- 1 - !"!# $" %% && '%( ) !"# $ %& '( &) ( **" Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"# ( **" & # !+# #! #( ,,,+ $ %*,,!- . () ( ( +%)( ( ( & ,,!,! & %)#,# ( & / & - 3 - " %/ &) 0122345645 7895:34; 149 1<1=9 91;39 ,,!,! >1??39 @A B;B= CC6934; 216:? =6@8412 16C08= %DB= ?0B=; E;=6@8412F)644B#,#;06?1>>3126?D6239 :;671A121G?0:6 16GB96 231=439 CB84?32 1>>31=645DB==61?1H1=171;0?8@:6;;39;01;1>>312<1? @A C216:14;? DB= 34014C3:34; BD CB:>34?1;6B4 ; <1? ?8@:6;;39 B4 ,,#,# 1451>>1 <1? ;=1H32645 2B==A 4B *,* <034 9=6H3= BD 14B;03= 2B==A 4B **" 9=BH3 6; 64 =1?0 149 43526534; :1443= 149 91?039 15164?;1451>>1<0623=3H3=?6456;C18?64506?931;0B4?>B; 6? <6D3 149 :B;03= D6239 C216: >3;6;6B4 15164?; 9=6H3= B<43= 149 64?8=3= BD BDD349645 2B==A 8493= 3C;6B4 BD B;B= 306C23?C; 4 CB4;3?; <03=364 =3?>B4934;? B>>B?39 C216: >3;6;6B4 B4 122 5=B849? 64C289645 934A645 153 BCC8>1;6B4 64CB:3 14993>34934CA 1? <322 1? 12235645 H6B21;6B4 BD ;3=:? 149 CB496;6B4? BD >B26CA ;=6@8412 D=1:39 6??83? 149 =3CB=939 3H6934C3216:14;4B3I1:64391? 149I?;B" - 4 - <3=35B;:1=G39B>63?BD9=6H64526C34C314964?8=14C3>B26CA <3=35B;:1=G391?I?149<6;0CB4?34; # 4 CB4?693=1;6B4 ;=6@8412 0329 1CC6934; 019 BCC8==39983;B=1?014943526534;9=6H645BD2B==A@A6;?9=6H3= 149C216:14;?<3=334;6;239DB=CB:>34?1;6B41?DB22B<? 24B 319?BDB:>34?1;6B4 :B84;64 B??BD93>34934CA ",,, B??BDCB4?B=;68: ,,,,, B??BD3?;1;3 ,,,, # (843=12149B@?3J863?3I>34?3? !,,, *+, -##. ! 6??1;6?D639<6;0?1:3C216:14;?<3=3641>>312; <1? D6=?;2A ?8@:6;;39 C216:14;? 019 ?;1;39 ;01; 93C31?39 1451>>1<1?<B=G6451?9=6H3=BD2B==A14931=4645,,,, >3=:B4;01??121=A149,, >3=91A1?@1;103A01912?B >=B98C39 CB>A BD 9=6H645 26C34C3 1? I" B<3H3= ;=6@8412 1??3??39 06? :B4;02A 64CB:3 4B;6B4122A 1; ,,, 149 1<1=939 64193J81;3 CB:>34?1;6B4 ; <1? D8=;03= ?8@:6;;39 ;=6@8412 12?B 969 4B; 199 D8;8=3 >=B?>3C;? 03=3DB=3 34014C3:34;<1??B850; 4 B;03= 0149 :;=33;6 1;62 32G8496 231=439 CB84?32DB=64?8=3=B>>B?391>>312 - 5 - + 31=9 231=439 CB84?32 149 >3=8?39 6:>85439 7895:34;1491<1=9 " (=B:1@BH3149?64C3B42AC216:14;?1=3641>>312 >B64;;01;<B8291=6?3DB=CB4?693=1;6B46? K 03;03= C216:14;? 1=3 34;6;239 DB= 34014C3:34; 1? ?B850;DB=LM * 1:36?14?<3=39>1=;2A641DD6=:1;6H3DB=DB22B<645 =31?B4? , 0B850 C216:14;? ?;1;39 ;01; 93C31?39 <1? 9=6H3= 149 31=4645 ,,,, >3= :B4;0 1? ?121=A N ,,, >3= :B4;0 1? @1;1 1:3 <1? 4B; ?8@?;14;61;39 B<3H3= ;03A 01H3 >=B98C39 9=6H645 26C34C3 BD 93C31?39 :1=G39 1? I" 3=8?12 BD ?1:3 <B8296496C1;3 ;01; 93C31?39<1? >B??3??645 9=6H645 26C34C3 DB= 2650; :B;B= H306C23 % ) <6;0 ;=14?>B=; 349B=?3:34; 149 93C31?39 <1? 