- 1 - ! " # $ %& %'()*+%(( , ! " ! # # $% " ! # &' # ( %%% ( %% # ( $% ( (# ) # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # * +( +( ! ,-.//01-234 5$%546,-738-576,- 8-.94-2 2236354.8 -4359 3:38 (02;- .42 (# .8.<09.;3 =759 1,596 >93.8 5096?@ 31 3AB0;434; 6,- C02;A-462.6-2%'%%%/54:3/634;6,-.//01-27596,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& ' $ .42 % 57 423.4 -4.8 52- =759 1,596 >?@ .42 042-9 -/6354 $' 57 5659 -,3/8-1 /6 =759 1,596 > /6?@ D,3/, D.1 /54739A-2 34 98 5%% 54 6,- 738- 57 6,- 8-.94-2 2236354.8 31693/6 .42 -113541 (02;- .8.<09.;3=7591,596>#3916BB-88.6-5096?@,5D-:-96,- C02;A-46 57 /54:3/6354 .42 592-9 57 1-46-4/- B.11-2 <E 6,- 93.8 5096 759 6,- 577-4/-B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 $57D.11-6.132-<E6,-#3916BB-88.6-5096 - 3 - #./61 57 6,- /.1- 34 <93-7 .9- 6,.6 * 6,- 34C09-2 -E-D364-11 738-2 6,- 73916 34759A.6354 D36, .A.8.B09583/-6.6354.;.3416.//01-27596,-577-4/-1 B0431,.<8-042-9-/63541'&'$.42%57 .42042-9-/6354$'57/66D.16,-/546-46354 576,-B951-/063546,.66,-.//01-2<-34;6,-293:-9576,- <01 <-.934; 9-;3169.6354 5#$ 295:- 6,- 1.A- 54 E2-9.<.2 65 .8.<09.;3 95.2 34 9.1, .42 4-;83;-46 A.44-9 15 .1 65 -42.4;-9 6,- ,0A.4 837- .42 2.1,-26,-1.A-656,-B-2-1693.41D,5D-9-B95/--234; <E 6,- 132- 57 6,- 95.2 .1 9-1086 57 D,3/, 7509 B-91541 ,.:- 23-2 .42 1-:-9.8 34C09-2 :-4 .76-9 /.0134; 6,- .//32-46 .//01-2 9.4 .D.E 795A 6,- 1B56 D36,506 34759A34; 6,31 7./6 65 6,- 583/- 59 B95:32-2 .4E A-23/.8 .11316.4/- ,-9-<E ,- ,.1 /5AA366-2 6,- 577-4/- .1 16.6-2.<5:- 4 6,- <.131 57 6,- # 34:-163;.6354 D.1 042-96.F-4 .42 734.8 9-B596 /.A- 65 <- 738-2 .;.3416 6,- .//01-2 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& - 4 - ' $ .42 % 57 .42 -/6354 $' 57 /6 //01-2 .BB-.9-2 <-759- 6,- 93.8 5096 B8-.2-2 456 ;0386E ,- B951-/06354 -G.A34-2 *1 65 .42 ;56 A.9F-2 G1 65 $ 34 10BB596 57 361 /546-46354 ,- .//01-22-43-2.886,-34/93A34.634;A.6-93.81.:.38.<8-54 9-/59234,3116.6-A-46042-9-/6354579<06 ,.14568-2.4E-:32-4/-3410BB59657,312-7-4/- ,- 93.8 5096 .76-9 6.F34; 3465 /54132-9.6354 .886,-1-A.6-93.81549-/592/.A-656,-/54/8013546,.6 6,- B951-/06354 31 10//-11708 34 B95:34; ;0386 57 6,- .//01-2 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& '$.42%57.42042-9-/6354$'57 /6 //59234;8E /54:3/6-2 6,- .