Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58302 (KAR)
THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. SHAMA BEGUM AND ORS
MFA/202205/2022 · 2025-10-13
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58302 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58302 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "# #$ !! %$& '( !! %$&
'
(
! "#
$%$ &
' (
)
*
+ ,
'
)
" ,
*
+ ,
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
+ ,
, + *
+ , %
$ # *
+ , $
"
$
*
#
-
*
$. * (
$%$""$
. *
#
/*/$"$
0
#
&
'
+
#
*/
-1 . )
- 3 -
# # .')
#
+ "%"""
%*"" + /! ! #
'
(
*
+ ,
'
)
" ,
*
+ ,
*
+ ,
, + *
+ , %
$ #
*
+ ,
"
$
*
#
-
*
- 4 -
$. * (
$%$""$ &
'
+
)
*
#
/*/$"$ *
*
0
"
"#
! $%$ &
' (
#
"1
)
# # .')
#
# +
"%"""
+ /! %*""
# #+
(
- 5 -
# #
+
2+
2+ +
# '
2+
)
# 3"""$*""" 45 64789 :; <=8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; ?>98@ 8B<43> .') 36 <=8 3<3@ 8=4B785 B< BA774>E 4> F?85<43> 6A5<8>4>E 36 %G 74A:474<; 3> <=8 ADD877A></4>5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; # 3"""-*""" 45 64789 :; <=8 98D8>98><5 36 98B8A589/3=ACC89 8HAI ?>98@ 8B<43> .') 36 <=8 3<3@ 8=4B785 B< :84>E AEE@48J89 :; <=8 H?9EC8>< A>9 AKA@9 9A<89 "%""" DA5589 :; <=8 8>43@ 4J47 +?9E8 L /!
=4<<AD?@ '63@ 5=3@< M<=8 @4:?>A7N) 4> 3%*"" 588O4>E 8>=A>B8C8><36B3CD8>5A<43>
" #AB<5 E4J4>E @458 <3 6474>E 36 <=858 ADD8A75 A@8 <=A< 3> -"% A< A:3?< % DC 98B8A589 3=ACC89 8HAIKA59@4J4>E<=873A989A>O8@:8A@4>E3 /"//
- 6 -
%$6@3CA94<3 4>9=A>33@4>C398@A<85D8893>786< 36 <=8 5A49 =4E=KA; >8A@ A74 ?@EACCA 8CD78 3>
4>9=A>33@/A4B=?@ CA4> @3A9 A< <=A< <4C8 A 5D8894>E 4DD8@3@@;:8A@4>E8E3///$"$9@4J8>:;4<5 9@4J8@ 4> A @A5= A>9 >8E74E8>< CA>>8@ BAC8 4> 3DD354<8 94@8B<43> A>9 4<5 9@4J8@ 735< B3><@37 3J8@ <=8 J8=4B78 A>9 9A5=89 AEA4>5< <=8 A>O8@ 36 98B8A589 ?8 <3 4CDAB< :3<= J8=4B785 :?@>89 A>9 98B8A589 3=ACC89 8HAI 5?5<A4>896A<A74>H?@485A>994893><=85D3<
<456?@<=8@BA58<=A<98B8A589/3=ACC89 8HAI KA5 8A@>4>E 5"$*/ D8@ C3><= A5 A 9@4J8@ ?8 <3 ?><4C87;98A<=3698B8A589B7A4CD8<4<43>BAC8<3:864789 :;=4598D8>98><5588O4>EB3CD8>5A<43>
?@5?A>< <3 >3<4B8 @85D3>98>< 3 / <=8 3K>8@ 36 4DD8@ 3@@; A>9 @85D3>98>< 3" 4>5?@A>B8 B3CDA>;
ADD8A@89 A>9 64789 58DA@A<8 K@4<<8> 5<A<8C8>< 98>;4>E 8><4@8 AJ8@C8><5 8PB8D< A9C4<<4>E 4>J37J8C8>< 36
- 7 -