12?B 64 >B??3??6B4 BD 9=6H3=? @1953 DB= 031HA >1??3453= H306C23 %) 1:3 <B829 ?8@?;14;61;306?1HBC1;6B406?B8=;64(4B,+, 01?CB4?693=39:B4;02A64CB:3BD9=6H3=0B296459=6H64526C34C3 <6;0;=14?>B=;349B=?3:34;14926C34C3;B9=6H3031HAH306C23 1;,,,, >3=:B4;0B<3H3=?64C3C216:14;?;03:?32H3? - 6 - 01H3?;1;39;01;93C31?39<1?31=4645,,,, >3=:B4;01? ?121=A N ,, >3= 91A 1? @01;1 63 ,,, >3= :B4;0 ,,, 01?;B@393;3=:64391?06?:B4;02A64CB:3 ?>3=93C6?6B4BDB4F@238>=3:3B8=;64C1?3BD H C216:14;? <B829 @3 34;6;239 DB= 1996;6B4 BD D8;8=3 >=B?>3C;?;B:B4;02A64CB:364C393C31?39<1??;1;39;B@3 " A31=? BD 153 149 <1? ?32D 3:>2BA39 D8;8=3 >=B?>3C;? 1; #,O01?;B@319939=6@8412=650;2A9398C;39=9;B<1=9? >3=?B412 3I>34?3? 149 1>>2639 :82;6>263= BD E+F 08? CB:>8;1;6B4 ;B<1=9? 2B?? BD D8;8=3 64CB:3 <B829 @3 1? DB22B<? ,,,N#,O) =9P''+Q#+! 1:36?1<1=939;BC216:14;? ;6??334;=6@84121<1=939,,21G0;B<1=9?2B?? BDCB4?B=;68:,,,, ;B<1=9?2B??BD3?;1;3149!,,, ;B<1=9? D843=12 3I>34?3? <06C0 <B829 4B; @3 64 CB4?B414C3 <6;0=1;6B21699B<464F?C1?3%?8>=1)B<3H3= ;1G645 4B;3 BD D1C; ;01; C216:14;? 1=3 <6D3 149 :B;03= BD 1 %,+)", - 7 - 93C31?39 ;03A <B829 @3 34;6;239 DB= #,,,, 31C0 ;B<1=9? 2B??BD?>B8?12CB4?B=;68:149D62612CB4?B=;68:149!,,, ;B<1=9?2B??BD3?;1;3149!,,, ;B<1=9?D843=123I>34?3? 64C3 :B=3 ;014 ?6I A31=? 01H3 21>?39 1D;3= =3493=645 BD 93C6?6B464F?C1?3%?8>=1);03A<B829@334;6;239 DB=1996;6B4BD,O63,,, 1<1=98493=CB4H34;6B412 0319?;0B850:1=564122A3IC3??@A,,, 6?23D;8496?;8=@39 08?;B;12CB:>34?1;6B4<B829@3, ?>3=B=93=91;39,",,!C216:14;?<3=30329 96?34;6;239DB=64;3=3?;DB=9321A>3=6B9BD#+!91A?03=3DB=3 C216:14;? <B829 4B; @3 34;6;239 DB= 64;3=3?; DB= ?169 >3=6B9 B64; DB= CB4?693=1;6B4 6? 14?<3=39 >1=;2A 64 1DD6=:1;6H3 B4?3J834;2ADB22B<645 6 >>312 6? 122B<39 64 >1=; 7895:34; 149 1<1=9 91;39 ,,!,! >1??39 @A B;B= CC6934; 216:? =6@8412 16C08= 64 4B#,# 6? :B96D639 C216:14;? 1=3 34;6;239 DB= CB:>34?1;6B4 BD , 1? 15164?; *!,,, 1<1=939 @A ;=6@8412 <6;0 64;3=3?; R O >3= 1448: D=B: 91;3 BD >3;6;6B4 ;622 93>B?6; 3IC289645 DB= #+! 91A? - 8 - 66 8; BD 34014C39 CB:>34?1;6B4 #,, 21G0? <6;0 1CC=839 64;3=3?; 6? 1>>B=;6B439 64 D1HB8= BD C216:14; 4B :B;03= 1:3 6? B=93=39 ;B @3 =3231?39 666 3:164645 1:B84; 6? 1>>B=;6B439 64 D1HB8= BD C216:14;4BS<6D3493>B?6;!,O6?B=93=39 ;B@3=3231?39149=3:164645!,O6?B=93=39;B@3 G3>; 64 D6I39 93>B?6; 64 14A 41;6B4126T39 @14G B= >B?;12 93>1=;:34; 31=4645 06503?; 64;3=3?; DB= 1 >3=6B9 BD D6H3 A31=? <6;0 >=BH6?6B4 DB= =3C36>; BD 64;3=3?; 6H 4?8=3=6?96=3C;39;B93>B?6;?1:3@3DB=3;=6@8412 <6;0 64;3=3?; 1; O D=B: 91;3 BD >3;6;6B4 ;622 >1A:34;<6;064?6I<33G? /. '%% ( " 6?;B2B