- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( !"#" $ % & " ' (! "# ( ) !"#" ( ( "*% & ###*+ $ %' (, ##+(#(( "& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' "+%"& ' ' ##((#(# ' - "*# (#" ' ' . # /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 ( 4=9 0>>/0? =9 ;=?/2 050=893 34/ @6257/83 082 0A012 203/2 ##((#(# >099/2 <B 34/ 22=3=:80? =931=C3082/99=:89625/082/7</1:3:1CC=2/839 ?0=791=<680?-=@0B0>61=8:"*#:;(#" 4/ ;0C39 :; 34/ C09/ 01/ 3403 :8 ##D(#" A4=?/34/C?0=7083A09>1:C//2=85:87:3:1CBC?/</01=85 1/5=93103=:8 : (! *!* :8 03=:80? =54A0B :("! 931/3C4=85 </3A//8 =@0B0>610 E 050?F:3 34/ 21=G/1:;34/7=8=5::29C011=/121:G/=3=84=549>//2082 10940828/5?=5/837088/1082?:93C:831:?:G/134/907/ - 3 - 082 34/1/<B C069/2 34/ 0CC=2/83 09 0 1/96?3 :; A4=C4 C?0=708396930=8/251=/G:69=8@61=/9 D 4/ =8@61/2 C?0=7083 05/2 # B/019 ;=?/2 0 C?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? C?0=7=85 C:7>/8903=:8 :; 9" #### 4/ 1=<680? C:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ /G=2/8C/ :8 1/C:12 51083/2 C:7>/8903=:8 :; 9(! + A=34 =83/1/93 03 *H >0 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=903=:8 082 2=1/C3/2 1/9>:82/83 :( 896108C/:7>08B3:2/>:9=334/907/ 551=/G/2 <B 34/ 90=2 @6257/83 082 0A012 :; 34/ 1=<680? 34/ =8@61/2 C?0=7083 409 >1/;/11/2 34=9 0>>/0?=8A4=C4=3=9C:83/82/2340334/07:6830A012/2 <B34/1=<680?=9:834/?:A/19=2//A09027=33/2=8 34/4:9>=30?;:1"(20B90828:07:683A0951083/2682/1 34/4/02>0=808296;;/1=85/96930=8/2;10C361/:;?/;3 4=> 082 F8// 01341=3=C C4085/ A=34 ?/;3 ;/761 C0??/?6/2 ;:1703=:8 =8 940;3 A=34 =83/1 ?:CF=85 80=? 082 :34/1 =8@61=/9/A0905/2(B/019082/018=859"#### >/1 7:834 <B 2:=85 C::?=/ A:1F <63 34/ 1=<680? 409 - 4 - 30F/84=9=8C:7/039+ ## >/17:8344/2:C3:1409 099/99/234/2=90<=?=3B03(#H3:#H1/?03=853:34/?/;3 ?:A/1?=7<4/07:6830A012/2682/134/4/02?:99:; 07/8=3=/9 =9 3: </ /8408C/2 3: 9 #### 4/1/;:1/ 1/I6/93/2;:1/8408C/7/83:;C:7>/8903=:8 4/ 0>>/??083 7/3 A=34 08 0CC=2/83 :8 ##D(#" 08296930=8/234/;:??:A=85(=8@61=/9 + //J07=8/234/:C3:109(A4:099/99/2 34/2=90<=?=3B 03 ( H 3: #H 63 34/ 1=<680? 409 8:3 C:89=2/1/234/2=90<=?=3B:834/51:682340334/0>>/??083 409 8:3 /J07=8/2 34/ :C3:1 A4: 31/03/2 4=7 ( =9 34//8=:1 134:>0/2=C615/:8/9303/209;:??:A9 ! ! " # # $ # $ ! - 5 - ! "% & '! ! ! $ ! (% &)% & * $ ! + , $! ! 4/1/;:1/ C:89=2/1=85 34/ 0<:G/ ;0C39 082 703/1=0?9 082 0?9: C:89=2/1=85 4=9 05/ 082 :CC6>03=:8 34=9 :613;=829=31/09:80<?