3668>94>E 4DD8@ CA98 4> <=8 B7A4C D8<4<43>5 A>9 53?E=< 63@945C455A736<=8B7A4CD8<4<43>5
$ > <=8 :A545 36 <=8 D78A94>E5 36 <=8 DA@<485 <=8 7A4C5@4:?>A76@AC89<=8455?85>3@98@<3D@3J8<=8 BA58<=8K4683698B8A589458PAC4>89A5A>9E3< 8P=4:4<8993B?C8><5>AC87;P<3P.38J498>B8 KA5 78< 4> 3> :8=A76 36 <=8 @85D3>98><5 >3@ E3< CA@O89 A>; 93B?C8><5 =8 7A4C5 @4:?>A7 :; <=8 4CD?E>89 H?9EC8><=879<=A<<=8ABB498><<33OD7AB83> ABB3?>< 36 @A5= A>9 >8E74E8>< 9@4J4>E 36 <=8 3668>94>E 4DD8@ 3@@; :; 4<5 9@4J8@ A>9 9?8 <3 K=4B= 98B8A589 5?5<A4>89 E@48J3?5 4>H?@485 A>9 5?BB?C:89 <3 <=8 5A49 4>H?@485 3> <=8 5D3< =8 @4:?>A7 6?@<=8@ =879 <=A< <=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 <3 A <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5...*/A73>EK4<=4><8@85<A<<=8@A<836-GDA A>9 94@8B<89 <=8 4>5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; <3 DA; <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> 84>E 9455A<456489 K4<= <=8 F?A><?C 36 B3CD8>5A<43> <=8 B7A4CA><5 A>9 4>5?@A>B8 B3CDA>;
- 8 -
BA774>E4>F?85<43><=874A:474<;5A997893>4<A@8:863@8<=45 3?@<4><=858ADD8A75
-
@4 3=9 :9?7 (?A;?C 78A@>89 B3?>587 63@ <=8 ADD877A><*>5?@A>B8B3CDA>;4># 3"""$*"""=A5 @A4589<=863773K4>EB3><8><43>5
A #4@5<7; <=8 ABB498>< KA5 3BB?@@89 3> <=8 C49978 36 <=8@3A99?8<3@A5=A>9>8E74E8><9@4J4>E36<=89@4J8@36 <=8 A>O8@ :8A@4>E 8E45<@A<43> 3 /"//%$ =8 B7A4CA><5=AJ8>3<8PAC4>89A>;8;8K4<>855<3D@3J8<=A< <=8 9@4J8@ 36 4DD8@*3@@; 45 >8E74E8>< 4> BA?54>E <=8 ABB498>< >98@ <=858 B4@B?C5<A>B85 <=8 @4:?>A7 =A5 8@@894>6A5<8>4>E%G74A:474<;3><=89@4J8@36<=84DD8@ 3@@; 4> BA?54>E <=8 ABB498>< 8 6?@<=8@ B3><8>989 <=A< <=8374B8=AJ8@8E45<8@89#AEA4>5<<=89@4J8@536:3<= <=8 J8=4B785 A>9 9@4J8@ 36 :3<= <=8 J8=4B785 9489 =8@863@8 <=8 @4:?>A7 =A5 8@@89 4> 6A5<8>4>E %G B3><@4:?<3@;>8E74E8>B83><=89@4J8@36<=84DD8@
- 9 -
:
8B3>97; 4> @85D8B< 36 F?A><?C 36 B3CD8>5A<43> 78A@>89B3?>587B3><8>989<=A<8J8><=3?E=<=8B7A4CA><5 B7A4C89<=A<98B8A589KA58A@>4>E5"$*/DC6@3C <=8D@3685543>A5@4J8@:?<<=8;=AJ8>3<D@39?B89A>; 93B?C8><<385<A:745=<=8D@336364>B3C8A>9<=84>B3C8 A5585589 :; <=8 @4:?>A7 A< 5$*/ DC 45 3> <=8 =4E=8@5498
B A5<7; B3>5498@4>E <=8 AE8 A>9 AJ3BA<43> 36 98B8A589 <=8 3J8@A77 B3CD8>5A<43> AKA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7453><=873K8@54988>B8=8D@A;563@A773K4>E <=8ADD8A7
.
