 5>3. 31516; 1-51 -6 =53 /<5A>6 1. >2:1 1-6 .A@6813:7.41-607./<;" " 657<6; 8./<36> :.7 1-6 5996>>5<18>5245<1 -53 8.<16<;6; 1-51 1-6 5996>>5<1 =53 5 8..? 5<; 1-/3 -23 :/<812.<5>;235A2>21B231.A615?6<53(&E2<3165;.:!&E+, -./01230,401,355+6,/0"-6>.33.::/1/7657<2<02< 8595821B8.4631. 3"$! !*&!)$$D!$D!!D!&E"-6 961212.<67 =53 075<16; 3"($$ 1.=57;3 46;285> 6D96<363 AB1-672A/<5>5<;21<66;3<.2<167:676<86"-6961212.<67=53 -.39215>2G6;:.7!!;5B35<;1-676:.768.<32;672<01-6<51/76 .: 2<@/7263 1-6 9672.; .: -.39215>23512.< 5<; .1-67 76>6C5<1 :581.73 1-23 ./71 :2<;3 21 7653.<5A>6 1. 075<1 5< 54./<1 .: 3"*&&& :.7 952< 5<; 3/::672<0 3"(&&&& :.7 >.33 .: - 5 - 546<21263 3"(&&&& :.7 175<39.71512.< 6D175 <./723-46<1 5<;5116<;5<18-570635<;5>3. 3"&&&&:.7:/1/7646;285> 6D96<363539671-66C2;6<86.: $"-6961212.<67420-1<.1 -5C6 5116<;6; 5<B .1-67 =.7? 51 >6531 :.7 5 9672.; .: :./7 4.<1-3;/61.1-62<@/72633/3152<6;2<1-65882;6<1"-676:.76 1-6>.33.:2<8.46;/72<0>52;/99672.;8.4631. 3"%&&& ! *&D " %" -/3 2< 5>> 1-6 8>5245<1 23 6<121>6; :.7 1-6 8.496<3512.<.: 3" ) %$=21-2<16763151)E9675<</4 535052<31 3"()! $5=57;6;AB1-672A/<5>" !&"-65=57;.:8.496<3512.<95336;AB1-672A/<5> 234.;2:26;53/<;67 65;3 4./<12< 3" !".33.::/1/762<8.46 $! !*& $"+6;285>6D96<363 ($$ (" 52<5<;/::672<0 *&&& ".33.:546<21263 (&&&& "116<;5<18-570636D175 <./723-46<15<;;261:..; (&&&& - 6 - )".33.:657<2<0;/72<01-6>52;/9 9672.; %&&& *"'/1/7646;285>6D96<363 &&&& .15> ) %$7 !!"<1-6763/>11-6:.>>.=2<0.7;672395336; 2 9965>235>>.=6;2<9571" 22 -6 5996>>5<18>5245<1 23 6<121>6; :.7 1-6 1.15> 8.496<3512.<.: 3" ) %$=21-2<16763151)96786<1967 5<</4:7.41-6;516.:961212.<12>>1-6;516.:765>2G512.<" 222 -6 7639.<;6<12<3/75<86 8.495<B -53 5>765;B ;69.3216; 1-6 5=57;6; 54./<1 A6:.76 1-6 72A/<5> 5<; 1-676:.761-6B576;276816;1.;69.3211-66<-5<86;54./<1.: 3"! %&=21-2<16763151)E9675<</4=21-2<.<64.<1- :7.41-6;516.:8.9B.:1-23.7;67" 2C < 3/8- ;69.321 1-6 8>5245<1 23 96742116; 1. =21-;75=1-66<127654./<15>.<0=21-1-62<1676315887/6;.< 21" 267 ('""!) &! 231."!>."*!