- 1 - ! "#" $%#!&!! % '( ')*+ '!!** , !"#" $ %&& ' ( ) (( "# $ %& ' (* (%' #+#+*#* ) ( +," ( *#" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ( & & & -& % -& ' ./01 02 &/3/1/450 6./07.1 8957:.6 ;90 <=. 4.<2<297.0 /71 02 /3/1/0 =/=/>51127 6./07.1 2?= 950< 9@.073.7<6./1.0;90<=.</<. * .<2<297.0 2: <=. /885:.1 A=9;26.1 /7 /44./6 >.;90. <=. (20:< 44.66/<. 950< 8=/66.7?27? <=. 901.0 4/::.1 27 9*"*## A=.0.27 =. =/: >..7 897@28<.1 ;90 =/@27? 32:/4409402/<.1 / :53 9; :#" /71 897@28<.1 571.0 .8<297#,9;<=.712/7.7/691./71901.0.1<9571.0?9 :2346. 23402:973.7< ;90 <A9 B./0: /71 <9 4/B ;27. 9; :"####A2<=1.;/56<:.7<.78.9;:2C397<=: + .27? /??02.@.1 >B <=. 01.0 9; 897@28<297 /7 /44./6 8/3. <9 >. ;26.1 >B <=. 4.<2<297.0 97 <=. ;26. 9; <=. 116 2:<028< /71 .::297: 51?. 2D/B/450/ 27 02327/6 44./6 9 *#" ;26.1/7/44628/<297571.0.8<297,"9; - 3 - 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. <9 120.8< <=. =2.; 13272:<0/<2@. ;;28.0 /1/@/6/?/@266/?.<9409158.8.0</2719853.7<: 27:54490<9;=2:8/:. 7/44628/<297571.0:.8<297+,"9;<=.91.9;02327/6 098.150.A/:/6:9;26.1:..E27?<946/8./112<297/6.@21.78.97 0.8901 /71 :53397 <=. A2<7.::.: /: 2: 3.7<297.1 27 <=. A2<7.::62:</714.032<<=./44.66/7<<96./1;50<=.0.@21.78. 9<=/44628/<297:97897<.:<8/3.<9>.12:32::.1 .27? /??02.@.1 >B <=. 01.0 4/::.1 >B <=. 6./07.1 51?.27<=.(20:<44.66/<.950<97<=./44628/<297;26.1571.0 .8<297,"9;<=.91.9;02327/6098.150.4.<2<297.0=.0.27 /4409/8=.1 <=2: 950< 27 02327/6 .<2<297 9*#"+"*#*+ A=28= 97 897<.:< 8/3. <9 >. /669A.1 >B <=. 01.0 1/<.1 *##,*#*/7194.0/<2@.490<2979;<=.:/21901.0A95610./1: /:571.0 !" # $ - 4 - % & ' ( ! /:.197<=.120.8<297:/7162>.0<B<=/<A/:?2@.7>B<=. 8990127/<. .78= 9; <=2: 950< 27 <=. /;90.:/21 02327/6 .<2<297 4.<2<297.0 =.0.27 :/21 <9 =/@. ;26.1 97. 390. /44628/<297571.0:.8<297+,"9;<=.91.9;02327/6098.150. >.;90.<=.(20:<44.66/<.950< ./07.1 51?. 27 <=. (20:< 44.66/<. 950< /;<.0 .7<.0</2727? <=. 9>D.8<297: ;26.1 >B <=. </<. 0.D.8<.1 <=. :.8971 /44628/<297 ;26.1 571.0 .8<297 +," 9; <=. 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. 450:5/7< <9 <=. 901.0 4/::.1 27 02327/6 .<2<297 9*#"+"*#*+ >B <=. 8990127/<. .78= 9; <=2: 950<97<=.?09571<=/<<=./44.66/7<;/26.1<98=/66.7?.<=. 901.04/::.1>B<=.(20:<44.66/<.950<571.0.8<297+,"9; <=.91.9;02327/6098.150../062.0 02 &/3/1/450 6./07.1 8957:.6 A9561 897<.71 <=/< /::5327? <=/< <=. /44.66/7< =/: 69:< <=. 02?=< 9; 6./127? <=. /112<297/6 .@21.78. 27 @2.A 9; <=. ./062.0 901.0 >.27? 79< 8=/66.7?.1 27 @2.A 9; <=. 120.8<297: 2::5.1 >B <=. 8990127/<. - 5 - .78= 9; <=2: 950< 27 02327/6 .