- 1 - !" # " $ % & %' ( ' ! " # " # Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % & % ' (% ) * + " # , , " # , - 3 - ( " # %- .(-(% / " # %( .(-(0 % " # -, * .(-(0 ! " 1"#" #2 1(%2 %0, , 11 1 001 * 00 * -0 * 1 000 /00( * " # 1 1 1* - 4 - ( ' ( / (%0/ ! " # " # ( .(%0/ $ 0, - 5 - % & % ' (% ) ! " 1"#" #2 1 001 * (0%00% %00, 1 * 000, -- * "# 1 1 * 3* - 6 - A.Chandrashekhar (Died on 14.12.2000) Saraswati (1st Wife) (Died on 15.05.1993) Sushilabai (2nd Wife) Ravidnra Appellant No.1 Kavita Appellant No.2 Mamata (R1) Jayprakash (R2) Laxmi (R3) Savitha (R4) Gnayaneshwar (R1) Son Omkareshwar (R1-B) SON Subhashchandra (R1-C) Husband #" "3* # )*+,-.)/0122)-,% 456$778$956$:565;<=:>?@48ABC<?8;@$;CC8':88 5; >00 >; @48 =598 >=:5;'57$9 56@:5'@ *BC<8 B9&$:<$D45'45;@B:;$:>68=:>?$ABC<?8;@$;CC8':88 5; >/00( >; @48 =598 >= 5E59 *BC<8 " 8;5>: 5E565>;# 8C$?48$C?5@@8C<8;8$9><F>=@487$:@586 56$6B;C8:G - 7 - 4$;C:$648H$: D$6 @48 7:>7>65@B6 $;C 48 C58C>;,000C?5@@8C9F484$C@D>D5E86;$?89F $:$6D$@5 @48 =5:6@ D5=8 D4> C58C >; (0( $;C B6459$ $5 @48 68'>;C D5=8 D4> $C?5@@8C9F ?$::58C 4$;C:$648H$: CB:5;< @48 6B&656@8;'8 >= @48 =5:6@ ?$::5$<84$6@D>'459C:8;=:>? 4$;C:$648H$: $E5;C:$ @48 6>; >= 4$;C:$648H$: $;C B6459$$55679$5;@5==>$;C$E5@$@48C$B<4@8:>= 4$;C:$648H$:$;C B6459$$55679$5;@5==> , 486B5@=>:7$:@5@5>;$;C687$:$@87>668665>;56 =598C $<$5;6@ '459C:8; >= 4$;C:$648H$: =:>? 456 =5:6@ D5=8 $:$6D$@5F@48@5?8@486B5@D$6=598C $:$6D$@5 D$6;>?>:8486B5@56C8':88C5;7$:@48@:5$9 >B:@ 489C @4$@ 79$5;@5==6 $:8 8;@5@98C @> 7$:@5@5>; $;C 687$:$@8 7>668665>; >= 0@4 64$:8 5; @48 6B5@ 9$;C &8$:5;< F>(, ?8$6B:5;< / $':86 0 <B;@$6 65@B$@8C $@ 8C$? - 8 - ( <<:58E8C&F@48$=>:8?8;@5>;8CABC<?8;@$;C C8':88@4879$5;@5==6=598C$778$95;>0048 6$5C $778$9 56 C56?5668C 8;'8 @48 7:868;@ 68'>;C $778$9 &F @48 >:5<5;$9 79$5;@5== 5; >/00( 456 68'>;C $778$9 D$6 $C?5@@8C >; 0, @> '>;65C8: @48=>99>D5;<6B&6@$;@5$9IB86@5>;6>=9$DG ! " # $$ " # " % & ' ( ) $ * + # ! ! ' !*, # ! -$ ./00 "! # * ! !1 % & ' ( ) $ * + ! ' " *#! # " ! *" ! -$ ./00 $! 2 3 % !!