Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58239 (KAR)
ERANNA S/O MAHADEVAPPA HOSALLI v. TIPPANNA S/O BHIMASHAPPA AND ORS
MFA/200981/2021 · 2025-03-26
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58239 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58239 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "##
$ %
! "
"
# $ %
"
&$" '' (
$! "
$ '! ! &)
")*+ $ %
"
&$" ''
"
$
! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
&$" '') (
$! &" ,
"
"
)
! ! -"
) $! -"
&$"
$! $" ! &$ %
'! "
" $ %
"
&$" '' (
$! "
$ '! ! &)
")*+ $ %
"
&$" ''
"
$
! - 3 -
$
&$" '') (
$! &" ,
"
"
)
! ! -"
) $! -"
&$" *
$! $" ! !-"
" .$
-" -
# .$
-" -
/012 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 =>/ 099/3304=89/=:=:64/18 042 =>/ 3/014/2 56748/3 <61 1/89642/4=64871045/6?904@:4A6=>=>/099/038
$/:4; 0;;1:/B/2 A@ =>/ C72;?/4=8 :4 68*042A@=>/22:=:6403/4:61 :B:3-72;/042 &030A710;:<618>61=D=>/ 1:A7403E =>/ 9/=:=:64/18 01/ A/<61/ =>:8 671= :4 099/038 8//F:4; /4>045/?/4=6<=>/56?9/480=:64
- 4 -
)
>/ <05=703 ?0=1:G 6< =>/ 508/ :8 =>0= 64 ' 0= 9? H>/4 =>/ 9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0 :46*H089:33:641:2/164=>/?6=615@53/ A/01:4; 6&))
")*+ 21:B/4 A@ 64/ 0:A0440 =>/ 1:2/1216B/=>/80?/:44/;3:;/4=?044/1042208>/2=6 9/2/8=1:04 10440 :/ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :4
6 <16? A05F 8:2/ 042 08 0 1/873= =>/@ </33 26H44=>/80:2055:2/4==>/9:33:641:2/1:2203:4;0H08 :4C71/2042=>/@H/1/8>:<=/2=6=>/>689:=03
* = :8 564=/42/2 =>0= =>/ 9/=:=:64/1
10440 :4 6 H08 :490=:/4= <16? + =6 042 >/ >02 87<</1/2 305/10=:64 6B/1 =>/ 3/<= 8:2/6<<61/>/020426B/13/<=/@/A16H655:9:=0301/0042 0A108:646B/13/<=F4//042=>/1/H080<105=71/6<166<6< =>/?/2:03H0336<3/<=61A:=0423/<=I@;6?0=:5015>
' = H08 564=/42/2 =>0= =>/ 80:2
10440 H08 04 0;1:573=71:8= /014:4; 8 9/1 ?64=> 042 27/ =6 =>/ 055:2/4=03 :4C71:/8 >/ >08 87<</1/2 9/1?04/4=
- 5 -
2:80A3/?/4=04208875>>/:8/4=:=3/2<6156?9/480=:64 <16?=>/6H4/1042=>/:4871/16<=>/?6=615@53/
+
>/ 9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0 :4
6* 564=/42/2 =>0= >/ H08 :490=:/4= <16? ' =6 042 >/ >02 87<</1/2 0A108:64 6B/1 <05/ 042 878=0:4/2 <105=71/ 64 >:8 3/<= =/?96103 1/;:640423/<=655:9:=031/;:64=:8564=/42/2=>0=>/H08 04 0;1:573=7103 H61F/1 /014:4; 8 9/1 ?64=> A@ 26:4; 5663:/ H61F 042 =>/1/<61/ >/ ?0@ A/ 0H012/2 02/J70=/56?9/480=:64<16?=>/6H4/1042:4871/16<=>/ ?6=615@53/
$6=> =>/ 9/=:=:648 A@ =>/8/ 9/=:=:64/18 H/1/ 2/03= 8/9010=/3@ A@ =>/ 1:A7403 4 A6=> =>/8/ 9/=:=:648 1/89642/4=6H08=>/1:2/16<=>/?6=615@53/042=>/ 9/=:=:64 H08 46= 91/88/2 0;0:48= >:?
