- 1 - !! " #$% ! & #$%% ""' ( !"!#$" % & ' $ $ (!)**# # + , (!"!#*$ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ (!)**# - . (!"!#*$ ! (!"!#*$ ) . (!"!## (!"!## % & - / $ ' - ##*!#*# #**!0*#*#/ 1 #$##*## #*## # - &+ ' ' 1 #-$##*## #*## #! &+ ''/ ! - 3 - 2 2 % $ & 2 ' 34 566477589 :5; 934 649<9<84= >4?=4 934 745=84@ <8A74B@A435@5;;5<74@934=@4=59884CB=4 <8934 6=D44@<8A; :34=4>E 3<; ;4=F<D4; :4=4 94=G<8594@ >E =@4= @594@ #$##*## 34 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 >E 5 @495<74@ =@4= 35@ >;4=F4@ 9359 934 649<9<84= :5; 566<894@ 8 94G6=5=E D89=5D9B57 >5;<; 58@ 934 ;5<@ 64=<@ 35@ DG4 9 58 48@ 58@ 5DD=@<8A7E 649<9<84= DB7@8935F4D357748A4@3<;94=G<859<834B=935@ 57;>;4=F4@9359<894=G;?75B;4 $?9345A=44G489 48A5A<8A 934 ;4=F<D4; ? 934 649<9<84= 934=4 :5; 5 6=F<;<8 ? @<;D35=A4 >E G5H<8A 65EG489 ? 84 G893 ;575=E<87<4B?89<D464=<@58@>E9=459<8A934=@4=? 94=G<859<8 5; 84 9359 :B7@ ?577 :<93<8 75B;4 $ 35@ B6347@ 934 =@4= ? 94=G<859<8 58@ 5DD=@<8A7E 649<9<8 D5G49>4@<;G<;;4@34;5<@=@4=<;B8@4=D357748A4<8 9346=4;4896=D44@<8A; - 4 - # 9 <; 934 D5;4 ? 934 649<9<84= 9359 34 :5; 566<894@ 5; 5 GGB8<9E 45793 ??<D4= <8 934 465=9G489 ? 45793 58@ 5G<7E 47?5=4 8 #-$$#*$ 58@ 9359 934 ;5<@ 48A5A4G489 :5; 8 D89=5D9B57 >5;<; B=934= <9 <; ;B>G<994@ 9359 @B=<8A 3<; ;4=F<D4 34 :5; 5>;489 8 *$*#*## :348 934 57BH 45793 ??<D4= F<;<94@ 934 =<G5=E 45793 489=4 ?= <8;64D9<8 58@ <8 7<A39?934;5G4;3:D5B;489<D4D5G49>4<;;B4@8 $-$*#*##9<;934D5;4?934649<9<84=9359934;3: D5B;4 89<D4 <;;B4@ :5; 9 934 4??4D9 9359 934 649<9<84= :5; 9 ;3: D5B;4 5; =4A5=@; 3<; 5>;48D4 :<93B9 6=<= 64=G<;;<88*$*#*##599349<G4?<8;64D9<8?934 57BH 45793 ??<D4= 58@ 934=4>E 35@ DGG<994@ 756;4 <8 5@34=<8A 9 3<; =4;68;<><7<9<4; ; =4A5=@; 934 ;3: D5B;489<D459884CB=4 @594@$-$*#*##<9<;;9594@ 9359 934 649<9<84= 35; G5@4 B9 3<; =467E @594@ $-$*#*##58@;B>G<994@8$!$*#*##<8:3<D3<9:5; 5;;4=94@935934:5;5>;489>49:448#-!6G58@* 6G5;3435@A84B9959948@859B=42;D577<87<A39? - 5 - 934=4;9=G<83<;:=H675D48935F<8A:594=?5D<7<9E58@ 5DD=@<8A7E3435@;BA39?=D8@8<8A3<;756;4 8 934 G458:3<74 <9 <; ;B>G<994@ 9359 =4DGG48@59<8:5;G5@4993457BH45793 ??<D4=>E 934 4@<D57 ??<D4=?934=<G5=E45793489=4@495<7<8A 3<; D8@BD9 ;B>;4IB489 9 *$*#*## 5; :477 58@ 5;;4=9<8A935934 :5;5>;4898*"$*#*##$*$*#*## 58@$$*#*##5H<8A894?;BD3=4DGG48@59<8934 57BH 45793 ??