- 1 - !"! #"$$ %% &$' ( ! " #$ $ % & ' $ ( $ ) $)* +))* , $ +! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - - , + , ( $ ) $)* !) , . + , /)0) ( % - $ $ $ $ +! , % % ! " #$ % ( . , & ( ( *#&( ( , $ ( % , 0! ! $ ) % !0 (% ( ( % , 1$ % - 3 - " 23452 677869 :; 9:;<8= >3? 6=@:;;:3A B:<2 C3A;8A< 3> 986?A8=C34A;89>3?76?<:8;:<:;<6D8A47>3?>:A69=:;73;69 26998A5:A5E4=5@8A<6A=6B6?==6<8=0! ! 76;;8= FG )==:<:3A69 :;<?:C< 6A= 8;;:3A; %4=58 6:C24? #>3?;23?<H?:F4A69I&:A A3!0<2:;677869:;>:98= ?: $6;6J6?6E 6<2 986?A8= C34A;89 ;4F@:<<8= 677869 B6; FG C96:@6A< >3? 8A26AC8@8A< 3> C3@78A;6<:3A < B6; ;4F@:<<8= 6< 0! 6@ 3A !!!0 B28A C96:@6A< B6;?:=:A57:99:3A3A@3<3?CGC98F86?:A5A3) )+3A 6:C24?)26D<:A656?@6:A?36==?:J8?3>6AD8?3??GF86?:A5 A3) $)* =?3J8 :< :A ?6;2 6A= A859:58A< @6AA8? 6A= =6;28= 656:A;< @3<3?CGC98 C64;:A5 6CC:=8A< ; 6 ?8;49< C96:@6A< ;4;<6:A8= ;8J8?8 C?4;2 :AE4?G <3 2:; ?:52< >33< 6A= ?:52< 6?@ 676?< >?3@ 3<28? :AE4?:8; 6:= :AE4?:8; 98= <3 6@74<6<:3A3>2:;?:52<9856F3J8DA886A=?:52<26A=6<89F3B 98J89;6C3A;8K48AC828;4;<6:A8=93;;3>86?A:A5C676C:<G 6A=>:98=C96:@78<:<:3A4A=8?8C<:3A 3> 3<3?82:C98;C< 656:A;<=?:J8?3BA8?6A=:A;4?8?3>6AD8?3??G - 4 - + AC3A<8;<B28?8:AC96:@78<:<:3AB6;3773;8=3A 699 5?34A=; <?:F4A69 >?6@8= :;;48; 6A= ?8C3?=8= 8J:=8AC8 96:@6A<8L6@:A8=2:@;89>6A=<B33<28?;6;,;<36A= 53<@6?D8=L;<3*>>:C:693>:A;4?8?B6;8L6@:A8=6; ,6A=L; 6A= B8?853<@6?D8= A C3A;:=8?6<:3A <?:F4A69 289= 6CC:=8A< 3CC4??8= =48<3?6;26A=A859:58A<=?:J:A53>6AD8?3??GFG:<;=?:J8? C96:@6A< ;4;<6:A8= 78?@6A8A< 72G;:C69 =:;6F:9:<G 6A= 93;; 3> 86?A:A5 C676C:<G 6A= 8A<:<98= >3?C3@78A;6<:3A 6;;8;;8=FG :< >?3@:A;4?8?6;>3993B; ) *+,-./*0-+120 .301 3B6?=;76:A6A=;4>>8?:A5 ;!!!!) 3;;3>>4<4?886?A:A5 ;!+!!!) (3? @8=:C69 8L78A;8; F6;8= 3A @8=:C69F:99;6A=8J:=8AC8 ;! !) + (33=34?:;2@8A<6A=C3AJ8G6AC8 ;!!!!) (4<4?8 8=:C698L78A;8; ;!!!!!) 3B6?=;6<<8A=6AC8C26?58; ;!!!!) * 3;;3>:AC3@8=4?:A596:=)3>>78?:3= ;!!!) 3;;3>6@8A:<:8; ;!!!!!) 0 3;;3>>4<4?88=4C6<:3A ;!!!!!) ! 3;;3> 6??:6587?3;78C<; ;!!!!!) 