- 1 - !"! #$"% $% & '&()* +&)) , ! " # $% ! & ''$$$ ( # )$ $ ##$ ##)$ $$ $! & ' ## # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ) * ) # ) ( # " ( "! # ( ' ') "!*"! ) #)) )#)) # " % ) # ) ) # ' ) ( # " ( +"! ! "!"" # # , ' # # ( # # # # ( # ) # ( # " ( # # )) # # % # # -' ( # # -' ( # #./01 02'/20/3$455/6./07.18947:.6;90<=. >.<2<297.0/71 02 =/=/?41127'/@/1/06./07.1#2A=940< 9B.07@.7<6./1.0;90<=.0.:>971.7< </<. " =.0.B2:297>.<2<297.0:/0./884:.1 9:"/71 C=9=/B.:4;;.0.1/7901.09;897B28<29727 9"! /71 :.7<.78.1 /: 471.0 C=28= =/: ?..7 897;20@.1 27 02@27/6>>./6 9+"! - 3 - ! " # $% &' ( !% &' ! ) " *# !% &'( !% &' " *+ " , - * . / /:.9;<=.>09:.84<29727<=.74<:=.662:<=/<97 !"! /< /?94< !!! >@ C=.7 <=. 27340.1 /<2:= /697AC2<==2:>/0.7<:/;<.0;272:=27A<=.1277.0C.0.:2<<27A 27 ;097< 9; <=.20 =94:. <=. /884:.1 9 :</0<.1 4027/<27A 7./0 =2: =94:. =. :/@. C/: 9?3.8<.1 <9 ?D <=. % E /<2:= /71 /< <=/< 3478<40. <=. /884:.1 9 >285.1 4> F4/00.6 /71 27 <=. F4/00.6 /884:.1 9:" /71 /6:9 3927.1 /71 /::/46<.1 /<2:= %=.7 /<2:= C/: ?.27A :94A=< <9 ?. 0.:84.1 ?D =2: @9<=.0 E /7A/6/?/2 <=. /884:.1 >.0:97: /6:9/::/46<.1=.0 - 4 - =.F4/00.6C/:>/82;2.1?D<=.7.2A=?940:/7127 <=/<0.A/01/89@>6/27<8/@.<9?.691A.1 ;<.0 0.A2:<.027A <=. 8/:. >9628. 897148<.1 1.</26.1 27B.:<2A/<297 /71 ;26.1 8=/0A.:=..< /A/27:< <=. 0.B2:297>.<2<297.0:/71<=./884:.1 9 + ;<.0 14. <02/6 <=. <02/6 '41A. 897B28<.1 <=. /884:.1>.0:97:/71:.7<.78.1/:0.;.00.1<9:4>0/ * =. /884:.1 9 >/21 / :4@ 9; :"!!! ;27. /@947</:901.0.1?D<=.<02/6/A2:<0/<.?4</884:.1 9:" /71 ;26.1 />>./6 ?.;90. <=. 12:<028< 940< 8=/66.7A27A <=. 901.0 9; 897B28<297 /71 :.7<.78. 27 02@27/6 >>./6 9+"! ./07.1'41A.27<=.;20:</>>.66/<.940<970. />>0.82/<297 9; <=. @/<.02/6 .B21.78. 97 0.8901 12:@2::.1 <=. />>./6 /71 897;20@.1 <=. 901.0 9; :.7<.78. .27A ;40<=.0 /AA02.B.1 ?D <=. :/@. /884:.1 9:" /71 /0. ?.;90.<=2:940<27<=2:0.B2:297 - 5 - 02 '/D/0/3 455/ 6./07.1 8947:.6 ;90 <=. 0.B2:297 >.<2<297.0: 0.2<.0/<27A <=. A09471: 40A.1 27 <=. 0.B2:297>.<2<297897<.71.1<=/</<02B2/627821.7<=/:?..7 ?69C794<?D<=. >09:.84<297/710.B2:297>.<2<297.0:?.27A <=.;20:<<2@.9;;.71.0:<02/6'41A./71<=.6./07.1'41A.27 <=.;20:</>>.66/<.940<94A=<<9=/B.A0/7<.1<=.?.7.;2<9; >09?/<297 ;90 <=. 0.B2:297 >.<2<297.0: C=28= =/: 79< ?..7 197. 0.:46<27A 27 @2:8/002/A. 9; 34:<28. /71 :94A=< ;90 /669C27A<=.0.B2:297>.<2<297 ! .0 897<0/ 02 =/=/?41127 '/@/1/0 6./07.1 #2A= 940< 9B.07@.7< 6./1.0 :4>>90<: <=. 