<D4= 35; ?B=934= ?=:5=@4@ 3<; =4DGG48@59<8 9 934 @<;D<67<85=E 5B93=<9E 9359 <; 934 <;9=<D945793 ??<D4=34 <;9=<D945793 ??<D4=5;64= 884CB=4 95H<8A894?934;3:D5B;489<D4<;;B4@ 58@ >;4=F<8A 9359 4F48 5?94= <;;B58D4 ? ;3: D5B;4 89<D4934649<9<84=35@DGG<994@756;4<864=?=G58D4 ?3<;@B9E35;=47<4F4@934649<9<84=34;5<@=@4=:5; B8@4=D357748A4>4?=4934745=84@<8A74B@A4 - ; >;4=F4@ 5>F4 934 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 89<D4@ 9359 934 4G67EG489 ? 934 649<9<84= :5; 8 D89=5D9B57>5;<;75B;4 $?9345A=44G4896=F<@4@?= - 6 - 94=G<859<8 :<93 * @5E; 89<D4 58@ 9359 ;<8D4 934 48A5A4G489 :5; 8 D89=5D9B57 >5;<; :3<D3 :B7@ 35F4 DG4 9 58 48@ 934 =@4= ? 94=G<859<8 :5; B6347@ >E 9=459<8A94=G<859<85;84>4<8AB8@4=75B;4 $58@934 :=<9649<9<8:5;=4J4D94@ ! 9<;934D5;4?934649<9<84=9359934=@4=? 94=G<859<859884CB=4 :5;;9<AG59<D58@@4;6<94934 649<9<84= >4<8A 5 D89=5D9B57 4G67E44 58@ =@4= ? 94=G<859<8 :3<D3 :5; ;9<AG59<D BA39 9 35F4 >448 6=4D4@4@ >E 59745;9 5 ;BGG5=E 48IB<=E 48;B=<8A 5@34=48D496=<8D<674;?859B=57JB;9<D4 ) 9 <; ?B=934= D8948@4@ 9359 934 ;3: D5B;4 89<D4=47594;93<;5>;48D48*$*#*##:34=45;934 =@4= ? 94=G<859<8 ;64D<?<D577E =4?4=; 565=9 ?=G 3<; 5>;48D4 8 *$*#*## 756;4 <8 64=?=G<8A @B9<4; ?= 5 ;B>;4IB48964=<@:3<D3:5;89934;B>J4D9G5994=?934 ;3:D5B;489<D49:5;57;D8948@4@9359;BD35;64D9 35; 89 >448 95H48 894 ? >E 934 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 58@ 9359 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 >E 9=459<8A 934 =@4= ? - 7 - 94=G<859<85;58=@4=?94=G<859<8<894=G;?75B;4 $35;<84??4D9A7;;4@F4=9345;64D99359934=@4=? 94=G<859<8:5;;9<AG59<D 45=84@ F4=8G489 @FD594 8 934 934= 358@ :B7@ D8948@ 9359 934 =@4= ? 934 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 @4; 89 =4IB<=4 <894=?4=48D4 5; 4G67EG489 :5; G4=47E8D89=5D9B57>5;<;58@93596:4=?94=G<859<8 :5;5F5<75>74B8@4=75B;4 $?9345A=44G489 " 45=@745=84@DB8;478>93;<@4; ) 9 <; 9 >4 89<D4@ 9359 934 ;3: D5B;4 89<D4 <;;B4@ :5; 87E 5; =4A5=@; 3<; 5>;48D4 8 *$*#*## :348 934 57BH 45793 ??<D4= 35@ DG4 ?= <8;64D9<8 34=467EG5@49;BD389<D459884CB=4 :B7@6<89 B993593435@A84B9>49:448#-!6G9*6G ?= 59948@<8A 859B=42; D577 <8 7<A39 ? 88 5F5<75><7<9E ? :594=?5D<7<9E<8934=4;9=GBD35;64D9BA39935F4 >44895H48894?>E9345B93=<9<4;:33:4F4=35F4 D89<8B4@96=D44@:<939346=D44@<8A; - 8 - $* 34 4@<D57 ??