Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58286 (KAR)
THE MANAGER RELIANCE v. TIPPANNA AND ANR
MFA/200478/2021 · 2025-04-02
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58286 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58286 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$ $
""
%& '(
"")
%&
' (
! " #
$
" "
%&' %
$" ( #) *'
& # $ #
%+' %
$" (
#) *' ! & #
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
,
,
, -
) *&&
$&+ # ) ),
, -
#)
, ) # ,,
)' (
! " #
$"
%& %
$ (
. (
#) *'
& # $ #
%+' %
$" (
#) *' ! & #
- 3 -
,
,
, -
) *&&
$&+ # ) ),
, -
#)
, ) # ,,
,
)# % % / )
)
$ %/ )
)
0123450601270389:7;06<924501==06617497051; 1==01203<9245020;=973074
& 7>945450;01==016; 45020;=9730749&>0<920 4506012703
9??@;;@9702A@B 06@1780077;:21780
943 @;>0<92045@;
9:24>0@7C1CC2@0A03>D45089??97E:3C?074 @7
9$&+173$&+31403*&&
50 C2@0A1780 9< 450 1==066174 5020@7 @; 4514 450 E:216 20614@97;5@= 9< =04@4@9702; 173 450 20;=973074 9 1;
- 4 -
0?=69D001730?=69D02F1;7940;41>6@;503>0<9204506012703 9??@;;@9702 4 F1; 897407303 >D 450 1==066174@7;:21780 89?=17D 4514 450 =04@4@9702; @7 >945 450;0 ?14402; F020 794 4500?=69D00;:730245020;=973074917345020<920 450D F020 794 074@4603 49 ?1@741@7 1 861@?
=04@4@97 >0<920 450 6012703
9??@;;@9702
+ 50 2@>:716 51A@7C >0;49F03 @4; 144074@97 97 450 1A1@61>600A@3078097208923 81?04945089786:;@97451445020 0G@;4; 450 20614@97;5@= 9< 450 0?=69D02 173 0?=69D00 173 45020<920 @4 F074 15013 49 30402?@70 450 89?=07;14@97 1?9:74 50 6012703 89:7;06 1==012@7C <92 450 1==066174 F9:63;:>?@44514450=04@4@9702;17345020;=9730749 51A013?@4403;:8520614@97;5@=;@780450DF0208966:3@7C F@450185945024@;;:>?@440345141713?@;;@97>D450 20;=973074 79 1>9:4 450 20614@97;5@= @; 794 >@73@7C 97 450 1==066174@7;:21780 89?=17D 173 @730=073074 0A@30780 ;59:63 51A0 >007 603 >D 450 =04@4@9702; >0<920 450 2@>:716 49 0;41>6@;5 ;:85 1 20614@97;5@= 4 @; @7 45@;
>18HC29:73 4514 450 @?=:C703 E:3C?074 7003 49 >0
- 5 -
=02:;03 50 6012703 89??@;;@9702 @7 =121 &* 9< 450 @?=:C703E:3C?074;4140;1;>069F% &* 50 20;=973074 9& F59 51; <@603 450 F2@4407 ;4140?074
307@03 450;0 1;;024@97; ;=08@<@8166D @7 450 F2@4407 ;4140?074 50 20;=9730749&8974073034514450=04@4@9702;>0 =:4 49 ;42@84 =299< 9< 450 ;1?0 F 173 & 51A0 20@4021403 45@; <184 1;;02403 @7 450 =04@4@97; 173 450D51A0C94=293:803450398:?074;14G49 I F5@85C949;59F45149745031401734@?09< 450 188@3074 450 =04@4@9702; F020 F92H@7C 1; 61>9:2;97450:7@49<20;=97307491737012
"96512 A@661C0 450 32@A02 9< A05@860 329A0 450 A05@860 70C6@C0746D @749 3@485 3:0 49 F5@85 450 =04@4@9702; <066 39F7 173 ;:;41@703 <2184:216 @7E:2@0;7450?03@816208923;9<450=04@4@9702;14 G173I 45081:;09<@7E:2@0;@;;4140349>0 50 20;=973074 9 51; 16;9 13?@4403 450 <184 9< 20614@97;5@= 9< 0?=69D02 173 0?=69D00 @7 >04F007 =04@4@9702; 173 5@?;06< 173 @7E:2@0;
;:;41@703 >D 450 =04@4@9702; @7 450 ;1@3 188@3074 3:2@7C 450 89:2;0 9< 0?=69D?074 50 398:?074;
14 G 49 I 120 A96:?@79:; 398:?074; 50 398:?074; 14 G 49 I ;=08@<@8166D 20A016 4514 @7E:2@0; ;:<<0203 >D 450 =04@4@9702; 51A0 988:2203 3:2@7C 450 89:2;0 9< 450@2 0?=69D?074 :7302 20;=973074 9 97 5@; :7@4 1; 61>9:2 50;0 398:?074; 14 G 49 I 817 >0 1880=403 173 206@03<92450=299< 9<450<184;89A0203 :7302450 =20;074@;;:0;@74506@C549<450308@;@979<97/>60
- 6 -
@C5
9:24 9< "127141H1 @7 450 81;0 9< 21785 171C02 0F 73@1 ;;:21780
9 43 #; @331==1 1E92 20=92403 @7 &+
"127141H1 @C5
9:24 5020<920 450 =04@4@9702;
51A0 =29A03 4514 450D F020 F92H@7C 1; 61>9:2 97 450 :7@4 >012@7C >012@7C & 9"&*$*I **4@;79445081;09<45020;=9730749&4514 450 @7E:2@0; ;:<<0203 >D 450 =04@4@9702; 120 794 988:2203 3:2@7C 450 89:2;0 9< 0?=69D?074 173 F92H?17 F1; 794 184:166D F92H@7C 14 450 4@?0 9< 188@30745020@;790A@30780493@;=29A0450;1@3 398:?074;20<022031>9A0
5:; @4 @; 0A@3074 <29?
1 >120 2013@7C 9< 450 201;97@7CC@A07>D4506012703
9??@;;@97024514@4@;794 >D F1D 9<13?@;;@97 9< 45020;=9730749 >:450513 >1;03 5@; 201;97@7C 97 450 1A1@61>60 398:?07412D 0A@3078050=96@80=1=02;F5@85F020=61803>0<920450 6012703
9??@;;@9702 C1A0 1?=60 =299< 9< 450 <184 4514 450 =04@4@9702; F020 450 0?=69D00; 9< 450 20;=973074 9 50 , 173 94502 =1=02; 51A@7C 89?0 @749 0G@;40780 9:4 9< 450 @7A0;4@C14@97 8973:8403 >D 450 7A0;4@C14@7C <<@802 173 450D 51A@7C 450 >070<@4 9< ;=974170@4D F020>06@0A03>D4506012703
9??@;;@9702 A@30746D 79 0A@30780 F1; 603 F5@85 F9:63 0<<084@A06D
- 7 -
20>:4 450;0 =96@80 =1=02; 5020<920 45@;
9:24 39 794 <@73 17D ?02@4 @7 450 =20;074 1==016 ?:85 60;; 17D ;:>;4174@16J:0;4@979<61F ' 745020;:64 >945450;01==016;1203@;?@;;03 14450;41C09<13?@;;@97
3$ %$ & $
@;49%69% %"