/ 41 / ; @48 =$'@6 $;C '5:'B?6@$;'86 D48@48: @48 :5$9 >B:@$;C@4815:6@77899$@8 >B:@$:8AB6@5=58C5;C8'95;5;<@48 :8958= >= 7$:@5@5>; $;C 687$:$@8 7>668665>; $99>@@5;< @48 64$:8 - 9 - D5@4@4879$5;@5==6"D4>$:8@48'459C:8;>=9$@8 4$;C:$648H$: =:>?45668'>;CD5=8#5;:8678'@>=@8?>6$;C(>= @486B5@6'48CB987:>78:@586J )*+,-.)/0122)-,(% % 456 $778$9 56 $:565;< =:>? @48 ABC<?8;@ $;C C8':885;>%00,>;@48=598>= 8;5>: 5E59*BC<8 8C$?D45'45;@B:;$:>68=:>?@48ABC<?8;@$;CC8':88 5; >-- >; @48 =598 >= 5E59 *BC<8 "*B;5>: 5E565>;# 8C$? 48 $=>:86$5C 6B5@ 56 =598C &F @48 '459C:8; >= 4$;C:$648H$: $;C $:$6D$@5 688H5;< $ :8958=>=C8'9$:$@5>;>=@5@98$;C5;AB;'@5>; - 48 6B5@ 56 =598C $<$5;6@ 4$;C:$648H$: @48 =$@48:$;C B6459$@4868'>;CD5=8486$5C6B5@56=598C5; :8678'@ >= @4:88 $<:5'B9@B:$9 9$;C6 &8$:5;< F >% ?8$6B:5;< ( $':86 <B;@$6 F >% ?8$6B:5;< , $':86 <B;@$6 &>@4 65@B$@8C $@ B:E$: E599$<8 $9BI 8C$? F>/?8$6B:5;<$':86,<B;@$665@B$@8C $@ $@@7$@$;$995$;C$96>>B68>%'>?7:565;<>=, - 10 - :>>?6@>D$:C6@48;>:@465@B$@8C$@ $@@7$@$;$99548 $=>:86$5C6B5@56C56?5668C 4879$5;@5==5;@486$5C6B5@=598C$778$95; >%00, $;C 6$5C $778$9 56 $99>D8C <:$;@5;< :8958= >= C8'9$:$@5>; >= @5@98 >D8E8: 5;AB;'@5>; 56 :8=B68C <<:58E8C&F @48C8':88<:$;@5;< C8'9$:$@5>;>= @5@98 @48 C8=8;C$;@65; >--$:8&8=>:8@456 >B:@ 0 48 15:6@ 77899$@8 >B:@ <:$;@8C :8958= >= C8'9$:$@5>;$;C:8=B68C:8958=>=5;AB;'@5>;>;@487:8?568 @4$@ 6>98 C8=8;C$;@ 4$C C58C CB:5;< @48 78;C8;'F >= @48 6B5@ $;C '$B68 >= $'@5>; @> 7:>68'B@8 @48 :8958= >= 5;AB;'@5>;C>86;>@6B:E5E8$<$5;6@@48'459C:8;>=@486>98 C8=8;C$;@D4>C58CCB:5;<@4878;C8;'F>=@486B5@ =@8: 48$:5;< &>@4 7$:@586 @456 >B:@ 56 >= @48 E58D @4$@ =>99>D5;< @D> 6B&6@$;@5$9 IB86@5>;6 >= 9$D $:8 :8IB5:8C@>&8=:$?8C$6B;C8: , # $, 5. !6 , ' - 11 - "! ! ! @ 56 $; $C?5@@8C =$'@ @4$@ =5:6@ D5=8 $;C 48: '459C:8;4$C=598C$6B5@5; >(-->;@48=598>= 5E59*BC<8*B;5>: 5E565>; 8C$?486$5C6B5@D$6=>: ?$5;@8;$;'8 48 6$5C 6B5@ D$6 C8':88C &$68C >; @48 '>;68;@<5E8;&FC8=8;C$;@ 4$;C:$648H$:D4>$<:88C @><5E8@4:88$<:5'B9@B:$99$;C6&8$:5;<6B:E8F>%% $;C / :8=8::8C @> $&>E8 $;C $96> >B68 7:>78:@F &8$:5;<>%:8=8::8C@>$&>E8@>D$:C6@48?