//01-2 .42 1-46-4/-2 ,3A:32-C02;A-462.6-2%'%%% -34;.;;93-:-2<E6,-1.A-6,-.//01-2,.2 B9-7-99-298 5%%,-#3916BB-88.6-509654 9-.BB9-/3.6354 57 6,- A.6-93.81 54 9-/592 /54739A-2 6,- C02;A-46 57 /54:3/6354 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& ' .42 % 57 .42 -/6354 $' 57 - 5 - /6 ,5D-:-9 1-6 .132- 6,- C02;A-46 57 /54:3/6354 .42 592-9 57 1-46-4/- 759 6,- 577-4/- B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/6354 $ 57 -34; .;;93-:-2 <E 6,- 3AB0;4-2 C02;A-46 57 /54:3/6354 .42 592-9 57 1-46-4/- B.11-2 <E 6,-93.850966,-.//01-231<-759-6,315096 H -.9293.:3429.8-.94-2/5041-87596,- 9-:31354B-636354-9.4293 5B.8F931,4..2.:8-.94-2 3;, 5096 5:-94A-46 8-.2-9 759 6,- 9-1B542-46 6.6--901-26,-A.6-93.81549-/592 ' 4 :3-D 57 6,- 93:.8 /546-463541 09;-2 <E 6,- 8-.94-2/5041-81759<56,6,-B.963-16,-B53466,.6D5082 .931-759AE/54132-9.635431 E .41D-9 65 6,- .<5:- B5346 31 7596,-75885D34; - 6 - $ ,- 1B-/373/ /546-46354 6.F-4 <E 6,- B951-/06354 31 6,.6 6,- .//01-2 31 6,- 293:-9 57 6,- 577-4234;<01 01<-.934;9-;3169.6354 5 #$ ,31 7./6 31 456 34 231B06- ,- B951-/06354 ;56A.9F-2G&D,3/,31456231B06-2<E6,-.//01-2 & 6 31 6,- 1B-/373/ /546-46354 57 6,- B951-/06354 6,.66,-<01293:-4<E6,-.//01-2/.01-26,-95.269.773/ .//32-4634D,3/,7509B-2-1693.41,.:-23-2.421-:-9.8 56,-91D-9-34C09-2,317./631.81545634231B06-,- B951-/06354 ;56 A.9F-2 G1 65 ' 6,- 34I0-16 A.,.J.91B516A596-A9-B5961.1B-9G1$65.42 *5042 -96373/.6-1 .1 B-9 G 65 .42 ,- B951-/06354,.1.815B8./-29-83.4/-546,--B596 .1 B-9 G .//59234; 65 D,3/, 6,-9- D.1 45 A-/,.43/.82-7-/6D,3/,9-1086-23495.269.773/.//32-46 ,-9-759- 36 31 6,- /546-46354 57 6,- B951-/06354 6,.6 36 D.16,-.//01-2D,5D.1293:34;6,-<0134I0-1635434. - 7 - 9.1,.424-;83;-46A.44-9D,3/,9-1086-23495.269.773/ .//32-46 6.F34; 837- 57 6,- 7509 B-2-1693.41 .42 /.0134; 34C093-1651-:-9.856,-9B-91541 % * 852;-2 6,- 73916 34759A.6354.1 B-9 G *1 H ' $ .42 & .9- 6,- -E-D364-11-1 *1.9-6,-34C09-2-E-D364-11-1631B-9634-46 65456-6,.6.886,-1--E-D364-11-1.9-6,-90163/:388.;-91 .42 6,-E ,.:- ;3:-4 6,-39 -:32-4/- 34 6,-39 5D4 D.E 16.634; 6,.6 54 6,- 2.6- 57 6,- .