Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58327 (KAR)

GURUBASAYYA S/O CHANNAVEERAYYA KALLIMATH v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.RP/200069/2022 · 2025-09-22

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "!#!! !$ %& %'()*&+%(( , ! " ! # $ ! !! % ! "& !# ! $ '() *% $!! & %%+%++ ! & % +%+ & $ $ '%+%+ ! & $ +% $ $$ ! +('(%"# $! ( $ ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $ $ , -& "! -&# ./ )/012134 5/616134/) 7/148 9::;2/< 14 3 +% 34 6./ =1>/ 3= 6./ >/9)4/< &$ 3;)6 14892;8;)"./)/149=6/))/=/))/<6392?6./)19>3;)6@#12 1A5;84148 6./ B;<8A/46 3= :3401:6134 94< 3)</) 3= 2/46/4:/<96/<'%+%+:3401:61486./9::;2/<=3)6./ 3==/4:/25;412.97>/;4</)/:61342+('(%3=6./ 4<194!/49> 3</ C% "=3) 2.3)6 ?!@# 94< ( 3= 6./ 4<194 363) /.1:>/ :6 "=3) 2.3)6 ? :6@# 94< 2/46/4:148 63 ;4</)83 21A5>/ 1A5)1234A/46 =3) 34/A346.94<6359D9=14/3=2%%% =3)6./3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 +(' 3= !E 63 ;4</)83 21A5>/ 1A5)1234A/46=3)34/A346.94<6359D9=14/3=2%% =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 ( 3= !E 63 ;4</)8321A5>/1A5)1234A/46=3)34/D/9)94<6359D9 =14/3=2%%% =3)6./3==/4:/5;412.97>/;4</)/:6134 - 3 - %3=!E*16.</=9;>62/46/4:/2*.1:.*92:34=1)A/< 14 )1A149> 55/9> 3% +%+ 7D 6./ >/9)4/< <<> 126)1:694</221342&;<8/91:.;)"./)/149=6/))/=/))/< 6392?6./$1)2655/>>96/3;)6@#7D<12A1221486./955/9> 01</B;<8A/46<96/<%%+%++ + ./ =9:62 3= 6./ :92/ 14 7)1/= 9)/ 6.96 34/ 3= 6./14B;)/</D/*164/227/1486./)/>9610/3=6./</:/92/< >3<8/< 6./ =1)26 14=3)A96134 92 5/) F! 9891426 6./ 9::;2/< *16. ;661 53>1:/ 2696134 126 91:.;) 9>>/8148 :3AA122134 3= 6./ 3==/4:/2 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:61342 +(' ( % 3= ! 94< ( 3= :6 =6/) 140/2618961346./=149>)/53)6:9A/637/=1>/< ./ 9::;2/< 955/9)/< 7/=3)/ 6./ )19> 3;)6 5>/9</< 436 8;1>6D 3 5)30/ 162 :346/46134 6./ 5)32/:;6134/F9A14/<!,263C94<836A9)G/<F2! 63 !+( ./ 9::;2/< .92 </41/< 9>> 6./ 14:)1A1496148 A96/)19>29091>97>/34)/:3)<7;6.92436:.32/463>/9< 94D/01</4:/142;553)63=.12</=/4:/ - 4 - ./ )19> 3;)6 9=6/) 69G148 1463 :3421</)96134 9>> 6./ A96/)19>2 34 )/:3)< :9A/ 63 6./ :34:>;2134 6.96 6./ 5)32/:;6134 12 2;::/22=;> 14 5)30148 6./ 8;1>6 3= 6./ 9::;2/< =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:61342 +(' ( % 3= ! 94< ;4</) /:6134 ( 3= :6 9::3)<148>D 6./ 1A5;84/< B;<8A/46 3= :3401:6134 94< 3)</) 3= 2/46/4:/ :9A/ 63 7/ 5922/< :3401:6148 94< 2/46/4:1486./9::;2/<922696/<9730/ /148988)1/0/<7D6./29A/6./9::;2/<.92 5)/=/))/<)1A149>55/9> 3% +%+./$1)2655/>>96/ 3;)6 34 )/955)/:196134 3= 6./ A96/)19>2 34 )/:3)< <12A122/< 6./ 955/9> 94< :34=1)A/< 6./ B;<8A/46 3= :3401:613494<3)</)3=2/46/4:/5922/<7D6./)19>3;)6 /148 988)1/0/< 7D 6./ 29A/ 6./ 9::;2/< 12 7/=3)/ 6.12 3;)6 C /9)< )1 .104949< !961> >/9)4/< :3;42/> =3) 6./ )/012134 5/616134/) 94< )1 &9A9<9) .9.97;<<14 >/9)4/< 18. 