Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58287 (KAR)
P NAGAMANI AND ORS v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/201522/2023 · 2025-11-04
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58287 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58287 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ %& $
%& "&#" $$
'#( )* $$
)
*
!"# $
! #
"
%
"&' ! (
%
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"' ! &
! %
" ! ( &
! "! ! %
"
) %
"'*
% +,
"
"
$
" ! #
! *&#
"
" !" )!"
(((
&&%((
)!"
)! ! )
*
"
%
"&' ! - 3 -
(
%
"' ! &
! %
" ! ) %
"'*
( &
!%" ! % +,
"
"
$
" ! #
$
! #
! *&#
"
&&%(( )!"
(((
- 4 -
)!" )
"
)! ! -
"
)!"
! .)! .)! ")
&
.)!
#
/(&%((& 01 20345 67 894 2/: 19/:8 ;
/:</:=80/>-# =>5 /(((%((& 01 20345 67 894 ?3=0@=>81A>54:4?80/>*&#/2894/8/:490?341?8 + 2/: 19/:8 ;894 ?8-# ?9=334>B0>B 894 CA5B@4>8 =>5 =D=:5 5=845 ((( <=1145 67 894 553 4>0/:
0E03 )A5B4 =>5 )
05=: 2/: 19/:8 ;894 :06A>=3-# 0>
/&&%(( ( 0>?4 6/89 894 =<<4=31 =:4 =:010>B /A8 /2 894 1=@4 =??054>8 =>5 ?9=334>B0>B 894 1=@4 CA5B@4>8 =>5 =D=:58941=@4=:4?3A66458/B4894:94=:5=>5?/@@/> CA5B@4>801640>B<=1145
- 5 -
& =?81 B0E0>B :014 8/ 894 2030>B /2 894 =<<4=31 6:0423718=845=:489=8/>((=8=6/A8+<@894 54?4=145=33=0=9=3/>BD089=9419 D=1 <:/?4450>B /> = @/8/:?7?34 64=:0>B :4B018:=80/> /,%),(& 2:/@ =@F/34 8/
9=>5:=><=337 /> ,' =9419 D=1 :050>B 894 @/8/:?7?34 94> 8947 :4=?945 >4=: A594:= E033=B4 894 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 64=:0>B :4B018:=80/> /, &% ,'+5:/E48941=@40>=:=19=>5>4B30B4>8@=>>4: =>55=1945=B=0>188941=05@/8/:?7?342:/@6490>51= :41A38 /2 894 =2/:41=05 =??054>8 894 54?4=145 =33=0=9 1A18=0>45 B:04E/A1 0>CA:041 D=1 1902845 8/ =>B=:4557 /1<08=3=>53=84:1A??A@6458/8940>CA:041
94?3=0@=>8120345=<48080/>A>54:4?80/>'' /2 894 ?8 144F0>B ?/@<4>1=80/> 2/: 894 54=89 /2 894 54?4=145=3/>BD0890>84:418
!</> 14:E0?4 /2 >/80?4 894 :41</>54>8, /:</:=80/> =<<4=:45 89:/AB9 ?/A>143 =>5 20345 D:0884>
- 6 -
18=84@4>8 54>70>B 894 =E4:@4>81 @=54 0> 894 ?3=0@ <48080/> ' >8946=101/2894<34=50>B1/2894<=:8041894 3=0@1:06A>=32:=@45894011A41=>5894:4=284::4?/:545 894 4E054>?4 94 ?3=0@=>81 0> /:54: 8/ <:/E4 894 ?=14 4G=@0>45 ?3=0@=>8 / =1 , =>5 B/8 4G9060845 5/?A@4>81 >=@437 G 8/ G > 649=32 /2 :41</>54>81 />4 D08>411 D=1 4G=@0>45 =1 , 6A8 >/ 5/?A@4>8D=14G9060845 * 94 3=0@1 :06A>=3 67 894 0@<AB>45 CA5B@4>8 9435 89=8 894 =??054>8 /??A::45 /> =??/A>8 /2 :=19 =>5 >4B30B4>8 5:0E0>B /2 894 /224>50>B E490?34 67 081 5:0E4: =1 = :41A38 /2 D90?9 894 54?4=145 1A18=0>45 0>CA:041 =>5 1A??A@645 8/ 894 0>CA:041 94 :06A>=3 2A:894: 9435 89=8 894 ?3=0@=>81 =:4 4>808345 8/ = ?/@<4>1=80/>/21(%,=3/>BD0890>84:418=8894 :=84 /2 +H <= =>5 50:4?845 894 :41</>54>8, 8/
- 7 -
54</108 894 ?/@<4>1=80/> =@/A>8 =3/>B D089 0>84:418 40>B=BB:04E4589414=<<4=319=E4644>20345
@8 :4480 =803 43FA>50 34=:>45 ?/A>143 =<<4=:0>B 2/: 894
/:</:=80/> 9=1 :=0145 894 2/33/D0>B ?/>84>80/>1
= 0:1837 894 =??054>8 /??A::45 5A4 8/ 894 >4B30B4>?4/2894:054:/2894@/8/:?7?3494:054:/2894 @/8/:?7?34D=1:050>B8941=@4=8=90B91<445=>50>= :=19 =>5 >4B30B4>8 @=>>4: 5=1945 =B=0>18 894 6A1 4 D=1 =31/ ?/>8:06A845 8/ 894 /??A::4>?4 /2 894 =??054>8 94:06A>=39=14::450>9/350>B89=88945:0E4:/28946A1 =3/>4D=1>4B30B4>80>?=A10>B894=??054>8
6 4?/>537 0> :41<4?8 /2 IA=>8A@ 01 ?/>?4:>45 4E4>89/AB9894?3=0@=>819=E418=84589=889454?4=145 D=1D/:F0>B=1=@=1/>=>5D=14=:>0>B1(%,<4:
@/>89 8947 9=E4 >/8 <:/5A?45 =>7 5/?A@4>81 8/ 1A618=>80=848941=@494:42/:4894:06A>=39=1:0B9837
- 8 -
?/>1054:45 894 >/80/>=3 0>?/@4 /2 894 54?4=145 =1 1%,<4:@/>89
?
