- 1 - !"# $ %&$ %&!&"! $$ '"( )* $$ + '"( ) * !"#$ % & '( " ) # ")## &( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ * ##$+ % & ,$- $#$#$$" ,,( , , ".)&"( , , #$#"$#$" )+$#" , , , ' ).###/ ,0 , +) * $. & ( !$"" % & '( " ) - 3 - # ")## &( $ * ##$+ % & ,$- $#$#$$" ,,( , , ".)&"( , , #$#"$#$"+#!$#" , , , ' "++++#/ ,0 , , 1 1 - 4 - & &1 ( , 2$## + $#$" 345 6778 9:;7< =8<7> 7?@:28 ".)&"(292@2>73:?;75?@"+ &37>7:849@7>>797>>7<@2 45A@37?@0(6B@37?;4:C48@:82 )+$#"92>@37 <74@3 29 <7?7457< :D4C64> 48< , 2$##+!)$#$" 34567789:;7<6B@37?;4:C48@:82+#!$#"67:8D 4DD>:7E7< 6B @37 ?2CC28 F=<DC78@ 48< 4G4>< <4@7< #$#"$#$"H4557<6B@37<<:@:284;78:2>:E:;=<D7 48< 7C67> ' :F4B4H=>4 &92> 532>@ A@37 >:6=84;0( $ 37 6>:79 94?@5 D:E:8D >:57 @2 @37 9:;:8D 29 @37 4HH74;5 4>7 @34@ 28 $"#$#" 4@ 462=@ +)# <7?7457< :D4C64> G45 >:<:8D @37 C2@2>?B?;7 674>:8D >7D:5@>4@:28 2/")/#.) 4;28D G:@3 484><348 &?;4:C48@ :8 2+#!$#"( @2 48D4>7 7@>2; H=CH ;2?4@7<287D428/48D4;G7<4>24<874>@37;48<29287 4HH= =D4> 48< 2=>: 4>4;7 4@ @34@ @:C7 4 7CH2 674>:8D 7D2/"$/"$$$ ?4C7 9>2C - 5 - 2HH25:@7 5:<7 <>:E78 6B :@5 <>:E7> :8 3:D3 5H77< 48< :8 4 >45348<87D;:D78@C4887><4537<@2@37C2@2>?B?;75 4 >75=;@ 29 @37 492>754:< 4??:<78@ :D4C64> 5=5@4:87< D>:7E2=5 :8F=>:75 48< 5=??=C67< @2 @37 :8F=>:75 48< 484><348 5=5@4:87< D>:7E2=5 :8F=>:75 48< G45 325H:@4;:I7< ) 37?;4:C48@59:;7<H7@:@:285=8<7>7?@:28"!! 29@37?@577J:8D?2CH7854@:28@G45H;74<7<@34@@37B 5H78@ 3=D7 4C2=8@ @2G4><5 C7<:?4; 7KH78575 ?28E7B48?79=87>4;7@? 857>E:?72982@:?7>75H28<78@2$4HH74>7< @3>2=D3 ?2=857; 48< 9:;7< G>:@@78 5@4@7C78@ :8 G3:?3 @37 4E7>C78@5C4<7:8@37H7@:@:285G7>7<78:7<75H28<78@ 2"<:<82@4HH74>6792>7@37>:6=84;:85H:@72957>E:?7 2982@:?748<G45H;4?7<7K/H4>@7 8 @37 645:5 29 H;74<:8D5 29 @37 H4>@:75 @37 ;4:C5>:6=84;9>4C7<@37:55=7548<@37>749@7>>7?2><7< @377E:<78?737C2@37>29@37<7?7457<G457K4C:87< - 6 - 45 /$@37:8F=>7<?;4:C48@G457K4C:87<45 /"48< D2@ 7K3:6:@7< <2?=C78@5 84C7;B K" @2 K" 8 6734;929@37>75H28<78@2$287G:@8755G457K4C:87< 45 /" 48< D2@ 7K3:6:@7< <2?=C78@5 84C7;B K" @2 K 37 ;4:C5 >:6=84; 6B @37 :CH=D87< F=<DC78@ 37;<@34@@374??:<78@@22JH;4?7284??2=8@29 >453 48<87D;:D78@ <>:E:8D 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 6B :@5 <>:E7>454>75=;@29G3:?3@37?;4:C48@5=5@4:87<:8F=>:75 48<@37<74@329:D4C64>37>:6=84;9=>@37>37;<@34@ @37 ?;4:C48@ :8 2 )+$#" :5 78@:@;7< @2 ?2CH7854@:28 29 5." ###/ 48< @37 ?;4:C48@ :8 2+#!