<D4= 59 =<G5=E 45793 465=9G489 35@ G5@4 B9 5 =46=9 9 934 57BH 45793 ??<D4= @594@ $$*#*## :34=4<8 565=9 ?=G =4?4==<8A 9 9345774A4@B85B93=<K4@5>;48D48*$*#*##934=4<; 5=4?4=48D49;B>;4IB489756;4<88959948@<8A??<D48 *"$*#*## $*$*#*## 58@ $$*#*## BD3 =4DGG48@59<8 :5; G5@4 58@ 4F489B577E ?=:5=@4@ 9 934 <;9=<D9 45793 ??<D4= 93=BA3 57BH 45793 ??<D4= 34 57BH 45793 ??<D4= <8 3<; D==4;68@48D4 :<93 934 <;9=<D9 45793 ??<D4= 35@ =4?4==4@ 9 ;B>;4IB489 756;4 5?94=*$*#*##34=@4=59884CB=4 >E934 <;9=<D9 45793 ??<D4= 89 87E =4?4=; 9 934 ;3: D5B;4 89<D4 <;;B4@ <9 35; 5 =4?4=48D4 9 ;B>;4IB489 756;4 5?94= <;;B58D4?;3: D5B;4 89<D4:3<7465;;<8A934=@4=? 94=G<859<8 34 =@4= 59 884CB=4 <; 5665=4897E ;9<AG59<D 5; <9 ;9594; 9359 34 35@ =464594@7E DGG<994@ 756;4<864=?=G<8A3<;@B9<4;8G58EDD5;<8;957; =4?4=;93<;D8@BD9;B>;4IB4897E?8935F<8AD==4D94@ 3<G;47? 34 ;5<@ =@4= 5; =<A397E D8948@4@ >E 934 DB8;47 ?= 934 649<9<84= <; ;9<AG59<D 58@ 4F48 5 - 9 - D89=5D9B57 4G67E44 <; 489<974@ ?= 5@34=48D4 9 6=<8D<674;?859B=57JB;9<D458@<89344F489934=@4=? 94=G<859<8 <; ;BA39 9 >4 65;;4@ F<;<9<8A ;9<AG5 47<58D48934JB@AG489?93464CB=9<8 <8<F<7664575=<;<8AB9?&' $*!-)#*$0 59 5=5A=563 $0 >E 934 649<9<84= <; 569 5=5A=563 $0 D745=7E ;9<6B7594; 9359 4F48 5 D89=5D9B57 4G67E44 <; =4IB<=4@ 9 >4 5??=@4@ 58 66=9B8<9E <8 D8;858D4 :<93 6=<8D<674; ? 859B=57 JB;9<D4 34 ;5<@ JB@AG489=4IB<=4;9>495H48894?58@<87<A39?3<; 94=G<859<8>4<8A;9<AG59<D<89345>;48D4?58E48IB<=E 934=@4=59884CB=4 =4IB<=4;9>4;495;<@48;BD3 A=B8@;:3<D35;64D9 35; 89>44895H48894? >E934 745=84@<8A74B@A4 $$ 8;?5=5;934745=84@<8A74B@A49=459<8A934 =@4= ? 94=G<859<8 59 884CB=4 5; 84 ?577<8A :<93<8 75B;4 $ <9 <; 9 >4 89<D4@ 9359 934 =@4= :3<D3 <; ;9<AG59<DDB7@8935F4>448D8;9=B4@=9=4594@>E934 - 10 - B=99>4845;;<G67<D<9=<894=G;?75B;4 $:3<D3 :B7@ >4 D89=5=E 9 934 F4=E D89489; ? 884CB=4 :3<D3<;<G64=G<;;<>74 $# DD=@<8A7E :4 ;49 5;<@4 934 =@4= ? 934 745=84@ <8A74 B@A4 5; 57; 934 =@4= 59 884CB=4 49<9<84=<;@<=4D94@9>495H48>5DH84G67EG4898 D89=5D9B57>5;<;9<;D75=<?<4@9359934649<9<84=:B7@ 89>447<A<>74?=58E?B=934=;4=F<D4>484?<9 $ 4 :B7@ 57; >;4=F4 9359 ;B>;4IB489 D89<8B58D4 5?94= 95H<8A 934 649<9<84= 8 @B9E :B7@ >4 84>49:448934649<9<84=58@3<;4G67E4= $- DD=@<8A7E934:=<9566457<; *+ ' ! &( % *+ '% ( % <;9$7