@4 A>H88J A<47 78A@>89 B3?>587 ADD8A@4>E63@<=8ADD877A><5*B7A4CA><5B3><8>989<=A<<=8 ABB498>< =A5 3BB?@@89 9?8 <3 >8E74E8>B8 36 9@4J8@ 36 <=8 4DD8@*3@@; :8A@4>E 8E3///$"$ =8 9@4J8@ 36<=84DD8@BAC83><=88P<@8C8@4E=<5498A>99A5=89 AEA4>5<<=8A>O8@:8A@4>E8E3 /"//%$9?8<3 K=4B= <=8 9@4J8@ 6877 93K> A>9 5?5<A4>89 4>H?@485 A>9 - 10 - 5?BB?C:89 <3 <=8 4>H?@485 #?@<=8@ B3><8>989 <=A< <=8 @4:?>A7 =A5 8@@89 4> 6A5<8>4>E "G 74A:474<; 3> <=8 98B8A5899@4J8@36<=8A>O8@A>95AC845B3><@A94B<3@;<3 <=8 CA<8@4A7 3> @8B3@9 >98@ <=858 B4@B?C5<A>B85 <=8 @4:?>A7 3?E=< <3 =AJ8 6A5<8>89 8><4@8 74A:474<; 3> <=8 9@4J8@36<=84DD8@ % > @85D8B< 36 8>=A>B8C8>< 36 B3CD8>5A<43> <=8 78A@>89B3?>587B3><8>95?>98@ A) =A< A< <=8 <4C8 36 ABB498>< 98B8A589 KA5 8A@>4>E 5"$*/ DC 6@3C <=8 D@3685543> A5 A @4J8@ 3K8J8@<=8@4:?>A7=A5A5585589<=8>3<43>A7C3><=7; 4>B3C83698B8A589A<5$*/K=4B=453><=873K8@ 5498 :) 8B3>97;A5D8@<=8H?9EC8><36<=83>N:78 ?D@8C8 3?@< 4> <=8 BA58 36 !"#<=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 63@ B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5*/ 8AB= - 11 - B) A5<7; B3>5498@4>E <=8 AE8 A>9 AJ3BA<43> 36 <=8 98B8A589 <=8 3J8@A77 B3CD8>5A<43> AKA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7453><=873K8@54988>B8=8D@A;563@A773K4>E <=8ADD8A7 08A@9<=878A@>89B3?>587ADD8A@4>E63@<=8DA@<485 A>9D8@?589<=8H?9EC8><A>9AKA@9 =8BA5836<=8B7A4CA><545<=A<3>-"%A< A:3?<%DC98B8A5893=ACC89 8HAIKA59@4J4>E <=8 73A989 <A>O8@ :8A@4>E @8E45<@A<43> 3 /"*/%$ 6@3CA94<3 4>9=>33@4>AC398@A<85D8893>786<5498 36 <=8 =4E=KA; =8> =8 @8AB=89 >8A@ A74 ?@EACCA 8CD78 3> 4>9=A>?@ A4B=?@ CA4> @3A9 A< <=8 <4C8 A 4DD8@ 3@@; :8A@4>E @8E45<@A<43> 3/*/$"$ 9@4J8>:;4<59@4J8@4>A@A5=A>9>8E74E8><CA>>8@BAC8 4>3DD354<894@8B<43>A>9735<B3><@373J8@<=8J8=4B78A>9 9A5=89AEA4>5<<=8A>O8@3698B8A5893=ACC89 8HAI ?8 <3 5A49 4CDAB< <=8 98B8A589 3=ACC89 8HAI 6877 93K>A>95?668@894>H?@485 - 12 - 3 D@3J8 <=8 BA58 B7A4CA>< 3/K468 36 <=8 98B8A589 =A5 :88> 8PAC4>89 A5 > =8@ 8J498>B8 5=8=A5BA<8E3@4BA77;5<A<89<=A<<=8ABB498><=A53BB?@@89 9?8 <3 <=8 >8E74E8>B8 36 9@4J8@ 36 <=8 4DD8@ 3@@; > B@355/8PAC4>A<43> 36 <=8 @85D3>98><5 =AJ8 >3< 874B4<89 A>; K3@<=K=478 4>63@CA<43> =8@85D3>98><3" =A5 8PAC4>89 <=8 3664B8@ 36 <=8 B3CDA>; 3>8 36 <=8 DA@<485 =AJ8 8PAC4>89 A>; 8;8K4<>85585 <3 <=A< 8P<8>< =8 D374B8 =AJ8 64789 <=8 # A>9 B=A@E8 5=88< AEA4>5< :3<=<=89@4J8@536<=8J8=4B785=85D3<5O8<B==A5:88> D@39?B89 A5 P 3>5498@4>E <=8 5D3< 5O8<B= # B=A@E8 5=88< A>9 8J498>B8 36 4< ADD8A@5 <=A< :3<= <=8 9@4J8@5 A@8 >8E74E8>< 4> BA?54>E <=8 ABB498>< =8 9@4J8@36<=8A>O8@BAC8K4<=A=4E=5D8894>@A5=A>9 >8E74E8>< CA>>8@ A>9 <=8@8 45 >3 8J498>B8 <3 D@3J8<=A< =8=A5CA98A>;A<<8CD<<3B3><@37<=85D88954>B84<45 5<@A4E=< @3A9 3>5498@4>E A77 <=858 6AB<5 A>9 B4@B?C5<A>B85<=8@4:?>A7=A5@4E=<7;=879<=A<<=89@4J8@ 36 <=8 3668>94>E 4DD8@ 3@@; KA5 9@4J4>E <=8 5AC8 4> A - 13 - @A5=A>9>8E74E8><CA>>8@A>9B3><@4:?