- 1 - !"!# $%"& % ' () (*+' )(++ , ! " ! " ! #" $ %& " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ %& " ' ($$) * $ +** "# , $ % " ' ( *- $*) * * % * . " !"" * * * $ **** () () ! !() ! ( ) !() * , * , / $ - 3 - ( / $ ) 012324154164770128039:;8<07=:26>0 ?06464:802<24 1@1312>1>1A;334870128034B>:;26 :5028@086701302=:26>0=42<620<?:83086616018324 ;3>1C12 1: 7012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 <09:83 20<?:83086 >4< ?06464:8 4< =4703 AD 6>0 199;<03 ?02<:8< ;83020964:8:=>12164D1 1B124C;21C<>118>461 "!E46>6>0=:77:E48B?21D02 ! " ! #$ $ #% &' '( $ ) ) ) *+$,+-. /) ))' 012 3(23("1 ("123(" !2!3("213 )/4' ($ % %( )& ' 5 ' 6 78# $ ) '' ' ) '( )& ' %9 - 4 - ! *196<488;6<>077=:26>034<?:<17:=6>0?20<086 ?06464:81201<;8302 ! >0 <09:83 20<?:83086 >04C 700@ 7:3B03 1 9:@?71486 E46> A0=:20 4312 ;217 :7490 6164:8 :8 !"6> :50@A02 " E>49> E1< 20B4<60203 48 24@0 :.:= " =:2 :==0890< ?;84<>1A70 ;8302 0964:8< () () ! !() ! ( ) !() := >12164D1 D1D1 18>461"! ! >0 B4<6 := 6>0 9:@?71486 1502@086< E:;73 205017 6>16 :8" 16 1A:;6 !" ?@E>086>0 9:@?7148186E1<<618348B80126>0=12@>:;<0:= 1213;771 >18481@471?;2<143 1213;771>1891@04818264B1 12 A01248B :! ! 48 =2:86 := 6>0 =12@>:;<0 >14C 184 4DD1 4860290?603 6>0 912 AD ?12C48B >4< 912 1213;771 >18 E46> 18 4860864:8 6: B06 6>0 E1D 9701203 >:8C0366>16F;896;20<143>14C 1844DD1B:63:E8 =2:@6>0912183?49C03;?6>0G;12207E46> 1213;771>18 183<6126031A;<48B 12;3;771>1848=476>D718B;1B0 - 5 - !! 4??; : ;C;2 A3;7 1@43 : D03 A21>4@ 183 D03 ;3; : D03 1>4A18<1A E>: 120 48@160<:=6>0912:=>14C 1844DD117<:B:63:E8183 F:4803 6>0 G;12207 :@?7148186 183 1A20H 183 :80 :>1@@03421F;3348624036:?194=D6>0G;1220766>16 F;896;20 >14C 184 4DD1 1A;<03 6>0 9:@?7148186 183 1<<1;7603 6>0 9:@?7148186 E46> 1 97;A 183 D03 ;3; 1<<1;76031A20H183C49C03>4@ ! 1<03 :8 6>0 9:@?71486 7:3B03 AD 6>0 9:@?714818620<?:83086 :91<091@06:A020B4<60203 1B148<6 6>0 <143 >14C 184 4DD1 4??; A3;7 1@003 183D03;3;1836>0@166024<A048B4850<64B1603 012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 ?06464:802< 9:86083< 6>164820<?096:=6>0?2:?026D34<?;60?06464:802<>02048 >1501??2:19>036>04547:;261836>0204<18:2302:= 60@?:212D 48F;8964:8 48 =15:;2 := 6>0 ?06464:802< >02048 183 30<?460 <;9> 18 :2302 := 48F;8964:8 6>0 9:@?7148186 183>4<=:77:E02<1<<1;76036>0?06464:802<48>4<7183183 - 6 - E>020AD6>0=42<6?06464:8027:<6>4<9:8<94:;<183>0B:6 13@46603 6: 6>0 >:<?4617 183 A1<03 :8 6>0 20?:26 91<0 91@0 6: 20B4<60203 1B148<6 6>0 9:@?7148186 183 >4< =:77:E02< < 1 9:;8602 A71<6 := <;9> 9:@?71486 1 =17<0 9:@?71486>1<A0087:3B03AD6>0<09:8320<?:831B148<6 6>0?06464:802<1836>;<>0<:;B>6=:2G;1<>48B6>0* ' 24 1@1312 >1>1A;3348 7012803 4B>:;26:5028@08670130218324;3>1C121: 7012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 20<?:83086< E:;73 9:86083 E>06>02161776>0?06464:802<120488:9086183489430861< 4<@0864:803486>0*>1<8:661C08?7190:28:69188:6 3094303AD6>4<:;26AD>:7348B1@48462417 # 0128034B>:;26:5028@086701302E:;83 =;26>029:860836>166>0@166024<A048B4850<64B16031834= 464<6>091<0:=6>0?06464:802<6>166>0?20<08691<04<1 9:;8602 91<0 1< 1B148<6 6>0 9:@?71486 7:3B03 AD 6>0 ?06464:802< >02048 6>0 <1@0 <>177 A0 4850<64B1603 AD 6>0 - 7 - :7490486>074B>6:=6>03420964:8<4<<;03AD6>0*;77089> := 6>4< :;26 48 6>0 91<0 := 20?:2603 48 183 <:;B>6 =:234<@4<<17:=6>0?06464:8 1548B>01236>012B;@086<:8A:6><430<6>4< :;26?02;<036>0@1602417:8209:23@0649;7:;<7D . 8<;9>?02;<17:=6>0@1602417:8209:23464< <008 6>16 6>020 4< <:@0 94547 34<?;60 A06E008 6>0 =42<6 ?06464:8021839:@?7148186?126D " 6 4< 1770B03 6>16 6>0 =42<6 ?06464:802 4< >1548B 6>0 A080=46 := 18 :2302 := 48F;8964:8 =2:@ 6>0 3;7D 9:8<646;603 4547 :;26 E>49> >1< A008 54:71603 AD 6>0 9:@?7148186?126D 1C48B8:60:=6>0<01<?096<:=6>0@16602183 6>0 91<0 =4703 AD 6>0 =42<6 ?06464:802 1B148<6 6>0 9:@?7148186 ?126D 4< 0127402 48 6>0 64@0 850<64B1648B - 8 - ==4902<>1774850<64B1606>0@16602483061471834=>04<:= 6>0:?484:86>166>091<0:=6>0?20<0869:@?71481864<1 9:;8602 A71<6 183 1< 1 9:;8602 91<0 6: 6>0 91<0 =4703 AD 6>0 =42<6 ?06464:802 8090<<1247D 6>0 850<64B1648B ==4902 >1<6:4850<64B160A:6>6>0@16602<48199:231890E46>6>0 ?24894?70< := 71E 08;8941603 48 6>0 91<0 := I J 91<0 1< 20=02203 6: 183 =470 1??2:?2416020?:26 = 18D 13502<0 20?:26 4< =4703 ?12640< 120 16 74A026D 6: 1??2:19> 6>4< :;26 1B148 E46> 8090<<12D ?06464:8 ! 0<02548B <;9> 74A026D =:2 6>0 ?12640< 6>0 =:77:E48B 06464:84< -' (&+ " 4<6 :7 :!