$#" :5 78@:@;7< @2 D;264; ?2CH7854@:28 29 5####/4;28DG:@3:8@7>75@4@@37>4@729!LH448< <:>7?@7<>75H28<78@2"/2G87>29@3729978<:8DE73:?;7@2 H4B ?2CH7854@:28 4C2=8@ 4;28D G:@3 :8@7>75@ @2 @37 ?;4:C48@57:8D4DD>:7E7<@37574HH74;534E767789:;7< 6B@37?;4:C48@5577J:8D78348?7C78@ ! 37;74>87<?2=857;4HH74>:8D92>@37?;4:C48@5 345>4:57<@3792;;2G:8D?28@78@:28 - 7 - 7D7D;:D78?7 &:(374??:<78@2??=>>7<<=7@2@3752;787D;:D78?7 29 @37 <>:E7> 29 @37 7CH2 674>:8D >7D:5@>4@:28 2/ "$/"$$$ G3:?3 ?4C7 :8 >453 48< 87D;:D78@ C4887> G:@33:D35H77<48<<4537<4D4:85@@37<7?7457<G32G45 >:<:8D@37C2@2>?B?;7674>:8D7D2/")/#.) 7 9=>@37> ?28@78<7< @34@ :CC7<:4@7;B 49@7> @37 4??:<78@ 4 ?2CH;4:8@ 345 6778 ;2<D7< 4D4:85@ @37 <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8DE73:?;737H2;:?734E7>7D:5@7>7<@37,48< 49@7>@32>2=D3:8E75@:D4@:289:;7<@37?34>D75377@4D4:85@ @37<>:E7>29@3729978<:8DE73:?;72H>2E7@37?457@37 ?;4:C48@5:862@3@37?457534E767787K4C:87<45 5" 48<$ ":5@377B7G:@8755G32:54;52H>2?77<:8D45 H:;;:28>:<7>28@3754:<C2@2>?B?;77345?4@7D2>:?4;;B 5@4@7< @34@ 4??:<78@ 2??=>>7< <=7 @2 87D;:D78?7 29<>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 2 <:5H>2E7 @37 7E:<78?7 29 ?;4:C48@5>75H28<78@2$34582@7K4C:87<48BG:@8755 K?7H@7K4C:8:8D:@5299:?:4;@37B34E782@7K4C:87<@37 <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 37>792>7 @37 >:6=84; - 8 - 345 >:D3@;B 37;< @34@ <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 :5 87D;:D78@:8?4=5:8D@374??:<78@ 7D=48@=C:82 )+$#" &:(,:>5@;B@37?;4:C48@?;4:C5@34@@37<7?7457<G45 4D7< 462=@ $ B74>5 48< G45 74>8:8D 5"###/ H7> C28@36B<2:8D6=5:8755=@@37>:6=84;:582@F=5@:9:7< :8 @4J:8D @37 C28@3;B :8?2C7 29 @37 <7?7457< 45 28;B 5!###/ &::( 7?28<;B 45 H7> @37 ;4G ;4:< <2G8 6B @37 =H>7C72=>@:8@37?45729 >7H2>@7< :8 #L 29 @37 75@46;:537< :8?2C7 :5 @2 67 4<<7< @2G4><5 A9=@=>7 H>25H7?@50 37 54C7 C4B 67 ?285:<7>7<78?737H>4B592>4;;2G:8D@374HH74; 7D=48@=C:82+#!$#" &:( ,:>5@;B <=7 @2 @37 4??:<78@ @37 ?;4:C48@ 345 5=997>7<:8F=>:7573455=997>7<9>4?@=>729@:6:448<37 G45 :8H4@:78@ 92> 4 H7>:2< 29 # <4B5 37 D;264; - 9 - ?2CH7854@:28 29 5####/ 4G4><7< 6B @37 >:6=84; :5 28 @37 ;2G7> 5:<7 378?7 37 52=D3@ 92> 78348?7C78@ 29 ?2CH7854@:28 . !" ;74>87< ?2=857; 92> @37 85=>48?7 2CH48B345>4:57<@3792;;2G:8D?28@78@:285 7D7D;:D78?7 &:( 37 >:<7> 29 @37 C2@2>?B?;7 G45 >:<:8D @37 C2@2>?B?;7:8>45348<87D;:D78@C4887>G:@33:D35H77< 48< <4537< @2 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 45 4 >75=;@ @37 4??:<78@ 345 2??