Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58329 (KAR)
THE MANAGER, CHOLAMANDALAM MS GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., v. SHARANU @ SHARANAPPA AND ANR
MFA/201803/2022 · 2025-10-27
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58329 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58329 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#!$!%!! !!%%
&'( )* !!%%
&'(
)
*
!"
"
## !$ % & # '
$ ( ) *
)
!+!$*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
) #
,*+-, )
!+!$* % & #
$. *'
) $-,&$'
# $,$**$
#
*+-)*$+
"
# /
)
*
( ) *
0
)
/
% & '
$
) #
0 ,*)+-, ) /
!+!*$$
- 3 -
*
!+!$* % &
$. #
*'
)$-,&$' '
#
# $,$**$
#
*+-)*$+
# /
#
1
1 " #
$
$ 23 45678493 9:;<84= 285 <73>3773? :*$+,)*** 8@8A45B B23 #6?@;34B 84? 8C87? ?8B3? $,$**$<8553?A4 :*+-)*$+D=B2334A:7 AEAF #6?@3 84? 2ABB8<67 &>:7 52:7B GB23 B7AD648FH' C237385 B23 9F8A;84B 285 <73>3773? :*$,*+)*** 533IA4@3428493;34B:>B239:;<3458BA:4
- 4 -
* 23 9F8A;84B ;3B CAB2 8 7:8? B78>>A9 899A?34B :4 -$*$! 23 9F8A;84B C85 5B6?34B 84? ?:A4@ ;AFI E34?A4@ D65A4355 84?23 C858@3?* =3875 8BB23 BA;3 :> B23899A?34B
63B:B23A4J67A35565B8A43?A4B237:8?B78>>A9 899A?34B 23 C85 8?;ABB3? A4 B23 2:5<AB8F 84? B8I34 B738B;34B 23 9F8A;84B >AF3? 9F8A; <3BABA:4 533IA4@ 9:;<3458BA:4 :> 5*) 8F:4@ CAB2 A4B3735B 8B B23 78B3 :> K <37 8446; 23 B7AD648F 8>B37 9:45A?37A4@ B23 34BA73 3EA?3493 :4 739:7? 8C87?3? B23 9:;<3458BA:4 :> 5) 8F:4@ CAB2 A4B3735B 8B B23 78B3 :> K <37 8446; >7:; B23 ?8B3 :> <3BABA:4 BAFFB23 ?8B3 :> 738FAL8BA:4 23 735<:4?34B :*45678493 9:;<84= C85 ?A739B3? B:
?3<:5ABB238C87?8;:64B8F:4@CAB2A4B3735BCAB2A48<37A:? :> B2733 ;:4B25 3A4@ 8@@7A3E3? D= B23 58A? :7?37 B23 45678493 9:;<84= 85 C3FF 85 B23 9F8A;84B 28E3 <73>3773? B23<73534B8<<38F5
, 38743? 9:6453F >:7 B23 45678493 9:;<84= 56D;AB5B28BA45<AB3:>537EA93:>4:BA93B23:C437?A?4:B <7:?693 B23 ?7AEA4@ FA93493 D6B B23 B7AD648F 377:43:65F= 52A>B3?D67?34:4B23456737)A456784939:;<84=A493B23
- 5 -
?7AE372854:?7AEA4@FA93493B23456784939:;<84=A54:B FA8DF3 B: <8= B23 9:;<3458BA:4 23493 73M635B3? B: 3N:4378B3 B23 45678493 9:;<84= >7:; <8=A4@ B23 9:;<3458BA:4 67B237 23 8F5: 9:4B34?3? B28B B23 A49:;3 :>B239F8A;84BC85B8I3485 5)<37;:4B2CAB2:6B 84= D85A5 84? B23 ?A58DAFAB= 8B $!K B: B23 C2:F3 D:?= N-A5B23?A58DAFAB=937BA>A98B323
:9B:7C2:3N8;A43? 84?8553553?B23?A58DAFAB=A58@34378F<2=5A9A84D6B4:B8 67@3:4 3493 B23 ?A58DAFAB= 8553553? D= 2A; 9844:B D3 9:45A?373? 84? B265 73M635B5 B: 73?693 B23 9:;<3458BA:4 239F8A;84B285565B8A43?BC:5A;<F3A4J67A3585<37N! 4 B23 C:64? 937BA>A98B3 AB A5 5<39A>A98FF= 5B8B3? B28B B23 A4J67A35>7:;F:$B:,8735A;<F3A448B6733285D334 B738B3?A4 B23 2:5<AB8F >7:; -$*$! B: $$$*$! A3 >:78<37A:?:>>AE3?8=5 :45A?37A4@B2348B673:4A4J67A35 84? B23 <37A:? :> 2:5<AB8FAL8BA:4 B2A5 :67B >A4?5 AB 7385:48DF3 B: @784B 8 56; :> 5) B:C87?5 A4J67A35 5,$) B:C87?5 ;3?A98F 3N<34535 5!) B:C87?5 <8A4 84? 56>>37A4@5 84? F:55 :> 8;34ABA35 84? 5!) B:C87?5 B7845<:7B8BA:4 3NB78 4:67A52;34B 84?
