- 1 - !"# $#% # # &' ( !" # $ "! # % % % Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '( %( %( ) ! ! % $ "!* +, * +, * +)# + ) ' + + + )() ( ! &% &%+ %) &% &% ' ( ( ( &% ! + ) ( + !+ + ! - 3 - + ! -!* " -!*# ./ 0/121234/5 26 7/835/ 1.26 3951 6//:24; 83<<3=24; 5/<2/8>6, ! " #$%&' ! " #( %& )#* ! " #+ %& ' ,- ! " #.%&'/ ! " #% ! 0 ) 1 2 * 3 ( 4 4 - 3 5 6 ' 13 7 33 4 7 8 - 4 - ./ ?@6/ 38 1./ 0/121234/5 26 1.@1 6./ 095?.@6/A@4/B1/4138 @?5/ (;941@638<@4A8@5C24; 0@51 38 D3) 6219@1/A @1 @<C@4;2 2<<@;/ E, 24A.@495 853C 34/ @BC@CC@ 3 .@4A5@00@ 1./ 5/6034A/413./5/24241/5C6385/;261/5/AA//A386@</ A@1/A F(F (( /121234/5 @<63 095?.@6/A @431./5 /B1/41 38 @?5/ ;941@6 38 <@4A 853C 34/ .@44CC@ 3 !@6@4@;39A@ 24 1/5C6 38 5/;261/5/A A//A 38 6@</ A@1/A )( (( 8@5C24; 0@51 38 1./ G/5D 6@C/ 695G/D 49C7/5 .96 1./ 0/121234/5 24 1/5C6 38 1./ @835/6@2A 5/;261/5/A A//A6 38 6@</ 7/?@C/ @763<91/ 3=4/5 13 @4 /B1/41 38 @?5/ ;941@6 38 <@4A 24 D3) /5 4@C/ =@6 C91@1/A24 1./5/G/49/5/?35A6G2A/C91@1234 35A/53 ((% (( A@1/A ( (( /54@C/=@6 @??35A24;<D5/8</?1/A241./5/?35A63852;.16853C1./D/@5 ((%( 34=@5A6 1 26 8951./5 ?@6/ 38 1./ 0/121234/5 1.@1 @1 1./ 2461@4?/ 38 5/6034A/41 3 1./ 5/6034A/41 3% /G/49/ 460/?135 05/0@5/A @ 5/0351 @4A 697C211/A 1./ - 5 - 6@C/135/6034A/413 !@6/A34=.2?.1./5/6034A/41 3 %@.62<A@5 .@6 5/?3CC/4A/A 835 ?@4?/<<@1234 38 5/G/49/ 5/?35A6 24 5/60/?1 38 D3) /6034A/41 3%66261@413CC266234/5@?124;90341./6@2A5/0351 =21.391266924;@4D4312?/130/121234/5.@6053?//A/A13 0@661./35A/5A@1/A )() (A/</124;1./4@C/381./ 0/121234/5853C1./5/G/49/5/?35A6131.//B1/4138 @?5/ (;941@638<@4A24D3)346/E9/419034=.2?. 1./5/6034A/413 .@65/C3G/A1./4@C/380/121234/5 853C1./5/G/49/5/?35A6G2A/ 3 (% (F@4A .@66.3=41./4@C/381./5/6034A/41313@4/B1/41 38 ) @?5/6 ;941@6 24 D3) 2461/@A 38 @?5/ ;941@6 ./5/835/1./5/6034A/413 =21.391266924; @4D 4312?/ 13 1./ 0/121234/5 ?34A9?1/A 1./ 03A2 38 6@2A 695G/D 49C7/56 34 ( ( 24 1/5C6 38 =.2?. D3) .@6 7//4 @662;4/A 4/= 695G/D 49C7/56 @6 D3) H C/@69524; @?5/6 ;941@6 D3) H C/@69524; ) @?5/6 ;941@6 - 6 - D3) H C/@69524;@?5/6(;941@6./<@4A38 1./0/121234/5.