=>>7< 37 >:<7> 29 @37 C2@2>?B?;7 4;52 ?28@>:6=@7< @2 @37 4??:<78@ 37 >:6=84; 345 7>>7< :8 32;<:8D@34@<>:E7>29@3722<57CH24;287:587D;:D78@ :8?4=5:8D@374??:<78@37>792>737?28@78<7<@34@@37 <7?7457< >:<7> 29 @37 C2@2>?B?;7 G45 4;52 87D;:D78@ :8 ?4=5:8D@374??:<78@ 7D=48@=C:82 )+$#" E78 @32=D3 @37 ?;4:C48@ ?;4:C5 @34@ @37 <7?7457<G4574>8:8D5"###/H7>C28@3@3754C7:5 - 10 - 82@75@46;:537<6B@37?;4:C48@6BH>2<=?:8D<2?=C78@5 37>792>7 @37 >:6=84; 345 >:D3@;B 4557557< @37 C28@3;B :8?2C729@37<7?7457<4@5!###/82@:284;;B &:( 7?28<;B 5:8?7 @37 ?;4:C48@ 345 82@ 75@46;:537< @37:8?2C729@37<7?7457<@37>:6=84;>:D3@;B37;<@34@ @37 ?;4:C48@ :5 82@ 78@:@;7< 92> ?2CH7854@:28 @2G4><5 A9=@=>7H>25H7?@50 &::(3:><;B284HH>7?:4@:28292>4;48<<2?=C78@4>B 7E:<78?7 48< ?285:<7>:8D @37 4D7 48< 4E2?4@:28 29 @37 <7?7457< @37 2E7>4;; ?2CH7854@:28 4G4><7< 6B @37 >:6=84; :5 F=5@ 48< >7452846;7 78?7 37 52=D3@ 92> <:5C:554;29@374HH74; 7D=48@=C:82+#!$#" &:(37:8F=>:755=997>7<6B@37?;4:C48@4>7C:82>:8 84@=>7734582@7K4C:87<@37<2?@2>285:<7>:8D@37 84@=>7 29 :8F=>:75 5=5@4:87< 6B @37 :8F=>7< ?;4:C48@ @37 D;264; ?2CH7854@:28 4G4><7< 6B @37 >:6=84; :5 F=5@ 48< >7452846;748<:@<27582@>7M=:>748B78348?7C78@ - 11 - 7D :46:;:@B + 74>87<?2=857;92>@3785=>48?72CH48B345 ?28@78<7< @34@ 4@ @37 @:C7 29 4??:<78@ @37 <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 G45 82@ 32;<:8D 4 E4;:< 48< 7997?@:E7 <>:E:8D ;:?78?7 5 5=?3 @37 :85=>7< 345 E:2;4@7< @37 H2;:?B?28<:@:2837>792>7@3785=>48?72CH48B:582@ ;:46;7@2H4B48B?2CH7854@:2837>:6=84;345>:D3@;B 7K287>4@7< @37 85=>48?7 2CH48B 9>2C H4B:8D @37 ?2CH7854@:28 "# 74>< @37 ;74>87< ?2=857; 92> @37 H4>@:75 48< H7>=57<@37>7?2><5 "" @ :5 @37 ?457 29 @37 ?;4:C48@5 @34@ 28 $"#$#"4@462=@+)#@37<7?7457<:D4C64>G45 >:<:8D @37 C2@2>?B?;7 674>:8D >7D:5@>4@:28 2/")/ #.) 4;28DG:@34H:;;:28>:<7>484><348&?;4:C48@:8 2+#!$#"( @2G4><5 48D4>7 7@>2; =CH 28 :>4F >255 >24< 287D428/48D4;G7<424<4@ @34@ @:C7 4 @>=?J674>:8D>7D:5@>4@:282/"$/"$$$67:8D<>:E78 - 12 - 6B:@5<>:E7>4@43:D35H77<48<:84>45348<87D;:D78@ C4887> <4537< @2 @37 C2@2>?B?;7 5 4 >75=;@ 29 @37 492>754:< 4??:<78@ :D4C64> 5=5@4:87< D>:7E2=5 :8F=>:75 48< 5=??=C67< @2 @37 :8F=>:75 48< 484><348 5=5@4:87< D>:7E2=5:8F=>:7548<G45325H:@4;:I7< "$ 2 H>2E7 @37 ?457 ?;4:C48@5 34E7 7K4C:87< >:484><348 45 /" G:97 29 <7?7457< C@:C4;4 45 /$48<H>2<=?7<"<2?