$5;@8;$;'8 C?5@@8C9F $:$6D$@5 =5:6@ D5=8D$68;@5@98C@> ?$5;@8;$;'8 B;C8: 9$D $;C 48: 6>; 56 $96> 8;@5@98C @> ?$5;@8;$;'8 CB:5;< 456 ?5;>:5@F $;C @48 C$B<4@8: 56 8;@5@98C@>?$5;@8;$;'8@599@48C$@8>=?$::5$<8 , ; @8:?6 >= @48 C8':88 7$668C &F @48 >B:@ 5; >(-- @48 C8=8;C$;@ 56 C5:8'@8C @> 4$;C >E8: $=>:8?8;@5>;8C 7:>78:@586 48 79$5;@5==6 5; @48 6$5C 6B5@ =598C $; 8K8'B@5>; 7:>'88C5;<6 $;C @48 7>668665>; >= @48 7:>78:@F D$6 C895E8:8C 7B:6B$;@ @> @48 C8':88 7$668C 5; - 12 - >(-- 4B6 $:$6D$@5 =5:6@ D5=8 $;C 48: '459C:8;'$?85;9$D=B97>668665>;>=@487:>78:@F ( ; @48 6B5@ =>: 7$:@5@5>; =598C &F @48 79$5;@5==6 D4> $:8 @48 '459C:8; >= 68'>;C D5=8 5; >/00( @48 >B:@C8'95;8C@><:$;@@48:8958=>=7$:@5@5>;5;:8678'@ >=@487:>78:@586'>E8:8C5; >(--48 >B:@ 489C @4$@ @48 7:>78:@586 <5E8; @> $:$6D$@5 '$;;>@ &8 6B&A8'@?$@@8:>=7$:@5@5>;$6 $:$6D$@5$'IB5:8C$&6>9B@8 :5<4@ >E8:@487:>78:@FB;C8: 8'@5>; ,"#>= @485;CB B''8665>; '@ $;C '>;68IB8;@9F C56?5668C @48 6B5@ 5; :8678'@ >= 7:>78:@586 '>E8:8C $;C @48 C8':88 7$668C 5; >(-->D8E8:@486B5@56C8':88C5;:8678'@ >=7:>78:@F&8$:5;< B:E8F>(,?8$6B:5;</$':86 0<B;@$6D45'4D$6$C?5@@8C9F@486B&A8'@?$@@8:>=6B5@ 5; >(-- / 8$:;8C'>B;689$778$:5;<=>:@48$77899$;@65; >%0(-0 D>B9C 6B&?5@ @4$@ 8'@5>; ,"# '$;;>@ &8 $77958C 5; :8678'@ >= 8;@5:8 8K@8;@ >= 9$;C '>E8:8C 5; >(-- >; @48 7:8?568 @4$@ 8'@5>; - 13 - ,"#D>B9C$779F>;9F5;:8678'@>= $:$6D$@5L67:>78:@F $;C ;>@ 5; :8678'@ >= '459C:8;L6 7:>78:@F @ 56 456 '>;@8;@5>;@4$@'459C:8;4$E8$@@$5;8C?$A>:5@F4B6@48 7:>78:@586 <5E8; @>'459C:8; >= 4$;C:$648H$: @>D$:C6 ?$5;@8;$;'8 $:8 95$&98 =>: 7$:@5@5>; $;C 79$5;@5==6 58 @48 '459C:8;>=68'>;CD5=8$:88;@5@98C@>'9$5?64$:85;5@@ 56456=B:@48:'>;@8;@5>;@4$@>;'8@48'459C:8;$@@$5;@48 $<8 >= ?$A>:5@F @48 7:>78:@F <5E8; @> '459C:8; @>D$:C6 ?