@67//4@662;4/A=21.D3) H 34<D 131.//B1/4138 @?5/6 ;941@6 .@1 1@:24; 94A9/ @AG@41@;/ 38 1./ @835/6@2A @43C@<D@A//A38;281@00/@5613.@G/7//4/B/?91/A24 8@G395385/6034A/4137@6/A34=.2?.5/G/49//4152/6 .@G/ 7//4 @88/?1/A G2A/ 3 34 ()(F (F 4 8951./5@4?/ 1./5/38 5/6034A/41 3 .@6 /B/?91/A 5/;261/5/A A//A 38 6@</ A@1/A ( ( ( 24 8@G395 38 5/6034A/413)13@4/B1/4138 @?5/ (;941@6!@6/A 34 1./ 6@2A A//A 38 6@</6 5/G/49/ 5/?35A6 .@G/ 7//4 C91@1/A241./4@C/385/6034A/413)131.//B1/4138 @?5/ (;941@6G2A/ 3 ' ) /@54/A ?3946/< 13 1./ 0/121234/5 1@:24; 1.26 39511.539;.1./@835/6@2A5/?35A697C2161.@11./131@< /B1/41381./<@4A24D3)=.2?.6133A241./4@C/ 38 5/6034A/41 3 %@:6.C@C@ =@6 34<D @?5/6 ( ;941@624?/1./0/121234/5./5/24.@6095?.@6/A@?5/6 - 7 - ;941@694A/51=3A//A6386@</5/8/55/A13@73G/34<D 1./5/C@2424;/B1/4138<@4A?39<A.@G/7//45/8</?1/A24 1./ 4@C/ 38 5/6034A/41 3 =.2?. =@6 34<D @?5/6 ;941@6 @4A 431 ) @?5/6 ;941@6 /4?/ 1./ </@54/A ?3946/<8351./0/121234/5697C2161.@11./34<D;52/G@4?/ 381./0/121234/5261.@15/6034A/413=21.391@AG/5124; 13 1./ A//A6 38 6@</ 24 1/5C6 38 =.2?. 1./ 0/121234/5 @?E925/A@?5/ (;941@638<@4A@4A=21.391@AG/5124;13 1./ 5/G/49/ /4152/6 =.2?. @5/ /88/?1/A 24 ./5 4@C/ .@6 942<@1/5@<<D =21.391 @00<2?@1234 38 C24A .@6 A/</1/A 1./ 4@C/381./0/121234/5131.//B1/4138 @?5/ (;941@638 <@4A 34 1./ 0950351/A 05/C26/ 38 6@C/ 7/24; 1./ 5/0/@1/A A397<//415D??35A24;<D./6//:6835@<<3=24; 381./0/121234 ' /@54/A@00/@524;8355/6034A/413613 697C216 1.@1 1.@1 1./ 131@< /B1/41 38 <@4A 6.3=4 24 D3) 26 @?5/6 =.2?. @00/@56 13 .@G/ 7//4 697I/?1C@11/538G@5239615@46@?1234624?/1./0/121234/5 ?<@2C/A 13 .@G/ 095?.@6/A 03512346 38 <@4A 4@C/<D - 8 - @?5/ ;941@6@4A @?5/ (;941@6241/5C6381=3A//A6 38 6@</ 1./ 5/6034A/41%@91.3521D =39<A <33: 2413 1./ C@11/5 @4A 0@66 @0053052@1/ 35A/56 28 5/E925/A 5/613524; 1./ 4@C/ 38 1./ 0/121234/5 13 1./ /B1/41 38 @?5/ ( ;941@638<@4A /@54/A?3946/<@00/@524;8355/6034A/413) 697C216 1.@1 5/6034A/41 3) .@6 43 @AG/56/ ?<@2C 35 241/5/61@;@24611./?@6/381./0/121234/524@6C9?.