3;)6 30/)4A/46 !>/9</) =3) 6./ )/2534</46696/!/);2/<6./A96/)19>234)/:3)< - 5 - ( 4 01/* 3= 6./ )109> :346/461342 ;)8/< 7D 6./ >/9)4/<:3;42/>=3)736.6./59)61/26./531466.96*3;>< 9)12/=3)AD:3421</)9613412 D 942*/) 63 6./ 9730/ 53146 12 =3)6./=3>>3*148 0/4 6.3;8. 2/0/)9> 8)3;4<2 9)/ )912/< 14 6./ )/012134 5/616134 >/9)4/< :3;42/> =3) 6./ 5/616134/) )/26)1:6/<.129)8;A/46234>D632//G>/41/4:D14=903;)3= 6./5/616134/)*.1>/2/46/4:148=3)6./3==/4:/5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 % 3= ! /9)4/< :3;42/> =3) 6./ 5/616134/) 25/:1=1:9>>D 2696/< 6.96 6./ 5/616134/).92 810/4 9>> 36./) :346/461342 )912/< 14 6./ )/012134 5/616134 94< 5)9D/<=3))/<;:1486./2;72694610/2/46/4:/1A532/<=3) - 6 - 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 % 3= ! 14 6./ 146/)/263=B;261:/ ' ./ 291< 2;7A122134 *92 35532/< 7D 6./ >/9)4/< 18. 3;)6 30/)4A/46 !>/9</) :346/4<148 6.96 92 9 )/2;>6 3= 6./ )39< 6)9==1: 9::1</46 6*3 </96.2 .90/ 3::;))/< 94< 92 A94D 92 + 14A96/2 .90/ 2;26914/< 14B;)1/2 4</) 2;:. :1):;A2694:/2 6./ 5/616134/) 12 436 /4616>/<=3) 94D >/41/4:D ::3)<148>D 5)9D2=3) <12A1229> 3=6./5/616134 % 6126./:346/461343=6./5)32/:;61346.966./ 5/616134/)9::;2/< *92 6./ <)10/) 3= 6./ 6/A53 7/9)148 )/8126)96134 3+C ++<)30/6./29A/149)92.94< 4/8>18/46 A944/) 14 9 .18. 25//< 23 92 63 /4<948/) .;A94 >1=/ 34 %C+% 96 % 9A 34 14892;8;) 91:.;)A914)39<929)/2;>63=*.1:.*./46./6/A53 :9A/4/9).1GG9./29);)01>>98/166355>/<346./>/=621</ 3= 6./ )39< 92 9 )/2;>6 3= *.1:. .9)949559 94< 92.9 *.3 */)/ 14A96/2 3= 6./ 6/A53 2;26914/< =969> 14B;)1/2 - 7 - 94<<1/<94<+14A96/2.90/2;26914/<14B;)1/2=6/)6./ 14:1</46 6./ 9::;2/< )94 9*9D =)3A 6./ 2536 *16.3;6 14=3)A148 6.12 =9:6 63 6./ 53>1:/ 3) 5)301</< 94D A/<1:9> 92212694:/ 63 6./ 14B;)/< .;2 ./ .92 :3AA166/< 6./ 9=3)/291<3==/4:/2 3 5)30/ 162 :346/46134 6./ 5)32/:;6134 /F9A14/<!,2637/1486./14B;)/</D/*164/22/2 *.3 9)/ 3::;59462 3= 6./ 3==/4<148 6/A53 >> 6./2/ *164/22/2.90/</532/<)/89)<1486./)92.94<4/8>18/46 <)101483=6./0/.1:>/7D6./9::;2/<*.1:.)/2;>6/<14162 6355>148 :9;2148 </96. 3= 6*3 14A96/2 94< 14B;)1/2 63 92 A94D92+*164/22/20/46.3;8.6./2/*164/22/2*/)/ /F9A14/<96 >/486. 436.148.92 7//4/>1:16/< =)3A6./A 63<127/>1/0/6./1)0/)2134./9::;2/<.92</41/<9>>6./ 14:)1A1496148 A96/)19>2 9091>97>/ 34 )/:3)< 7;6 .92 436 69G/494D25/:1=1:</=/4:/4</)2;:.:1):;A2694:/26./ )19> 3;)6 .92 )18.6>D :3401:6/< 6./ 9::;2/< =3) 6./ 9=3)/291<3==/4:/2 4)/955)/:1961346./$1)2655/>>96/ 3;)6<12A122/<6./:)1A149>955/9>./)/=3)/<3436 - 8 - =14<94D1>>/89>16D146./1A5;84/<B;<8A/463=:3401:6134 5922/<7D6./)19>3;)6*.1:.12:34=1)A/<7D6./$1)26 55/>>96/3;)6 + 6124361:/<6.966./)19>3;)6.925)3://</< 63 :3401:6 6./ 9::;2/< 736. =3) 6./ 3==/4:/2 5;412.97>/ ;4</)/:61342+('94<%3=!6122/66>/<53216134 3=>9*6.966./3==/4:/;4</)/:6134+('3=!7/1486./ A143) 3==/4:/ A/)8/2 *16. 