Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58248 (KAR)

SHIVAMMA AND ORS v. THE CHAIEF GENERAL MANAGER AND ANR

WP/203164/2019 · 2025-09-19

H P Sandesh, K S Hemalekha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ " %!$&""" %!$"&""$! '"( !"# $%% & " # '$ ( ) Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % !" & " # '$ ($) $ % * % % $ % % $$ $$ *#"# ## +! , % $$ % $ $ $ $% $ %$ -. $ / $ / - 3 - ! ($/ $) 0123 450 6012703 89:7;06 1<<012=7> ?92 450 <04=4=9702; 17316;989:7;061<<012=7>?9220;<973074; 508516607>0@130=745=;A2=4<04=4=97B0?92045=; 9:24 =; 4514 1 82C<4=8 92302 =; <1;;03 BC 450 074216 3@=7=;4214=D0 2=B:716 07>16:2: =7 2=>=716 <<6=814=97 9*##"# 31403 ## 173 79 201;970392302 51;B007<1;;03 50 89:7;06 16;9 A9:63 ;:B@=4 4514 976C ?=D0 6=70 92302 51; B007 <1;;03 173 17 9B;02D14=97 =; @130 4514 450 @14402 206140; 49 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074 A5020=7 ?92 450 @=7=@:@20E:=2039? A0=>541>0<9=74;B081:;09?5=;618F9? =73=>078C 1<<6=8174 89:63 ;08:20 976C <9=74; 173 45020?920 794 B0=7> 06=>=B60 97 450 @=7=@:@ 82=402=1 <<6=8174 =; 794 06=>=B60 49 B0 897;=30203 ?92 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074 173 507803=;@=;;03450;1@0 012703 89:7;06 A9:63 D050@0746C 8974073 4514 A507 450 2=B:716 51; 794 <1;;03 17C 201;9703 92302 =7 450 - 4 - 92=>=716<<6=814=979*##"# 31403##173 16;9 A9:63 D050@0746C 8974073 4514 450 A0=>541>0 2:60; 794 1<<6=81B60;=78045030801;03<1;;031A1C97#*# ##*173 450 ;850@0 A1; =74293:803 97 *###* 0 16;9 A9:63 89740734514450A0=>541>0>=D07=;16;9794<29<0217350780 =420E:=20;49;04!1;=30450;1@09220@173450@14402 450 6012703 89:7;06 1<<012=7> ?92 450 20;<973074;A9:6389740734514459:>530801;03<1;;031A1C 97 #*# ##* 1<<6=814=97 =; ?=603 =7 # 1?402 61<;0 9? ?=D0 C012; =4 860126C 3=;869;0; 4514 ?1@=6C A1; 794 =7 450 ?=7178=16 897;421=74; 173 450 D02C 9BG084 9? B2=7>=7> 45=; 07184@074 9? 89@<1;;=971401<<9=74@074=;D02C860124514A507450?1@=6C =; :7302 3=;420;; 4507 976C 450 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074 A9:63B0>=D071737941;1@144029?861=@450C817794861=@ 450;1@0 012703 89:7;06 16;9 A9:63 ;:B@=4 4514 459:>5 ;850@0 A1; =74293:803 ;:B;0E:074 49 450 30145 9? 450 30801;03173450;1@0A1;B29:>54A=45=71;<179?9701731 516?@97451731;9745031409??=6=7>9?1<<6=814=974502:60; - 5 - 120 <20D1=603 0780 E:0;4=97 9? 450 897;=30214=97 1; 897407303BC450<04=4=9702;390;79412=;0 * 1D=7> 50123 450 89:7;06 1<<012=7> ?92 450 <04=4=9702;17316;945089:7;061<<012=7>?9245020;<973074; 173 16;9 897;=302=7> 450 92302 <1;;03 BC 450 2=B:716 =7 92=>=716<<6=814=979*##"# 31403##173 79 39:B4 450 2=B:716 <1;;03 17 92302 =7 89@=7> 49 450 89786:;=97 4514 A507 450 @14402 206140; 49 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074 A5020=7 ?92 450 @=7=@:@ 20E:=203 9? A0=>541>0 <9=74; 173 450 ;1@0 =; 618F 9? =73=>078C 1<<6=8174 89:63 ;08:20 976C <9=74; 1; 1>1=7;4 <9=74; 173 16;9 89@0;4945089786:;=974514794@04450@=7=@:@82=402=1173 51D=7> 41F07 7940 9? 450 ;1=3 ?184 =749 897;=30214=97 450 20E:=203@=7=@:@82=402=19? A0=>541>0<9=74;51;794B007 @04 <124 ?29@ 4514 =7 450 81;0 97 5173 =4 51; 49 B0 79403 451445030801;03<1;;031A1C97#*# ##*17313@=44036C 450 1<<6=814=97 =; ?=603 =7 # 173 51; 49 B0 ?=603 A=45=7 1 <02=93 9? 970 C012 173 79 ;:85 1<<6=814=97 =; 16;9 ?=603 <<6=814=97=;?=60316@9;41?402?=D0C012;173450D02C9BG0849? 450 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074=; 49 506< 450 ?1@=6C A5=85 =; - 6 - :7302?=7178=163=;420;;A507450?1@=6C=;:71B60496=D0A=45 450 ?=7178=16 1;;=;41780 :7302 450 8=28:@;41780; 450 1<<9=74@07489:63B0@130:4;1@0=;794?9:73=745081;0 97 5173 ;=780 1<<6=814=97 =; ?=603 16@9;4 1?402 ?=D0 C012; 173 450D02C9BG084=;<29D=3=7>45141<<9=74@074=;16;949506<450 ?1@=6CA5=85=;=7?=7178=163=;420;;173450;1@0=;794?9:73=7 45081;0975173<124?29@45144508974074=979?45089:7;06 4514450;850@0A5=85=;=74293:803;:B;0E:07449450301459? 45030801;03=;7941<<6=81B60817794B01880<403 " 745081;09751731<<6=814=97=;?=603=7#173 601270389:7;06?92450<04=4=9702;7943=;<:4045144502:60A1; B29:>54=7450@97459?:70##*=0*###*1731;97 450 3140 9? 897;=30214=97 9? 450 1<<6=814=97 16;9 450 ;850@0 A5=85A1;B29:>540D07?=D0C012;0126=02494501<<6=814=97=; <20D1=6=7>0780450D02C8974074=979?45089:7;061<<012=7> ?92450<04=4=9702;817794B01880<40317345020=;79?9280=7 4508974074=979?450<04=4=9702;89:7;065020?920A039794 ?=7317C=7?=2@=4C=7450923029?4502=B:7161734502=B:716 16;941F0779409?@=7=@:@20E:=203A0=>541>017389@0;49 45089786:;=9745141<<6=8174=;79406=>=B6049B0897;=30203?92 - 7 - 89@<1;;=97140 1<<9=74@074 94 450 E:0;4=97 9? 450 3041=603 92302B:4A507450@1402=16?9:73451479406=>=B60?92450<9;4 A5=85 450C 20E:=20 4514 499 :7302 450 89@<1;;=97140 >29:73 A039794?=7317C=7?=2@=4C=745092302078079@02=4=7450 A2=4<04=4=9749=7402?020A=45450923029?4502=B:716 H 7D=0A9?4503=;8:;;=97@1301B9D0A0<1;;450 ?9669A=7> $04=4=97=;3=;@=;;03 ")* '""( & ")* '"$!( & =;4969