<89<3<=88P<8>< 36 %G A>9 98B8A589 KA5 B3><@4:?<89 <3 <=8 8P<8>< 36 "G 8>B8 4> @85D8B< 36 >8E74E8>B8 45 B3>B8@>89 <=8 64>94>E36<=8@4:?>A745B3>64@C89 " > @85D8B< 36 <=8 F?A><?C <=3?E= <=8 B7A4CA><5 B7A4C <=A< 98B8A589 KA5 8A@>4>E 5"$*/ D8@ C3><= :?<<=8; =AJ8 >3< D@39?B89A>; 93B?C8><5 <3D@3J8 <=8 4>B3C8 36 <=8 98B8A589 > <=8 A:58>B8 36 D@336 36 4>B3C8 <=8 >3<43>A7 4>B3C8 =A5 <3 :8 A5585589 5 D8@ <=8 E?49874>85 455?89 :; <=8 A@>A<AOA <A<8 8EA7 8@J4B85 ?<=3@4<;63@<=8ABB498><<AO8>D7AB84><=8;8A@ "%<=8>3<43>A74>B3C836<=898B8A589=A5<3:8<AO8> A<5.$*/DC <<=8<4C836ABB498><<=898B8A589
KA5AE89;8A@53<=8A63@85A494>B3C8G=A5<3 :8A99893>ABB3?><366?<?@8D@35D8B<54>J48K36<=87AK 7A4993K>:;<=83>5<4<?<43>8>B=36<=8 ?D@8C83?@< 4> $%& '$( ')*+$',- %. /) 0+$'$1 -%2& '. %2-+) ! 33!"
4>B8 <=8@8 A@8 54P 98D8>98><54<45ADD@3D@4A<8<3989?B<*<=36<=84>B3C8
- 14 -
36<=898B8A589<3KA@95D8@53>A78PD8>585A>9@8CA4>4>E AC3?><=A5<3:8<AO8>A5=45B3><@4:?<43><3<=86AC47;
=8 C?7<4D748@ ADD74BA:78 <3 =45 AE8 E@3?D 45 M-N =?5 <=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 <3 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5"-%%*/ '5-$Q"Q-Q*) 3> ABB3?>< 36 M73553698D8>98>B;N > A994<43> <=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 <3 B3CD8>5A<43>365$*/3>ABB3?><36M73553685<A<8N A>9 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5$*/ 3> ABB3?>< 36 M6?>8@A7 8PD8>585N >J48K36<=87AK7A4993K>:;<=8 ?D@8C83?@<4> <=8BA58364$56$-'-+$(')*+$',-7'5?D@A)B7A4CA>< 3K46836<=898B8A589458><4<789<3B3CD8>5A<43>36 5*/ ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 36 M7355 36 5D3?5A7 B3>53@<4?CNB7A4CA><535"<3$:84>E<=8B=479@8>36<=8 98B8A589A@88><4<789<3B3CD8>5A<43>365*/8AB= ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 36 M7355 36 DA@8><A7 B3>53@<4?CN A>9 B7A4CA><3-K=345C3<=8@36<=898B8A589458><4<789<3
- 15 -
B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5*/ ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 36 27355 36 6474A7B3>53@<4?C2 $ =?5 <=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 <3 <=8 63773K4>E B3CD8>5A<43> )*+,-./0,1,2+3 20+3+,/+.2- )1,/0, %-& 3553698D8>98>B; '-$PRP"P-)
"-%%*/ #?>8@A78PD8>585 $*/ 3553685<A<8 $*/ 355365D3?5A7B3>53@<4?C */ 35536A@8><A7B3>53@<4?C -*/ 35536#474A7B3>53@<4?C */ /.4
55'
- ><=8@85?7<<=863773K4>E3@98@45DA5589
A) =8ADD8A75A@8.&)8 )-. :) =8 H?9EC8>< 36 <=8 7A4C5 @4:?>A7 45C3946489
- 16 -
B) =8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 8><4<789 <3 A <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 - 55' A5 AEA4>5< 5...*/AKA@989:;<=8@4:?>A7 9) =8>5?@A>B83CDA>;4594@8B<89<3 98D354< <=8 %G 36 <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AC3?>< A73>E K4<= 4><8@85<A< -GDA6@3C <=89A<836 6474>E 36 <=8 B7A4C D8<4<43> <477 <=8 9A<8 36 @8A74IA<43>K4<=4>AD8@4393654PK88O56@3C<=8 9A<836@8B84D<36B3D;36<=45H?9EC8><
2' %!& #
2' % #$ & #
*
45<3
73.