=C78@575H28<78@2$345 7K4C:87< 48 299:?7> 29 @37 85=>48?7 2CH48B 45 /" 48<H>2<=?7<#<2?=C78@58@37:>7E:<78?7@37B34E7 ?4@7D2>:?4;;B5@4@7<@34@@37<>:E7>29@3729978<:8DE73:?;7 G45 87D;:D78@ :8 ?4=5:8D @37 4??:<78@ 37 <>:E7> G45 <>:E:8D@3729978<:8D7CH2:8>45348<87D;:D78@C4887> G:@33:D35H77<48<<4537<4D4:85@@37C2@2>?B?;729@37 <7?7457< CC7<:4@7;B 49@7> @37 4??:<78@ @37B 34E7 ;2<D7< @37 ?2CH;4:8@ 4D4:85@ @37 <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 37 H2;:?7 49@7> @32>2=D3 :8E75@:D4@:28 9:;7< @37 ?34>D7 5377@ 4D4:85@ @37 <>:E7> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 " G32 :5 48 7B7G:@8755 345 ?4@7D2>:?4;;B 5@4@7< @34@ - 13 - @37<>:E7>29@3729978<:8D7CH2G45<>:E:8D@37E73:?;7 :8>45348<87D;:D78@C4887>2<:5H>2E7@377E:<78?729 ?;4:C48@5>75H28<78@2$34582@7K4C:87<<>:E7>29@37 29978<:8D 7CH2 37B 34E7 7K4C:87< @37 299:?7> 29 85=>48?7 2CH48B 45 " E78 :8 @37 ?>255/ 7K4C:84@:28 29 5" 48< $ 82@3:8D G2>@3G3:;7 :892>C4@:28 :5 7;:?:@7< B ?285:<7>:8D @37 7E:<78?7 29 5"48<$,&K"(?2CH;4:8@&K$(48?3484C4 &K)(48<?34>D75377@&K!(@37>:6=84;345>:D3@;B ?2C7@2@37?28?;=5:28@34@4??:<78@3452??=>>7<<=7@2 87D;:D78?729<>:E7>297CH2674>:8D7D2/"$/ "$$$ 7D=48@=C:82 )+$#" ") 37 ?;4:C48@ ?;4:C5 @34@ <7?7457< :D4C64> G4574>8:8D5"###/H7>C28@36B<2:8D6=5:8755=@ 537 345 82@ H>2<=?7< 48B <2?=C78@ @2 H>2E7 @37 54C7 8@3746578?729H>22929:8?2C7@3782@:284;:8?2C7345 @2 67 4557557< 5 H7> @37 D=:<7;:875 :55=7< 6B @37 4>84@4J4@4@7 7D4;7>E:?75=@32>:@B92>@374??:<78@ - 14 - @4J78H;4?7 :8@37 B74> $#" @3782@:284; :8?2C7 29 @37 <7?7457< 345 @2 67 @4J78 4@ 5 ###/ HC 2 @37 492>754:< :8?2C7 #L 345 @2 67 4<<7< 28 4??2=8@ 29 9=@=>7 H>25H7?@5 :8 E:7G 29 @37 ;4G ;4:< <2G8 6B @37 285@:@=@:2878?329@37=H>7C72=>@:8 &5=H>4(3=5@37C28@3;B:8?2C7?2C75@25""$##/ :8?7 @37 <7?7457< G45 4 64?37;2> :@ :5 4HH>2H>:4@7 @2 <7<=?@ #L 29 @37 :8?2C7 29 @37 <7?7457< @2G4><5 H7>5284;7KH7857548<>7C4:8:8D4C2=8@:75!##/ 345 @2 67 @4J78 45 3:5 ?28@>:6=@:28 @2 @37 94C:;B 37 <7?7457< G45 4D7< 462=@ $ B74>5 4@ @37 @:C7 29 @37 4??:<78@48<C=;@:H;:7>4HH;:?46;7@23:54D7D>2=H:5A" 0 3=5 @37 ?;4:C48@ :5 78@:@;7< @2 ?2CH7854@:28 29 5"$#+!##/ &5!##N"$N" ( 28 4??2=8@ 29 A;255 29 <7H78<78?B0 " 8 4<<:@:28 @37 ?;4:C48@ :5 78@:@;7< @2 ?2CH7854@:28295"###/284??2=8@29A;2552975@4@70 48< ?2CH7854@:28 29 5"###/ 28 4??2=8@ 29 A9=87>4; 7KH785750 - 15 - " 8 E:7G 29 @37 ;4G ;4:< <2G8 6B @37 =H>7C7 2=>@ :8 @37 ?45729 #$% & '! "( )*+ ' % ,',' % ( , -. / .0 ?;4:C48@ :7 C2@37> 29 @37 <7?7457< :5 78@:@;7< 92> ?2CH7854@:28 29 5####/ =8<7> @37 374< 29 A;255 29 9:;:4;?2852>@:=C0 "! 