Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58241 (KAR)
MD. SHAHABAZ HUSSAIN S/O M.D. GAZIMIYA v. M.NASEER S/O M. KHAJAMIYAN AND ANR
MFA/200334/2022 · 2025-09-19
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58241 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58241 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$%&& ##
'&( )
!" "#
$ %
" &'('
%%$
" ) "
" &'('*+
! $
"%,
"
+-+ #
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% % - !# %
" % % (++
"
". +-
% /'+++++
0
%
% %
% %
"
1
"$
"
% 23/ 455647 3/ 83769 :; <26 4556774=< 0 >743?4=< /66@3=A6=24=>6?6=<B8>B?56=/4<3B=4/4C4D9693=<26 EF9A?6=< 4=9 4C4D9 94<69 (++ 54//69 3=
"B.
+- :; <26 997 6=3BD 3G37 F9A6 4=9 4<394D!8BD/2BD<HD3:F=47I#
- 3 -
+ 26 84></ 76493=A <B 8373=A B8 >743? 56<3<3B= 4D6 4/F=96D0
24< B= +(++- 4< 4:BF< +*+ 5? <26 4556774=<&>743?4=<47B=AC3<223/8D36=9C6D65DB>6693=A B= 4 ?B<BD>;>76 :64D3=A 6AB$0(00*+' 8DB? 4F:49 <B 394D B= <26 5DB56D /396 3= =BD?47 /5669 4< <24< <3?6 <26 ?B<BD>;>76 :64D3=A 6AB$0(00.'+ >4?6 8DB? :4>@/396 3= 4 23A2 /5669 4=9 D4/2 4=9 =6A73A6=< ?4==6D 4=9 94/269 <B <26 G623>76 B8 <26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 8DB? 23=9 /396 F6 <B C23>2 <26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 24/ /F/<43=69 AD36GBF/ 3=EFD36/ 26 4556774=< 0 >743?4=< <4@6= <D64<?6=< 4=9 83769 <26 >743?
56<3<3B=26D3:F=474 69>B?56=/4<3B=4=954//69 <26 3?5FA=69 4C4D9 26 >743?4=< 24/ 83769 <26 5D6/6=< 455647/66@3=A6=24=>6?6=<B8<26>B?56=/4<3B=
+ 64D9 764D=69 >BF=/67 8BD <26 4556774=< 0 >743?4=< 4=9 764D=69 >BF=/67 8BD D6/5B=96=< B & 3=/FD4=>6>B?54=;
- 4 -
+* 64D=69 >BF=/67 8BD <26 4556774=< 0 >743?4=< CBF79 >B=<6=9 <24< <26 4>>396=< 24/ <4@6= 574>6 3= <26 ;64D+-4=94<<24<<3?6<264556774=<&>743?4=<C4/ 4A694:BF<.;64D/4=926C4//<F96=<263=>B?6 83J69 3= <26 24D< 5D654D69 8BD /6<<76?6=< B8 93/5F<6/ 3= B@09474<2:;<26$4D=4<4@46A476DG3>6/F<2BD3<;8BD <26;64D+-3//+'+
056D?B=<24=9<26D3:F=47 24/6DD693=<4@3=A<263=>B?6B8<264556774=<&>743?4=< 4< /.+++
0 56D ?B=<2 6 8FD<26D /F:?3</ <24< <26 9B><BD C2B 24/ 3//F69 <26 J ' & 93/4:373<; >6D<383>4<6 24/ /<4<69 <24< <26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 3/ 24G3=A *K 93/4:373<;B=F556D73?:4=9*KB=<267BC6D73?:3=/53<6 B8<26/4?6<26D3:F=4724/6DD693=<4@3=A<2693/4:373<; 4<K68FD<26D/F:?3</<24<<264556774=<&>743?4=< 24/ /F/<43=69 83G6 8D4><FD6/ 4=9 C4/ 49?3<<69 <B <26 2B/53<47 8BD
94;/ B=/396D3=A <26 /4?6 <26 >B?56=/4<3B= 4C4D969 8BD 543= 4=9 /F886D3=A 4<<6=94=< 4=9>B=G6;4=>6>24DA6/7B//B83=>B?69FD3=A<267439F5 56D3B94=97B//B84?6=3<36/4D6B=7BC6D/3963<2<26/6 265D4;/<B477BC<26455647
- 5 -
+' 64D=69 >BF=/67 8BD D6/5B=96=< B & 3=/FD4=>6 >B?54=; CBF79 >B=<6=9 <24< <26 D3:F=47 24/ D3A2<7;<4@6=<2693/4:373<;4<K4=9D3A2<7;4C4D969<26 >B?56=/4<3B=F=96D477B<26D2649/3<2<26/6/265D4;/ <B93/?3//<26455647
+ 4G3=A264D9764D=69>BF=/678BD<264556774=</ 4=9 764D=69 >BF=/67 8BD D6/5B=96=< B & 3=/FD4=>6 >B?54=;<23/BFD<56DF/69<263?5FA=69EF9A?6=<4=9 D347BFD<D6>BD9/