1+) - 45 3< ;6<:;>:8= B:<2 ;6@8 C96:@6A< :; :A 677869 < B6; >:?;<9G ;4F@:<<8= 6; 78? L;+ <3 C96:@6A< B6; - 5 - ;<4=8A<3>;8C3A=G86? C34?;86><8?C3@798<:3A3> < B6; ;4F@:<<8= C96:@6A< B6; ! G86?; 3> 658 6A= 26= F?:52< 7?3;78C<;3>8@793G@8A<6A=86?A:A53AF6;:;3>;6:=C34?;8 48 <3 6@74<6<:3A 3> ?:52< 4778? 9:@F 6; B899 6; ?:52< 93B8? 9:@F6<89F3B 6A=DA88 98J89 2826=F8C3@8 <3<699G =:;6F98= 6A= =878A=8A< < B6; ;4F@:<<8= C3A;:=8?6<:3A 3> @3A<29G :AC3@8 6< ;+!!!) FG <?:F4A69 B6; A3< E4;<:>:8= < B6; ;4F@:<<8= <23452 <?:F4A69 ?:52<9G 6;;8;;8= 93;; 3> 86?A:A5 C676C:<G 6< !!M :< 8??8= :A A3< 6==:A5 >4<4?8 7?3;78C<; <3 @3A<29G :AC3@8 6; 78?=8C:;:3A 3>3AIF98 47?8@8 34?< :A C6;8 3> ?873?<8= :A ! < B6; ;4F@:<<8= C96:@6A< 26= 74?C26;8= 7?3;<28<:C 9:@F 6A= 7?3=4C8= F:99; <3B6?=; ;6@8 6A= 26= 69;3 8L6@:A8= 6?<:>:C:69 9:@F C3A;49<6A<<8C2A:C:6A 6; , , 26= =873;8= 6F34< ?8K4:?8@8A< 3> 78?:3=:C69 ?8796C8@8A< 6A= C3;< 3> ;6@8 28?8>3?8 <?:F4A69 B6; A3< E4;<:>:8= :A 6B6?=:A5 3A9G ;!!!!!) <3B6?=; >4<4?8 @8=:C69 8L78A;8; < B6; ;4F@:<<8=8J8AC3@78A;6<:3A6B6?=8=<3B6?=;93;;3>:AC3@8 =4?:A596:=)4778?:3=B6;:A6=8K46<86A=;3452<8A26AC8@8A< - 6 - < B6; 96;<9G ;4F@:<<8= C3@78A;6<:3A 6B6?=8= 4A=8? 3<28? 286=;69;3?8K4:?88A26AC8@8A< * A3<28?26A=@<26;2:D696%6265:?=6?986?A8= C34A;89>3?:A;4?8?3773;8=677869 <B6;;4F@:<<8=3A>6:94?8 3> C96:@6A< <3 ;4F;<6A<:6<8 @3A<29G :AC3@8 <?:F4A69 26= 6;;8;;8= :< 6< ;+!!!) 8J8A <23452 A3<:3A69 :AC3@8 >3? G86?!0B6; ;!)FG<6D:A5:A<36CC34A<7?3;78C<;3> 3CC476<:3A6><8?C3@798<:3A3>E3F3?:8A<8=C34?;828?8>3?8 <28?8 B6; A3 ;C378 >3? 8A26AC8@8A< < B6; ;4F@:<<8= <?:F4A69 26= 6B6?=8= >4<4?8 @8=:C69 8L78A;8; 6< ;!!!!!)93;;3>6@8A:<:8;6< ;!!!!!)93;;3>>4<4?8 8=4C6<:3A 6< ;!!!!!) 6A= 93;; 3> @6??:658 7?3;78C<; 6< ;!!!!!) B2:C2 B349= 3>>;8< 6AG ;C378 >3? 8A26AC8@8A< 6A=3A;6:=5?34A=;3452<>3?=:;@:;;693>677869 86?=986?A8=C34A;898?4;8=:@745A8=E4=5@8A< 6A=6B6?=6A=C8?<:>:8=C37:8;3>=873;:<:3A6A=8L2:F:<;@6=8 6J6:96F98FG986?A8=C34A;89>3?C96:@6A<6778996A< - 7 - 0 (?3@6F3J86A=;:AC83A9GC96:@6A<:;:A677869>3? 8A26AC8@8A< 3> C3@78A;6<:3A 73:A< <26< B349= 6?:;8 >3? C3A;:=8?6<:3A:; ! A;3>6? 6; @3A<29G :AC3@8 C96:@6A< 26= ;<6<8= <26< 28 B6; :A ;8?J:C8 B:<2 7?:J6<8 C3A<?6C<3? 