2@>4A7.1 '41A@.7<: #/B27A=./01<=./0A4@.7<:;09@?9<=:21.:<=2: 940<>.04:.1<=.@/<.02/6970.8901@.<284694:6D " 7:48=>.04:/69;<=.@/<.02/6970.8901>6/827A <=. 90/6 <.:<2@97D 894>6.1 C2<= <=. C9471 8.0<2;28/<.: 9; %(/:/7<= /71 %/7A/6/?/2 <=. 6./07.1 <02/6 '41A.C/:34:<2;2.1270.890127A/7901.09;897B28<297;90<=. /;90.:/21:.7<.78.: - 6 - =. ;20:< />>.66/<. 940< 97 0./>>0.82/<297 897;20@.1<=.901.09;897B28<297 =2:940<27<=.0.B2:297/63402:128<29719.:79< ;271/7D89@>.6627A0./:97:90>/<.7<;/8<4/6.009090.0090 9;3402:128<297<927<.0;.0.C2<=<=.901.09;897B28<29790. :9C=.7/884:.1 9=/:/88.><.1<=.897B28<297/71=/: >/21 <=. ;27. /@947< /71 121 79< 8=99:. <9 8=/66.7A. <=. 901.09;897B28<297.7.:2:9;<=.802@.2:97/88947<9;<=. /884:.1 9 4027/<27A 27 ;097< 9; <=. =94:. 9; <=. 89@>6/27/7< =.0.;90. <=. 901.0 9; 897B28<297 7..1: 79 27<.0;.0.78. + #/B27A:/21<=4:2<2:<9?.79<.1<=/<<=.096.9; <=.940<C=26.>/::27A/7901.09;897B28<2972:/66<9A.<=.0 12;;.0.7<;09@<=.096.9;<=.940<C=26.>/::27A/>>09>02/<. :.7<.78.27/A2B.78/:. * 7 <=. 8/:. 97 =/71 :278. /66 <=. /884:.1 >.0:97: /0. ;20:< <2@. 9;;.71.0: /71 <=. 6./07.1 <02/6 - 7 - /A2:<0/<.</527A79<.9;<=.2712B214/69B.0</8<:2@>9:.1 976D;27.9;:"!!!;90<=./884:.1 9/71901.0.1;90 :.7<.78. 9; 2@>02:97@.7< ;90 0.B2:297 >.<2<297.0: ;90 <=. >.0291 9; :2G @97<=: ;90 <=. 9;;.78. 471.0 .8<297 " 9; <=2:940<2:9;<=.897:21.0.19>27297<=/<<=.84:<91D >.0291 /60./1D 471.0A97. ?D <=. 0.B2:297 >.<2<297.0: 2: <0./<.1 /: >.0291 9; 2@>02:97@.7< ;90 <=. >09B.1 9;;.78.: /71 ?D 120.8<27A <=.@ <9 >/D .7=/78.1 ;27. 9; :"!!! ./8=.71:9;34:<28.C9461?.@.< 8890127A6D;9669C27A901.0 2 =.0.B2:297>.<2<2972:/669C.127>/0<H 22 %=26.@/27</2727A<=.897B28<2979;<=. 0.B2:297 >.<2<297.0: ;90 <=. 9;;.78.: >472:=/?6. 471.0 .8<297: " ! 0./1 C2<= .8<297 9; <=. 84:<91D >.0291 /60./1D 471.0A97. ?D <=.@ 2: <0./<.1 /: >.0291 9; 2@>02:97@.7< ?D .7=/7827A ;27. /@947< 27 / :4@ 9; :"!!! ./8= - 8 - 222 4< 9; <=. ;27. /@947< 0.89B.0.1 / :4@9;:"!!!!./8=2:901.0.1<9?.>/21/: 89@>.7:/<297 <9 % E /<2:= /71 % /7A/6/?/2471.014.21.7<2;28/<297 2B 2@.2:A0/7<.1<9>/D<=.;27./@947< <266"!!"!"H B )/2640. <9 >/D <=. .7=/78.1 ;27. /@947< C9461 0.:46< 27 /4<9@/<28 0.:<90/<297 9; <=.:.7<.78.9;2@>02:97@.7<901.0.1?D<=.<02/6 /A2:<0/<.897;20@.1?D<=.;20:</>>.66/<.940< B2 ;;28. 2: 120.8<.1 <9 0.<407 <=. <02/6 940<0.8901:C2<=89>D9;<=2:901.0;902::4/78. 9;@912;2.1897B28<297C/00/7< -* &%) " (# 2:< 9 6 9* $