90:537 10>?4 894 ?3=0@=>81 9=E4 2=0345 8/ 1A618=>80=848940>?/@4/289454?4=145894:06A>=39=1 :0B9837>/8B:=>845=>72A8A:4<:/1<4?81
5 /A:8937894:06A>=39=14::450>=D=:50>B894 ?/@<4>1=80/> /2 1%, A>54: 894 94=5 /2 ;3/11 /2 2A8A:40>?/@4-4>?41941/AB982/:=33/D0>B894=<<4=3 2034567894
/:</:=80/> 4# =1837 0> 30B98 /2 894 0E010/> 4>?9 /2 8901 /A:80>894?=14/2
' +
)
$
! (894:=84/20>84:418=D=:54567894:06A>=3 +H <= /> 894 ?/@<4>1=80/> =@/A>8 01 /> 894 90B94: 1054
- 9 -
+ 4:?/>8:=:044:=>=B/A5==30<=80334=:>45 ?/A>143 =<<4=:0>B 2/: 894 ?3=0@=>81 9=1 ?/>84>545 =1 643/D
=# 0:1837 894 =??054>8 /??A::45 5A4 8/ 894 >4B30B4>?4/28945:0E4:/28946A1945:0E4:/28946A1 D=15:0E0>B894/224>50>BE490?34=8=90B91<445=>50>= :=19 =>5 >4B30B4>8 @=>>4: =>5 5=1945 =B=0>18 894 @/8/:?7?34A48/8940@<=?889454?4=145D9/D=1894 <0330/>:054:24335/D>=>51A18=0>45B:04E/A10>CA:041=>5 1A614IA4>8371A??A@6458/8940>CA:041@@450=8437=284: 894=??054>8=?/@<3=0>8D=13/5B45=B=0>188945:0E4:/2 8946A1=>5=284:=89/:/AB90>E4180B=80/>894</30?420345 = ?9=:B4 19448 94
/:</:=80/> 9=1 >/8 8=F4> =>7 ?/>84>80/> 89=8 894 >4B30B4>?4 D=1 /> 894 <=:8 /2 894 54?4=145 947 9=E4 :=0145 894 B:/A>5 2/: 894 20:18 80@4 642/:4 8901
/A:8 94:06A>=3 =284: ?/>1054:0>B894 9=:B4 19448 =>5 894 4E054>?4 /2 894 <=:8041 9=1 :0B9837 943589=88945:0E4:/28946A1D=1>4B30B4>80>?=A10>B894 =??054>8
- 10 -
6# 4?/>537 0> :41<4?8 /2 IA=>8A@ =8 894 80@4 /2 =??054>8 894 54?4=145 D=1 4=:>0>B 1(%, <4: @/>8994:06A>=39=1=1141145>/80/>=30>?/@4/2894 54?4=145=11%,D90?901/>8943/D4:1054
?# 90:537=1<4:8943=D3=055/D>67894/>-634 <4G
/A:80>894?=14/2 ! " # $
%
%& H/28940>?/@49=18/64=55452/:2A8A:4<:/1<4?81
5# /A:8937 =1 <4: 894 CA5B@4>8 /2 894 />-634 A<:4@4 /A:8 0> 894 ?=14 /2 ' ' ! ! $
( %(& 4=?9 /2 894 ?3=0@=>81 01 4>808345 8/ ?/@<4>1=80/> /2 1%,
4=:5 894 34=:>45 ?/A>143 2/: 894 <=:8041 =>5 <4:A145894CA5B@4>8=>5=D=:5/2894:06A>=3 94 ?=14 /2 894 ?3=0@=>81 01 89=8 /> ((89454?4=145=33=0=9D=1<:/?4450>B=3/>B
- 11 -
D089 =9419 D9/ D=1 :050>B 894 @/8/:?7?34 64=:0>B :4B018:=80/>
/,%),(& 2:/@ =@F/34 8/ 9=>5:=><=337 94> 8947 :4=?945 >4=: A594:= 033=B4 =8 =6/A8 + <@ 894 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 64=:0>B :4B018:=80/> /,&% ,'+?=@42:/@6490>50>=:=19 =>5>4B30B4>8@=>>4:=>55=1945=B=0>18894:4=:</:80/> /2 894 @/8/:?7?34 A4 8/ 894 0@<=?8 894 54?4=145 2433 2:/@ 894 @/8/:?7?34 1A18=0>45 B:04E/A1 0>CA:041 =>5 1A??A@6458/8940>CA:041