+- 26 94<6 B8 4>>396=< 4A6 B8 <26 4556774=< & >743?4=<4=9734:373<;B8<263=/FD4=>6>B?54=;4D6=B<3= 93/5F<6264556774=<&>743?4=<C4/4A69.;64D/4/B= <2694<6B84>>396=<36B=+(++-G6=<2BFA23<3/ >B=<6=969<24<<264556774=<&>743?4=<C4/4/<F96=<3= /6?6/<6DB8 >BFD/6:F<=B9B>F?6=<3/5DB9F>69 3=<24<D6A4D9/<263=>B?63/=B<5DBG69<26D3:F=47 BFA2<<B24G6<4@6=<26=B<3B=473=>B?64/56D<2624D< 5D654D698BD/6<<76?6=<B893/5F<6/3=B@09474<2:;<26
- 6 -
$4D=4<4@4 6A47 6DG3>6/ F<2BD3<; :F< <26 D3:F=47 24/ <4@6=<263=>B?6B8<264556774=<&>743?4=<4</.+++
0 56D ?B=<2 / 56D <26 24D< 5D654D69 8BD /6<<76?6=< B8 93/5F<6/ 3= B@09474<2 :; <26 $4D=4<4@4 6A47 6DG3>6/ F<2BD3<; <26 =B<3B=47 3=>B?6 8BD <26 ;64D +- 3/ /+'+
0 56D ?B=<2 26D68BD6 <26 /439 =B<3B=47 3=>B?6 4< /+'+
0 56D ?B=<2 3/ <B :6 <4@6= 26 9B><BD C2B 24/ 3//F69 <26 93/4:373<; 4< J ' 24/ :66= 6J4?3=69 4/ 6 24/ /<4<69 <24< <26 4556774=< & >743?4=<3/24G3=A*K93/4:373<;B8F556D73?:4=9*K B8 7BC6D 73?:26 4556774=< &>743?4=<24/ /F/<43=69+' 8D4><FD6/ B=/396D3=A <26 /4?6 <26 93/4:373<; <4@6= :; <26D3:F=474<K3/=B<5DB56D4=93<3/<B:6<4@6=4< (K4=9<26?F7<35736D45573>4:763/(
+( =G36CB8<264:BG6<26>743?4=<3/6=<3<769<B 7B//B88F<FD63=>B?64/F=96D0
/'+
0JJ(J(KL/.('++
0
- 7 -
+.
B=/396D3=A <24< <26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 24/ /F/<43=69 83G6 8D4><FD6/ 3/ 6=<3<769 <B /'++++
0 <BC4D9/ 543= 4=9 /F886D3=A 4/ 4A43=/< /*++++
0 4/ 4C4D969:;<26D3:F=47
+ 26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 3/ 6=<3<769 <B /'++++
0 4/ 4A43=/< /'+++
0 4/ 4C4D969 :; <26 D3:F=47<BC4D9/7B//B84?6=3<36/4/26C4//<F96=<4=9 <26D63/7B//B85DB/56></B8?4DD34A6
264556774=<&>743?4=<24/:66=49?3<<69<B <262B/53<478BD94;/4=926C4/49G3/69<B<4@6D6/< 26D68BD6 26 3/ 6=<3<769 <B ?693>47 4<<6=94=< 4=9 >B=G6;4=>6>24DA6/4</+++
04/4A43=/</(+++
0 4/4C4D969:;<26D3:F=47
26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 3/ 6=<3<769 <B 7B// B8 3=>B?6 9FD3=A 7439 F5 56D3B9 8BD + ?B=<2/ 3= 4 /F? B8 /+-'+
0 !/+'+
0 J # 4/ 4A43=/< /-+++
0 4/ 4C4D969:;<26D3:F=47
- 8 -
26 D3:F=47 24/ D3A2<7; 4C4D969 <26 >B?56=/4<3B=<BC4D9/?693>476J56=/6/4</*-(+
0
* =G36CB8<264:BG6<264556774=<&>743?4=<3/ 6=<3<769<B<B<47>B?56=/4<3B=4/F=96D0
*
+,-. /01+2.,342 01+2.,342 ,5,6-+-78394.:63
B//B88F<FD63=>B?6 /.('+
0
43=4=9/F886D3=A /'++++
0
<<6=94=<>24DA6/ /+++
0 * B// B8 3=>B?6 9FD3=A 7439F556D3B9 /+-'+
0 ' 693>476J56=/6/ /*-(+
0
B//B84?6=3<36/ /'++++
0
3,* . !;<
' =G36CB8<264:BG6<264556774=<&>743?4=<3/ 6=<3<769 <B >B?56=/4<3B= B8 /.-''+
0 4/ 4A43=/< /--+'+
04/4C4D969:;<26D3:F=47C3<23=<6D6/<4< <26 D4<6 B8 K 54 8DB? <26 94<6 B8 56<3<3B= <377 3</ D6473M4<3B=
=G36CB8<264:BG6<268B77BC3=A,
- 9 -
264556473/477BC693=54D<
26EF9A?6=<4=94C4D994<69(++54//693=
"B.
+- :; <26 997 6=3BD 3G37 F9A6 4=94<394D3/?B9383694/F=96D0
26 4556774=< & >743?4=< 3/ 6=<3<769 <B <B<47 >B?56=/4<3B= B8 /.-''+
0 4/ 4A43=/< /--+'+
04/4C4D969:;<26D3:F=4747B=AC3<2 3=<6D6/< 4< <26 D4<6 B8 K 54 8DB? <26 94<6 B8 56<3<3B=<3773</D6473M4<3B=
26 D6/5B=96=< B & 3=/FD4=>6 >B?54=; /2477 965B/3< <26 /439 4C4D9 4?BF=< C3<2 3=<6D6/< :68BD6 <26 D3:F=47 C3<23= +( C66@/ 8DB? <23/ 94; 84373=A C23>2 3< 3/ 734:76 <B 54; 3=<6D6/< 4< <26 D4<6 B8 .K 54
- 10 -
26 BD96D B8 965B/3< 54//69 :; <26 D3:F=47 3/ D6?43=69F=47<6D69
-< '&&( %
$ 3/<B7B. "$