8BB34?84B
- 6 -
9287@35A49323;3BCAB2899A?34BA4B23=387*$!5<37 B23 8748B8I8 3@8F 37EA935 6B2:7AB= B23 A49:;3 >:7 B23 =387 *$! 285 B: D3 B8I34 8B 5+) 23 9F8A;84B A5 34BABF3? >:7 F:55 :> A49:;3 ?67A4@ F8A? 6< <37A:? >:7 :43 ;:4B2A3 5+)3493B23B:B8F9:;<3458BA:49:;35 B: 5!!)
4 5<AB3 :> 537EA93 :> 4:BA93 B23 :C437 84? B23 ?7AE37 :> B23 E32A9F3 28E3 4:B 8<<3873? 23 :C437 :> B23 E32A9F32854:B<7:?693?B23?7AEA4@FA93493:>B23?7AE37:> B23 :>>34?A4@ E32A9F3 5 B2373 A5 4: ?7AEA4@ FA93493 AB 8;:64B5 B: EA:F8BA:4 :> B37;5 84? 9:4?ABA:45 :> B23 <:FA9= 84? B265 B23 45678493 9:;<84= A5 8B FAD37B= B: <8= 84? 739:E37 B23 9:;<3458BA:4 >7:; B23 :C437 :> B23 E32A9F3 A4 EA3C:>B239AB8BA:473<:7B3?A4
73<:7B3? A4
! "
! BB2A55B8B3B239F8A;84BA5A4B34?A4@B:<7:?693 B23 ?7AEA4@ FA93493 D3>:73 B2A5 :67B 23 899A?34B A5 :> B23 =387*$!239F8A;<3BABA:45>AF3?A4B23=387*$+84?873
- 7 -
?A5<:53? :> A4 B23 =387 **$ 23 <73534B 8<<38F5 873 <73>3773? A4 B23=387 *** 23 9F8A;84B ;A@2B 28E3 B8I34 A4B3735BB:<7:?693B23?7AEA4@FA93493387FA37D6B>8AF3?B:?: 5:34938BB2A55B8@3M635BA:4:>9:45A?37A4@B23?7AEA4@ FA93493 :7 73;84?A4@ B23 ;8BB37 B: B23 B7AD648F ?:35 4:B 87A53
239:;<3458BA:48C87?3?D=B23B7AD648FA4
:*+-)*$+ A4 8 56; :> 5) A5 73?693? B: 5!!)8F:4@CAB2A4B3735B8BB2378B3:>K<378446; >7:;B23?8B3:><3BABA:4BAFFB23?8B3:>738FAL8BA:4
- 38743? 9:6453F >:7 B23 45678493 9:;<84= 56D;AB5 B28B B23 9:;<3458BA:4 8;:64B 8C87?3? D= B23 B7AD648F285D334?3<:5AB3? + 99:7?A4@F=B23>:FF:CA4@1
&A' 23 8<<38F >AF3? D= B23 45678493 9:;<84= A3 :*$+,)*** A5 8FF:C3? A4 <87B. - 8 -
&AA' 23 8<<38F >AF3? D= B23 9F8A;84B A4 :*$,*+)***A5?A5;A553?. &AAA' 23 9:;<3458BA:4 8;:64B 8C87?3? D= B23B7AD648FA4856;:> 5)A573?693?B: 5!!)8F:4@CAB2A4B3735B8BB2378B3:>K<37 8446; >7:; B23 ?8B3 :> <3BABA:4 BAFF B23 ?8B3 :> 738FAL8BA:4. &AE' 23 9F8A;84B A5 34BABF3? B: 5!!) 8F:4@ CAB2 A4B3735B 8B B23 78B3 :> K A4B3735B >7:;
B23?8B3:><3BABA:4BAFFB23?8B3:>738FAL8BA:4. &E' 23 3N9355 8;:64B ?3<:5AB3? D= B23 45678493 9:;<84= 528FF D3 73>64?3? 8F:4@ CAB2 A4B3735B. &EA' 4 EA3C :> <8= 84? 739:E37= B23 45678493 9:;<84= A5 8B FAD37B= B: 739:E37 B23 9:;<3458BA:48;:64B>7:;B23:C437:>B23E32A9F3 D=B23<7:9355:>F8C
+,) &%!! ( $
A5B:1$F:1