//32-46 .6 % .A -.98E A59434; 6,-E D-9- B95/--234; <E 6,- 132- 57 6,- 95.2 ,- <01 /.A- 795A 6,- <./F 132- D36,506 <85D34; ,594 .42 9.4 5:-9 6,- B-2-1693.41 4 6,.6 9-;.92 * K 34759A.46 ,.1 738-2 6,- /5AB8.346 .1 B-9 G 0934; /9511-G.A34.6354 -:-4 6,50;, 36 D.1 10;;-16-2 65 6,- D364-11 6,.6 1,- ,.1 456 1--4 6,- .//01-2 .1 6,- 293:-9 57 6,- 577-4234; :-,3/8- D364-11 16.6-1 6,.6 ,- D.1 6,- 293:-9 .42 45D ,- 31 <-759- 6,- 5096 *364-11 .815 16.6-1 6,.6 .6 6,- 63A- 57 6,- 34/32-46.<506%B-9154134.;950BD-9-B95/--234;<E - 8 - 6,-132-576,-95.2:-46,50;,6,-1.32D364-11D.1 /9511-G.A34-2.6 8-4;6, 456,34;,.1 <--4-83/36-2 795A ,-965231<-83-:-,-9:-91354 ,- 56,-9 34C09-2 -E-D364-11-1 .42 6,- -E-D364-11-1.8152-B51-3413A38.9834-116.634;6,.634. ;950B 6,-E D-9- B95/--234; <E 6,- 132- 57 6,- 95.2 .6 %.A,-.//01-2<-34;6,-293:-9576,-01 D36,506<85D34;6,-,594/.A-795A<./F132-.429.45:-9 6,-A D,3/, 9-1086-2 34 6,- 2-.6, 57 7509 B-91541 .42 /.0134;34C093-1651-:-9.856,-91 631B-9634-4665456-6,.6-:-46,50;,6,-1- D364-11-1D-9-/9511-G.A34-2<E6,-8-.94-2/5041-8759 6,- .//01-2 .6 8-4;6, 45 1B-/373/ 2-7-4/- D.1 6.F-4 <E 6,- .//01-2 10;;-1634; 6,- 9-.154 759 6,- 95.2 69.773/ .//32-46 6 31 B-9634-46 65 456- 6,.6 454- 57 6,- 25/0A-461B9520/-2<E6,-B951-/0635431231B06-2<E6,- .//01-2,-16.6-A-46576,-.//01-2042-9-/6354 57 9 D.1 9-/592-2 <E 6,- 93.8 5096 D,-9- 6,- .//01-2 ,.1 456 577-9-2 .4E -GB8.4.6354 -G/-B6 2-4E34; - 9 - 6,-34/93A34.634;A.6-93.81.:.38.<8-549-/592#95A6,- A.6-93.81549-/5923631/8-.96,.66,-.//01-2D.16,- 293:-9576,-577-4234;01.42,-/.01-26,-95.2 69.773/ .//32-46 9-108634; 34 7509 2-.6,1 .42 73:- 34C09-2 D,5 D-9- B95/--234; 34 ;950B <E 6,- 132- 57 6,- 95.2 ,- .//01-2 ,.1 456 -GB8.34-2 .1 65 ,5D .42 D,E 6,- .//32-46,.25//099-2 -.94-2 /5041-8 759 6,- B-636354-9 /546-42-2 6,.6454-576,--E-D364-11-1,.:-1B5F-4.<5066,-9.1, .424-;83;-46293:34;576,-<01<E6,-.//01-225456 7342.4E10BB5967596,-/546-463546.F-4<E6,-B-636354-9 .1 6,- D364-11-1 ,.:- 16.6-2 6,.6 6,- .//01-2 <-34; 6,- 293:-9576,-<01/.A-795A<./F132-D36,506<85D34;6,- ,594.429.45:-96,-;950B576,-B-91541361-871B-.F1 .<506 6,- 9.1,4-11 .42 4-;83;-4/- 54 6,- B.96 57 6,- .//01-2 34 293:34; 6,- <01 ,- B934/3B8-1 57 ! ".B68E.BB83-1656,-7./61576,-/.1-,-.//01-2 ,.14566.F-46,-9-1B5413<3836E57-GB8.3434;.165,5D6,- - 10 - .