- 1 - !"# $"%"" " & '( ')*& ('** + ! " # # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ %& '()(%& ! $ # * # " # %) # ! "() # !" # &% # ## + ++!," +!"!-" (&+ &! " &. & % # %(+ # & # # # $ ! " +(&% # / $ ! / $" 0,1-02 345-607 841 9:0 ;09<9<4-016 :,6 8<702 4&(5-201039<4-&!)"10,2=<9:039<4-%)48 1 600><-? ;01@<66<4- 841 34@;45-2<-? 9:0 4880-306 - 3 - ;5-<6:,A70 5-201 039<4-6 + ++!," +!"!-" (&+ & .& & 10,2 =<9: 039<4- % 48 ,-2 039<-46%(+,-248 39,-294B5,6: 9:0 31<@<-,7 ;143002<-?6 10?<690102 <- 1<@0 4&% AC:,--51,47<309,9<4- <2,1-4=;0-2<-?A084109:0 70,1-02 22<9<4-,7 <691<39 ,-2 066<4-6 $52?0 <2,1 <- ;7,604+(&% -0@9@,4,159<,?,1,-2;09<9<4-01 4,335602 4 D 1< <?,@A,1 4 :,E1,4 ,?,1 :,E08<7029:0<1,88<2,E<9665;;419<-?9:0,;;7<3,9<4- 0,1-02 345-607 841 9:0 ;09<9<4-016 ,-2 106;4-20-9 4 65A@<96 <- 5-<64- 9:,9 ,335602 46 ,-2106;4-20-94,-29:0E<39<@:,E060997029:0<1 2<6;590,@<3,A7C3356024@,11<029:0E<39<@ =:4 <6 9:0 2,5?:901 48 106;4-20-9 4 9:0108410 ;1,C6 841 ,774=<-?9:0,;;7<3,9<4- % :0,88<2,E<96=41-94AC@9@,4,159< ,?,110,26,65-201 - 4 - !"#$ #! #%#&'(#)*"+,(,&$-.%,/-%$#00*(/.!#!,- #!+#.'-",( #/ !+, (,.1-",-! 23 45 *- !+, #&6, 7#.,8-9!+,0#7!.0!+,7#.,#77("*-)%$#/ .9,#(*-)!!+*.#00*"#6*!#77/1#-$*-)#11%*7#!*- 0(7/1'-"*-)000,-7,. : .!#!, !+#! !+, 7/1%#*-#-! 4 9+ *. /!+,( 0*%," !+, 7/1%#*-! "', ! "*.1'!, 0 (,%#!*-.+*1&,!9,,-!+,1,!*!*-,(.#-"'(0#/*%$ ! /#8, 1,!*!*-,(. ! 7/, ! '( !,(/. #-" 7-"*!*-. 3 .!#!, !+#! #-" ; 1,!*!*-,( +#6, 7/1(/*.," #-" .,!!%," !+, #&6, /#!!,( '! 0 !+, 7'(! #-" #%. 6*7!*/ /#((*," ! !+, < 1,!*!*-,( #! '&4,)*.!(#( +#%8* 6*", "#!," =>3:>:5&!+%,#6*-)+#11*%$#-"%,#"*-)0#/*%$ %*0, #. # +'.&#-" #-" 9*0, !+'. !+, 7/1%#*-#-! 6*7!*/"-!9*.+!7-!*-',9*!+!+, #&6,7#.,#.#)#*-.!!+,1,!*!*-,(.*-!+,#&6, 7#., ? .!#!, !+#! !+, 1,!*!*-,(. #-" 7/1%#*-#-! 6*7!*/ +#6, 7/1(/*.," #-" .,!!%," !+,#&6,7#.,'!07'(!#-"!+,$+#6,)!- - 5 - 7%#*/ #. #)#*-.! ,#7+ !+,( #-" #%. &!+ !+, 1#(!*,. .+#%% +#6, - (*)+! ! *-.!*!'!, #-$ 1(7,,"*-). 7#.,&,0(,!+,7'(!0%#9#.#)#*-.! ,#7+!+,( 5.!#!,!+#!"',!#/*7#&%,.,!!%,/,-!0,-!*(, "*.1'!, &,!9,,- !+, 0#/*%$ /,/&,(. #! !+, *-!,(6,-!*-0,%",(.#-"9,%%49*.+,(.0&!+!+, 0#/*%*,.&,*-)!+,7/1%#*-#-!.,,8.!9*!+"(#9 #%% !+, #%%,)#!*-. /#", *- 7/1%#*-! #)#*-.! !+, 1,!*!*-,(. &$ 1,(/*!!*-) ! 7/1'-"*-) !+, 00,-7, @ .!#!, !+#! *- !+, 7#., *-6%6*-) 00,-7,. *. (,A'*(," ! !#8, *-! !+, 7-.*",(#!*- !+, )(#6*!$ 0 00,-7,. #-" #%. -#!'(, 0 !+, 00,-7,. *0 !+, #%%,),"00,-7,.#(,1'(,%$1(*6#!,*--#!'(,#-"*0 *! *. &,!9,,- !+, 7%., 0#/*%$ /,/&,(. #-" *0 # .,!!%,/,-! *. #((*6," &,!9,,- !+, 1#(!*,. 9+ #(, !+,7%.,0#/*%$/,/&,(.-9*-!,-"!)*6,,-"! #%% "*.1'!, !+, 00,-7,. 7#- &, 7/1'-"," 9*!+ !+,1,(/*..*-0!+*.-B&%,'(! C *! *. /.! (,.1,7!0'%%$ 1(#$," !+#! !