3=5@37?;4:C48@54>778@:@;7<@2@3792;;2G:8D ?2CH7854@:28 2CH7854@:28=8<7> <:997>78@74<5 C2=8@:8 &5( 25529<7H78<78?B "$#+!## ,=87>4;7KH78575 "### 2552975@4@7 "### 25529,:;:4;?2852>@:=C #### 2@4; "$.+!## ". 37?;4:C48@:578@:@;7<@2@2@4;?2CH7854@:2829 5"$.+!##/ 45 4D4:85@ 5." ###/ 4G4><7< 6B @37 >:6=84; - 16 - 7D=48@=C:82+#!$#" " @ :5 82@ :8 <:5H=@7 @34@ @37 ?;4:C48@ 345 5=5@4:87< :8F=>:75 :8 @37 >24<@>499:? 4??:<78@<=7 @2>453 48< 87D;:D78@ <>:E:8D 29 @37 7CH2 37 ?;4:C48@ 345 5=997>7< 9>4?@=>7 29 @:6:4 48< 9:6=;4 48< >:D3@ ?28@=5:28 >:D3@92>74>C48<2@37>:8F=>:754;;2E7>@3762<B7345 82@7K4C:87<@37<2?@2>285:<7>:8D@37C7<:?4;>7?2><5 48< :8F=>:75 5=997>7< 6B @37 ?;4:C48@ G7 4>7 29 @37 2H:8:28 @34@ @37 D;264; ?2CH7854@:28 29 5####/ 4G4><7< 6B @37 >:6=84; :5 >7M=:>7< @2 67 78348?7< @2 5"#####/ 4;28D G:@3 :8@7>75@ 4@ @37 >4@7 29 !L H7> 488=C "+ @:582@:8<:5H=@7@34@<>:E7>29@3729978<:8D E73:?;7G4587D;:D78@:8?4=5:8D@374??:<78@7G4582@ 34E:8D4E4;:<48<7997?@:E7<>:E:8D;:?78?74528@37<4@7 @2 <>:E7 @37 54:< E73:?;7 37 :85=>7< 345 E:2;4@7< @37 H2;:?B ?28<:@:28 37>792>7 @37 >:6=84; 345 >:D3@;B 7K287>4@7< @37 85=>48?7 2CH48B 9>2C H4BC78@ 29 ?2CH7854@:283754:<F=<DC78@:582@?34;;78D7<6B@37 - 17 - 2G87> 29 @37 29978<:8D E73:?;7 37 2G87> :5 57>E7< 6792>7 @37 >:6=84; 45 G7;; 45 6792>7 @3:5 2=>@ 78?7 >75H28<78@2":557>E7<48<=8>7H>7578@7< $# 8E:7G29F=<DC78@29@372806;7H7K2=>@ :8@37?4572911'( ,*"(2'%%3 ( ", -4.56 .0 >75H28<78@ 2$ :5 <:>7?@7< @2 H4B @37 ?2CH7854@:28 4C2=8@ G:@3 ;:67>@B @2 >7?2E7>@3754C79>2C@372G87>29@3729978<:8DE73:?;7 $" ??2><:8D;BG7H455@3792;;2G:8D2><7> &:(374HH74;54>7"7(1 &::( 37 F=<DC78@5 29 @37 ;4:C5 >:6=84; :5 C2<:9:7< &:::( 37 ?;4:C48@ :8 , 2$## + $#$" :5 78@:@;7< @2 ?2CH7854@:28 4C2=8@ 29 5"$.+!##/ 45 4D4:85@ 5." ###/ 4G4><7<6B@37>:6=84; - 18 - &:E( 37 ?;4:C48@5 :8 , 2$##+!)$#$" :5 78@:@;7< @2 4 @2@4; ?2CH7854@:28 29 5"#####/ 45 4D4:85@ 5####/ 4G4><7<6B@37>:6=84; &E( 37 85=>48?7 2CH48B :5 <:>7?@7< @2 <7H25:@ @37 78@:>7 ?2CH7854@:28 4C2=8@ 4;28D G:@3 :8@7>75@ 4@ !L :8 62@3 @37 4HH74;5 G:@3:8 4 H7>:2< 29 5:K G77J5 9>2C @37<4@729>7?7:H@29?2HB29@3:5F=<DC78@ G:@3 ;:67>@B @2 >7?2E7> @37 54C7 9>2C @37 2G87>29@3729978<:8DE73:?;7 ,) '$( & ,) '!&"!( & :5@2";2