//32-46,.25//099-237.6.88,-D.1456-36,-99.1,59 4-;83;-4634293:34;6,-<01 -.94-2 /5041-8 759 6,- B-636354-9 B8./-1 9-83.4/-546,-2-/3135457B-G509634 65 /546-42 6,.6 6,- B934/3B8-1 57 ! " 31 456 .BB83/.<8- 65 6,- 7./61 57 6,- B9-1-46 /.1- 4 6,- 1.32 /.1- 6,- 7./61 .9- -4639-8E 2377-9-46.16,-.//01-2D.16,-293:-9576,-<01293:34; 6,-1.A-54.B0<83/95.2,-9-D.12--B236/,54-36,-9 132- 57 6,- 95.2 A56,-9 .//5AB.43-2 ,-9 E504; 2.0;,6-9.;-2E-.91D-9-B95/--234;546,-95.2,- A56,-9 ,.2 .89-.2E /9511-2 6,- 95.2 .42 1,- 341690/6-2 ,-92.0;,6-9.;-2E-.9165;5<./F656,-,501-631 6,- -:32-4/- 54 9-/592 6,.6 6,- E504; ;398 D.1 .89-.2E ,.87 D.E 6,950;, 759 /951134; 6,- 95.2 .42 1,- D.1 34 . 238-AA. D,-6,-9 65 /9511 6,- 95.2 59 65 ;5 <./F .1 341690/6-2<E,-9A56,-9,-B-G5096/54132-9-26,- B934/3B8-1 57 ! " .42 ,-82 6,.6 6D5 7582 1 &'&$$ - 11 - 9-I039-A-461.9-9-I039-265<-1.63173-2759.BB83/.635457 6,-A.G3A:3J6,-7391654-316,.66,-A016456548E 1B-.F .<506 6,- 4-;83;-4/- <06 36 1,5082 B34 36 54 6,- .//01-2 46,-/.1-<-759-6,-54?<8-B-G50966,- .//01-2,.1;3:-4,31-GB8.4.635434,3116.6-A-46042-9 -/6354 57 9 .1 65 ,5D 6,- 34/32-46 ,.2 5//099-2 - 16.6-2 6,.6 ,- D.1 293:34; 6,- :-,3/8- 185D8E.426,-/,382/.A-546,-95.2795A6,-8-76132- .8857.1022-465/951136L65.:5326,-/58801354D36,6,- /,382,-3AA-23.6-8E6094-26,-:-,3/8-65D.92193;,6132- 576,-95.2<06,-7.38-2651.:-6,-/,382,-2-7-4/- B8-. 6.F-4 <E 6,- .//01-2 34 6,- 1.32 /.1- D.1 6,.6 ,- /5082456.:5326,-.//32-46341B36-57<-34;:-9E/.9-708 ,-B-G5096,.16.F-43465/54132-9.63546,--:32-4/- 8-2<E6,-B951-/06354346,-83;,6576,-2-7-4/-6.F-4<E 6,-.//01-2.42/.A-656,-/54/8013546,.66,-A56,-9 D.1 34131634;6,-/,382 45665 75885D ,-9 <06659-6094 65 ,5A- ,-9-759- 6,- /,382 D,3/, /.A- 54 6,- 95.2 D36, - 12 - .4 346-46354 65 /9511 6,- 95.2 165BB-2 34 <-6D--4 759 . A5A-46 .42 B95<.<8E D-46 .,-.265 /9511 6,- 95.2 4 6,-A-.463A-6,-.//01-26,-9-34<-34;6,-293:-9576,- 577-4234;<0134592-965.:5326,-/,382655F6,-<0154 6,-56,-9132-576,-95.2<06,-/5082456.:532,36634; 6,- /,382 ,- B-G 5096 ,.1 .815 6.F-4 3465 /54132-9.6354 6,- 7./6 6,.6 6,-9- D.1 . ;9-.6-9 931F 57 ,.9A34; 6,- B.11-4;-91 34 6,- <01 .1 6,-9- D-9- 2--B 236/,-1 54 -36,-9 132- 57 6,- 95.2 54132-934; .88 6,-1- 7./61 .42 /39/0A16.4/-1 6,- B-G 5096 ,-82 6,.6 6,- B934/3B8-57! "/.4456<-A.2-.BB83/.<8-65 6,-7./61576,-1.32/.1- H 06 34 6,- B9-1-46 /.1- 45 10/, 2-7-4/- D.1 6.F-4 <E 6,- .