$5;@8;$;'8D>B9C<>@>@48=$@48: 4$;C:$648H$:$;C $=@8: @48 C8$@4 >= 4$;C:$648H$: @48 '459C:8; $:8 8;@5@98C@>@4864$:8 % 8$:;8C'>B;689$778$:5;<=>:@48:867>;C8;@6 >;@48>@48:4$;CD>B9C'>;@8;C@4$@@487:>78:@F<5E8; @>=5:6@D5=8$;C'459C:8;64>B9C&89>;<@>=5:6@D5=8$6648 D$65;7>668665>;>=@487:>78:@F$;C 8'@5>;,"#D>B9C $779F $;C 648 D>B9C $'IB5:8 $&6>9B@8 @5@98 >E8: @48 7:>78:@F'>E8:8CB;C8:C8':886B5@5; >(-- - 456 >B:@ 4$6 '>;65C8:8C @48 '>;@8;@5>;6 :$568C$@@48&$:$;C78:B68C@48:8'>:C6 - 14 - C?5@@8C9F D48; 6B5@ D$6 =598C 5; >(-- '459C:8; =:>? @48 =5:6@ D5=8 58 '459C:8; >= $:$6D$@5 D8:8 ?5;>:6 $;C $:$6D$@5 $;C '459C:8; D8:8 8;@5@98C@>?$5;@8;$;'8;'8@48'459C:8;$@@$5;@48$<8 >=?$A>:5@F@48F9>68@48:5<4@>=?$5;@8;$;'8>D8E8: @48 C8':88 C>86 ;>@ 6$F @4$@ $=@8: @48 '459C:8; $@@$5; ?$A>:5@F@48 7:>7>:@5>;$@88K@8;@>=@487:>78:@F64>B9C :8E8:@@>@48=$@48: 4$;C:$648H$:48C8':88>;5@6 79$5;:8$C5;<D>B9C6B<<86@@4$@ $:$6D$@5D$68;@5@98C@> :8@$5;@487:>78:@FD5@4>B@$;F:86@:5'@5>;6;C8:@4868 '5:'B?6@$;'86@48:8IB5:8?8;@>= 8'@5>;,"#>=5;CB B''8665>; '@ (/ 56 ?8@ $6 @48 7:>78:@F 56 <5E8; @> $:$6D$@5 5; :8'><;5@5>; >= 48: :5<4@ @> ?$5;@8;$;'8 $;C 648 D$6 7B@ 5; 7>668665>; >= @48 7:>78:@F $;C 48: 7>668665>;569$D=B9456 &85;< @48 7>65@5>; @48 '>;@8;@5>; @4$@ 7:>7>:@5>;$@8 8K@8;@ >= 7:>78:@F <5E8; @> @48'459C:8;:8E8:@@>@48=$@48:'$;;>@&8$''87@8C@56 ;>@@48@8;>:>=@48C8':885; >(-- - 15 - 0 1>: @48 $=>:86$5C :8$6>;6 @48 :5$9 >B:@ $;C @48 15:6@ 77899$@8 >B:@ D8:8 AB6@5=58C 5; C56?5665;< @48 6B5@5;:8678'@>=@487:>78:@586'>E8:8C5;C8':885; >(-- 6=$:$6@487:>78:@F5;&8$:5;< F>(, 56 '>;'8:;8C @48 :5$9 >B:@ 4$6 <:$;@8C $ C8':88 =>: 7$:@5@5>; $;C @48 =5:6@ $77899$@8 >B:@ 4$6 '>;=5:?8C @48 6$5C ABC<?8;@ $;C C8':88 >D8E8: 4$;C:$648H$: C58C>; ,000 4$;C:$648H$: D$6 $96> 8;@5@98C @> 64$:85;@486$5C 7:>78:@F > =$: $6 F >(,56 '>;'8:;8C@48C8':88=>:7$:@5@5>;56<:$;@8C5;:8678'@>= 8;@5:8 / $':86 0 <B;@$6 48 @:5$9 >B:@ $;C 15:6@ 77899$@8 >B:@ 4$E8 $96> 489C @4$@ '459C:8; @4:>B<4 68'>;C D5=8 58 79$5;@5== 5; >-- $:8 $96> 8;@5@98C @> 64$:8 5; @48 7:>78:@F 4B6 @456 >B:@ C>86 ;>@=5;C$;F5;=5:?5@F @ 56 :898E$;@ @> ;>@8 @4$@ @48 C8=8;C$;@6 5; >/00( 4$E8 @$H8; $ 6@$;C @4$@ @48 7:>78:@F &8$:5;<>(,?8$6B:5;</$':860<B;@$656@48689= - 16 - $'IB5:8C 7:>78:@F >= $:$6D$@5 456 '>;@8;@5>; D$6 ;8<$@5E8C&F@48:5$9 >B:@4>9C5;<@4$@@486$5C7:>78:@F 56 @48 7:>78:@F 7B:'4$68C &F 4$;C:$648H$: 5; @48 ;$?8>=456D5=8 $:$6D$@5 8$:;8C '>B;689 $778$:5;< =>: @48 $77899$;@6 '4$998;<5;<@486$5C=5;C5;<D>B9C'>;@8;C@4$@ $:$6D$@5 C5C ;>@ 4$E8 $;F ?8$;6 $;C 58 &>:;8 >B@ =:>? @48 C8':885; >(--D48:8648D$6<5E8;7:>78:@F @56$96>456=B:@48:'>;@8;@5>;@4$@:8'>:C>=:5<4@66@>>C 5; @48 ;$?8 >= 4$;C:$648H$: C8675@8 @48 6$98 C88C &85;< 5; @48 ;$?8 >= $:$6D$@5 >:?$99F @48 >B:@ D>B9C ;>@ $@@$'4 ?B'4 5?7>:@$;'8 @> @48 8;@:586 5; @48 :8'>:C6 >= :5<4@6 B;9866 5@ 56 6B77>:@8C &F @48 E$95C ?B@$@5>;>:@5@98C88C6;@48'$68>;4$;C@4865@B$@5>; 56 C5==8:8;@ @ 56 &>:;8 >B@ =:>? @48 :8'>:C6 @4$@ $:$6D$@5 C5C ;>@ 7>66866 ?8$;6 @> 7B:'4$68 @48 7:>78:@F 48:8$6 4$;C:$648H$: 48: 4B6&$;C C5C 7>66866?8$;6@>7B:'4$68@487:>78:@F$648D$64>9C5;< - 17 - >@48:=>B:7:>78:@586D45'4484$6@:$;6=8::8C7B:6B$;@@> C8':885; >(-- , ;C8: @4868 '5:'B?6@$;'86 @48 8;@:F 5; @48 :8'>:C>=:5<4@D>B9C6B<<86@@4$@@487:>78:@FD$65;C88C 7B:'4$68C &F 4$;C:$648H$: $;C 48 7>668668C @48 7:>78:@F$;C456D5=8 $:$6D$@5D$6>;9F$;$?898;C8: 456&85;<@487>65@5>;@48=5;C5;<>=@48@:5$9 >B:@@4$@ @487:>78:@F56@48689=$'IB5:8C7:>78:@F>=@48 $:$6D$@5 4$6 @> &8 :8A8'@8C $;C 5@ 56 @> &8 '>;6@:B8C $6 @48 689= $'IB5:8C7:>78:@F>= 4$;C:$648H$: 48;@4$@56@48 7>65@5>; $=@8: @48 C8?568 >= 4$;C:$648H$: $99 456 '459C:8; =:>? =5:6@ D5=8 $;C $99 456 '459C:8; =:>? 68'>;C D5=8$:88;@5@98C@>8IB$964$:8 ( 8;'88$'4>=@4879$5;@5==5; >/00( 56 8;@5@98C @> /@4 64$:8 5; @48 7:>78:@F &8$:5;< F >(, ?8$6B:5;< / $':86 0 <B;@$6 $;C 8$'4 >=456 '459C:8; =:>? @48 =5:6@ D5=8 56 8;@5@98C @> /@4 64$:8 > @4$@8K@8;@@48:5$9 >B:@$;C15:6@77899$@8 >B:@4$E8 '>??5@@8C$;8::>: - 18 - / 6 =$: $6 >/%-00% D48:85; @48 79$5;@5==6 6>B<4@ C8'9$:$@5>; @4$@ @48F $:8 @48 >D;8:6 >= @487:>78:@F'>E8:8C5; >(--56'>;'8:;8C@48 7:>78:@586$:8489C@>&8@487:>78:@586>= $:$6D$@5$;C $:$6D$@556;>?