- 1 - !" # $% # $% "%&" ## '&( ) ! !"#$% & ' "( $ " Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )! #$% & ' ( " * * " '( * !" "* !" " + !" %,$ * * !" " - !" - !" ! % '- !" ! ( ./ 011/220345 6/738 4./ 1/474793/:5 6/;9:/ 4./ 2/0:3/< <<7479302 /379: 7=72 !><8/ 03< # 7?0@01>:0 73 9%,$ ';9: 5.9:4 A4./ :76>302B( .0=/ C9D/ >1 E74. 4.75 011/02 6/738 088:7/=/< 6@ 4./ ?><8D/34 03< 0E0:< <04/< E./:/73 4./ 1/474793 ;72/< 6@ 4./ 1/474793/:5 >3</: /C4793 9; 4./ - 3 - 949: /.7C2/ C4 ,%% E05 <75D755/< E74. C9545 6@ 4./ 4:7029>:4 ./ 1/474793/:5 6/738 4./ 10:/345 E7;/ 03< D739: <0>8.4/: 9; 4./ </C/05/< ;72/< 4./ 1/474793 6/;9:/ 4./:76>302C207D738C9D1/3504793:/80:<7384./</04.9; 4./ </C/05/< <7=/110 9 030D034 0F030447 73 4./ :90<4:0;;7C0CC7</349CC>::/<9304069>4 1D ./C05/9;4./1/474793/:5754.044./</C/05/< 6/738 4./ :7</: 9; 4./ D949:C@C2/ 6/0:738 :/8754:04793 9# % #%,E051:9C//<73849E0:<5 .7:08>11757</ ;:9D !0D0F.03<7 57</ 4 4.04 47D/ 0 4:0C49: 4:072/: 6/0:738 :/8754:04793 9#$ "# $ C0D/ ;:9D 9119574/<7:/C4793730:05.03<3/8278/34D033/:03<4./ <:7=/: .0=738 6//3 >3062/ 49 C934:92 4./ =/.7C2/ <05./< 0807354 4./ 507< D949:C@C2/ 03< C0>5/< 0CC7</34 >/ 49 5>C.7D10C44./</C/05/<5>54073/<8:7/=9>573?>:7/503< 7DD/<704/2@ ./ E05 40F/3 49 07F 9517402 ><.92 E./:/73E.72/./E05>3</:4:/04D/34./<7/<9;73?>:7/5 - 4 - 5>;;/:/<734./0CC7</34./1/474793/:551/34D9:/4.03 5 #;9:D/<7C0203<;>3/:02/G1/35/5 :79: 49 4./ 0CC7</34 4./ </C/05/< E05 .02/ 03< ./024.@ 03< ./ E05 <9738 C9927/ E9:F 03< 8/44738 D934.2@ 73C9D/ 9; 5$ # ./ 1/474793/:5 E/:/ </1/3<738934./73C9D/9;4./</C/05/< $ 3 1>:5>03C/ 9; 4./ 5/:=7C/ 9; 3947C/ 4./ :/5193</34 6/738 4./ 9E3/: 9; 4./ =/.7C2/ 011/0:/< 4.:9>8. .75 C9>35/2 6>4 ./ <7< 394 C.995/ 49 ;72/ 03@ 96?/C47935494./1/47479303<C934/544./C05/ 3 5>119:4 9; 4./ C05/ 9; 4./ 1/474793/:5 4./ 1/474793/:9894/G0D73/<0503<1:9<>C/<5/=/3 <9C>D/345051/:G549 ;4/:./0:7384./0:8>D/3459;4./10:47/503< 93C9357</:7384.//=7</3C/93:/C9:<4./:76>302C0D/ 49 4./ C93C2>5793 4.044./1/474793/:5 ;072/< 49 1:9=/4.04 4./0CC7</3473=92=7384./D949:C@C2/6/0:738:/8754:04793 9# % #%, 935/H>/342@ 4./ :76>302 ./2< 4.04 - 5 - 4./ 1/474793/:5 0:/ 394 /34742/< 49 4./ C9D1/3504793 03< <75D755/<4./1/474793>3</:4./7D1>83/<?><8D/3403< 0E0:< 9; 4./ :76>302 /738 088:7/=/< 6@ 4./ 50D/ 4./ 1/474793/:5 .0=/ 011:90C./< 4.75 9>:4 6@ ;72738 4./ 1:/5/34011/02 % 35174/9;5/:=7C/9;3947C/4./:/5193</34.05 394C.95/349011/0: , /0:< 4./ 2/0:3/< C9>35/2 ;9: 4./ 011/220345 03<1/:>5/<4./:/2/=034D04/:702593:/C9:< ./ 2/0:3/< C9>35/2 ;9: 4./ 011/220345 .05 :075/<4./;9229E738C934/34793503<>:8/<4./8:9>3<573 4./011/024.04 '0( ./:76>302.05C9DD744/</::9:73<75D755738 4./ 1/474793 93 4./ 8:9>3< 4.04 4./ =/.7C2/ E05 394 73=92=/< 73 4./ 022/8/< 0CC7</34 ./ :76>302 ;072/< 49 011:/C704/ 4./ ;0C4 4.044./ C9D120734 E05 29<8/< 6@ 4./ C9D12073034 E.9 C0D/ 49 F39E 4./ :/8754:04793 3>D6/: 9; 4./ =/.7C2/03< 4.04 0;4/: <>/ 73=/547804793 4./ 927C/ - 6 - ;72/<0C.0:8/5.