//01-2 -GB8.3434; .1 65 ,5D .42 D,E 6,- .//32-46 ,.2 5//099-2 6 31 456 ,31 /546-46354 6,.6 ,- ,.2 6.F-4 /.9- 65 .:532 6,- .//32-46 42-9 10/, /39/0A16.4/-1.A576,-5B343546,.66,-B951-/0635431 10//-11708 34 B95:34; 6,- ;0386 57 6,- .//01-2 759 6,- - 13 - 577-4/-1B0431,.<8-042-9-/63541'&'$% ! 57.42$'575659-,3/8-1/6 ' *,-46,-.//01-23175042;0386E7596,-577-4/- B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& .42 % 57 6,- 577-4/-042-9-/6354'&57<-34;6,-A3459577-4/- A-9;-1D36,6,-A.C59577-4/-042-9-/6354%57 34 :3-D 57 6,- 2-/31354 57 6,- 54?<8- B-G 5096 34 ! 4 :3-D 57 6,- 1.A- .A 57 6,- 5B34354 6,.66,-B-636354-93145683.<8-7591-46-4/-7596,-577-4/- B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/6354 '& 57 1-B.9.6-8E 0/, 592-9571-46-4/-3183.<8-65<-1-6.132- $ ,- 93.8 5096 /54:3/6-2 .42 1-46-4/-2 6,- .//01-2 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& '$%57.42042-9-/6354$'57/6 ,- #3916 BB-88.6- 5096 54 9-.BB9-/3.6354 57 6,- A.6-93.81549-/592/54739A-26,-C02;A-4657/54:3/6354 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/63541 '& ' .42 2 (2012) 8 SCC 734 - 14 - %57.42-/6354$'57/6,5D-:-9361-6 .132-6,-C02;A-4657/54:3/6354.42592-9571-46-4/-759 6,-577-4/-B0431,.<8-042-9-/6354$57-4/- 25 456 7342 .4E 9-.154 65 346-97-9- D36, 6,- 1.A- //59234;8E .41D-9 6,- .<5:- B5346 " .42B95/--265B.116,-75885D34; (i) ,- 93A34.8 -:31354 -636354 31 # (ii) ,-C02;A-4657/54:3/6354B.11-234 5$%546,-738-576,-8-.94-2 228 3:38 (02;- .42 (# .8.<09.;3 D,3/, D.1 /54739A-2 34 93A34.8 BB-.8 5%% 54 6,- 738- 57 6,- 8-.94-2 2236354.8 31693/6 .42 -113541 (02;- .8.<09.;3 :32- C02;A-46 2.6-2 %%% 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9-/63541'&'%57.42 042-9 -/6354 $' 57 /6 31 ,-9-<E /54739A-2 (iii) ,-592-9571-46-4/-B.11-2<E6,-93.8 5096 759 6,- 577-4/-1 B0431,.<8- 042-9 - 15 - -/63541 ' % ! 57 .42 $' 57 /631.815$ (iv) ,-592-9571-46-4/-B.11-2<E6,-93.8 5096 759 6,- 577-4/- B0431,.<8- 042-9 -/6354'&5731,-9-<E (v) #34- .A5046 37 .4E 2-B5136-2 759 6,- .<5:- 1.32 577-4/- 31 592-9-2 65 <- 9-7042-2 65 6,- B-636354-9 54 20- 32-46373/.6354 -;3169E 31 239-/6-2 65 1-42 <./F 6,- 93.8 5096 9-/5921 .854; D36, /5BE576,31 592-9 759 34759A.6354 .42 4--2708./6354 -) % ( # 316 58 5