@61./ 131@</B1/4138 <@4A /G/4 @??35A24;135/G/49/5/?35A626 @7391 @?5/6 ( ;941@6 38 =.2?. 0/121234/5 ?<@2C/A 13 .@G/ 095?.@6/A @?5/6 ;941@6 94A/5 1=3 A//A6 38 6@</ G/4 @81/5 /B?<9A24; 1./ 6@2A /B1/41 38 <@4A 095?.@6/A7D0/121234/51./G/4A356381./0/121234/5612<< =/5/ .3<A24; <@4A =.2?. 1./ 5/6034A/41 3) .@6 095?.@6/A / 8951./5 697C216 1.@1 A/6?5201234 38 1./ 0530/51D 095?.@6/A 7D 1./ 5/6034A/41 3) 26 A288/5/41 @4A A26124?1 853C 1./ 34/ 94A/5 =.2?. 1./ 0/121234/5 26 ?<@2C24;./5/835/./697C2161./5/6034A/41%@91.35212/6 7/ A25/?1/A 13 ?3462A/5 1./ /4121</C/41 38 5/6034A/41 - 9 - 3) =.2</ 5/613524; 1./ 4@C/ 38 1./ 0/121234/5 13 1./ 5/G/49/5/?35A6 F /@5A0/596/A1./5/?35A6 ( ./5/ 26 43 A26091/ 38 1./ 8@?1 1.@1 1./ 0/121234/5 ./5/24 095?.@6/A @?5/6 ( ;941@6 38 <@4A 24 D3)38@<C@4;2 2<<@;/E24A.@495241/5C638 5/;261/5/A A//A 38 6@</ A@1/A )( (( 853C .@44@CC@ 3 !@6@4@;39A@ @4A @431./5 /B1/41 38 @?5/6 ( ;941@6 853C @:6.C@CC@ 3 .@4A5@00@% 5/6034A/413241/5C6385/;261/5/AA//A6386@</A@1/A F(F (( ./5/ 26 @<63 43 A26091/ 38 1./ 8@?1 1.@1 24 8951./5@4?/131./6@2A5/;261/5/AA//A6386@</4@C/38 1./0/121234/5=@6C91@1/A241./5/G/49/5/?35A6131./ /B1/4138 @?5/6 ;941@6G2A/3A@1/A ( (( @431./5/B1/4138 @?5/6 (;941@6G2A/3./5/ 26 @<63 43 A26091/ 3G/5 1./ 8@?1 1.@1 1./ 4@C/ 38 1./ 0/121234/5?341249/A137/5/8</?1/A245/G/49/5/?35A6@4A /B15@?1612<< (' - 10 - 126@<6343124A26091/1.@11./131@</B1/4138 1./<@4A24D3)=.2?.6133A241./4@C/38G/4A356 381./0/121234/57/835/1.//B/?9123438A//A6386@</=@6 @?5/6(;941@61264/?/66@5D13431/1.@1@AC211/A<D 1./5/ =@6 @ 0@5121234 7/1=//4 .@44@CC@ @4A @:6.C@CC@ =.3 @5/ 1./ G/4A356 38 1./ 0/121234/5 4 1/5C6386@2A0@5121234@4/B1/4138 @?5/6 ;941@6=@6 @<<311/A131./6.@5/38.@44@CC@@4A5/C@2424;/B1/41 38)@?5/6 (;941@6=@65/1@24/A7D@:6.C@CC@.26 26 5/8</?1/A 24 1./ 5/G/49/ 5/?35A6 24 3 .26 26 6//4@1A3?9C/413)053A9?/A@<34;=21.1./6D430626 =./5/241./4@C/38@:6.C@CC@266.3=413@4/B1/41 38 ) @?5/6 ;941@6 =.2</ 1./ 4@C/ 38 .@44@CC@ 26 6.3=4131.//B1/4138 @?5/6 ;941@624?/ @?5/6 ;941@638<@4A=.2?.=@6@<<311/A136.@5/38.@44@CC@ .@67//4095?.