<2<297 9*#"+"*#*+ 4.<2<297.0A/:.7<2<6.1<9;26.:.8971/44628/<297571.0.8<297 +,"9;<=.91.9;02327/6098.150. , . A9561 ;50<=.0 897<.71 <=/< 976B 97 <.8=728/62<B 6./07.1(20:<44.66/<.51?.=/:0.D.8<.1<=.:/21/44628/<297 /71 <=.0.;90. :95?=< ;90 F5/:=27? 9; <=. :/21 901.0 /71 ;90 /669A27?<=./44628/<297 "# 6./07.1 2?= 950< 9@.073.7< 6./1.0 :54490<:<=.2345?7.1 01.0 "" /@27? =./01 <=. /0?53.7<: 9; >9<= :21. <=2: 950< 4.05:.1<=.3/<.02/6970.89013.<285695:6B "* 7 :58= 4.05:/6 9; <=. 3/<.02/6 97 0.8901 <=. 901.0 8/3. <9 >. 4/::.1 >B <=. 8990127/<. .78= 9; <=2: 8950< 27 02327/6 .<2<297 9*#"+"*#*+ /;<.0 =./027? 6./07.1 2?= 950<9@.073.7<6./1.0 "+ =.0.;90.6./07.1 2?=950<9@.073.7<6./1.095?=< 79<<9=/@.9>D.8<.1;90/669A27?9;<=.:.8971/44628/<297;26.1 - 6 - 571.0 .8<297 +," 9; <=. 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. 27 4027824/6>.;90.<=.(20:<44.66/<.950< " .<=/<A=/<2<3/B278.<=.0.A/:/120.8<297<9;26. /44628/<297 571.0 .8<297 +," 9; <=. 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. /71 .8<297 ," /44628/<297 2: /60./1B /669A.1 <9 46/8. 2< 97 0.8901 >B A/B 9; 90/6 .@21.78. 7.8.::/026B /112<297/6.@21.78.2:<9>.46/8.1970.8901 " 9A.@.0 2< 2: 79<28.1 <=/< <=. <02/6 2: 1.6/B.1 97 97. /88957<90<=.9<=.0>B<=./44.66/7<>B;2627?/44628/<297/;<.0 /44628/<297 02?27/6 02327/6 8/:. 2: 9; <=. B./0 *## /71 /44./62<:.6;2:9;<=.B./0*#" "! /E27? 79<. 9; <=.:. /:4.8<: 9; <=. 3/<<.0 /44628/<297 ;26.1>B<=.4.<2<297.0571.0:.8<297+,"9;<=.91.9;02327/6 098.150. 450:5/7< <9 <=. 120.8<297: 2::5.1 >B <=2: 950< 27 02327/6 .<2<297 9*#"+"*#*+ 7..1: <9 >. /669A.1 >B :.<<27?/:21.<=.901.04/::.1>B<=.6./07.151?.27<=.(20:< 44.66/<.950</71/44./635:<>.120.8<.1<9>.8978651.127 / <23. >9571 3/77.0 /;<.0 /;;90127? 94490<572<B ;90 <=. /44.66/7<<946/8./112<297/6.@21.78.970.8901 - 7 - " 8890127?6B;9669A27? %2' .<2<2972: %22' 97:.F5.7<6B <=. 901.0 1/<.1 #+#+*#* 4/::.197/7/44628/<297;26.1571.0.8<297+,"9; <=. 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. 27 069 9; *#"97<=.;26.9;<=.1162:<028</71.::297: 51?.2D/B/450/2:=.0.>B:.</:21. %222' 44628/<297 ;26.1 571.0 .8<297 +," 9; <=. 91. 9; 02327/6 098.150. >.;90. <=. (20:< 44.66/<.950<:</71:/669A.1 %2@' ./07.1 51?. 27 <=. (20:< 44.66/<. 950< :=/662::5.:53397:?.<<=.19853.7<::.850.<=. 40.:.78.9;<=.A2<7.::.:27/<23.>95713/77.0 A2<=27/4.02919;97.397<=;093<91/B0.8901<=. /112<297/6.@21.78./718978651.<=.=./027?9;<=. /44./69790>.;90.+":< 8<9>.0*#* %@' ..16.::<9.34=/:2G.<=/<<=./44.66/7<:=/66 8994.0/<.;90<=../06B12:49:/69;<=./44./6>.;90. <=.(20:<44.66/<.950< !-+ '&!! * # E83 2:<9"69,