( !>54: 894 /8/: 490?341 ?8 0> 894 ?3=0@ <48080/>642/:4894
3=0@1:06A>=389418=>5=:5/2<://2 01@A?9643/D89=>D9=801:4IA0:450>=?:0@0>=3?=14=1 D433 =1 0> 894 ?0E03 ?=14 / 5/A68 642/:4 894 :06A>=3 894:4 @A18 64 1/@4 @=84:0=3 /> 894 6=101 /2 D90?9 894 :06A>=3 ?=> =::0E4 /: 54?054 890>B1 >4?411=:7 8/ 54?054 2/: =D=:50>B ?/@<4>1=80/> 6A8 894 :06A>=3 01 >/8 4G<4?8458/8=F4/:8/=5/<8=>0?487/2=?0E03/:?:0@0>=3
- 12 -
?=14 284: =33 08 01 = 1A@@=:7 4>IA0:7 =>5 08 01 894 34B013=80/>2/:894D432=:4/2894/?048794<:/?4450>B1 A>54: 894 /8/: 490?341 ?8 =:4 >/8 =F0> 8/ 894 <:/?4450>B1 A>54: ?0E03 :A341 4>?4 18:0?8 :A341 /2 4E054>?4=:4>/8:4IA0:458/642/33/D450>8901:4B=:5> 894 ?=14 /2
" E,
! (#
'' 894 />-634<4G
/A:89=19435=194:40>643/D ) *+,-.*/01*/*203456.3 +1507/8.*02 3.8.,/1 3.5+/5.
* 96010 560 0".20*-0
-,/.8/*5:3 0;09.5*033 9/3 2.3-/1202 <; 560 1.<+*/, /*2 56/5 560 103= *20*5 .* 56/5 -/30 9/3 /->+.5502 .* 560 -1.8.*/, -/30 - *-01*.*? 560/--.20*5 6.3 +1546 90"014 =.*0256/5 .5-/** 5<0 "01, @0256/5+= *.*"035.?/5. * 560 -/30 10?.350102 /?/.*35 560 103= *20*54 =1.8//-.048/501./,336 9.*?*0?,.?0*-09010 +*2 5 =+5 6.8 * 51./, 60 +15 1035/502 560 3055,02 =1.*-.=,0 56/5 560 0".20*-0 560 -,/.8/*53 +?655 <007/8.*02<;5601.<+*/, * 560 5 +-635 *0
=10= *201/*-0
=1 </<.,.5; /*2 -015/.*,; 560 35/*2/12 =1
- 13 -
<0; *2 10/3 */<,0 2 +<5 - +,2 * 5 6/"0 <00* /==,.02 A & /<:/E4894?=14?3=0@=>8 /D=14G=@0>45 =1>94:4E054>?4194?=84B/:0?=33718=84589=8894 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 D=1 >4B30B4>8 0> ?=A10>B 894 =??054>8 E4> 89/AB9 894
/:</:=80/> 4G=@0>45 894 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 08 9=1 >/8 <:/5A?45 =>7 5/?A@4>81 8/ 501<:/E4 894 4E054>?4 /2 894 ?3=0@=>81 94 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 >40894: 3/5B45=>7?/@<3=0>8>/:?9=334>B45894?9=:B41944820345 =B=0>18 90@ A:894:@/:4 894
/:</:=80/> 505 >/8 <34=5 89=8 894:054: /2 894@/8/:?7?34D=1 >4B30B4>8 0> ?=A10>B 894 =??054>8
/>1054:0>B 894 4E054>?4 /2 894 ?/@<3=0>8 :4</:8 ?9=:B4 19448 894 :06A>=3 9=1 :0B9837 9435 89=8 894 5:0E4: /2 894 6A1 D=1 >4B30B4>8 0> ?=A10>B894=??054>8 ,$ E4> 89/AB9 894 ?3=0@=>81 ?3=0@45 89=8 894 54?4=145 D=1 4=:>0>B 1(%, <4: @/>89 8947 9=E4
- 14 -