042 08 875> >:8 40?/ H08 2/3/=/2 >/ 46=:5/8 :887/2 =6 =>/ 1/89642/4= 66H4/16<=>/?6=615@53/1/=714/2088/1B/2A7=>/ 2:2 46= 099/01 A/<61/ =>/ 1:A7403 >/1/<61/ >/ H08 9305/2
- 6 -
>/ 1/89642/4= 6)4871045/ 6?904@ 099/01/2 042 1/8:8=/2 =>/ 9/=:=:648 564=/42:4; =>0= =>/ 56?9/480=:64530:?/2:8>:;>3@/G61A:=04=:?0;:401@042 74=/40A3/ :4 30H 042 1:2/1 6< =>/ ?6=615@53/ H08 46= >0B:4; B03:2 21:B:4; 3:5/45/ 0= =>/ =:?/ 6< 055:2/4=
/1?:4; =>/ 56?9/480=:64 530:?/2 :8 >:;>3@ /G61A:=04= =>/ 4871045/ 6?904@ :8 867;>= <61 2:8?:8803 6< =>/ 9/=:=:648
>/ 1:A7403<10?/20991691:0=/:887/8042=>/ /B:2/45/ H08 1/5612/2 $6=> =>/ 9/=:=:64/18 H/1/ /G0?:4/2 08 042 =>/ 265=61 H>6 088/88/2 =>/ 2:80A:3:=@ H08 /G0?:4/2 08 :4 A6=> =>/8/ 9/=:=:648 042;6=?01F/2
G8=6:46042 G8=6*:46*
<=/1 >/01:4; A6=> =>/ 8:2/8 =>/ 1:A7403 0H012/256?9/480=:64742/12:<</1/4=>/028:808A/36H
- 7 -
46 ' ()*+ ,-./
6H012890:404287<</1:4; 8*
6H0128?/2:503/G9/48/8 8) )
6H0128<662042/G=10 4671:8>?/4=042?/2:503 0==/4204= 8 *
6H0128564B/@045/ 8 '
6H012836886<:456?/271:4; =1/0=?/4= 8+' +
6H01289/1?04/4=2:80A:3:=@ 8'**
/91:B0=:646<<7=71/0?/4:=:/8 8 /)' +0!0
!$
46* ' ()*+ ,-./
:4C71@90:404287<</1:4; 8*
6H0128?/2:503/G9/48/8 8+) )
6H0128<662042/G=10 4671:8>?/4=042?/2:503 0==/4204= 8 *
6H0128564B/@045/ 8 '
6H012836886<:456?/271:4; =1/0=?/4= 8+' +
6H01289/1?04/4=2:80A:3:=@ 8+
/91:B0=:646<<7=71/0?/4:=:/8 8 /)' -.*(*/ +1!01!&
$
+1!01!$
$/:4; 0;;1:/B/2 A@ =>/ 80?/ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 10440 :4 6 :8 :4 099/03 :4 6, H>/1/08 9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0 :4 6*:8:4099/03:46
- 8 -
/012 =>/ 3/014/2 56748/3 <61 A6=> 8:2/8 042 9/178/2=>/=1:03671=1/56128
)
>/ 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 =>/ 9/=:=:64/18 H6732 87A?:= =>0= =>/ 1:A7403 /11/2 :4 088/88:4; =>/ 2:80A:3:=@ 6< =>/8/ 9/=:=:64/18 :4 9169/1 ?044/1 / 87A?:=8 =>0= =>/ >/02 :4C71:/8 H/1/ 46= 5648:2/1/2 9169/13@ A@ =>/ 1:A7403 042 =>/1/<61/ =>/ 56?9/480=:64A/1/088/88/2
*
3/014/2 56748/3 <61 1/89642/4= 64871045/ 6?904@ 87A?:=8 =>0= =>/ 56?9/480=:64 0H012/2A@=>/ 1:A7403:802/J70=/04246:4=/1</1/45/:8 1/J7:1/2:4=>/80?/
'
>/ 9/=:=:64/1
