- 1 - !"# $%# & % '( !')*+(! ' ** , !"! #$ % $ &' $ $$$ ( )) "* #$ % $' $ ( ( $ %' * ( % +' $ $ $ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ""*"* $ ( ($ & %' ( ( (( $ $ $ *""% ,' $ !" *"!,!*!-*,"* ! $ ( + . & %$ . & ' /012 13 4//10504060 7289:0201 8;;0<81 9/01;/2 =>8;?/9 @>1 A5/ </A3A3>;/1 0;2 13 040201 505078223;9/01;/23B5>81A>C/1;4/;A$9/02/1@>1 A5/1/?<>;2/;ADA0A/ * $/A3A3>;8;2/1/=A3>;*>@ *"*E3A5 A5/@>99>E3;B<10F/1 ! ! " # $#%& #'( ! !! )*+ ) * + $,& - ./ 0 0 0/. 0,/ /1 , .0 /2 - 3 - (0=A? 3; 713/@ E53=5 01/ 8A4>?A ;/=/??01F @>1 23?<>?09>@A5/</A3A3>;01/0?8;2/1 13 05/;210:8401 A5/ $>93=/ 87 ;?</=A>1 >@ 84;0702 <>93=/ ?A0A3>; 3201 9>2B/2 0 1/<>1A ?A0A3;B A50A 5/ 1/=/3C/2 0 =1/2379/ 3;@>140A3>; A50A ?>4/7>2F 50C/3;289B/23;28<93=0A3;BA5/G$0;0?090H==>123;B9F 5/@>14/201032A/04=>4<13?3;B>@534?/9@?87?A0@@0;2 <0;=5 E3A;/??/? 0;2 <1>=//2/2 3; A5/ >C/1;4/;A 6//< 7/013;B >, 0A 07>8A -"" <4 >; *")*"* A>E012? A5/ 0B13=89A8109 90;2 7/013;B 81C/F >* ->;53A0B8<<082B31>02 ; 10323;B A5/ B1>8< >@ </><9/ E5> 502 0??/479/2A5/1/A5/1032A/04E0?079/A>?/3I/?<813>8? 0;2?87?A0;201210E40A/1309?E53=5E/1/8?/2@>1A5/ <81<>?/ >@ 28<93=0A3;B A5/ $0; 0?090 0;2 ?/3I/2 A5/ ?04/ * 0?/2 >; A5/ 1/<>1A 84;0702 <>93=/ 1/B3?A/1/2 0 =0?/ 3; 134/ > ""*"* >; *)")*"* - 4 - $1/?/;A</A3A3>;/13?01103B;/20?0==8?/2 > $>93=/01/ 3;C/?A3B0A3;B A5/ 40AA/1 0;2 <1/?/;A </A3A3>;/1 3? ;>A 0C039079/A>A5/ ;C/?A3B0A3;BB/;=F/0<<1>0=5/2A5/ 3?A13=A>81A@>1B10;A>@0;A3=3<0A>1F70390;2A5/9/01;/2 1309 82B/ 7F 682B4/;A 20A/2 *)"*"*) 1/6/=A/2 A5/ ?04/5/1/0@A/1A5/</A3A3>;/13?7/@>1/A53?>81A /01;/2 =>8;?/9 @>1 A5/ </A3A3>;/1 1/3A/10A3;B B1>8;2?81B/23;A5/</A3A3>;=>;A/;2/2A50AA5/</A3A3>;/1 3?3;;>=/;A>@A5/099/B/2>@@/;=/?0;25/50?7//;@09?/9F 34<93=0A/23;A53?=0?/0;2?>8B5A@>1B10;A>@0;A3=3<0A>1F 7039 ) 9/01;/2 3B5 >81A >C/1;4/;A $9/02/1 ><<>?/? @>1 B10;A >@ 0;A3=3<0A>1F 7039 >; A5/ B1>8;2 A50A A5/ </A3A3>;/1 3? 0 :;>E; =1343;09 0;2 A5/1/ 01/ ?3J =1343;09 =0?/? 091/02F </;23;B 0B03;?A 534 5/1/@>1/ 5/ =0;;>A 7/ A/14/2 0? 0 90E 07323;B =3A3I/; 0;2A58??>8B5A@>123?43??09>@A5/</A3A3>; - 5 - ! 0C3;B 5/012 A5/ 9/01;/2 =>8;?/9 @>1 A5/ <01A3/? A53? >81A </18?/2 A5/ 40A/1309 >; 1/=>12 4/A3=89>8?9F , ;?8=5</18?09>@A5/40A/1309>;1/=>123A3? =1F?A09 =9/01 A50A A5/ </A3A3>;/1 50? @039/2 A> @81;3?5 A5/ 3;@>140A3>; E3A5 1/B012 A> A5/ ;847/1 >@ =1343;09 =0?/? A50A01/</;23;B0B03;?A53458? 3A3?0=9/01=0?/>@ ?8<<1/??3>;>@40A/1309@0=A? A 3? </1A3;/;A A> ;>A/ A50A A5/ </1?>; E5> 3? ?//:3;B 0;A3=3<0A>1F 7039 48?A 7/ 0 90E 07323;B =3A3I/; E53=53?0 3 @>1=>;?32/13;B?</=3091/4/2F>@ 0;A3=3<0A>1F70391/K8/?A - ; A5/ =0?/ >; 50;2 C/1F @0=A A50A A5/ </A3A3>;/1 50? ?8<<1/??/2 53? =1343;09 0;A/=/2/;A? 0;2 A50A 3A?/9@ ?5>E? A50A 5/ 3? ;>A 0 90E 07323;B =3A3I/; ==>123;BA>A5/<1>?/=8A3>;A5/</A3A3>;/13?3;C>9C/23; ?3J=1343;09=0?/?0;25/3?;>A0C039079/A>A5/<>93=/@>1 90?AA51//F/01? - 6 - " +5/; 099 A5/?/ @0=A>1? E/1/ =84890A3C/9F =>;?32/1/2A53?>81A3?>@A5/=>;?32/1/2><3;3>;A50AA5/ </A3A3>;/1 3? ;>A /;A3A9/2 @>1 ?</=309 1/4/2F >@ B10;A >@ 0;A3=3<0A>1F70397F1/?>1A3;BA5/?</=309<>E/1?C/?A/23; A53?>81A8;2/1/=A3>;*>@ *"* (81A5/1 3A 3? 09E0F? ></; @>1 A5/ </A3A3>;/1 A> ?811/;2/17/@>1/A5/1309>81A0;2?//:1/B89017039 @ 0;F ?8=5 0<<93=0A3>; 3? @39/2 7F A5/ </A3A3>;/1 A5/ ?04/ ?50997/=>;?32/1/23;0==>120;=/E3A590E * +3A5A50A>7?/1C0A3>;@>99>E3;B 1343;09</A3A3>;3?23?43??/2 -+ '& * # 3?A > 9 > -