6./ A9B3) 3==/4:/ ;4</) /:6134%3=!1401/*3=6./</:121343=6./34@7>/ 5/F 3;)6 14 /4:/ 9A 3= 6./ 3514134 6.96 *.1>/ :34=1)A148 6./ B;<8A/46 3= :3401:6134 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 +(' 3= ! 1A532148 3= 2/46/4:/ =3) 6./ 29A/12>197>/637/2/6921</ 4 6./ A/9461A/ :3421</)148 6./ 2;7A122134 A9</ 7D 6./ >/9)4/< :3;42/> =3) 6./ 5/616134/) 23A/ >/41/4:D A9D 7/ 2.3*4 14 =903;) 3= 6./ 5/616134/) *.1>/ 1 "+%+#( - 9 - 2/46/4:148 6./ 5/616134/)9::;2/< =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ ;4</) /:6134%3=!69G1481463:3421</)961346./=9:66.96 6./14:1</46.9<3::;))/<34%C+%94<6./9::;2/< *9298/<D/9)2966./61A/3=9::1</46 ./ )19> 3;)6 2/46/4:/< 6./ 9::;2/< 63 ;4</)83 21A5>/ 1A5)1234A/46 =3) 9 5/)13< 3= 34/ A346. 94< 63 59D =14/ 3= 2%% =3) /9:. 3= 6./ 3==/4:/2 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:61342 ( 3= ! 94< ( 3= :6<3436=14<94D)/923463146/)=/)/*16.6./29A/ 401/*3=6./9730/942*/)6./9730/53146 94< 5)3://< 63 5922 6./ =3>>3*148 1# )1A149>)/0121345/61613412!" 11# ./ B;<8A/46 3= :3401:6134 5922/< 14 3 +% 34 6./ =1>/ 3= >/9)4/< &$ 3;)6 14892;8;) =3) 6./ 3==/4:/2 5;412.97>/ - 10 - ;4</)/:61342+('(%3=!94<( 3= :6 *.1:. *92 :34=1)A/< 14 )1A149> 55/9> 3% +%+ 34 6./ =1>/ 3= >/9)4/< <<161349> 126)1:6 94< /221342 &;<8/ 91:.;)12./)/7D# " 111# ./3)</)3=2/46/4:/5922/<7D6./)19>3;)6 3=6./3==/4:/5;412.97>/;4</)/:61342(3= !94<(3=:612./)/7D# " 10# 3*/0/) 6./ 3)</) 3= 2/46/4:/ 5922/< 7D 6./ )19> 3;)6 =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134+('3=!12 " 0# $14/ 9A3;46 1= 94D </53216/< =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/;4</)/:6134+('3=!123)</)/< 637/)/=;4</<636./)/0121345/616134/)34<;/ 1</461=1:96134 01# ./3)</)3=2/46/4:/5922/<7D6./)19>3;)6 =3)6./3==/4:/5;412.97>/;4</)/:6134% 3=!12./)/7DA3<1=1/<92;4</)E - 11 - "9# ./ )/012134 5/616134/) 9::;2/< 12 2/46/4:/< 63 ;4</)83 )183)3;2 1A5)1234A/46 =3) 6.)// A346.2 94< 63 59D 9 =14/ 3= 2%%%% =3) 6./ 3==/4:/ 5;412.97>/ ;4</) /:6134 % 3= ! 4 </=9;>6 63 59D =14/ ./ 2.9>> ;4</)83 21A5>/ 1A5)1234A/46 =3) 6*3 A346.2 011# ./ )/012134 5/616134/)9::;2/< 12 /4616>/< =3) 6./7/4/=163=2/63==925)301</<;4</)/:6134 +3=)! 0111# ./ 2;72694610/ 2/46/4:/2 2.9>> );4 :34:;))/46>D /8126)D 12 <1)/:6/< 63 2/4< 79:G 6./ )19> 3;)6 )/:3)<2 9>348 *16. 6./ :35D 3= 6.12 B;<8A/46 =3) 14=3)A9613494<4//<=;>9:6134 -) %!!( # 126 3> 3+ !