+*. -B&%, '(! &, 1%,#.," ! #%%9 !+, #77/1#-$*-) #11%*7#!*- #. 1(#$," 0( *- !+, *-!,(,.!0D'.!*7,E - 6 - ( :0 ,88<2,E<9 8<702 AC ,335602 4 10,26 ,6 5-201 :3 !"#$ #! #%#&'(#)* " +,(,&$-.%,/-%$#00*(/.!#!,-#!+#.'-",( #/!+,.!1,!*!*-,(*-!+,#&6,7#.,8-9 !+,0#7!.0!+,7#.,#77("*-)%$#/.9,#(*-)! !+*. #00*"#6*! #-" #%. &,+#%0 0 #-!+,( 1,!*!*-,( #77/1#-$*-) #11%*7#!*- 0( 7/1'-"*-) 0 00,-7,. : .!#!, !+#! !+, 7-!,-!. 0 /#*- 1,!*!*- &, (,#" 1#(! #-" 1#(7,% 0 !+, #00*"#6*! .,,8*-) ! 7/1'-"*-)000,-7,. 3 .!#!, !+#! *- !+, #&6, 7#., #-" !+, *7!*/ 45 +#6, 7/1(/*.," #-" .,!!%," !+, #&6, /#!!,( '! 0 !+, 7'(! #-" #%. 6*7!*/ /#((*,"!!+,1,!*!*-,(#!'&4,)*.!(#(+#%8* 6*", "#!," =>3:>:5 &!+ %,#6*-) +#11*%$ #-" %,#"*-)0#/*%$%*0,#.#+'.&#-"#-"9*0,!+'.!+, 7/1%#*-#-! 6*7!*/"-!9*.+!7-!*-',9*!+!+, #&6,7#.,#.#)#*-.!!+,1,!*!*-,(.*-!+,#&6, 7#., - 7 - 3 .!#!, !+#! !+, 1,!*!*-,( #-" 6*7!*/ 45 +#6,7/1(/*.,"#-".,!!%,"!+,#&6,7#.,'! 07'(!#-"!+,$+#6,)!-7%#*/#.#)#*-.!,#7+ !+,(#-"#%.&!+!+,1#(!*,..+#%%+#6,-(*)+! ! *-.!*!'!, #-$ 1(7,,"*-). 7#., &,0(, !+, '(! 0%#9#.#)#*-.!,#7+!+,( ?.!#!,!+#!"',!#/*7#&%,.,!!%,/,-!0,-!*(, "*.1'!, &,!9,,- !+, 0#/*%$ /,/&,(. #! !+, *-!,(6,-!*-0,%",(.#-"9,%%49*.+,(.0&!+!+, 0#/*%*,. &,*-) !+, 1,!*!*-,(. #)(,,*-) .,!!%, #%% !+,"*.1'!,#/*7#&%$&$1,(/*!!*-)!+,7/1%#*-#-! #-"/$.,%0!7/1'-"!+,00,-7,. 5 .!#!, !+#! *- !+, 7#., *-6%6*-) 00,-7,. *. (,A'*(," ! !#8, *-! !+, 7-.*",(#!*- !+, )(#6*!$ 0 00,-7,. #-" #%. -#!'(, 0 !+, 00,-7,. *0 !+, #%%,),"00,-7,.#(,1'(,%$1(*6#!,*--#!'(,#-"*0 *! *. &,!9,,- !+, 7%., 0#/*%$ /,/&,(. #-" *0 # .,!!%,/,-! *. #((*6," &,!9,,- !+, 1#(!*,. 9+ #(, !+,7%.,0#/*%$/,/&,(.-9*-!,-"!)*6,,-"! #%% "*.1'!, !+, 00,-7,. 7#- &, 7/1'-"," 9*!+ !+,1,(/*..*-0!+*.-B&%,'(! C *! *. /.! (,.1,7!0'%%$ 1(#$," !+#! !+*. -B&%, '(! &, 1%,#.," ! #%%9 !+, #77/1#-$*-) #11%*7#!*- #. 1(#$," 0( *- !+, *-!,(,.!0D'.!*7,E - 8 - + 09<9<4-014106;4-20-94,-29:0E<39<@ @9@,4,159<,?,1,10;1060-9A084109:04519 ,-29:0C,10<20-9<8<02AC9:0<1106;039<E0345-6076 0,1-02 345-607 841 9:0 ;09<9<4-016 :,6 ;1425302 34;C 48 9:0 019<8<3,90 48 0?<691,9<4- 48 <-25 ,11<,?033412<-?94=:<3:;09<9<4-014@,11<029:0 E<39<@ 4- +&&( ,-2 9:0 6,@0 :,6 A00- 10?<690102 4-)&&(09<9<4-014,-29:0E<39<@@9@, 4,159<,?,1,2@<934-90-96489:0,88<2,E<96 ) 06;4-20-9 4 ,-2 9:0 E<39<@ 65A@<9 -4 4AF039<4-94374609:031<@<-,7;143002<-?6 . ,9<68<02 =<9: 9:0 901@6 48 9:0 34@;14@<60 09<9<4-01 4 ,-2 106;4-20-9 4 ,10 ;01@<9902 94 34@;45-29:04880-30 & - E<0= 489:0,A4E0200@ <9,;;14;1<,9094 B5,6: 9:0 31<@<-,7 ;143002<-?6 <-<9<,902 ,?,<-69 9:0 ;09<9<4-0160-309:084774=<-? - 9 - !<" :031<@<-,7;09<9<4-<6,774=02 !<<" :0 31<@<-,7 ;143002<-?6 <-<9<,902 ,?,<-69 9:0 ;09<9<4-016 <- 1<@0 4&% 10?<690102AC 9:069 106;4-20-9;47<30 ,10 :010ACB5,6:02 ,& '""* % <69474(