6A= 86?A:A5 ;!!!) 78? @3A<2 F4< >6:98= <3 ;4F;<6A<:6<8 ;6@8 A 6F;8AC8<?:F4A696;;8;;8=:<A3<:3A699G <:;A3<:A=:;74<8<26< L;+ 6A= 6?8 399858 98<<8? 699 :CD8< 6A= 6?D;6?=3>C96:@6A<:A=:C6<:A5<26<28B6;74?;4:A5;8C3A= G86? 3> C34?;8 6:= C34?;8 :; 6><8? C3@798<:3A 3> 28?8>3?8 3CC476<:3A 3> C96:@6A< C6AA3< F8 C3A;:=8?8= 6; 3?=:A6?GC339:8F4<6;8=4C6<8=;D:998=8@793G88A=8?;4C2 C:?C4@;<6AC8; 6;;8;;@8A< 3> 2:; @3A<29G :AC3@8 6< ;+!!!)B2:C2:;;9:52<9G6F3J8A3<:3A69:AC3@8B349=A3< F8677?37?:6<86D:A5A3<83>>6C<;6A=C:?C4@;<6AC8;A6@89G 8=4C6<:3A69F6CD5?34A=7?3;78C<;3>>:A=:A53>8@793G@8A<3A F6;:;3>E3F3?:8A<8=C8?<:>:C6<8C34?;8:<B349=F8677?37?:6<8 <3C3A;:=8?@3A<29G:AC3@83>C96:@6A<6< ;!!!);78? =8C:;:3A :A " C6;8 #;47?6& 8J8A :A 78?;3A69 - 8 - :AE4?G C96:@; >4<4?8 7?3;78C<; 6?8 ?8K4:?8= <3 F8 6==8= <3 @3A<29G:AC3@86D:A5A3<83>>6C<<26<C96:@6A<B6;!G86?; 3> 658 6A= ;89>)8@793G8= +!M 26; <3 F8 6==8= <3 @3A<29G :AC3@824;?8)C3@74<6<:3A3>C3@78A;6<:3A<3B6?=;93;;3> >4<4?8:AC3@8B349=F8 # ;!!!)N+!M&-!!M--O ;++!!) 6D:A5A3<83>6@74<6<:3A3>?:52<4778?9:@F6A= ?:52< 93B8? 9:@F 6< 89F3B 6A= DA88 98J89 <?:F4A69 6B6?=8= ;!!!!) <3B6?=; 76:A 6A= ;4>>8?:A5 6A= ;!!!!!) <3B6?=; 93;; 3> 6@8A:<:8; A 3J8?699 C3A;:=8?6<:3A ;6@8 B349= 67786? 6=8K46<8 6A= B349= A3< C699 >3? 8A26AC8@8A< ?:F4A69 26; 6B6?=8= ;! !) <3B6?=; @8=:C69 8L78A;8; :A C3@798<8 ?8:@F4?;8@8A< 3> F:99; 7?3=4C8= 28?8>3?8<28?8B349=F8A3;C378>3?8A26AC8@8A<6D:A5 A3<8 3> ! =6G; :A)76<:8A< 78?:3= 6B6?= 3> ;!!!!) 86C2 <3B6?=; >33= A34?:;2@8A< 6A= C3AJ8G6AC8 6A= 6<<8A=6AC8 C26?58;B349=F86=8K46<86A=A3<C699>3?8A26AC8@8A< A C6;8 3> 6@74<6<:3A 3> 93B8? 9:@F A3?@699G 78?:3= 3> ;:L @3A<2;:;C3A;:=8?8=6;96G)3>>3A;8K48A<9GC96:@6A<B349= F8 8A<:<98= <3 6 ;4@ 3> ;!!!!) <3B6?=; 93;; 3> :AC3@8 - 9 - =4?:A596:=)4778?:3=?:F4A6926;6B6?=8= ;!!!!!)86C2 <3B6?=; 93;; 3> >4<4?8 8=4C6<:3A 6A= 93;; 3> @6??:658 7?3;78C<;:AC8:A;4?8?26;A3<C26998A58=;6@8<6D:A5A3<8 3> G34A5 658 3> C96:@6A< <28?8 B349= F8 A3 ;C378 >3? :A<8?>8?8AC8 8>8??:A5 <3 =873;:<:3A 3> ,)8A:3? 