10440 :4 6 >0287<</1/2=>/<105=71/6<166<6<?/2:03H0336<3/<=61A:= 042I@;6?0=:5015>901=<16?=>0==>/1/H08564=78:64 6B/1 =>/ 655:9:=03 01/0 >/ 2:85>01;/ 87??01@ 6< =>/ >689:=03 H>:5> :8 0=
G+ H6732 8>6H =>0= =>/1/ H08 >/?611>0;:5564=78:64H:=>:4B63B:4;=>/1:;>=<164=03
- 9 -
561=/G901=<16?=>/<105=71/6<=>/166<6<=>/3/<=61A:= 042 I@;6?0=:5 015> := H08 =1/0=/2 5648/1B0=:B/3@ :887/22:80A:3:=@5/1=:<:50=/089/1
G042>/8=0=/8=>0= =>/1/01/B01:6782:80A:3:=:/864055674=6<=>/>/02:4C71@ / 8=0=/8 =>0= := H08 =107?0=:5 A10:4 :4C71@ 042 := >08 1/873=/2:4901=:0336886<>/01:4;:43/<=/0127/=620?0;/ =6=>/072:=61@4/1B/04273=:?0=/3@>/69:4/8=>0==>/1/ :82:80A:3:=@6<)K=6=>/H>63/A62@:8=/8=:?64@H08 5648:2/1/2A@=>/ 1:A7403042:=>02088/88/2<745=:6403 2:80A:3:=@ 0= K 648:2/1:4; =>/ 0;/ 6< =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 H>:5> :8 )) @/018 042 =>/ 40=71/ 6< =>/ :4C71:/8 87<</1/2 A@ >:?
=>:8 671= :8 6< =>/ B:/H =>0= =>/ <745=:6403 2:80A:3:=@ :8 K >/ 46=:6403 :456?/ 5648:2/1/2 A@ =>/
1:A7403 0= 8)' 26 46= 1/J7:1/ 04@ 1/5648:2/10=:64 /45/ =>/ 3688 6< <7=71/ :456?/ 27/ =6 2:80A:3:=@:85035730=/208+1!!$ )'G+G GK
- 10 -
+ 648/J7/4=3@ =>/ 56?9/480=:64 742/1 =>/ >/026<36886<:456?/271:4;30:2799/1:62:85648:2/1/2 <6109/1:626<)?64=>808+1!&$ )'G)
>/ 1:A7403 >08 0H012/2 0 56?9/480=:64 6< 8* 742/1 =>/ >/02 90:4 042 87<</1:4; 042 5648:2/1:4; =>/ 40=71/ 6< =>/ :4C71:/8 901=:573013@ =>/ >/02:4C71@=>/80?/:8/4>045/2=6+!$
6H0128 3688 6< 0?/4:=:/8 =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 0 87? 6< +0!$ H>:5> =0F/8 :4=6 :=8 055674==>/20?0;/=6=>/072:=61@4/1B/
>/ 56?9/480=:64 0H012/2 742/1 =>/ 1/?0:4:4;>/0282646=1/J7:1/04@/4>045/?/4=
>78 =>/ 9/=:=:64/1
10440 :4
6:8/4=:=3/2<61<6336H:4;56?9/480=:64
- 11 -
' ()*+ ,-./
0:404287<</1:4; 8'
/2:503/G9/48/8 8) )
6H0128<662042/G=10 4671:8>?/4=042?/2:503 0==/4204= 8 *
6H0128564B/@045/ 8 ' 6886<:456?/271:4;30:279 9/1:62 8)' + 6886<<7=71/:456?/27/=6 9/1?04/4=2:80A:3:=@ 8)'
6886<0?/4:=:/8 8*' /)' +!0!1$
(++/2(),-./)3)4*(*56/2( 475-.)' +0!0
!$
.2).8(,(./ +!1$
