Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58264 (KAR)
SMT. MADHUSHREE, v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203107/2025 · 2025-11-04
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58264 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58264 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$%
! & %'!! & %'!#'$ #
(!)
! !"" #
#$%&
'
(
)
*
) )
"
" #&&&
"
) )
"++")
"
" #&&,
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#$%&
%
! ")
#$%&
'
( )
"
" %
*
"
" , -*
&#
"&#&
&# . " )
"
--*
%
"
)( *
" /&
".(*(-*/(*
" ---*
)
"
%01
2-*"
%
" 0" ) "
- 3 -
" -2*
" "" "
" ( &#*
&#&# (* +
) *
" 3
%
"
""
"
%01
"
%& && ($
&&" % &&*"
"
4
& &# ( ")
(** 01
&& &# ""
"
+" ! +" ! !""
- 4 -
( +" ! *
567-189-6:;6-6-<5:;6-6-<5;97=1>=??;@-5AB;16-<5 67; <9@;9 @=6;@ & &# :=11;@ CD 67; )=95=6=E= 6=6; @F-5-169=6-2; 9-CB5=? )=?=CB9=G- -5 ::?->=6-<5 <&#&
&# 87;9;CD -56;9-F :9=D;9 1<BG76 CD 67; :;6-6-<5;97=1C;;59;H;>6;@=5@<C1;92;@67=667;:9-2=6; 9;1:<5@;567=1=?9;=@D9;:<96;@6<@B6D
7;>=1;<I67;:;6-6-<5;9-167=687-?;7;8=1 8<9E-5G=1=B@-6II->;9-59;1:<5@;56<1=5@17;
8=1 :<16;@ 6< 67; :?=>; <I 9;1:<5@;56 <% 87< 8=1 8<9E-5G =1 =5 >><B561 B:;9-56;5@;56 <5 &&% >><9@-5G?D 67; :;6-6-<5;9 7=1 9;:<96;@ 6< @B6D <5 &$&% 7;9;=I6;9 67; 9;1:<5@;56 <% 7=1 C;;5 :9<F<6;@ =1 = B@-6 II->;9 6< 67; <II->; <I 67;
<FF-11-<5;9 =7=5=G=9= =?-E;
=->7B9 2-@; <9@;9 @=6;@%&%9;=I6;967;:;6-6-<5;97=1=::?-;@ I<9 F=6;95-6D ?;=2; I9<F &&&# 6< &# =5@
- 5 -
17;7=@7=5@;@<2;9>7=9G;6<<5;9-;5E=6 ;@@D5 67; F;=587-?; 2-@; -F:BG5;@ <9@;91 @=6;@ & &# =5@ ,& &# 67; 9;1:<5@;56 <% 7;9;-5 7=1 C;;5 :<16;@ 6< 67; :?=>; <I 67; :;6-6-<5;9 =5@ :;6-6-<5;9 7=1 C;;5 69=51I;99;@ 6< 67; <II->; <I 67; <FF-11-<5;9 =7=5=G=9==?-E; =->7B9;-5G=GG9-;2;@CD67;1=F;
67; :;6-6-<5;9 7=1 I-?;@ =5 =::?->=6-<5 C;I<9; )=95=6=E= 6=6;@F-5-169=6-2;9-CB5=?=5@1<BG76I<916=D<I<9@;9 @=6;@& &#=5@,& &#
7; 9;1:<5@;56 <% 9;:9;1;56;@ 679<BG7 =@2<>=6; I<9 >=2;=6<9 7=1 :9<@B>;@ 67; ?;66;9 @=6;@ & &# -11B;@ CD J;>B6-2; 5G-5;;9 =->7B9 16=6-5G67=667;9;1:<5@;56<%7=16=E;5>7=9G;-567;
69=51I;99;@ :?=>; 5 67; C=1-1 <I 67; ><FFB5->=6-<5 @=6;@ & &# 67; 9-CB5=?