/3:30F/;68C3=:80?2=90<=?=3B03" 12:; #H=/"#H>>/??083A0905/2#B/01909:834/203/:; 0CC=2/834/8C/34/0>>1:>1=03/76?3=>?=/10>>?=C0<?/3:4=905/ 51:6>=9."+.>>/??083C?0=7/234034/A:1F=8509::?=/082 /018=85 9"#### 63 4/ ;0=?/2 3: >1:G/ 34/ 907/ 9 4/ 7/3 A=34 08 0CC=2/83 :8 ##D(#" 4=9 8:3=:80? =8C:7/ =9 C:89=2/1/2099!### >/17:83409>/134/4013=996/2<B 34/ 018030F0303//50?/1G=C/9634:1=3B46934/?:99:; ;6361//018=85C0>0C=3BC:7/93:9!### J"(J"+J"#K 9"(## - 6 - * 4/ C:7>/8903=:8 0A012/2 <B 34/ 1=<680? 3:A0129 7/2=C0? /J>/89/9 03 9"(" + =9 09 >/1 34/ 7/2=C0? <=??9 A4=C4 =9 @693 082 >1:>/1 082 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8C/<B34=9:613 "# :89=2/1=85 34/ 80361/ :; =8@61=/9 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 0A012 9#### ;:1 >0=8 082 96;;/1=8509050=8939* ### 0A012/2<B34/1=<680? "" 27=33/2?B 34/ 0>>/??083 A09 4:9>=30?=L/2 "( 20B94/1/;:1/34=9:613;=829=31/09:80<?/3:/8408C/ 34/C:7>/8903=:83:9#### ;:1?:99:;07/8=3=/9082 9D#### ;:131089>:1303=:88:61=947/83082033/82083 C4015/9'6134/14/7=5438:340G/033/82/24=9A:1F03 ?/093;:10>/1=:2:;D7:83490CC:12=85?B4/=9/83=3?/2 ;:19(### %9!### JD&;:1?:99:;=8C:7/261=85 ?0=26>>/1=:2 "( 4/ 0A012 :; C:7>/8903=:8 >099/2 <B 34/ 1=<680?=97:2=;=/209682/1 - 7 - ? : /029 A012<B34/ 1=<680? A012<B34=9 :613 " 8@61B >0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9* ### 9#### ( /2=C0? J>/89/9 9"(" + 9"(" + :99 :; ;6361/ /018=85C0>0C=3B 9"(## D 1089>:1303=:8 /J310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 C4015/9 9(#### 9D#### :99 :; 07/8=3=/9 9(#### 9#### :99 :; =8C:7/ 261=85 ?0=2 6> >/1=:2 9#### 9(### :30? 9(! + 9DD! + 4/1/A=??<//8408C/7/83:;9"#(## " CC:12=85?B 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 /8408C/2 C:7>/8903=:8:;9"#(## A=34=83/1/9303H>/108867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=L03=:8 8 34/ 1/96?3 34/ ;:??:A=85:12/1=9>099/2 %=&>>/0?=90??:A/2=8>013 - 8 - %==& 4/ 0>>/??083 C?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 /8408C/2 C:7>/8903=:8 :; 9"#(## A=34 =83/1/9303H>/108867;1:734/203/:;>/3=3=:8 3=??=391/0?=L03=:8 %===& /9>:82/83 :( 896108C/ :7>08B =9 2=1/C3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ 0;:1/90=2 C:7>/8903=:8 07:6830?:85A=34=83/1/93A=34=8:8/7:834;1:7 34/203/:;34=9@6257/83 %=G& 8 96C4 2/>:9=3 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 >/17=33/23:A=34210A34//83=1/07:6830?:85A=34 =83/1/930CC16/2:8=3 )*+ %$ ' # =93:"?:*+