@6/A7D1./0/121234/5431.24;5/C@24624 1./ 4@C/ 38 .@44@CC@ 24?/ @?5/6 ( ;941@6 .@6 7//4095?.@6/A7D1./0/121234/5853C@:6.C@CC@ 3 .@4A5@00@ 34<D @4 /B1/41 38 @?5/ ;941@6 =39<A - 11 - 5/C@24 24 1./ 4@C/ 38 @:6.C@CC@ 3 .@4A5@00@ ./6/ 8@?16 @5/ /C@4@124; 853C 1./ C91@1234 5/;261/5 /B15@?16053A9?/A@4AC@A/@G@2<@7</7/835/1.263951 3?9C/41 @1 44/B95/% =.2?. 26 1./ 35A/5 A@1/A )() ( 0@66/A 7D 1./ 5/6034A/41 3% 66261@413CC266234/55/@A6@694A/5, !"#$%&%'()* *%+,&-./01 23 .3%451%67819: ;&< ==== >?@ >?@ >?@ >?@ >?@ >?@ >?@ >?@ AB AB AB AB BC BC BC BC* * * * D-8; EFB? D-8; EFB?;+G .H1167 0%1/H1 +/I;(J1K ! &LM0-;J1K N"0-;+/I;=DK/ (A:H1167 0%1/H1 ?%; $%1345.?%; 3O+667 670%PH1 "#$% - 12 - ./5/@634@662;4/A835A/</1234381./4@C/38 0/121234/5 13 @4 /B1/41 38 @?5/6 ( ;941@6 @6 6//4 @1 ?3<9C4 3F 38 1./ @835/6@2A 1@7</ 26 1./5/ 7/24; A397</ /415D 24 1./ 0@.@426 ./ 6@2A 35A/5 @4A 1./ 5/@634 835 A/</1234 26 34/ =21.391 @00<2?@1234 38 C24A @4A =21.391 5/8/5/4?/131./A//A6386@</94A/5=.2?.1./0/121234/5 .@6095?.@6/A@?5/6 (;941@638<@4A 4 1./ 3G/5@<< 8@?16 @4A ?25?9C61@4?/6 38 1./ C@11/5 @4A ?3462A/524; 1./ 697C2662346 C@A/ 7D 1./ </@54/A ?3946/< 835 1./ 0@512/6 5/?35A/A @73G/ 1./ 83<<3=24;, "@# ./0/121234260@51<D@<<3=/A "7# ./ 35A/5 A@1/A )() ( @1 44/B95/% 26 6/1@62A/@11/5265/C211/A131./5/6034A/41 3%66261@413CC266234/5 "?# /6034A/41 3 % 66261@41 3CC266234/5 @81/5 @8835A24; 3003519421D 38 0/5634@< ./@524; 131./0/121234/5@6=/<<@65/6034A/413)24 1./C@11/50@66@0053052@1/35A/56://024;24 - 13 - C24A 1./ 8@?16 4@55@1/A @73G/ 5/613524; 1./ 4@C/381./0/121234/513@4/B1/4138 @?5/ ( ;941@6 @4A @?5/ ;941@6 24 1./ 5/G/49/ 5/?35A6 @6 6133A 7/835/ 0@6624; 38 1./ @835/6@2A2C09;4/A35A/5 "A# ./ 0/121234/5 26 @1 <27/51D 13 697C21 @ 85/6. 5/05/6/41@1234 13 5/6034A/41 3 J 66261@41 3CC266234/5 @<34; =21. 1./ 690035124; A3?9C/41634<D138@?2<21@1/5/6034A/41313 ?3C0<D=21.1./A25/?123462669/A./5/24@73G/ "/# 9?. 35A/56 6.@<< 7/ 0@66/A 7D 5/6034A/41 3%66261@41 3CC266234/5 =21.24 @4 391/5 <2C21 38 F( A@D6 853C 1./ A@1/ 38 5/?/201 38 ?/51282/A?30D381.2635A/5 )' &# #( % 2613<3)