>/8<:/5A?45=>75/?A@4>818/418=630198941=@4>894 =614>?4/2<://2/20>?/@4894>/80/>=30>?/@49=18/64 =1141145 1 <4: 894 BA05430>41 011A45 67 894 =:>=8=F= 8=844B=34:E0?41A89/:0872/:=??054>8189=8/??A::45 0>89474=:((894>/80/>=30>?/@4/289454?4=1459=1 8/ 64 8=F4> =1 1(%, <4: @/>89 / 894 =2/:41=05 0>?/@4H9=18/64=55458/D=:512A8A:4<:/1<4?810> E04D/28943=D3=055/D>67894
/>1808A80/>4>?9/2894 A<:4@4
/A:80>894?=14/2B#:1A<:=#
0>?4 894:4 =:4 2/A: 54<4>54>81 08 01 =<<:/<:0=848/545A?8%89/28940>?/@4/289454?4=145 8/D=:51<4:1/>=34G<4>141=>5894:4@=0>0>B=@/A>89=1 8/648=F4>=1901?/>8:06A80/>8/8942=@03794@A380<304:
=<<30?=634 8/ 894 :434E=>8 =B4 B:/A< 01 ;- ??/:50>B37 8943/11/254<4>54>?79=18/64:4=1141145=12/33/D1 1(JHK(K,%L- + )
' > =55080/> 894 ?3=0@=>81 =:4 4>808345 8/ ?/@<4>1=80/>/21'%,/>=??/A>8/2;3/11/2418=84-
- 15 -
=>5 ?/@<4>1=80/> /2 1'%, /> =??/A>8 /2 ;2A>4:=3 4G<4>141-
* > E04D /2 894 3=D 3=05 5/D> 67 894 />-634 A<:4@4
/A:8 0> 894 ?=14 /2 ;' ' !
: ?3=0@=>8 /,D024 /2 894 54?4=145014>8083458/?/@<4>1=80/>/21%,A>54:
894 94=5 /2 ;3/11 /2 1</A1=3 ?/>1/:80A@-
3=0@=>8 /1( =>5 & ?9035:4> /2 894 54?4=145 =:4 4>808345 2/: ?/@<4>1=80/>/21%,4=?9A>54:89494=5/2;3/11 /2 <=:4>8=3 ?/>1/:80A@-
3=0@=>8 >/ 01 4>808345 2/:
?/@<4>1=80/> /2 1%, A>54: 894 94=5 /2 ;3/11 /2 2030=3?/>1/:80A@-
9A1 894 ?3=0@=>81 =:4 4>808345 2/: 894 2/33/D0>B?/@<4>1=80/> ./01-234151607 6407013026- .51341 '-( /11/254<4>54>?7 ('+&( A>4:=34G<4>141 '
- 16 -
/11/2418=84 ' /11/21</A1=3?/>1/:80A@
/11/2=:4>8=3?/>1/:80A@
/11/2 030=3?/>1/:80A@
/11/2 A8A:40>?/@4
328
+
+ ??/:50>B37D4<=118942/33/D0>B/:54:
94=<<4=31=:42.3= 302 6# 94CA5B@4>8/2894
3=0@1:06A>=301@/502045 ?# 94?3=0@=>81=:44>8083458/=8/8=3?/@<4>1=80/>/2 - +
)=1=B=0>181(%,=D=:545 67894:06A>=3 5# /33/D0>B894CA5B@4>8/28940E010/>4>?9/28901 /A:8 0> 894 ?=14 /2 9 &" : 1A<:=# 894 4>9=>?45 ?/@<4>1=80/> 19=33 ?=::7 0>84:418 =8 'H<=
- 17 -
4# 94 /:</:=80/> 01 50:4?845 8/ 54</108 894 ?/@<4>1=80/> =@/A>8 =3/>B D089 0>84:418 2:/@ 894 5=84 /2 2030>B /2 894 ?3=0@ <48080/> 8033 894 5=84 /2 :4=30M=80/> D0890> = <4:0/5 /2 10G D44F1 2:/@ 894 5=84/2:4?40<8/2=?/<7/28901CA5B@4>8 2# 94 =<</:80/>@4>8 54</108 =>5 :434=14 /2 =@/A>8 19=33 64 @=54 0> =??/:5=>?4 D089 894 84:@1 /2 894 =D=:5/2894:06A>=3 B# 94=@/A>80>54</10802=>719=33648:=>124::458/ 894:06A>=3
6) '$ ( &
6) '"&#"( &
018 /3 /*