6 <01 08 =>/ 9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0 :4 6* :8 5645/14/2 >/ >02 87<</1/2 :4C71:/8 =6 =>/ 3/<= =/?96103 1/;:64 042 3/<= 655:9:=03 1/;:64 042 >/ H08 :490=:/4= <16? ' =6 042 =>/ =1/0=?/4= H08 5648/1B0=:B/ :4 40=71/ >/ >08 :887/2
G 042 >08 8=0=/2 :4 >:8 =/8=:?64@ =>0= =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 >08 368= >/01:4; 0A:3:=@ :4 =>/ 1:;>= /01 042 73=:?0=/3@:=56?/8=6=>/5645378:64=>0==>/1/:82:80A:3:=@ 6<)K=6=>/H>63/A62@
- 12 -
>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 0;/2 0A67= * @/018 042 >08 87<</1/2>/02:4C71@042=>/1/<61/=>/<745=:64032:80A:3:=@ :85648:2/1/20=K/45/=>/56?9/480=:64742/1=>/ >/02 6< 3688 6< <7=71/ :456?/ 64 055674= 6< 2:80A:3:=@ :8 5035730=/208+! !$ )'GGGK )
>/ 56?9/480=:64 742/1 =>/ >/02 6< 3688 6< 0?/4:=:/8:8=6A//4>045/2=6+1!$
*
>/ 56?9/480=:64 0H012/2 742/1 =>/ 1/?0:4:4;>/0282646=1/J7:1/04@/4>045/?/4= '
>78 =>/ 9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0 :4
6* :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 =6=03 56?9/480=:64 742/1 =>/<6336H:4;>/028 ' ()*+ ,-./
6H012890:404287<</1:4; 8*
/2:503/G9/48/8 8+) )
6H0128<662042/G=10 4671:8>?/4=042?/2:503 0==/4204= 8 *
6H0128564B/@045/ 8 ' 6886<:456?/271:4;30:279 9/1:62 8+' +
6H012836886<<7=71/:456?/ 27/=69/1?04/4=2:80A:3:=@ 8+
6886<0?/4:=:/8 8)' /)' +0! !$
(++/2(),-./)3)4*(*56/2( 475-.)' +1!01!$
.2).8(,(./ +!$
- 13 -
+ 4 =>/ 1/873= A6=> =>/ 099/038 2/8/1B/ =6 A/ 0336H/2:4901=/45/=>/<6336H:4;
: $6=>=>/099/03801/0336H/2:4901=
:: >/ 099/3304=9/=:=:64/1
10440 :4 6 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 0 87? 6< 8) :4 022:=:64 =6 =>/ 56?9/480=:64 0H012/2 A@ =>/ 1:A7403 0364; H:=> :4=/1/8= 0= +K 90 <16? =>/ 20=/6<9/=:=:64=:33:=82/968:=
::: >/099/3304=9/=:=:64/1:2203:4;0:4 6* :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 0 87? 6< 8 :4 022:=:64 =6 =>/ 56?9/480=:64 0H012/2 A@ =>/ 1:A7403 0364; H:=> :4=/1/8= 0= +K 90 <16? =>/ 20=/6<9/=:=:64=:33:=82/968:=
:B >/1/89642/4=64871045/56?904@:8 2:1/5=/2 =6 2/968:= =>/ 56?9/480=:64
- 14 -
0?674= H:=>:4 0 9/1:62 6<8:G H//F8 <16?
=>/20=/6<=>:8612/1
B /8= 6< =>/ 612/1 6< =>/ 1:A7403 1/?0:4 7403=/1/2
B:
>/ /;:8=1@ =6 8/42 A05F =>/ =1:03 5671= 1/56128=6=>/5645/14/2 1:A7403
2 9# : #
$"
+)
&