7=1 9;IB1;@ 6< G9=56 -56;9-F <9@;9 -5 I=2<B9 <I67; =::?->=56 =5@@-9;>6;@67=6 9;:<96-5G <I 67; 9;1:<5@;56 <% 6< 67; :?=>; <I 67; :;6-6-<5;9CD2-96B;<I67=667;-F:BG5;@<9@;9-11BCH;>6
- 6 -
6<67;9;1B?6<I67;=::?->=6-<5 ;-5G=GG9-;2;@CD67; 1=F;67;:;6-6-<5;9-1C;I<9;67-1<B96 % 9- 9=1=55= )BF=9 / F6 =5-67= ?;=95;@ ><B51;?1 =::;=9-5G I<9 67; :;6-6-<5;9 7=1 1BCF-66;@ 67=6 67; )=95=6=E= 6=6; @F-5-169=6-2; 9-CB5=?7=15<6G9=56;@=5D-56;9-F<9@;9<567;C=1-1<I 67; ?;66;9 <I ><FFB5->=6-<5 :9<@B>;@ CD 67; 9;1:<5@;56 <%@=6;@ & =6-5G67=67;7=1=?9;=@D6=E;5 >7=9G;7;9;=I6;967;=::?->=567=1I-?;@=5=::?->=6-<5 B5@;9 -G766<5I<9F=6-<5>61<BG76I<9>;96-I-;@><:-;1 <I?;66;9@=6;@ & &#=?<5G8-67=::?->=6-<56<@=D7;
7=1 :9<@B>;@ 67=6 ><FFB5->=6-<5 -11B;@ CD -G76 6< 5I<9F=6-<5II->;9@=6;@&=6-5G67=667;9;-1 5<=5D1B>7?;66;97=1C;;5-11B;@I9<F67;<II->;<I7-;I 5G-5;;9 =5@ 7; 7=1 =?1< :9<@B>;@ 8-67 >-9>B?=9 @=6;@ &&% =5@ =?1< :9<@B>;@ 67; @<>BF;561 6< 17<867=6F<2;F;56<I67;I-?;-?;-59;1:;>6<I69=51I;9 <I9;1:<5@;565<%7=1C;;5<:;5;@<5&& &#C;I<9;
67=667;9; 8=1 5<=5D><FFB5->=6-<5<9?;66;9 8=1C;;5
- 7 -
-11B;@7;9;I<9;7;7=1I-?;@=5=::?->=6-<5B5@;9, <I & 1;;E-5G I<9 -5-6-=6-<5 <I =>6-<5 =G=-516 9;1:<5@;56 <% -5>; 67; =::?->=6-<5 I-?;@ CD 67;
:;6-6-<5;9 -1 :;5@-5G C;I<9; 67; )=95=6=E= @F-5-169=6-2; 9-CB5=?8;=9;<I67;<:-5-<567=667;89-6:;6-6-<5>=F; C;@-1:<1;@<I # 7; :;6-6-<5;9
=::?->=56 -1 :;9F-66;@ 6< I-?; =5 =::?->=6-<5 I<9 F<@-I->=6-<5 <I 67; <9@;9 :=11;@ CD )=95=6=E= @F-5-169=6-2; 9-CB5=? @=6;@ & &# =5@ =?1<:;9F-66;@6<I-?;=5=::?->=6-<5B5@;9;>6-<5, <I >6&
>><9@-5G?D 67; 89-6 :;6-6-<5 -1 @-1:<1;@ <I 9;1;92-5G ?-C;96D 6< 67; :;6-6-<5;9 6< I-?; 5;>;11=9D =::?->=6-<5 1;;E-5G I<9 F<@-I->=6-<5 <I <9@;9 @=6;@ & &# =5@ =?1< =::?->=6-<5 B5@;9 ;>6-<5 , <I & -I 1B>7 = =::?->=6-<51 =9; I-?;@ 8-67-5 <5;
8;;E I9<F 6<@=D 67; 9-CB5=? -1 @-9;>6;@ 6< @-1:<1; <I
- 8 -
67=6=::?->=6-<5<5<9C;I<9;;5@<I<2;FC;9&#=I6;9 7;=9-5GC<6767;:=96-;1
!,- (!) '
!,- (#'$ #) '
"-16<?<&