//408073544./</C/05/<E.975:7</:9; 4./D949:C@C2/05E/2205<:7=/:9;4./4:0C49: '6( ./:76>3020259;072/<49011:/C704/4.040;4/: ;727389;4./C9D1207344./C93<>C4/<037351/C47939; 4./ =/.7C2/ 03< ;72/< C.0:8/ 5.//4 9E/=/: 4./ :76>302 :/2@738 93 4./ :/19:4 E.7C. 5404/< 4.04 39 <0D08/ E05;9>3<934./4:0C49:C0D/494./C93C2>57934.044./ 022/8/<D949:C@C2/E0539473=92=/<734./0CC7</34 4 75 4:>/ 4.04 4./:/ E05 C.038/ 73 4./ :/8754:04793 3>D6/: 9; 4./ D949:C@C2/ D/34793/< 73 4./ :/19:403<4./C.0:8/5.//4./:/8754:047933>D6/: 9; 4./ D949:C@C2/ 75 D/34793/< 05 # % #%, 73 4./ C9D120734 E./:/05 05 1/: 4./ :/19:4 4./ =/.7C2/5 5>6?/C4/< 49 7351/C4793 0:/ D/34793/< 05 4./ D949:C@C2/ 6/0:738 :/8754:04793 9# % #%, 03< 4./ 4:0C49: 4:072/:6/0:738:/8754:047939#$ "# $./ 1/474793/:5 <7< 394 /G0D73/ 03@ 73</1/3</34 E743/55 49 1:9=/ 4./ 022/8/< 0CC7</34 9:/9=/: 4./ 1/474793/: 9 - 7 - E.9E05/G0D73/<936/.02;9;4./1/474793/:5E0539403 /@/E743/55494./0CC7</34 ./ 1/474793/:5 .0=/ 394 /G0D73/< 4./ 73;9:D034 E.9 80=/ 73;9:D04793 49 4./ 1927C/ :/80:<738 4./0CC7</344./C93C/:3/<3=/547804793;;7C/:'(03< 4./949:/.7C2/351/C49:'(739:</:49/5406275.4./ C9::/C4 :/8754:04793 3>D6/: 9; 4./ D949:C@C2/ 022/8/<2@ 73=92=/< 73 4./ 0CC7</34 *>:4./: 74 75 1/:473/34 49 394/ 4.04 73 5174/ 9; 011/0:03C/ 4./ :/5193</34 6/738 4./ 9E3/: 9; 4./ 9;;/3<738 =/.7C2/ ./ <7< 394 C.995/ 49 ;72/ 03@ 96?/C47935 03< C934/54 4./ 1/474793 /3C/ E.72/ <75D7557384./1/4747934./:76>3025.9>2<.0=/C9357</:/< 022 4./ D04/:7025 93 :/C9:< 49 C9D/ 49 4./ C93C2>5793 E./4./: 4./ 022/8/< D949:C@C2/ :/8754:04793 6/0:738 95# % #%, 9: # % #%, E05 73=92=/< 73 4./ 0CC7</34 /3C/ E/ 0:/ 9; 4./ C9357</:/< =7/E 4.04 4./ D044/: 5.9>2< 6/ :/D03</< 60CF 49 4./ :76>302 ;9: C9357</:738 4./ D044/: 0;:/5. 87=738 :/0593062/ 03< 5>;;7C7/349119:4>3747/549694.4./10:47/5490<<>C/4./7: - 8 - /=7</3C/./:/;9:/4./7D1>83/<?><8D/3403<0E0:<9; 4./ :76>302 75 27062/ 49 6/ 5/4 057</ 03< 4./ 011/02 </5/:=/5496/0229E/<03<:/D03</< 34./:/5>24E/1:9C//<4910554./;9229E738I '0( ./011/0275./:/6@0229E/< '6( 935/H>/342@4./?><8D/3403<0E0:<<04/< 73 9%,$ 9; 4./ 2/0:3/< <<7479302 /379: 7=72 !><8/ 03< #7?0@01>:0755/4057</ 'C( ./D044/:75:/D03</<60CF494./:76>302 ;9: C9357</:738 4./ D044/: 0;:/5. 87=738 5>;;7C7/3403<:/0593062/9119:4>374@49694. 4./ 10:47/5 49 0<<>C/ 4./7: /=7</3C/ 03< 1:9C//< E74. 4./ D044/: 73 0CC9:<03C/ E74. 20E '<( ./ 10:4@ 5.022 011/0: 6/;9:/ 4./ :76>302 93 ,$ E74.9>4 E074738 03@ ;>:4./: - 9 - 3947C/./:76>3025.022<75195/9;4./C05/ E74.7301/:79<9;57GD934.;:9D4./<04/9; :/C/7149;C91@9;4.759:</: '/( /8754:@ 75 <7:/C4/< 49 5/3< C91@ 9; 4./ ?><8D/34494./C93C/:3/<9>:402938E74. :7029>:4:/C9:<5;9:4.E74. ';( 99:</:0549C954 *+ '# ( % *+ '"%&"( % 7549 29