3A;49<6A< ?3;<28<:;<6F34<>:<@8A<3>@3=496?7?3;<28<:C985<3C96:@6A< ?8K4:?8@8A< 3> :<; 78?:3=:C69 @6:A<8A6AC8 6A= ?8796C8@8A< <28?8B349=F8A88=>3?6B6?=3>>4<4?8@8=:C698L78A;8;3;< 3>7?3;<28<:C9:@F6;=873;8=FG,6A=;4773?<8=FGF:99;6< L;<36B6?=3> ;!!!!!)<3B6?=;>4<4?8@8=:C69 8L78A;8; B28A C3;< 3> 7?3;<28<:C 9:@F B6; 6F34< ; !!!!)B349=A3<F8E4;<:>:8= <B349=F8677?37?:6<8 <3 8A26AC8 :< <3 ; !!!!!) 6:= 6@34A< :> D87< :A >:L8= =873;:< B349= 7?3J:=8 >3? C26A58 3> 7?3;<28<:C 985 B28A 6@34A< B349= =34F98 24; C96:@6A< 289= 8A<:<98= >3? <3<69 C3@78A;6<:3A3> ; ! !)6;;8;;8=6;>3993B; ) *+,-./*0-+120 .301 3B6?=;76:A6A=;4>>8?:A5 ;!!!!) 3;;3>>4<4?886?A:A5 ;++!!) (3? @8=:C69 8L78A;8; F6;8= 3A @8=:C69F:99;6A=8J:=8AC8 ;! !) + (33=34?:;2@8A<6A=C3AJ8G6AC8 ;!!!!) (4<4?8 8=:C698L78A;8; ; !!!!!) - 10 - 3B6?=;6<<8A=6AC8C26?58; ;!!!!) * 3;;3>:AC3@8=4?:A596:=)3>>78?:3= ;!!!!) 3;;3>6@8A:<:8; ;!!!!!) 0 3;;3>>4<4?88=4C6<:3A ;!!!!!) ! 3;;3> 6??:6587?3;78C<; ;!!!!!) 1+) -4 45 3:A< >3? C3A;:=8?6<:3A :; <24; 6A;B8?8= 76?<9G :A 6>>:?@6<:J86;6F3J83A;8K48A<9G>3993B:A5 : 77869:;6993B8=:A76?<E4=5@8A<6A=6B6?= =6<8= 0! ! 76;;8= FG )==:<:3A69 :;<?:C< 6A= 8;;:3A; %4=58 6:C24? :A A3!0 :; @3=:>:8= 96:@6A< :; 289= 8A<:<98= >3? <3<69 C3@78A;6<:3A 3> ; ! !) 6; 656:A;< ; !) 6B6?=8=FG?:F4A69B:<2:A<8?8;<6<?6<83> M 78?6AA4@>?3@=6<83>78<:<:3A<:99=873;:< :: 8;73A=8A<):A;4?8? <3 =873;:< 8A26AC8= C3@78A;6<:3A B:<2 :A<8?8;< F8>3?8 <?:F4A69 B:<2:A678?:3=3>;:LB88D; ::: A=873;:<;4@3> ; !!!!!):;3?=8?8=<3 F8 D87< :A >:L8= =873;:< ;876?6<89G :A 6AG 6<:3A69:;8= $6AD 3? 3;<69 =873;:< 86?A:A5 2:528;< ?6<8 3> :A<8?8;< >3? 6 78?:3= 3> 8:52< - 11 - G86?; <3 7?3J:=8 >3? ?8796C8@8A< 3> 6?<:>:C:69 9:@F :J 76?<>?3@6F3J8<?:F4A69:;=:?8C<8=<3D887 ;4@ 3> ;!!!!!) :A>:L8= =873;:< :A 6AG 6<:3A69:;8= $6AD 3? 3;<69 =873;:< 86?A:A5 2:528;< ?6<8 3> :A<8?8;< >3? 6 78?:3= 3> 8:52< G86?; B:<2 7?3J:;:3A >3? 76G@8A< 3> @3A<29G :A<8?8;< <3 C96:@6A< 96:@6A< B349= F8 6< 9:F8?<G<36779G>3??8986;83>677?37?:6<8;4@ :AC6;8:<:;?8K4:?8=>3?@6??:65874?73;83? 2:528? 8=4C6<:3A 3? ;4C2 3<28? E4;<:>:6F98 C64;8 J 8@6:A:A56@34A<:;3?=8?8=<3F8?8986;8= ,5 &$$' " $ :;<393* <D