>:8$;C48:'459C:8;$:87:>68'B@5;<@48 6B5@ $;C @48F $:8 C8'9$:8C @> &8 @48 >D;8:6 >= @48 7:>78:@F 456 >B:@ C>86 ;>@ =5;C $;F 8::>: 5; @48 6$5C ABC<?8;@ $6 '459C:8; =:>? @48 68'>;C D5=8 >= 4$;C:$648H$:C>;>@5;48:5@$;F64$:8>:$;F:5<4@5; @487:>78:@586489C&F $:$6D$@5 % 6 =$: $6 :8958= >= 5;AB;'@5>; 56 '>;'8:;8C @48 15:6@ 77899$@8 >B:@ 4$6 :5<4@9F :8A8'@8C @48 :8958= >= 5;AB;'@5>;>;@487:8?568@4$@@48>:5<5;$9C8=8;C$;@56;> ?>:8$;C@48'$B68>=$'@5>;$&$@86$<$5;6@@48C8=8;C$;@ D4>C58CCB:5;<@4878;C8;'F>=@486B5@ - 8;'8 @48:8 56 ;> ?8:5@ 5; @48 $778$9 5; >/%-00%$;C@486$?84$6@>&8C56?5668C 8;'8@48=>99>D5;<G - 19 - i) >%0(-056 ii) 48 5?7B<;8C ABC<?8;@ $;C C8':88 C$@8C 000 7$668C 5; >/00( >; @48 =598 >= 5E59 *BC<8 " 8;5>: 5E565>;#$@ 8C$?$:8?>C5=58C iii) 48 5?7B<;8C ABC<?8;@ $;C C8':88 C$@8C -0 7$668C 5; >00 $:8 ?>C5=58C $'4 >= @48 79$5;@5==6 5; >/00( 56 8;@5@98C @> /@4 64$:8 5; 7:>78:@F &8$:5;< F >(, ?8$6B:5;< / $':86 0 <B;@$665@B$@8C5; 8C$? iv) $'4 >= @48 '459C:8; >= $:$6D$@5 $5 56 8;@5@98C @> /@4 64$:8 5; @48 7:>78:@F &8$:5;< F >(, ?8$6B5;< / $':86 0<B;@$665@B$@8C5; 8C$? v) 486B5@5; >/00(5;:8678'@>= :8?$5;5;<7:>78:@58656 - 20 - vi) 8<B9$: 8'>;C778$9>/%-00%56 vii) 4:88 78:6>;6 D4> '9$5?8C @> &8 @48 656@8:6 >= 4$;C:$648H$: 4$E8 =598C $; $7795'$@5>;&8=>:8@456 >B:@@>'>?8>; :8'>:C >; @48 7:8?568 @4$@ @48 7:>78:@5865;E>9E8C5;@4868@D>$778$96 $:8 @48 $;'86@:$9 7:>78:@586 >= 4$;C:$648H$: $6 6B'4 @48F $:8 $96> ;8'866$:F7$:@F@>@48687:>'88C5;<6 viii) 48@48: @48 $7795'$;@6 D4> 4$E8 '>?8 >;:8'>:CD4>'9$5?8C@>&8@48656@8:6 >= 4$;C:$648H$: $:8 8;@5@98C @> 64$:8 5; @48 7:>78:@586 >: ;>@ 56 C878;C8;@ >; E$:5>B6 =$'@>:6 ;$?89F " ! " # ' $;C @4>68 IB86@5>;6 '$;;>@ &8 C8'5C8C 5; @4868 $778$96 - 21 - 8;'895&8:@F56:868:E8C@>@4878:6>;6 D4> '9$5?8C @> &8 @48 656@8:6 >= 4$;C:$648H$: @> '9$5? 64$:8 5= $E$59$&98$;C$6$CE568C5;9$D ix) @ 56 =B:@48: ?$C8 '98$: @4$@ $;F >&68:E$@5>;6?$C85;@4868$778$9664$99 ;>@ &8 B68C $<$5;6@ @48 78:6>;6 D4> '9$5?8C @> &8 @48 656@8:6 >= 4$;C:$648H$: = $;F 6B5@ 56 =598C &F 78:6>;6 '9$5?5;< @> &8 @48 656@8:6 >= 4$;C:$648H$: 6$?8 4$6 @> &8 $CABC5'$@8C D5@4>B@ :8=8:8;'8 @> @48 >&68:E$@5>;6?$C85;@4868$778$96 x) B&6@$;@5$9 IB86@5>;6 >= 9$D $;6D8:8C $''>:C5;<9F 1% $ " & # 56@> 9>,-